You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Time to discuss Summer clearout
November 16 2026 7.08am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Time to discuss Summer clearout


Page 1 of 12 1 2 3 4 5 > Last >>
pssguy Flag 23 Apr 18 11.26am

Assuming we stay in Premier League, there will be some tough decisions to make on out-of-contract players


I have added the ranking in terms of minutes played for us so far this season - excluding loan players

"Crystal Palace have an entire team who could be free agents next summer, including Julian Speroni(15), Damien Delaney(22), Yohan Cabaye(7), James McArthur(5), Wayne Hennessey, Bakary Sako(1, Joel Ward(12), Martin Kelly(14), Chung-Yong Lee(21) and Freddie Ladapo(24)"

A lot depends on whether the Getafe goalie comes, and any other irons in the fire, but assuming he does this is my take

Adieu: Delaney, Lee, Ladapo
Reduced salary offer: Speroni(stays), Cabaye(leaves)
Sako(leaves)
Similar salary offer: McArthue(stays), Kelly(stays),
Ward(leaves) Hennessey(stays)

In an ideal world, these are all bench players at best next year but you would think we would want at absolute minimum 1 of each McArthur/Cabaye; Speroni/Hennessey; Kelly/Ward to stay


 

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 23 Apr 18 11.28am

Originally posted by pssguy

Assuming we stay in Premier League, there will be some tough decisions to make on out-of-contract players


I have added the ranking in terms of minutes played for us so far this season - excluding loan players

"Crystal Palace have an entire team who could be free agents next summer, including Julian Speroni(15), Damien Delaney(22), Yohan Cabaye(7), James McArthur(5), Wayne Hennessey, Bakary Sako(1, Joel Ward(12), Martin Kelly(14), Chung-Yong Lee(21) and Freddie Ladapo(24)"

A lot depends on whether the Getafe goalie comes, and any other irons in the fire, but assuming he does this is my take

Adieu: Delaney, Lee, Ladapo
Reduced salary offer: Speroni(stays), Cabaye(leaves)
Sako(leaves)
Similar salary offer: McArthue(stays), Kelly(stays),
Ward(leaves) Hennessey(stays)

In an ideal world, these are all bench players at best next year but you would think we would want at absolute minimum 1 of each McArthur/Cabaye; Speroni/Hennessey; Kelly/Ward to stay


I agree with most of this. I have a sneaky feeling that Cabaye will go back to France.

 


One more point

pstrutt Flag Busselton, WA 23 Apr 18 11.35am

Originally posted by Badger11

I agree with most of this. I have a sneaky feeling that Cabaye will go back to France.

I have a sneaky feeling you may be right.

As for the OP, I think a lot of those players will be upgraded but seriously not all. Some will be shifted quickly, but others will have to remain in case the right replacements are either not secured or not confirmed. For example, McArthur we can improve on him, but I wouldn’t want to see him leave. Or Wayne, we can improve on him, but I would not like to see us sell before we’re covered.

 


So I manage a Workshop which provides a safe learning environment for blokes struggling with PTSD and other mental health issues. Being a Palace fan isn't listed yet.

Beanyboysmd Flag 23 Apr 18 11.49am

Henners is gone, as fans our treatment of him has just been horrible, every interview he gives he basicly says 'i know the fans hate me but im working hard to try to win them over' actually really feel for him. He deserves to be at a club that appreciate him, rather than 25'000 fans hissing at him for not being a new goalie...

 

Deleted11 23 Apr 18 12.02pm

I can deal with most of them going, but not McArthur. He's basically our Kante, budget, but we can't afford a proper Kante. I'd never let him leave.
Sako, I would also keep on a year rolling contract that increases in ££ terms the next year based on appearances and goals scored the previous year.
Benteke has to go, for sure, but who do we bring in. I prefer to have a squad of 15 class players than what we have atm, but not sure who's out there.

 

pssguy Flag 23 Apr 18 12.03pm

Originally posted by Beanyboysmd

Henners is gone, as fans our treatment of him has just been horrible, every interview he gives he basicly says 'i know the fans hate me but im working hard to try to win them over' actually really feel for him. He deserves to be at a club that appreciate him, rather than 25'000 fans hissing at him for not being a new goalie...

That would actually make a good stand-alone topic - which player did fans hate at first but managed to turn them round

 

mattteo Flag 23 Apr 18 12.15pm

McArthur and Cabaye to stay (it's hard to find a replacement for such a gifted player like the Frenchie is, you might find yourself relegated next year if it doesn't work with a new signing).

All the others I don't really care about. There can be massive improvements with little money on what they offer. If you want to finish in the top 10 and not be in the relegation fight anymore, they ought to go (even Ward). If you're going for continuity it's gonna be the same 12-15 place next year (if no injuries to Zaha and Townsend)

Edited by mattteo (23 Apr 2018 12.15pm)

 

CambridgeEagle Flag Sydenham 23 Apr 18 12.24pm

Originally posted by Jway89

I can deal with most of them going, but not McArthur. He's basically our Kante, budget, but we can't afford a proper Kante. I'd never let him leave.
Sako, I would also keep on a year rolling contract that increases in ££ terms the next year based on appearances and goals scored the previous year.
Benteke has to go, for sure, but who do we bring in. I prefer to have a squad of 15 class players than what we have atm, but not sure who's out there.

Why? He's had a poor season, but that happens. I don't think the club will sell him. As you said, who would we bring in. He scored 17 last season, which pretty much kept us up. Hopefully he goes to the World Cup, gets some game time and some goals and comes back with a clean slate, a bit of rest and some renewed confidence.

We certainly need another striker though!

