You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Roy Hodgson just announced as CPFC manager
November 16 2026 3.19am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Roy Hodgson just announced as CPFC manager


Page 20 of 20 << First< 16 17 18 19 20
Vaibow Flag vancouver/croydon 26 Mar 23 12.22am

I work with kids with behavioural issues - heck, you only need to compare wilf to other top pro's - Wilf's highly emotional and is lacking a good leadership role in his life that can connect with him and steer him the right way.
Wilf may not even be able to help such emotional issues, as if often the case.

 


This was once a quality forum....

YT Flag Oxford 26 Mar 23 8.58am

Originally posted by samprior

Macca spoke highly of him recently in an article posted the other day. Saying he's a winner and a role model for younger players!

Interviews with current footballers aren't worth the paper they are printed on. I learned that from reading Shoot! in the late-1960s and then from countless 'A word from the captain' columns in match programmes, home and away. They always tow the club line and never say anything controversial and rarely anything interesting for that matter.

 


Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes)

Painter Flag Croydon 26 Mar 23 9.32am

Originally posted by CT Charlie

Wilf won't receive offers nearly as generous as he'd wish, but he'll receive offers higher than what we're willing to pay him.

At that point, he'll need to decide between taking the risk of seeing less playing time elsewhere and remaining a star at Palace.

Apparently he has been offered £9m a year in the Middle East, I expect he would play every game in an obscure league.

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 26 Mar 23 9.47am

Originally posted by YT

Interviews with current footballers aren't worth the paper they are printed on. I learned that from reading Shoot! in the late-1960s and then from countless 'A word from the captain' columns in match programmes, home and away. They always tow the club line and never say anything controversial and rarely anything interesting for that matter.

They are probably all ghost written anyway

 

Phil’s Barber Flag Crowborough 26 Mar 23 11.19am

Originally posted by samprior

Macca spoke highly of him recently in an article posted the other day. Saying he's a winner and a role model for younger players!

I very much doubt he’s going to say publicly what he really thinks

 

Den1923 Flag 26 Mar 23 11.49am

Originally posted by Vaibow

I work with kids with behavioural issues - heck, you only need to compare wilf to other top pro's - Wilf's highly emotional and is lacking a good leadership role in his life that can connect with him and steer him the right way.
Wilf may not even be able to help such emotional issues, as if often the case.

I think your observations are indeed spot on, the trouble with Zaha
is you do not know which one is going to turn up. These days the sulking version seems to appear much more frequently than the skilful player and that results in him ''throwing the toys out of the pram'' if he thinks the referee are not protecting him. He should be. as a Senior Pro in the team, the leader and giving encouragement and advice but instead he over dribbles runs in to trouble and then throws his arm up in the air in despair. I think that whatever happens at the end of his contract the team would be better off without him in the long run as these days he cannot really walk the talk!

 

YT Flag Oxford 26 Mar 23 3.22pm

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

They are probably all ghost written anyway

Good point.

 


Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes)

Palacesince64 Flag Edinburgh 27 Mar 23 6.50pm

Originally posted by YT

Interviews with current footballers aren't worth the paper they are printed on. I learned that from reading Shoot! in the late-1960s and then from countless 'A word from the captain' columns in match programmes, home and away. They always tow the club line and never say anything controversial and rarely anything interesting for that matter.

I have a box of those in my attic. Must dig them out for a laugh. Methinks whatever else they are they definitely won’t be woke!

 

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 27 Mar 23 6.59pm

Originally posted by Palacesince64

I have a box of those in my attic. Must dig them out for a laugh. Methinks whatever else they are they definitely won’t be woke!

I remember the grainy photo of Cannon in the programme with comments without expletives. No way he said any of it.

 


Red and Blue Army!

PatrickA Flag London 30 Mar 23 5.40pm

I've just watched the press conference and Roy is clearly delighted to be back and he said he has never really considered himself retired.
He was asked if the next games went well whether he would consider staying next season.
As you would expect he batted this away and said he saw the upcoming games as a project in itself and wasn't looking beyond this.

Nonetheless, if it goes very well there could be a clamour for him to stay on.
Put it this way; with his enthusiasm and zest for the game I don't think he'll be in a rush to leave if it does go well.

 

VinceHilaire Flag London 30 Mar 23 6.03pm

And the latest video of the players training is testimony to Roy’s approach.

I love watching the little tips and advice he, Ray and Paddy are giving the players. Not sure I remember seeing this with PV?

 

PatrickA Flag London 30 Mar 23 7.22pm

One point that Roy made at the press conference struck me as slightly strange.
He was asked to compare the situation when he left the club to the current situation now.
He sought to differentiate the situations by referring to the amount of the players out of contract last time around (highlighting their concern about finding a new employer) from the situation now.
My understanding is that we have half a dozen players out of contract this summer too so some of the concerns surely remain although there is at least a little more choice this time around.

 

silvertop Flag Portishead 30 Mar 23 7.51pm

Originally posted by PatrickA

One point that Roy made at the press conference struck me as slightly strange.
He was asked to compare the situation when he left the club to the current situation now.
He sought to differentiate the situations by referring to the amount of the players out of contract last time around (highlighting their concern about finding a new employer) from the situation now.
My understanding is that we have half a dozen players out of contract this summer too so some of the concerns surely remain although there is at least a little more choice this time around.

