This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by Goal Machine
Tactical mismatch which was entirely predictable. Had shades of the Croatia semi final. Totally dominant for the first 30 mins and should have capitalised on that. Instead GS tries to shut up shop which always invites pressure - it’s the dumbest tactic in football. The game was crying out for Grealish to come on and take the game to the Italians, but he left it too late, as usual. He allowed them to run all over us. World class squad with an average manager, the players deserve better. Southgate does all the non important parts of his job well, but doesn’t have the nous to win against a big team on a big occasion. We couldn’t have had easier paths in the last two tournaments and this makes our run to semi and final seem more impressive that it actually is. Two things really pissed me off with the penalties. Firstly, why do players persist with the fancy stuttering run up? All you have to do look through the pens in this tournament to see that about 75% of the time this fails. What’s wrong with a simple no nonsense run up and smashing it in the corner out of the keepers reach like Kane and Maguire? - it’s a pretty simple closed skill for a professional footballer - much like a snooker player potting a spotted black or a golfer rolling in a flat 5 foot putt. Secondly, why was the least experienced player on the pitch given the responsibility of such an important penalty? Henderson and Walker who are the two most senior players in the squad and multiple trophy, were winners replaced with two kids. I’m also so angry with the manner of Rashford’s miss. We had the initiative and he tries to be clever and misses the target. I’m gutted for Saka. The lad had a terrific tournament and deserves nothing but praise. He shouldn’t have been put in that situation in the first place. I hope he realises that and can bounce back. He’ll carry that miss for the rest of his career. This was Southgate’s failure, not his.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Elpis
I am not entirely convinced that this was a deliberate tactic. We were pushed back by an Italian team that moved the ball well, we ended up with Kane deep into the England half and when we gained possession we could not retain the ball, could not instigate any counter attacks and the pattern continued with Italy having the lion's share of possession.
|
|
|
GS and his team a real credit to the country. The rest of it, good riddance.
|
|
|
Originally posted by steeleye20
GS and his team a real credit to the country. The rest of it, good riddance. The did well to reach the final it's just annoying that the manager and team failed to learn the lesson of 2018 against Croatia. You should not sit back when you get a goal try and finish the game off without being suicidal. we played well for the 20 minutes after the goal but you could see the Italians were just working us out after that we were on the back foot and the better team won in the end. Kane should have come off at half time for some reason he started really well and then ran out of steam. If I was Spurs I would cash in on Kane now. Rashford should not have been in the squad he lost form in the second half of the season at United and didn't deserve to be there. Henderson should not have gone. We've now had to great chances to win largely because we had favourable draws and we have blown it. I can't get excited about this team which is efficient but not entertaining in tournament football.
One more point |
|
|
Originally posted by sickboy
Poor post in defence of a poor manager. Check our history. A semi followed by a final is unprecedented. And we have had teams with far better individual players than the current crop. Why is that? We were not good enough to beat Croatia or France 3 years ago, but could probably have got a result against the rest, including Brazil and Argentina; and not good enough to beat Italy this time round though we could have beaten every other team including France, Belgium and maybe Spain. We have never taken this competition seriously (except in 96), and usually play lip service to the usual guff about doing the nation proud. This was always a step. The plan was openly stated yonks ago. Win in 2022. This one would have been amazing, but it was always a step on another ladder. You only get the right to wear the star as world champions. This team continues to mature towards the big event in 18 months. Southgate is the right head of a big team to get us there. We tried your way with Cappello, SGE etc. and it did not work. BTW, I agree one criticism. Should bring on penalty subs with at least 5-10 minutes to go so they get a run out and get used to the vibe. It is no coincidence that Kane and Maguire, who started the match, were the only ones to score. He isn't infallible and still has lots to learn.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Badger11
The did well to reach the final it's just annoying that the manager and team failed to learn the lesson of 2018 against Croatia. You should not sit back when you get a goal try and finish the game off without being suicidal. we played well for the 20 minutes after the goal but you could see the Italians were just working us out after that we were on the back foot and the better team won in the end. Kane should have come off at half time for some reason he started really well and then ran out of steam. If I was Spurs I would cash in on Kane now. Rashford should not have been in the squad he lost form in the second half of the season at United and didn't deserve to be there. Henderson should not have gone. We've now had to great chances to win largely because we had favourable draws and we have blown it. I can't get excited about this team which is efficient but not entertaining in tournament football. Agree with this. The more I think now, was that the loss firmly lays at the feet of GS. This was the first time that plan 'A' (patient building of pressure) hasn't worked. GS Tactics have been spot on all tournament. he hasn't needed to change mid game. but It required it this game, and he failed this test. It's a young team - and young manager. We're not easy to beat, but still struggle against real quality. GS has done enough to warrant a continuation of this project, hopefully all(incl. GS) will learn from this experience. if he's done nothing else, he's gotten me looking forward to major tournaments again.
