This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote palace_in_frogland at 18 Nov 2015 10.47am
Quote jcreedy at 18 Nov 2015 9.58am
Quote cornwalls palace at 18 Nov 2015 9.32am
Quote Hoof Hearted at 17 Nov 2015 3.54pm
Quote elgrande at 17 Nov 2015 3.49pm
Quote nickgusset at 17 Nov 2015 1.49pm
Quote dannyh at 17 Nov 2015 1.13pm
So the slimey bearded tramp has finally made a comment about the mass slaughter of innocent civillians by saying he doesnt agree with a shoot to kill policy on terrorists . Corbyn you are an utter utter spinless wnaker. if I ever meet you in public please dont be offended if I tell you so. You pathetic apologist hangwringing tawtt.
I actually think Corbyn has been naive although I understand his sentiment. Acouple of thoughts on that,and I am sure I will infuriate some on here with it.
Tragic case of mistaken identity, but no reason to adopt Corbyn's "let's talk about this" strategy when dealing with armed terrorists prepared to blow themselves up and kill/maim hundreds of innocent people.
He didn't vault the barrier. He didn't run. Complete lies. He also had a light denim jacket on. The death happened because the police messed up throughout the whole process. Edited by jcreedy (18 Nov 2015 10.22am) Could you provide your source for the above please? I think that was the finding of the IPCC and inquest. Fancy people running to catch a train. Certainly he didn't vault the barrier and was not wearing a thick or heavy coat, when he was grappled to the ground and shot six times in the head, on the floor of a tube train. More concerning maybe is that prior to this the police allowed him to get onto a bus, going towards the station.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote dannyh at 18 Nov 2015 12.12pm
Quote jamiemartin721 at 18 Nov 2015 9.25am
Quote dannyh at 17 Nov 2015 1.13pm
So the slimey bearded tramp has finally made a comment about the mass slaughter of innocent civillians by saying he doesnt agree with a shoot to kill policy on terrorists . Corbyn you are an utter utter spinless wnaker. if I ever meet you in public please dont be offended if I tell you so. You pathetic apologist hangwringing tawtt. I don't generally agree with a shoot to kill policy in any situation either, except where the situation is conflict based. Its never worked in the past, it won't work in the future. You may have to shoot, but the problem of a 'shoot to kill' policy is that 95% of the time you don't actually know with any certainity who is and who is not a terrorist, and even when you do, capture represents a better source of intelligence than death. Certainly in a situation where they're engaged in an operation and lives are actually in danger, or you've established the individual is engaged in terrorist activities beyond reasonable doubt, and capture is not possible. But as an operating procedure, its always backfired and blown up in the face of the state. Cobblers. Iran Embassy ring any bells ? The only situation where a shoot to kill policy would be enforced is where there "is an immanent threat to human life” you need to look up your Rules Of Engagement before you start telling people when and where deadly force can be used. What the Government is talking about is applying the ROE of a battlefield to civilian streets to save life. The ROE are legal and approved by NATO. If the terrorist wants to bring war to our streets then we should not have our hands tied in our response. I will repeat the point once more in case you decide to overlook it, Shoot to kill policy can only be implemented when there “is an immanent threat to human life” The SAS and SBS involved were reacting to an armed situation, where hostages had been killed. That's doesn't require a shoot to kill policy, that's UK law in a nut shell, proportional force to the situation. The Government doesn't actually need to change the laws in order to allow officers to fire on armed suspects, we've even recently established with Duggan, that they don't have to be armed, only that its reasonable for the police to believe them to be armed and a threat to life, for them to open fire (which is beyond the ROE used by NATO'. No ones hands are tied, the law is quite clear about the use of force, where a real or reasonable threat to life exists, the use of deadly force is permitted. And that applies to everyone in the UK, not just the police or armed forces (although most of us don't have access to firearms). Certainly, if I was at my dads, saw an incident in progress where someone was threatening other people with a firearm, or knife, and then shot them with his firearms (shotguns), it would be reasonable force. A shoot to kill policy is a bit different, as it permits the use of lethal force, without qualification of a threat to life. As far as using ROE, I think we'd be better off not doing so, as it would restrict the capacity for 'response' by armed police to a threat to life.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote bubble wrap at 18 Nov 2015 12.40pm
Quote paperhat at 18 Nov 2015 11.56am
Quote bubble wrap at 18 Nov 2015 11.23am