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 23 Apr 18 12.25pm

Originally posted by pssguy

That would actually make a good stand-alone topic - which player did fans hate at first but managed to turn them round

Townsend. Under Pardew he was pathetic.

 


COYP

pssguy Flag 23 Apr 18 12.37pm

Originally posted by Jway89

I can deal with most of them going, but not McArthur. He's basically our Kante, budget, but we can't afford a proper Kante. I'd never let him leave.
Sako, I would also keep on a year rolling contract that increases in ££ terms the next year based on appearances and goals scored the previous year.
Benteke has to go, for sure, but who do we bring in. I prefer to have a squad of 15 class players than what we have atm, but not sure who's out there.

Isn't Sako on 80 per week, as we picked him up on free. I imagine he will try the same game - with Wolves a more likely destination

I'd keep McArthur as well - though make sure he only plays in central midfield

 

pssguy Flag 23 Apr 18 12.39pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

Townsend. Under Pardew he was pathetic.

I guess Pardew did as a player - for 5 minutes

 

chateauferret Flag 23 Apr 18 12.54pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

Townsend. Under Pardew he was pathetic.

That says more about Pardew than about Townsend.

 


============
The Ferret
============

Aray Flag South London 23 Apr 18 1.21pm

Originally posted by pssguy

Assuming we stay in Premier League, there will be some tough decisions to make on out-of-contract players

I have added the ranking in terms of minutes played for us so far this season - excluding loan players

"Crystal Palace have an entire team who could be free agents next summer, including Julian Speroni(15), Damien Delaney(22), Yohan Cabaye(7), James McArthur(5), Wayne Hennessey, Bakary Sako(1, Joel Ward(12), Martin Kelly(14), Chung-Yong Lee(21) and Freddie Ladapo(24)"

A lot depends on whether the Getafe goalie comes, and any other irons in the fire, but assuming he does this is my take

Adieu: Delaney, Lee, Ladapo
Reduced salary offer: Speroni(stays), Cabaye(leaves)
Sako(leaves)
Similar salary offer: McArthue(stays), Kelly(stays),
Ward(leaves) Hennessey(stays)

In an ideal world, these are all bench players at best next year but you would think we would want at absolute minimum 1 of each McArthur/Cabaye; Speroni/Hennessey; Kelly/Ward to stay

Good post an agree with most of your analysis. IMO we cannot afford to lose Cabaye. He is our playmaker. When he's not on the pitch our ball retention and passing is awful. Hopefully no French team can afford to match our (reduced offer) I'd only give him 2 years max but unless we have a ready made ball playing midfielder (Jonny William s where are you?) We need to keep him and (obvs McArthur).

I would also like Ward to stay another season. We can have him as back up to AWB.

 

oldstand Flag Christchurch 23 Apr 18 1.53pm

Cheeky bid for cheek, pay mcarthur well to keep him or he, s gone for nothing. Defensively in good shape . Maybe 1 in . Tekkers will stay nobody will buy him for the price we’ll ask for him. Our focus is clearly on midfield, and not giving this division a 7 game start over us.

 

peterg Flag Anerley 23 Apr 18 3.55pm

When will our two January signings who haven't even made it to the bench be included in the reckoning?

 


The right place at the right time

edskan Flag 23 Apr 18 3.56pm

I really think the players we've got can really push us on next season, especially if Roy is still at the helm. There seems to a good comaradory between the players and imho I would solely focus on a replacement for Benteke.

 

oldstand Flag Christchurch 23 Apr 18 4.42pm

Originally posted by peterg

When will our two January signings who haven't even made it to the bench be included in the reckoning?

Indeed, where are these chaps. Not good enough, maybe. See off Leicester and we may get a viewing.

 

JRW2 Flag Dulwich 23 Apr 18 4.55pm

Originally posted by pssguy

That would actually make a good stand-alone topic - which player did fans hate at first but managed to turn them round

Can't remember his name - came from Spurs, played right back, scored a significant goal against Norwich and all was forgiven.

 

Palace in the Blood Flag 23 Apr 18 5.04pm

Originally posted by Beanyboysmd

Henners is gone, as fans our treatment of him has just been horrible, every interview he gives he basicly says 'i know the fans hate me but im working hard to try to win them over' actually really feel for him. He deserves to be at a club that appreciate him, rather than 25'000 fans hissing at him for not being a new goalie...

He does seem to want to stay in that sense. I think the management and very much SP have a very hard decision. WH main problem is that he is not Julian and this has resulted in the horrible behaviour by some fans. He is a competent EPL goalkeeper not the best but can we afford better? Julian is past his best and it is time he left the club. SP often seems to let sentiment overcome business logic eg appointment of Pardew, Salako,Freedman the signing AJ for a last contract and renewing Johhny Williams, Mcarthy etc. While Julian is at Club our goalkeepers will always be compared to him at his peak and this has resulted in players being abused and can not continue. SP has to decide that although a great servant Julian has been, it is time to part ways. I am afraid that this logic also applies to a front line coaching role maybe he would like to go elsewhere for a short period and then comeback as a coach?

 

Ginger Pubic Wig Flag Wickham de L'Ouest 23 Apr 18 6.18pm

This is the biggest summer for the club in many a year.

We need to set a price for Wilf and a deadline by when it needs to be hit. We need an early confirmation from Roy that he wants to stay. We need to work through all the out-of-contract players fast and work out which want the shilling we're willing to offer, and which don't.

We have a world cup to contend with and a window that shuts on Aug 9. With so many variables and so little time, we could be in serious trouble if we don't make fast, good decisions.

All this, and I personally am assuming our net transfer budget won't be vast given recent expenditure.


 


If you want to live in a world full of kindness, respect and love, try to show these qualities.

Page 1 of 12 1 2 3 4 5 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Time to discuss Summer clearout