This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
With your prediction record anyone taking advice from you needs insurance first. You only have opinion and excuses for an elite who have worsened working and middle class people's living standards over decades while becoming richer t hemselves. That's statistical fact. Answering you point by point has been done numerous times. You don't address anything and essentially it comes down to 'A is A because I say it is'.....Continuing to answer that is just feeding the troll, and sometimes I can be bothered to throw you some biscuits and sometimes I can't. Another personal criticism posing as a reply. I suggest you follow your own advice and stop posting “at” me, if you find the exercise so distasteful. I make no excuses for anyone. I just believe you are wrong in most of your analyses. That the wealth gap has widened is indeed a statistical fact, which no-one denies. What is wrong is your assertion that there is some kind of conspiratorial master plan by a group of “elites” behind it. We are the masters at home. If we want change we can get change. What we cannot change are things beyond any one country’s control. Global events demand global co-operation and that needs organisation and structure. Things you resist at every turn. So it’s the attitude of people like you that is responsible for restraining efforts to improve the fairer distribution of wealth. Of course you don’t really care about that at all! What concerns you is making sure that your situation isn’t negatively impacted by those efforts. Everyone else can go to hell.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
They are going to be stormtroopers tasked to operate in the combat zone for six months taking ground. Many of them won't survive and I should imagine far less will end up walking the streets than if they had served out their sentence. It is the atrocities they will certainly commit and their inevitable ineptitude that will cause the military to side line them as embarrassing; but not before a lot of civilians have suffered at their hands. Echoes of the Kaminsky Brigade.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
I would say sending billions of dollars of military equipment into a mostly lawless country is also pretty stupid for our own future security....but hey, no one seems to care much about the consequences of that. If the Russians want to increase their manpower and fight with their most scummy prisoners then that isn't going to affect us in Europe but be their own internal problem. All those sodding weapons though....that's something else. Edited by Stirlingsays (16 Sep 2022 10.06pm) A testing ground for weapons and tactics and the first time the West has had a chance to have a go at the Ruskies albeit via proxy. They must think it's Christmas.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
. I agree that it seems probable that Putin will turn to low yield nuclear at some point. However I don’t think there is any guessing about NATO’s response. It will condemn, encourage the rest of the world to do so too, especially China and India, but stick firmly to it’s red line of no direct intervention. Nor do I see any possibility of NATO member’s supplying nuclear weapons of any kind to Ukraine or, indeed, any very long range weapons. That scenario is unlikely not probable. Pure pub chat.
|
|
|
Originally posted by becky
Quite and as said above for the media to hype this up as a latter day Katyn is shameful.
|
|
|
Originally posted by silvertop
That scenario is unlikely not probable. Pure pub chat. Is an opinion worthy of a "pub chat". Sorry, but no time for one today.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
Is an opinion worthy of a "pub chat". Sorry, but no time for one today. Our politics are close and generally our views align more or less. But Putin will not release huge levels of radioactivity into a neighbouring nation with a prevailing westerly wind blowing it into his own peoples faces. He will not break the last post war taboo. That will be his legacy. Even the Chinese wont stand with him if he did (the khazaks have already secured a treaty of support from China in the event putin turns his gaze south). I would also be surprised if the military let him although I accept I don't know if he can bypass them. And there is no such thing as a "tactical" bomb. There is only the bomb.
|
|
|
Originally posted by silvertop
Our politics are close and generally our views align more or less. But Putin will not release huge levels of radioactivity into a neighbouring nation with a prevailing westerly wind blowing it into his own peoples faces. He will not break the last post war taboo. That will be his legacy. Even the Chinese wont stand with him if he did (the khazaks have already secured a treaty of support from China in the event putin turns his gaze south). I would also be surprised if the military let him although I accept I don't know if he can bypass them. And there is no such thing as a "tactical" bomb. There is only the bomb. Tactical nukes are very much a thing. They would be anywhere from half a kiloton to maybe 50-100 kilotons. You'd be looking at a few hundred metres radius of damage in the short term for the smaller weapons. The US famously had a nuclear mortar. [Link] Small tactical nukes are the UK'S current thinking on nukes.
Red and Blue Army! |
|
|
Originally posted by ASCPFC
Tactical nukes are very much a thing. They would be anywhere from half a kiloton to maybe 50-100 kilotons. You'd be looking at a few hundred metres radius of damage in the short term for the smaller weapons. The US famously had a nuclear mortar. [Link] Small tactical nukes are the UK'S current thinking on nukes. Isn't there a neutron bomb? It doesn't leave residual radiation?
One more point |
|
|
Originally posted by Badger11
Isn't there a neutron bomb? It doesn't leave residual radiation? The neutron bomb is designed to kill people whilst leaving infrastructure. The basic principle is that on detonation, the bomb emits mainly neutrons at incredibly high speed, and gamma rays. Both will pass through most buildings and vehicles yet kill anything living within the area almost immediately. It sounds useful, but not sure how much the actual blast and radiation has been reduced. I don't think they're as refined as was theoretically intended.