If you read his profile on Wikepedia it does say that he used is Oyster card at the barrier and walked through. It does say that he ran accross the platform to get the train but who hasnt done that. He wasnt challenged by the Police until on the train. Very hard for the officers as they were convinced he was involved in the bombings the day before and the potential for him to blow himself up. What do they do? Wait for him to ignite or take him out? Very difficult but IMO if one life is lost to save many others then that is the price to pay. He was as much as Victim as all the others killed in London in them two days. all well and good until that one life is your mother/father/son/daughter etc Dont think its all well and good as it means a life has been lost. As i said Very Difficult. Damed if they do Damed if they don't. Split second decision. Easy for some to take the moral high ground when the biggest danger they face is wiping their arse each day. Not at all, the idea itself isn't flawed, its in operational parameters and control of the operation where it fell down, badly. Obviously you have to make a decision to act, and that action has consequence, the problem was in the management and procedural operation that led to that decision being made, and the fact the police only had this solution and outcome from the start. They let him get on a bus and enter a station, and even get onto a tube platform before acting. Its lucky that he wasn't a suicide bomber.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
|
Quote jamiemartin721 at 18 Nov 2015 3.16pm
Quote dannyh at 18 Nov 2015 12.12pm
Quote jamiemartin721 at 18 Nov 2015 9.25am
Quote dannyh at 17 Nov 2015 1.13pm
So the slimey bearded tramp has finally made a comment about the mass slaughter of innocent civillians by saying he doesnt agree with a shoot to kill policy on terrorists . Corbyn you are an utter utter spinless wnaker. if I ever meet you in public please dont be offended if I tell you so. You pathetic apologist hangwringing tawtt. I don't generally agree with a shoot to kill policy in any situation either, except where the situation is conflict based. Its never worked in the past, it won't work in the future. You may have to shoot, but the problem of a 'shoot to kill' policy is that 95% of the time you don't actually know with any certainity who is and who is not a terrorist, and even when you do, capture represents a better source of intelligence than death. Certainly in a situation where they're engaged in an operation and lives are actually in danger, or you've established the individual is engaged in terrorist activities beyond reasonable doubt, and capture is not possible. But as an operating procedure, its always backfired and blown up in the face of the state. Cobblers. Iran Embassy ring any bells ? The only situation where a shoot to kill policy would be enforced is where there "is an immanent threat to human life” you need to look up your Rules Of Engagement before you start telling people when and where deadly force can be used. What the Government is talking about is applying the ROE of a battlefield to civilian streets to save life. The ROE are legal and approved by NATO. If the terrorist wants to bring war to our streets then we should not have our hands tied in our response. I will repeat the point once more in case you decide to overlook it, Shoot to kill policy can only be implemented when there “is an immanent threat to human life” The SAS and SBS involved were reacting to an armed situation, where hostages had been killed. That's doesn't require a shoot to kill policy, that's UK law in a nut shell, proportional force to the situation. They were authorised to Kill, not capture. Kill they did effectively and professionally, without any further loss to human life. There was a clear threat from the terrorists as they had already murdered hostages. Deadly force was authorised. Capture was not even on the cards. The Government doesn't actually need to change the laws in order to allow officers to fire on armed suspects, we've even recently established with Duggan, that they don't have to be armed, only that its reasonable for the police to believe them to be armed and a threat to life, for them to open fire (which is beyond the ROE used by NATO'. Another point that people are getting there pants in a twist about, if you shot someone with a high velocity rifle of significant caliber, if you got shot in the guts, the way the rounds bounce around inside you means your pretty f***ed up anyway. The only reall difference is aiming for head, rather than trunk. And no it isnt above and beyond the ROE for NATO, its the same really if you believe there to be a danger to your life or others you may open fire. ( I have attched a ROE card for your education). No ones hands are tied, the law is quite clear about the use of force, where a real or reasonable threat to life exists, the use of deadly force is permitted. And that applies to everyone in the UK, not just the police or armed forces (although most of us don't have access to firearms). Certainly, if I was at my dads, saw an incident in progress where someone was threatening other people with a firearm, or knife, and then shot them with his firearms (shotguns), it would be reasonable force. We are basically agreeing here again Jamie lad, leathel force is justified your just putting it slightly more tactfully than me, as already pointed out if've youv'e been shot with an MP5 unless you've been hit in a bodily extermity, your chances of survival are not great. A shoot to kill policy is a bit different, as it permits the use of lethal force, without qualification of a threat to life. As far as using ROE, I think we'd be better off not doing so, as it would restrict the capacity for 'response' by armed police to a threat to life. Errrrrr. No it does not that is just your sumation of the subject all it amounts to in reality is a volley or burst of shots rather than one, and possibley aiming for the bonce if the shot is on.
