You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Topic
November 22 2026 1.19am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

ukip (LOCKED)


Page 21 of 187 < 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 >
Johnny Eagles Flag berlin 10 May 14 7.55pm

Your glorious trotting out of lists of statistics would definitely make me cream myself, WH, but I already knocked one out earlier over a picture of the former Serbian warlord Ratko Mladic.

Edited by Johnny Eagles (10 May 2014 7.56pm)

 


...we must expand...get more pupils...so that the knowledge will spread...

TUX Flag redhill 10 May 14 8.06pm

White Horse..................

Stirling says it all and shows you many historical FACTS that should make you think, but I doubt they will. Oh well, your loss.
Stop swallowing everything that is shoved down your throat and open your eyes bud. With the current view that you and many hold we'll never progress!

Take the blinkers off and you'll see so much more.

 

The White Horse Flag 10 May 14 8.39pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 10 May 2014 7.44pm

Well, I don't say they are obviously a net contributor like you do. There are studies different from the one you consistently choose to cite as if it's unquestionable truth.

There are studies denying that climate change is man made, I think it's pretty obvious that I'm not going to struggle to be able to make any sort of case for immigration if the most obvious premises are denied.

Quote Stirlingsays at 10 May 2014 4.28pm

I don't believe the proper costs are apart of the calculation.

As for your example I don't know how many immigrants you know who are approximately on thirty plus grand but I'd wager it's a small minority.

I don't just mean £10,000 in income tax, I mean in terms of all taxes (including VAT, fuel duty, etc.). Someone on around £20,000/year will generally contribute around £10,000/year in tax. And it was a hypothetical example anyway, it doesn't really matter what the typical figure is, so long as the average tax paid surpasses the average services/benefits received.

Quote Stirlingsays at 10 May 2014 4.28pm

Rather obviously they feed less into the economy than workers who don't send money out of the country.

It is just ridiculous for you to even suggest that this unknowable calculation could be ascertained with the economy. Like much in economics it actually comes down to how you interpret.

Sending money back or not, they spend money in our economy, so they're assisting its growth in that respect. And they're obviously helping economic growth by working.

Quote Stirlingsays at 10 May 2014 4.28pm

Really....You don't mind competition for your job?....What a callous thing to say. We have tons of people looking for jobs.....Large competition for low skilled or semi skilled.....Forced upon zero hour contracts because of no choice and Horsey here thinks it's a good thing. Some Labour man you are......I hope you have lots of competition for your next job mate, I'm sure you'll welcome it.

I don't think mass unemployment and zero hour contracts are an indication that competition for jobs is too fierce, I think it's just an indication that (as with other areas) although there could be enough jobs to go round, the economy and state is just structured in such a way that employers are able to play workers off against one another.

That's not a problem of too many workers, it's a problem of the power balance between employers and employees being all wrong. There are economies elsewhere in the world where they have the same concentration of workers, but improved unemployment figures; it's not just a question of demography.

There is competition in my job (and in jobs I've had previously, including zero hours contracts), but I put that down to dubious employment practices, rather than the inevitable consequence of immigrant workers. I think a little bit of competition can be a good thing. If a Romanian can do my job better than me, I probably need to up my game.

Quote Stirlingsays at 10 May 2014 4.28pm

Yeah, I'm most definitely noticing a pattern.....Your head stuck firmly in the sand.

The figures you quote are theoretical and no doubt include private property that the state has absolutely no power to affect....The cost to the state to house today is significant...Head in the clouds stuff.

You waffling on about how the state could be structured rather than how it is and will continue to be structured and hence affect the most vulnerable is typical.

The figures aren't theoretical, they are actual (or very close to the correct figures at leas). There are about 26 million homes, which can house an average of at least 4 people. I think it's probably fair to say that the problem, as you seem to identify, is with the who owns properties rather than the number of properties.

I'd suggest that government in recent decades has encouraged people buying houses they have no intention of living in and has done nothing to protect those who rent from these people being ripped off. Not really a surprise, but capitalism is geared towards the benefit of those who own the capital.