Red and Blue Army! |
|
|
Originally posted by Badger11
Isn't there a neutron bomb? It doesn't leave residual radiation? Poor lass died a few weeks ago, Olivia I believe
|
|
|
Originally posted by Badger11
Isn't there a neutron bomb? It doesn't leave residual radiation? The pulse of neutron radiation would cause immediate and permanent incapacitation to unprotected outdoor humans in the open out to 900 meters, with death occurring in one or two days. The median lethal dose (LD50) of 6 Gray would extend to between 1350 and 1400 meters for those unprotected and outdoors, where approximately half of those exposed would die of radiation sickness after several weeks. So that’s all good then. They don’t really work in the rain Edited by Mapletree (18 Sep 2022 4.11pm)
|
|
|
Originally posted by ASCPFC
Tactical nukes are very much a thing. They would be anywhere from half a kiloton to maybe 50-100 kilotons. You'd be looking at a few hundred metres radius of damage in the short term for the smaller weapons. The US famously had a nuclear mortar. [Link] Small tactical nukes are the UK'S current thinking on nukes. I was talking political implications of the use of nuclear weapons.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Mapletree
The pulse of neutron radiation would cause immediate and permanent incapacitation to unprotected outdoor humans in the open out to 900 meters, with death occurring in one or two days. The median lethal dose (LD50) of 6 Gray would extend to between 1350 and 1400 meters for those unprotected and outdoors, where approximately half of those exposed would die of radiation sickness after several weeks. So that’s all good then. They don’t really work in the rain Edited by Mapletree (18 Sep 2022 4.11pm) Yup I dont think there is such a thing as a good nuke. I just hope that if Putin ever does decide to start lobbing nukes at the west ground zero is my home. I don't fancy surviving only to watch my skin and bits slowly drop off. Edited by Badger11 (18 Sep 2022 4.37pm)
One more point |
|
|
Originally posted by Goal Machine
Sterling…. I don’t post that regularly but follow this thread and it’s comments closely and daily. I’m interested in the topic because it’s a big deal and half my family (although I’m not close to them) live in Kiev. Generally, I agree with your opinions on most things, and you’re clearly an intelligent bloke, but I’m afraid you’re so off the mark with this. The way you conduct yourself against Wisbech suggests you have no proper response and resort to low level digs. For what it’s worth, I disagree with Wisbech on most of his centre/left views. If you want respect from passive HOLer’s, you need to post with more respect and up your game. This war is simply about a deranged bully (Putin) trying to forcefully take land from a democratic and peaceful country in Ukraine. Any sane leader would focus on trying to make their country and people prosperous and successful. NATO are standing up to a modern day Hitler and so we should. No one wants this war. If Ukraine/NATO/Europe accept it, then what country does Russia invade next? God forbid this war ever reaches our shores, but if it does, this is the sort of thing you fight for. The Russian army don’t know what they’re fighting for. The Ukrainians are fighting for their freedom and future. Good will win.
You present the war in goody v baddy terms, which is very much how our media have decided present it....it's no different to what the Russians are doing over there. I often find that while many people will freely admit that the media lie to them they will end up believing most of those lies and half truths. If you had been reading this thread since it began you would know that firstly my opinion was very much a pro Ukrainian one at the start (which agreed with supplying weapons) to what it is now....which essentially is one where I consider this war a hot potato with no up side to winning even if that were possible. The reason I aim barbs at WE is mostly because he continually wants to repeat arguments that we have already had earlier in the thread. I can't really be bothered to endlessly repeat myself to the same person only for the same points to be posted at me. Unlike him I don't see myself as on some kind of mission to convince people of a view, I have always come onto Hol to let off steam and just give an opinion. If I think someone is disingenuous then I'm not continually going to engage. My view changed to basically Victor Orban's 'the war would have been local, but the West intervened and made it global.' As my commentary earlier in the thread shows my position altered once I looked into the causes of this war and just the sheer level of lying that has gone on. As I said earlier in the thread the real victims of this war are the civilians killed and maimed for the hubris of politicians. I will respect any man who goes to war for their country while not always agreeing with the reasons why....some of those reasons have been lies fed to them....and in the Ukraine conscription has meant that many people have been forced to fight against their will. You say the Ukraine is a democratic and peaceful country. However the coup in 2014, which forced out the pro Russian president wasn't democratic was it. That's what caused the war back then. Also the Minsk agreement which ended the fighting was broken by the Ukraine by shelling the pro Russian side. The UN recognised that...and that went on for years right up till the invasion....How much of that was you getting in our media? Both Russia and the west have been meddling in the Ukraine for decades and all this goody/baddy stuff is a smoke screen. People like Biden's son have been working with their corrupt rich right up till a few years ago.....People have been sucking money out of the Ukraine for decades. Russia is bad and so is Nato.....a plague on all their houses as far as I'm concerned. The sooner this pointless war ends the better. Edited by Stirlingsays (18 Sep 2022 5.13pm)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Badger11