"It's not the bullet that's got my name on it that concerns me; it's all them other ones flyin' around marked 'To Whom It May Concern.'" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote dannyh at 18 Nov 2015 3.39pm
Quote jamiemartin721 at 18 Nov 2015 3.16pm
Quote dannyh at 18 Nov 2015 12.12pm
Quote jamiemartin721 at 18 Nov 2015 9.25am
Quote dannyh at 17 Nov 2015 1.13pm
So the slimey bearded tramp has finally made a comment about the mass slaughter of innocent civillians by saying he doesnt agree with a shoot to kill policy on terrorists . Corbyn you are an utter utter spinless wnaker. if I ever meet you in public please dont be offended if I tell you so. You pathetic apologist hangwringing tawtt. I don't generally agree with a shoot to kill policy in any situation either, except where the situation is conflict based. Its never worked in the past, it won't work in the future. You may have to shoot, but the problem of a 'shoot to kill' policy is that 95% of the time you don't actually know with any certainity who is and who is not a terrorist, and even when you do, capture represents a better source of intelligence than death. Certainly in a situation where they're engaged in an operation and lives are actually in danger, or you've established the individual is engaged in terrorist activities beyond reasonable doubt, and capture is not possible. But as an operating procedure, its always backfired and blown up in the face of the state. Cobblers. Iran Embassy ring any bells ? The only situation where a shoot to kill policy would be enforced is where there "is an immanent threat to human life” you need to look up your Rules Of Engagement before you start telling people when and where deadly force can be used. What the Government is talking about is applying the ROE of a battlefield to civilian streets to save life. The ROE are legal and approved by NATO. If the terrorist wants to bring war to our streets then we should not have our hands tied in our response. I will repeat the point once more in case you decide to overlook it, Shoot to kill policy can only be implemented when there “is an immanent threat to human life” The SAS and SBS involved were reacting to an armed situation, where hostages had been killed. That's doesn't require a shoot to kill policy, that's UK law in a nut shell, proportional force to the situation. They were authorised to Kill, not capture. Kill they did effectively and professionally, without any further loss to human life. There was a clear threat from the terrorists as they had already murdered hostages. Deadly force was authorised. Capture was not even on the cards. The Government doesn't actually need to change the laws in order to allow officers to fire on armed suspects, we've even recently established with Duggan, that they don't have to be armed, only that its reasonable for the police to believe them to be armed and a threat to life, for them to open fire (which is beyond the ROE used by NATO'. Another point that people are getting there pants in a twist about, if you shot someone with a high velocity rifle of significant caliber, if you got shot in the guts, the way the rounds bounce around inside you means your pretty f***ed up anyway. The only reall difference is aiming for head, rather than trunk. And no it isnt above and beyond the ROE for NATO, its the same really if you believe there to be a danger to your life or others you may open fire. ( I have attched a ROE card for your education). No ones hands are tied, the law is quite clear about the use of force, where a real or reasonable threat to life exists, the use of deadly force is permitted. And that applies to everyone in the UK, not just the police or armed forces (although most of us don't have access to firearms). Certainly, if I was at my dads, saw an incident in progress where someone was threatening other people with a firearm, or knife, and then shot them with his firearms (shotguns), it would be reasonable force. We are basically agreeing here again Jamie lad, leathel force is justified your just putting it slightly more tactfully than me, as already pointed out if've youv'e been shot with an MP5 unless you've been hit in a bodily extermity, your chances of survival are not great. A shoot to kill policy is a bit different, as it permits the use of lethal force, without qualification of a threat to life. As far as using ROE, I think we'd be better off not doing so, as it would restrict the capacity for 'response' by armed police to a threat to