Much of the fault for housing being unaffordable must fall on the shoulders of those who have identified this and gone for buy-to-lets so they can benefit financially from this situation.

Quote Stirlingsays at 10 May 2014 4.28pm

Personally I don't see how those statistics support your side of the argument.

Increased public spending has many fathers......But population growth at least can't lie.

Before Labour open the borders immigration was a minor topic in this country......Statistics and well as common sense informs that it is far more significant now.

Clearly the rate of population growth increasing 3 times has changed the political landscape, but when they economy is predicted to grow 3.2% this year, I can't say I'll be particularly concerned if population increases by 0.7% or so.

The size of the economy essentially determines how many jobs there are available and (in spite of cuts in public spending) largely determines how much state support is available and how much infrastructure spending occurs.

The whole UKIP argument would be much more credible if unemployment wasn't going down and if public spending on schools and hospitals hadn't been frozen.

 


"The fox has his den. The bee has his hive. The stoat, has, uh... his stoat-hole... but only man chooses to make his nest in an investment opportunity.” Stewart Lee

The White Horse Flag 10 May 14 8.50pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 10 May 2014 7.49pm

We were in relative terms a wealthy nation a hundred years ago due to trade, exploitation and the advance of capitalism.

The massive costs of war were based upon loans.....The recovery from the second world war was based upon austerity and massive grants from America (Marshall Plan) ....It enabled a large rebuilding plan and hence helped the post war population boom.

We certainly weren't wealthy anymore once the Second World War finished.

In what sense is creating the welfare state and a National Health System 'austere'?! It was ridiculously expensive when the loans you mention already amounted to 200% of GDP or so (2 or 3 times today's debts).

We didn't just sell some of the queen's old jewellery, it was a half century of huge social upheaval and hard work to balance the books. And we did it during a time of pretty much constant population increase.

 


"The fox has his den. The bee has his hive. The stoat, has, uh... his stoat-hole... but only man chooses to make his nest in an investment opportunity.” Stewart Lee

The White Horse Flag 10 May 14 8.53pm

Quote Johnny Eagles at 10 May 2014 7.55pm

Your glorious trotting out of lists of statistics would definitely make me cream myself, WH, but I already knocked one out earlier over a picture of the former Serbian warlord Ratko Mladic.

That's probably my second favourite Stewart Lee description behind "an ageing c*nt with an eskimo face from the 90s".

 


"The fox has his den. The bee has his hive. The stoat, has, uh... his stoat-hole... but only man chooses to make his nest in an investment opportunity.” Stewart Lee

Stirlingsays Flag 10 May 14 9.39pm

Quote The White Horse at 10 May 2014 8.50pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 10 May 2014 7.49pm

We were in relative terms a wealthy nation a hundred years ago due to trade, exploitation and the advance of capitalism.

The massive costs of war were based upon loans.....The recovery from the second world war was based upon austerity and massive grants from America (Marshall Plan) ....It enabled a large rebuilding plan and hence helped the post war population boom.

We certainly weren't wealthy anymore once the Second World War finished.

In what sense is creating the welfare state and a National Health System 'austere'?! It was ridiculously expensive when the loans you mention already amounted to 200% of GDP or so (2 or 3 times today's debts).

We didn't just sell some of the queen's old jewellery, it was a half century of huge social upheaval and hard work to balance the books. And we did it during a time of pretty much constant population increase.


We were skint after the war..Your statistics aren't an actual reflection of this country's financial state.....This country had food rationing until July 1954. .We were on food rations in WW1 as well from 17 to 20.

I repeat the money coming in to rebuild a lot of our infrastructure was American money....The NHS was on the never never.....In reality it always has been.

I have work to do so I just don't have time to go over your previous post. What I will say is your projection of a growth being suffice to cope with our population increase is economically illiterate in my view.


 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

The White Horse Flag 10 May 14 9.49pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 10 May 2014 9.39pm

Quote The White Horse at 10 May 2014 8.50pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 10 May 2014 7.49pm

We were in relative terms a wealthy nation a hundred years ago due to trade, exploitation and the advance of capitalism.