Fewer out of contract and not Dad's Army.

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 30 Mar 23 8.15pm

Originally posted by PatrickA

One point that Roy made at the press conference struck me as slightly strange.
He was asked to compare the situation when he left the club to the current situation now.
He sought to differentiate the situations by referring to the amount of the players out of contract last time around (highlighting their concern about finding a new employer) from the situation now.
My understanding is that we have half a dozen players out of contract this summer too so some of the concerns surely remain although there is at least a little more choice this time around.


Given squads of 25 and 4-5 year contracts it is usual for a club to have half a dozen contracts coming to the end each season (if the contracts haven't been extended).

By my reckoning, we have ELEVEN contracts coming to an end this summer as follows:

Butland
Matthews

Ward
Clyne
Ferguson
Tomkins

McArthur
Milivojevic
Schlupp
Zaha

Ayew

Two of them have been injury crocks virtually all season and like the two keepers out on loan are unlikely to be retained next year IMO.

Of the other seven I think Clyne or Ward might be offered one year extensions along with Schlupp and Ayew.

We know there's an offer on the table for Wilf.

I would be surprised if Tomkins is retained and not sure about Luka.

If the two keepers aren't replaced given Whitworth can act as 3rd keeper behind Guaita and Johnstone, and, if I'm right about who will be offered extensions (and accept them, of course), it leaves us needing to replace:
- the two crocks (Ferguson and McArthur)
- Ward or Clyne
- Tomkins
- possibly Luka
- and probably Zaha.

Of course, if all Eleven go we will be up the proverbial etc.


Edited by doombear (30 Mar 2023 8.16pm)

 

PatrickA Flag London 31 Mar 23 7.35pm

It’s just been announced that Schlupp and Ayew have signed new one year contracts.
I wonder if terms have been offered to other soon to be out of contract players ,other than Zaha where indications are that he has been offered a new deal already.

 

Elphers40 Flag Sunny South Coast 02 Apr 23 11.34am

I was really pleasantly surprised by the mentality shown by Roy in his approach to the game. It was the polar opposite to what I expected and whilst I was very down in the dumps around PV leaving and Roy coming in - I have to eat some humble pie here and say that the club may have got it right in the short term.

I’m not basing that on a euphoric end to a HUGE match, but the turnaround from a team that has created a premier league record for NO shots on target (in 3 games) to our magnificent first half performance. Roy, Ray and Paddy have done really well to get the squad to buy into their message. The aggressive “front foot” approach was exactly what was required for this game and hope this continues going forward.

I’m delighted to be proved wrong on this occasion. COYP!

 

rikz Flag Croydon 02 Apr 23 11.57am

Tbh Roy was on a hiding to nothing taking over, an underwhelming appointment, inheriting a fairly decent team in relation to the bottom half of the table. The easiest run in, I still don't belive we would have been relegated regardless who our manager is. I expected and still expect us to win half of our remaining games, I'll still give him credit for the performance yesterday and he had very little to gain and everything to lose taking charge.

 

Qwijibo Flag Bournemouth 02 Apr 23 2.15pm

I was one of those really worried about his appointment. I thought he did well before, but he left at the right time. His spell with Watford seemed a disaster. I seem to recall, we technically relegated them in a game where their performance was utterly devoid of any fight or belief.

But yesterday seemed to be a showpiece of man management. I don't think tactics were ever that significant. I got the feeling he'd spent the whole time since appointment telling players how good they were, and how much they needed to fight and believe in themselves.

I appreciated the comments after the game where he gave credit to the previous manager for leaving him with players that were so well coached. It was a classy touch that he didn't need to make. How often do you hear a new manager coming in who questions whether the players were fit enough, in a shameless tactic to buy himself time and put blame on the previous coaching team for any subsequent poor performances. In our case, given our poor running stats etc, this would have been a very easy case to make. Instead he has opted to tell our players how good they are, and they seemed to believe him.

We've had a couple of games in recent weeks where we have started fast, with desire and dynamism, only for the effort levels to wear off after fifteen to twenty minutes as belief waned. Whereas yesterday, we dominated that first half. I think had Wilf not gone off, we'd have dominated the second as well. We still carried a threat in the second half, but clearly Leicester felt more comfortable to attack without the threat of Zaha.

I was worried when Mateta and Mitchell feebly fluffed that late chance. I genuinely worried that we just couldn't score, and couldn't win, despite a game where we had created so much. But they didn't lose belief, and when we got a second bite of the cherry.... well... he just smashed it home. I think that belief through till the dying seconds has come from Roy, and he deserves credit for the win.

 

kingdowieonthewall Flag Sussex, ex-Cronx. 02 Apr 23 3.23pm

I was very anti Roy being given the temp job & gutted when he was announced.
I feared a moral sapping home defeat yesterday.
Was pleased how attacking we were & general application.
The job is to stay up & obviously still a fair few games to go still this season.
However I'll be more than happy to eat a large portion of humble pie should he do the job.(lets hope so !)

 


Kids,tired of being bothered by your pesky parents?
Then leave home, get a job & pay your own bills, while you still know everything.

Page 20 of 20 << First< 16 17 18 19 20

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Roy Hodgson just announced as CPFC manager