life. Errrrrr. No it does not that is just your sumation of the subject all it amounts to in reality is a volley or burst of shots rather than one, and possibley aiming for the bonce if the shot is on. I suspect that last part might not be necessary, as I don't believe that Police firearms are burst or automatic capable, but they are legally allowed to use expanding head rounds - Something only law enforcement are legally allowed to use (as it reduces the risk of exiting rounds and richochet). I'm not sure if the police in the UK still use these 'man stopper rounds' but effectively they're dum-dum rounds. But I agree, I never even had a problem with the ambushes of Terrorists at arms dumps in Ireland etc. Once you make that decision to take up arms, you can't really cry about people shooting at you when you do.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
|
I'm all for people having the right to wear what they want but I do think this is double standards, Senegal a country with a large majority Muslim population, bans the burqa and there doesn't seem to be much outrage. If a country in the West tried to do the same there would be an uproar about it. [Link] Edited by johnno42000 (18 Nov 2015 4.25pm)
'Lies to the masses as are like fly's to mollasses...they want more and more and more' |
|
| nickgusset |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote johnno42000 at 18 Nov 2015 4.24pm
I'm all for people having the right to wear what they want but I do think this is double standards, Senegal a country with a large majority Muslim population, bans the burqa and there doesn't seem to be much outrage. If a country in the West tried to do the same there would be an uproar about it. [Link] Edited by johnno42000 (18 Nov 2015 4.25pm) Should we also stop nuns from wearing their habits?
|
|
|
Quote nickgusset at 18 Nov 2015 4.28pm
Quote johnno42000 at 18 Nov 2015 4.24pm
I'm all for people having the right to wear what they want but I do think this is double standards, Senegal a country with a large majority Muslim population, bans the burqa and there doesn't seem to be much outrage. If a country in the West tried to do the same there would be an uproar about it. [Link] Edited by johnno42000 (18 Nov 2015 4.25pm) Should we also stop nuns from wearing their habits? Only sexy ones. I'm not really arguing for or against the ban just the fact that a predominately Muslim country brings in the ban and hardly a voice is raised in protest but if a Western country did so there would be a lot of protests against it. Just seems unfair to me.
'Lies to the masses as are like fly's to mollasses...they want more and more and more' |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote johnno42000 at 18 Nov 2015 4.24pm
I'm all for people having the right to wear what they want but I do think this is double standards, Senegal a country with a large majority Muslim population, bans the burqa and there doesn't seem to be much outrage. If a country in the West tried to do the same there would be an uproar about it. [Link] Edited by johnno42000 (18 Nov 2015 4.25pm) Well maybe we should look at why its not an issue in Senegal and its an issue here (esp given how few people actually wear a burqa in the UK and Europe).
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
|
Quote jamiemartin721 at 18 Nov 2015 4.36pm
Quote johnno42000 at 18 Nov 2015 4.24pm
I'm all for people having the right to wear what they want but I do think this is double standards, Senegal a country with a large majority Muslim population, bans the burqa and there doesn't seem to be much outrage. If a country in the West tried to do the same there would be an uproar about it. [Link] Edited by johnno42000 (18 Nov 2015 4.25pm) Well maybe we should look at why its not an issue in Senegal and its an issue here (esp given how few people actually wear a burqa in the UK and Europe). I have no idea why. That was really the point of my post.
'Lies to the masses as are like fly's to mollasses...they want more and more and more' |
|
|
Quote johnno42000 at 18 Nov 2015 4.24pm
I'm all for people having the right to wear what they want but I do think this is double standards, Senegal a country with a large majority Muslim population, bans the burqa and there doesn't seem to be much outrage. If a country in the West tried to do the same there would be an uproar about it. [Link] Edited by johnno42000 (18 Nov 2015 4.25pm) France did that in 2010!
Optimistic as ever |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.