The massive costs of war were based upon loans.....The recovery from the second world war was based upon austerity and massive grants from America (Marshall Plan) ....It enabled a large rebuilding plan and hence helped the post war population boom.

We certainly weren't wealthy anymore once the Second World War finished.

In what sense is creating the welfare state and a National Health System 'austere'?! It was ridiculously expensive when the loans you mention already amounted to 200% of GDP or so (2 or 3 times today's debts).

We didn't just sell some of the queen's old jewellery, it was a half century of huge social upheaval and hard work to balance the books. And we did it during a time of pretty much constant population increase.


We were skint after the war..Your statistics aren't an actual reflection of this country's financial state.....This country had food rationing until July 1954. .We were on food rations in WW1 as well from 17 to 20.

I repeat the money coming in to rebuild a lot of our infrastructure was American money....The NHS was on the never never.....In reality it always has been.

I have work to do so I just don't have time to go over your previous post. What I will say is your projection of a growth being suffice to cope with our population increase is economically illiterate in my view.

I'm not sure what the point is of this element of the discussion. The recovery in the nation's finances was clearly down to more than just American generosity, we had to pay billions of loans back. We both seem to be agreed that the UK was skint, so surely the fact that we hugely reduced national debt during periods of population increases shows it's possible.

 


"The fox has his den. The bee has his hive. The stoat, has, uh... his stoat-hole... but only man chooses to make his nest in an investment opportunity.” Stewart Lee

TUX Flag redhill 10 May 14 9.49pm

'White Horse' appears to love typing.

Oh dear.

 

Stirlingsays Flag 10 May 14 10.23pm

Quote The White Horse at 10 May 2014 9.49pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 10 May 2014 9.39pm

Quote The White Horse at 10 May 2014 8.50pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 10 May 2014 7.49pm

We were in relative terms a wealthy nation a hundred years ago due to trade, exploitation and the advance of capitalism.

The massive costs of war were based upon loans.....The recovery from the second world war was based upon austerity and massive grants from America (Marshall Plan) ....It enabled a large rebuilding plan and hence helped the post war population boom.

We certainly weren't wealthy anymore once the Second World War finished.

In what sense is creating the welfare state and a National Health System 'austere'?! It was ridiculously expensive when the loans you mention already amounted to 200% of GDP or so (2 or 3 times today's debts).

We didn't just sell some of the queen's old jewellery, it was a half century of huge social upheaval and hard work to balance the books. And we did it during a time of pretty much constant population increase.


We were skint after the war..Your statistics aren't an actual reflection of this country's financial state.....This country had food rationing until July 1954. .We were on food rations in WW1 as well from 17 to 20.

I repeat the money coming in to rebuild a lot of our infrastructure was American money....The NHS was on the never never.....In reality it always has been.

I have work to do so I just don't have time to go over your previous post. What I will say is your projection of a growth being suffice to cope with our population increase is economically illiterate in my view.

I'm not sure what the point is of this element of the discussion. The recovery in the nation's finances was clearly down to more than just American generosity, we had to pay billions of loans back. We both seem to be agreed that the UK was skint, so surely the fact that we hugely reduced national debt during periods of population increases shows it's possible.


We didn't pay off our WW2 until 2005.....That's how rich we are mate.....WW1 debt has never been fully repaid.

The points is your statistics are really a load of old bollocks when it comes to actual living standards on the ground.

Your picture of a country able to happily cope with the kind of changes happening now.....Well....If you were right Ukip wouldn't even be growing.

Still, never mind eh....I'll remember your happiness at extra competition for your future jobs when I see someone else suffer for it.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

The White Horse Flag 10 May 14 10.37pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 10 May 2014 10.23pm

Quote The White Horse at 10 May 2014 9.49pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 10 May 2014 9.39pm

Quote The White Horse at 10 May 2014 8.50pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 10 May 2014 7.49pm

We were in relative terms a wealthy nation a hundred years ago due to trade, exploitation and the advance of capitalism.

The massive costs of war were based upon loans.....The recovery from the second world war was based upon austerity and massive grants from America (Marshall Plan) ....It enabled a large rebuilding plan and hence helped the post war population boom.