Yup I dont think there is such a thing as a good nuke. I just hope that if Putin ever does decide to start lobbing nukes at the west ground zero is my home. I don't fancy surviving only to watch my skin and bits slowly drop off. Edited by Badger11 (18 Sep 2022 4.37pm) As Sting once sang: “I hope the Russians love their children too…”
hats off to palace, they were always gonna be louder, and hate to say it but they were impressive ALL bouncing and singing. |
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
As I said earlier in the thread the real victims of this war are the civilians killed and maimed for the hubris of politicians. I will respect any man who goes to war for their country while not always agreeing with the reasons why....some of those reasons have been lies fed to them....and in the Ukraine conscription has meant that many people have been forced to fight against their will. Edited by Stirlingsays (18 Sep 2022 5.13pm) In a survey by Rating on 1 March 2022, 80% of the Ukrainian respondents said they were ready to defend the territorial integrity of Ukraine with weapons in hand. Compared to the pre-war times, this figure has significantly increased (it was 59% in 2020). The highest level of readiness is observed in the West and in the Centre of the country, while a slightly lower level of readiness is observed in the South and in the East. But even in the South-Eastern regions, readiness to fight for the country is extremely high (almost 80% in the South and almost 60% in the East).
|
|
|
Originally posted by Mapletree
In a survey by Rating on 1 March 2022, 80% of the Ukrainian respondents said they were ready to defend the territorial integrity of Ukraine with weapons in hand. Compared to the pre-war times, this figure has significantly increased (it was 59% in 2020). The highest level of readiness is observed in the West and in the Centre of the country, while a slightly lower level of readiness is observed in the South and in the East. But even in the South-Eastern regions, readiness to fight for the country is extremely high (almost 80% in the South and almost 60% in the East). What you miss out here is the reality that all opposition media has been outlawed in Ukraine, the same with parties. No one is allowed to say anything other than what is approved. I don't believe those figures, especially in the east and south as that's where the separatist movement actually is. They haven't taken ground with squirrels, those people come from those regions. Also, 'respondents' hardly represents the actual population demographic does it. If those figures were real there would be no need for conscription would there Maple? Yet no male of fighting age has been allowed to leave the country since the war began. Edited by Stirlingsays (18 Sep 2022 6.40pm)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Behind Enemy Lines
As Sting once sang: “I hope the Russians love their children too…” You obviously didn't read what Medvedev said about this. When it comes to tens of millions dying in a war, the Russians have a history. You are willing for tens of millions to die over Ukraine? Which slav controls what piece of land. I'll fight in a war that make sense. I fight battles that have a clearly defined win as a result.....I would have thought that after the last twenty years more of us would have learnt this.....Anyway, you can fight for the State department's gay disco. Regardless I resent the suffering we will have to endure for this fiasco. But like I said, I never supported this....it's you lot who will have to answer for people not being able to pay their bills, going cold and not being able to feed their kids. And that's just the consequences over the next few months. Edited by Stirlingsays (18 Sep 2022 6.54pm)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
What you miss out here is the reality that all opposition media has been outlawed in Ukraine, the same with parties. No one is allowed to say anything other than what is approved. I don't believe those figures, especially in the east and south as that's where the separatist movement actually is. They haven't taken ground with squirrels, those people come from those regions. Also, 'respondents' hardly represents the actual population demographic does it. If those figures were real there would be no need for conscription would there Maple? Yet no male of fighting age has been allowed to leave the country since the war began. Edited by Stirlingsays (18 Sep 2022 6.40pm) I suggest you take your arguments to the LSE. I am merely reporting. But I see you know better so thrash it out with them. Ukraine is a country that already had subscription, a Soviet legacy. They have e.g. removed the right to defer (which links to banning people leaving) but this isn't the huge change it would be in the UK. Perhaps you also think we should not have had conscription during WW1 (1916) and WW2 (1939)? Or maybe you believe people were not feeling passionate about beating the Germans. Your argument is totally fallacious. It is a question of all hands to the pump and everyone in it together. What do you think the approval ratings will be now in Ukraine, six months on? Or indeed in Russia where people were more nationalistic than in Ukraine before the invasion. Russia has done a brilliant job of nation building in Ukraine Also, referring back to another of your fallacious statements a couple of months back, you will note in the article that the Russophones are not significantly less supportive of fighting for the Ukrainian homeland than the Ukrainian speakers. Remember how you so cleverly belittled me on that point? Edited by Mapletree (18 Sep 2022 7.37pm)
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.