"It was a Team effort, I guess it took all players working together to lose this one" |
|
|
Originally posted by Willo
Apropos Saka, I suppose he can console himself with the fact that 2 of his team-mates also missed penalties and they have an impressive penalty taking record. Prior to last night,Rashford had scored 15 and missed 2, Sancho had scored 10 and missed 1. Saka has never taken a penalty for Arsenal to the best of my knowledge. He has scored 2 in a Youth Cup match and in an U18 International friendly and missed 1, in a penalty shoot out in another U18 International friendly. Edited by Willo (12 Jul 2021 8.50am)
Edited by Phil’s Barber (12 Jul 2021 10.58am)
|
|
|
Originally posted by Badger11
Agreed. Sancho and Saka are kids they get a pass in my book. Where were the experienced players? As for Rashford's penalty, idiotic? He lost form at United during the second half of the season he shouldn't have been selected. During the tournament I saw nothing of his brief appearances to change that opinion. Any coach will tell you when you lose form go back to the basics he should just have taken a run and hit the ball, nothing fancy. I hate all this trickery it looks great when it works but if the keeper guess's right he will save it. Just hit the bloody ball. It was the Rashford penalty miss, when we were ahead, that was the pivotal miss and game changer. Put that one in and the pressure on Italy is HUGE.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Frickin Saweet
I'd give Southgate the world cup next year. Some of his decision making - or game management as everyone calls it now - is rightly being scrutinised, particularly around the subs. And I think the system we're playing does not allow us to attack in numbers as frequently as I'd like. I would hope that Southgate recognises that in his analysis and adapts his approach accordingly. Southgate part of a much bigger England project that is starting to bear fruit through to the first team - by that I mean the semi in the last WC and yesterday's final. Those were the markers set out by the FA when this plan started. We're no longer bound by making the most of a golden generation of which there is a sell-by date. We have a production line of talent coming through all age groups. So I think that belief in the big project mustn't waiver until it's run its course. It would be easy to pay a mercenary manager to come in and try to win a tour but that would kill the philosophy that we're building. That's the Rice/Phillips partnership - which I think he stumbled on somewhat.
"It was a Team effort, I guess it took all players working together to lose this one" |
|
|
Originally posted by orpingtoneagle
We can moan about tactics but the managers tactics are the thing that got us to the final. We can moan about the penalties - and I am not a fan of the stutter and stop run up, but those lads stepped up to take them. We had a fantastic tournament overall and bodes well for the future. There was a lot of dignity in Southgates presser this morning. More than shown by our fans at the matches and out and about, who lack the basic respect of another nations anthem, who storm the Stadium, who stick lit flares up there a**e and who Racially abuse their own team. With fans like that we don't deserve to win anything. Spot on. They are an embarrassment. A rabble of chavs who think they're patriots.