We certainly weren't wealthy anymore once the Second World War finished.

In what sense is creating the welfare state and a National Health System 'austere'?! It was ridiculously expensive when the loans you mention already amounted to 200% of GDP or so (2 or 3 times today's debts).

We didn't just sell some of the queen's old jewellery, it was a half century of huge social upheaval and hard work to balance the books. And we did it during a time of pretty much constant population increase.


We were skint after the war..Your statistics aren't an actual reflection of this country's financial state.....This country had food rationing until July 1954. .We were on food rations in WW1 as well from 17 to 20.

I repeat the money coming in to rebuild a lot of our infrastructure was American money....The NHS was on the never never.....In reality it always has been.

I have work to do so I just don't have time to go over your previous post. What I will say is your projection of a growth being suffice to cope with our population increase is economically illiterate in my view.

I'm not sure what the point is of this element of the discussion. The recovery in the nation's finances was clearly down to more than just American generosity, we had to pay billions of loans back. We both seem to be agreed that the UK was skint, so surely the fact that we hugely reduced national debt during periods of population increases shows it's possible.


We didn't pay off our WW2 until 2005.....That's how rich we are mate.....WW1 debt has never been fully repaid.

The points is your statistics are really a load of old bollocks when it comes to actual living standards on the ground.

Your picture of a country able to happily cope with the kind of changes happening now.....Well....If you were right Ukip wouldn't even be growing.

Still, never mind eh....I'll remember your happiness at extra competition for your future jobs when I see someone else suffer for it.

I never expressed that I was "happy" with "extra" competition, I just said I thought competition can be a good thing. I'd have thought that was a fairly standard belief in a capitalist society. Apparently not if a competitor is an immigrant.

 


"The fox has his den. The bee has his hive. The stoat, has, uh... his stoat-hole... but only man chooses to make his nest in an investment opportunity.” Stewart Lee

Stirlingsays Flag 11 May 14 1.06am

Quote The White Horse at 10 May 2014 10.37pm

I never expressed that I was "happy" with "extra" competition, I just said I thought competition can be a good thing. I'd have thought that was a fairly standard belief in a capitalist society. Apparently not if a competitor is an immigrant.


Wow....What a profound difference that is......So if you think extra competition is 'good', it doesn't mean you're 'happy' with it......Yeah, that makes sense.

Sure for big business having a larger group of sados to scramble around for your jobs is preferable.....But I believe in balance and....Well, what you state as a 'good' thing has lowered wages for many workers and resulted in less job security for most at the low to semi skilled level.

Immigration is a normal and healthy process for many nations. Still what it comes down to are numbers and planning/provision......And many many working class people in Britain have been shafted on housing/jobs by people in power holding opinions like yours.

Edited by Stirlingsays (11 May 2014 1.07am)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

The White Horse Flag 11 May 14 1.16am

Quote Stirlingsays at 11 May 2014 1.06am

Wow....What a profound difference that is......So if you think extra competition is 'good', it doesn't mean you're 'happy' with it......Yeah, that makes sense.

Sure for big business having a larger group of sados to scramble around for your jobs is preferable.....But I believe in balance and....Well, what you state as a 'good' thing has lowered wages for many workers and resulted in less job security for most at the low to semi skilled level.

Immigration is a normal and healthy process for many nations. Still what it comes down to are numbers and planning/provision......And many many working class people in Britain have been shafted on housing/jobs by people in power holding opinions like yours.

Surely you'd agree that the best circumstance isn't too much competition or no competition, it's something in between. The reason I objected in the first place to the notion that competition was bad is because there's clearly a level at which it's healthy.

Where we differ is that you believe that we're some point towards a "large group of sados scrambling" as a result of there being too many workers available, but i'd contend that most of the problems you point to occur in areas even where workers are relatively scarce.

In the job I'm currently working in for example, there are plenty of people willing and able to do my job instead of me, but i'm on a long term contract and my trade union is recognised and regularly consulted. In my previous job there weren't many people looking to take my place but I had no contract and no job security. Ultimately terms and conditions come down to the employer, not the supply of employees.

 


"The fox has his den. The bee has his hive. The stoat, has, uh... his stoat-hole... but only man chooses to make his nest in an investment opportunity.” Stewart Lee

matt_himself Flag Matataland 11 May 14 8.17am

Good news.

[Link]

I can't see TUSC on this poll. Can't understand why, given their apparent appeal to the working man, woman and/or person.

Edited by matt_himself (11 May 2014 8.19am)

 


"That was fun and to round off the day, I am off to steal a charity collection box and then desecrate a place of worship.” - Smokey, The Selhurst Arms, 26/02/02

Stirlingsays Flag 11 May 14 12.46pm

Quote The White Horse at 11 May 2014 1.16am

Surely you'd agree that the best circumstance isn't too much competition or no competition, it's something in between. The reason I objected in the first place to the notion that competition was bad is because there's clearly a level at which it's healthy.

Where we differ is that you believe that we're some point towards a "large group of sados scrambling" as a result of there being too many workers available, but i'd contend that most of the problems you point to occur in areas even where workers are relatively scarce.

In the job I'm currently working in for example, there are plenty of people willing and able to do my job instead of me, but i'm on a long term contract and my trade union is recognised and regularly consulted. In my previous job there weren't many people looking to take my place but I had no contract and no job security. Ultimately terms and conditions come down to the employer, not the supply of employees.


Like most people the situation I would regard as fair is an economy which provided enough well paid jobs to provide people a reasonable standard of living.

That means maintaining a balance between number of jobs and possible workers for them......Something this country is absolutely useless at doing.

We have a balance that is too hard for low and semi skilled workers and I'm saying that one of the reasons for that (not the only one) is that we are gaining a new population roughly the size of Southampton every year......Not all but most of those immigrants will be on the low to semi skilled areas and hence the areas that they will settle in will be affected by increased populations over and above what existed before.

Sorry Horsey what are those areas immigrants are settling in 'where workers are scarce'? Implicitly you're saying that where they are going isn't going to cause problems.

I was a teacher in Wisbech for five years..An area that you are maybe unknowingly talking about..I taught many a British college student next to an Eastern European....I can tell you that these British kids knew very well that they would be competing for jobs in town with these immigrants and more than a few weren't happy about it...And I didn't blame them...Their own government was breaking that unspoken contract that should exist between the state and subject/citizen (I work for you and you work for me). Because they are the weakest and most vulnerable they didn't matter.....Many bosses wouldn't even take on British kids when given the choice...That's the practical outcome of the idealism you support.

Too much immigration matters wherever you put it.....It's bleeding obvious that too many new people have a negative affect upon the existing population in terms of housing, jobs and community.

Immigrants tend to flock to areas that contain immigrant populations as we know the affect around the country isn't spread evenly....It means that British workers will face an uneven and unfair situation in those areas....Again that is the outcome of the idealism that you have supported.....Sure I don't believe you meant it but that is the practical outcome.

You saying that, if we used all the housing or if we did this differently or that is pure cop out. None of the main governments will do any of those things. So supporting the EU's open door policy directly leads to attacking the life chances of working class British workers already here.

So much for Labour in power.

Edited by Stirlingsays (11 May 2014 1.14pm)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Stirlingsays Flag 11 May 14 12.50pm

Cameron says that he won't be Prime Minister in the new elections if he isn't given the right to have an 'in out' vote.

.....This is a change...This is perhaps worth thinking about.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

The White Horse Flag 11 May 14 1.56pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 11 May 2014 12.46pm

Like most people the situation I would regard as fair is an economy which provided enough well paid jobs to provide people a reasonable standard of living.

I'd suggest that's achievable irrespective of the rates of immigration we have experienced and are experiencing in the UK.

Quote Stirlingsays at 11 May 2014 12.46pm

That means maintaining a balance between number of jobs and possible workers for them......Something this country is absolutely useless at doing.

This is something the country has been useless at doing for a number of decades, even when immigration was at relatively low levels. There wasn't much immigration in the 70s or 80s and yet successive governments oversaw mass unemployment and industrial decline.