I have now sufficient funds to last me the rest of my life. Provided I don't buy anything. |
|
|
Originally posted by orpingtoneagle
We can moan about tactics but the managers tactics are the thing that got us to the final. We can moan about the penalties - and I am not a fan of the stutter and stop run up, but those lads stepped up to take them. We had a fantastic tournament overall and bodes well for the future. There was a lot of dignity in Southgates presser this morning. More than shown by our fans at the matches and out and about, who lack the basic respect of another nations anthem, who storm the Stadium, who stick lit flares up there a**e and who Racially abuse their own team. With fans like that we don't deserve to win anything. We don't deserve to win anything because a small proportion of fans are scumbags? Do me a favour. Show me a country or club who doesn't have a pocket of fans like that. It's easy to get carried away and think a few viral videos and disproportionate media reporting tell the whole story. The racist abuse on social media should rightly be called out but it's not right that the majority of good fans suffer because of them. Also worth noting that a lot of the abuse on social media came from outside of the UK - according to Southgate in the presser this morning.
|
|
|
Originally posted by orpingtoneagle
We can moan about tactics but the managers tactics are the thing that got us to the final. We can moan about the penalties - and I am not a fan of the stutter and stop run up, but those lads stepped up to take them. We had a fantastic tournament overall and bodes well for the future. There was a lot of dignity in Southgates presser this morning. More than shown by our fans at the matches and out and about, who lack the basic respect of another nations anthem, who storm the Stadium, who stick lit flares up there a**e and who Racially abuse their own team. With fans like that we don't deserve to win anything. Yes on all points. Well said. Those yobs are not 'fans' or supporters of a football match. They made the occasion an excuse to get drunk and create mayhem. Must have been frightening for anyone accidentally caught up in it. Their behaviour was/is an embarrassment for our country as a whole and it brings shame on all true football supporters.
Dad and I watched games standing on the muddy slope of the Holmesdale Road end. He cheered and I rattled. |
|
|
Am I wrong or didn't Rashford hit the left-side post from a pen when we played ManU two years ago? (ManU-Palace 1:2, 08/2019)? Was my last (even more) away-game I visited ..... Originally posted by Phil’s Barber
It was the Rashford penalty miss, when we were ahead, that was the pivotal miss and game changer. Put that one in and the pressure on Italy is HUGE.
|
|
| BlueJay |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Willo
Apropos Saka, I suppose he can console himself with the fact that 2 of his team-mates also missed penalties and they have an impressive penalty taking record. Prior to last night,Rashford had scored 15 and missed 2, Sancho had scored 10 and missed 1. Edited by Willo (12 Jul 2021 8.50am) Good to have the numbers. I feel for the lad, for this all to fall on his shoulders. Character building though no doubt. Penalties are just such a crapshoot and so marginal. If it had gone the other way then few would be asking any questions. Our mistake was not leaving it all on the pitch prior to the nightmare pens scenario and getting the win (or going down fighting). Fortune favours the brave.
|
|
|
Originally posted by BlueJay
Good to have the numbers. I feel for the lad, for this all to fall on his shoulders. Character building though no doubt. Penalties are just such a crapshoot and so marginal. If it had gone the other way then few would be asking any questions. Our mistake was not leaving it all on the pitch prior to the nightmare pens scenario and getting the win (or going down fighting). Fortune favours the brave. Yep. I think part of Southgate's philosophy is that any situation can be managed. While I agree that in-game situations can be prepared for, players are people not robots and other variables such as emotion, human nature, momentum, (for us and the opposition) mean that things don't go to plan based on data, numbers statistics etc. As he matures as a manager I hope he starts to use his instinct and gut feeling when games start to change. This could have been capitalising on the 1-0 lead, or pre-empting Italy's command of the game. As has been spoken about a lot, he reacts to situations rather than being proactive to take charge of a game. Hopefully this will come. If it doesn't then I think it's 'thanks Gareth but your time is up', after the next world cup.
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.