Quote Stirlingsays at 11 May 2014 12.46pm

We have a balance that is too hard for low and semi skilled workers and I'm saying that one of the reasons for that (not the only one) is that we are gaining a new population roughly the size of Southampton every year......Not all but most of those immigrants will be on the low to semi skilled areas and hence the areas that they will settle in will be affected by increased populations over and above what existed before.

Sorry Horsey what are those areas immigrants are settling in 'where workers are scarce'? Implicitly you're saying that where they are going isn't going to cause problems.

I'm not saying immigrants are settling in areas where workers are relatively scarce, I'm saying that even in areas where they're not added to the pool of workers social problems persist and are in some cases even worse.

At the risk of making broad generalisations, I think it's fair to say that the most popular areas for immigrants are London and the South East. Areas like the South West and the North East are less popular.

Yet there are more jobs in London than anywhere else in the country and average pay is higher, whilst the reverse is true in the North East. London has more hospitals, many good schools, excellent transport links and so on.

Since the economic recovery started to take hold, 80% of the new jobs created were in London, meaning that in other regions unemployment actually went up even though in the country as a whole it was in decline.

Quote Stirlingsays at 11 May 2014 12.46pm

I've was a teacher in Wisbech for five years..An area that you are maybe unknowingly talking about..I taught many a British college student next to an Eastern European....I can tell you that these British kids knew very well that they would be competing for jobs in town with these immigrants and more than a few weren't happy about it...And I didn't blame them...Their own government was breaking that unspoken contract that should exist between the state and subject/citizen (I work for you and you work for me). Because they are the weakest and most vulnerable they didn't matter.....Many bosses wouldn't even take on British kids when given the choice...That's the practical outcome of the idealism you support.

Too much immigration matters wherever you put it.....It's bleeding obvious that too many new people have a negative affect upon the existing population in terms of housing, jobs and community.

And I think it's also bleeding obvious that they have a positive affect upon the economy and the state of public services that more than cancels any negative effects.

Quote Stirlingsays at 11 May 2014 12.46pm

Immigrants tend to flock to areas that contain immigrant populations as we know the affect around the country isn't spread evenly....It means that British workers will face an uneven and unfair situation in those areas....Again that is the outcome of the idealism that you have supported.....Sure I don't believe you meant it but that is the practical outcome.

You saying that, if we used all the housing or if we did this differently or that is pure cop out. None of the main governments will do any of those things. So supporting the EU's open door policy directly leads to attacking the life chances of working class British workers already here.

So much for Labour in power.

It would if immigration exacerbated government ineptness at dealing with social problems. But I don't believe it does. I'd say over the last century, the times when we have had the lowest levels of immigration have been the periods during which government was most ineffective at helping the majority of its citizens prosper (70s and 80s).

 


"The fox has his den. The bee has his hive. The stoat, has, uh... his stoat-hole... but only man chooses to make his nest in an investment opportunity.” Stewart Lee

The White Horse Flag 11 May 14 2.00pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 11 May 2014 12.50pm

Cameron says that he won't be Prime Minister in the new elections if he isn't given the right to have an 'in out' vote.

.....This is a change...This is perhaps worth thinking about.

When he thought he might win an overall majority, he didn't make the promise. Now he's worried he won't, he's making it. Either he's suddenly got a new found respect for democracy or he's desperate to hold onto power.

 


"The fox has his den. The bee has his hive. The stoat, has, uh... his stoat-hole... but only man chooses to make his nest in an investment opportunity.” Stewart Lee

Johnny Eagles Flag berlin 11 May 14 2.20pm

Putting aside the macroeconomics for a second, I have a few questions for you, White Horse.

(They are genuine questions, not loaded ones trying to get you to say things I can pounce on. I'm interested in your view.)

1. Do you accept that there are some negative social consequences of immigration? (ie, consequences which are caused by immigration and not just blamed on it like, say, housing shortages)

2. DO you accept the following premise: everyone will be happier and more prosperous if immigrants integrate into their host culture.

3. Given the unprecedented scale of the latest wave of immigration (ie, the last ten to fifteen years) how likely is it that these immigrants will integrate into the host culture and what will this integration look like?

4. If immigration were to continue on a similar scale, how likely do you think that "integration" will actually mean a radical transformation of the prevailing culture within a generation or two?

5. Do you think it is legitimate for people to be concerned and even resistant to the prospect of that transformation?

Ok, questions (4) and (5) are a bit loaded, but I'd still be interested in your answers.

 


...we must expand...get more pupils...so that the knowledge will spread...

Stirlingsays Flag 11 May 14 2.30pm

Quote The White Horse at 11 May 2014 2.00pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 11 May 2014 12.50pm

Cameron says that he won't be Prime Minister in the new elections if he isn't given the right to have an 'in out' vote.

.....This is a change...This is perhaps worth thinking about.

When he thought he might win an overall majority, he didn't make the promise. Now he's worried he won't, he's making it. Either he's suddenly got a new found respect for democracy or he's desperate to hold onto power.


True...It's food for thought.

As for our other skirmish we have probably come to an impasse.

Still, I enjoyed the debate.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

The White Horse Flag 11 May 14 8.13pm

Quote Johnny Eagles at 11 May 2014 2.20pm

1. Do you accept that there are some negative social consequences of immigration? (ie, consequences which are caused by immigration and not just blamed on it like, say, housing shortages)

I think immigration probably makes it harder for society to act as a cohesive unit because cultural differences and the absence of some shared experiences exposes the nation as an imagined community.

Quote Johnny Eagles at 11 May 2014 2.20pm

2. DO you accept the following premise: everyone will be happier and more prosperous if immigrants integrate into their host culture.

I think that depends on the culture of the host and the immigrant. Some elements of culture are almost always a good idea to integrate into; learning the language, obeying basic moral rules, etc.

I think it's a bit like a new signing at a football team. Learn the language, obey the rules of the club and so on, but don't abandon everything that made you a good footballer before. Keep making curry, for example.

Quote Johnny Eagles at 11 May 2014 2.20pm

3. Given the unprecedented scale of the latest wave of immigration (ie, the last ten to fifteen years) how likely is it that these immigrants will integrate into the host culture and what will this integration look like?

I think integration is inevitable over time, since it's pretty difficult to spend time within a society without being influenced by social norms, language and so on. Obviously there will be some exceptions, but I'd imagine any community that closes itself off from the rest of society will start to suffer over time.

In a crude multicultural melting pot analogy, imagine someone's making a nice chocolate mousse and throws in a few extra ingredients. A lump of sugar, some milk, a marshmallow. Practically speaking it may take a while, but at the end of the process the mousse isn't radically different from how it was at the start because 99% of the ingredients remained the same.

Quote Johnny Eagles at 11 May 2014 2.20pm

4. If immigration were to continue on a similar scale, how likely do you think that "integration" will actually mean a radical transformation of the prevailing culture within a generation or two?

I think prevailing cultures are always changing, so it's difficult to define what constitutes radical change, but I think it's unlikely that an "external culture" would be able to affect the original culture profoundly unless there were significant parallels to begin with.

Look at the resistance to Islam in the UK, for example. There are pretty strong parallels between Islam and Christianity and Muslims have been here for decades, so you'd think it might get some traction. But people are livid that someone's prayed at a cow before it ended up on their pizza.

Quote Johnny Eagles at 11 May 2014 2.20pm

5. Do you think it is legitimate for people to be concerned and even resistant to the prospect of that transformation?

Ok, questions (4) and (5) are a bit loaded, but I'd still be interested in your answers.

If people like something and it's changing, it's legitimate to be concerned about it, but as a liberal I like to think that people should be allowed to do what they want without harming others.

Boycotting Pizza Express because it uses halal meat, for example, I have no issue with. Having St George's Day as a national holiday to reinforce national identity once a year, fine. Banning burkhas, not on.

 


"The fox has his den. The bee has his hive. The stoat, has, uh... his stoat-hole... but only man chooses to make his nest in an investment opportunity.” Stewart Lee

Page 21 of 187 < 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Topic