You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Palace vs Swansea Match Thread
November 16 2026 11.09am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Palace vs Swansea Match Thread


Page 21 of 22 < 17 18 19 20 21 22 >
soulboy Flag Lewisham 04 Jan 17 1.24am

Originally posted by taylors lovechild

Full credit to the Campbell and Sako for showing some desire. Cabaye was the only player who managed to pass the ball accurately and once Wilf was moved to the right (why the hell he hasn't been starting there???) he was a threat. Aside from that it was woeful. It strikes me that perhaps sacking Pardew was not a popular decision with the first XI; of course they need to suck it up and show some desire now.

Unless Kelly has been hiding something from us he needs to go. Go away. He is a truly awful fullback. Even the bottom teams just look at our team and go "attack the wings and ye shall score!" And they do. Every game.

We need some strong characters in the team. McArthur will be key and hopefully if Remy stays fit and Bentenke isn't too badly hurt then we can find some threat. The first half was probably the worst performance in four years and I'm not blaming Allardyce, but there was no spirit, which despite all the problems was not something we were missing under Pardew.

Screw the FA Cup and lets build and recover for West Ham.

Excluding your comments about Benteke, I agree with you but Benteke is a waste of space in my opinion, doesn't effectively challenge, can't hold up the ball and his passing is atrocious...oh, and he fouls far too often. Sako was a breath of fresh air and actually lifted the team and let's face it he's a Championship player at best. Ship out Benteke and Townsend asap.

 


"Deviance is a freedom enjoyed in a city of lightly engaged strangers"

JonJon Blazino Flag 04 Jan 17 2.07am

What did the commentators on TV say about Wilf's goal?
It was amazing right?

 

DutchEagleJohan Flag Vlissingen, Netherlands 04 Jan 17 5.00am

Originally posted by robdave2k

On the bright side we conceded 3 less than last time we played Swansea.

This sits firmly at Pardew's door, though questions have to be asked why he was allowed to carry on for so long.

No wonder the players look like they wanted Pardew, the fitness levels are shocking.

Major surgery required, I know which of Pardew and Big Sam I'd hand my money too and expect them to sign a decent player (ignoring comments about skimming)

To all those doubting BFS there is a reason he has never been relegated and a reason Palace never seemed to beat his teams. They tend to be well setup, but Christ knows he has inherited a mess.

Jedi out not replaced
Bolasie out replaced with a lazy, sulking prima Donna
Murray out with replacement
Gayle out without replacement

Granted Benteke has come in, but neither he nor Cabaye have set the world alight.

This isn't Sam's team. Underperforming, on a bad run, unfit, lacking confidence - these are all hallmarks of how Pardew leaves a club.

Will never forget with Pardew the playoff year and him having "the academy" stamped all over the West Ham staff tops. All about the image, whereas Neil Shipperly wasn't overly concerned with image and had reputation as dour, but I know which one i would want in the trenches with me. Same as with Pardew or BFS

With BFS will be no comments or decisions like

Bringing on a striker with 5 mins to go against United when you have just equalised.
No picking a keeper based on distribution rather than ability to stop the ball.
No playing Zaha in the middle and Mcarthur on the right.
No stupid comments about "clean sheets not being overly important"
No Patrick Sanogo.

Apart from Tony Pulis there is no one better for this situation, it's a dog fight, it doesn't suit a Mancini style, it's a war to stay up.

Well he plays Wilf on the left, thats f***ing worse then anything else.... And still plays Ward on the wrong side too with Kelly starting, so don't give me the "he knows how to manage" s***e

 

DutchEagleJohan Flag Vlissingen, Netherlands 04 Jan 17 5.06am

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

Kelly has been destroyed by Pardew playing him LBe week after week for 6-8 weeks. Every fan knows Ward is better there or even play Fryers there for 45 mins, but no, destroy him there. His confidence has completely gone. Looks a bag of nerves now at RB.

Edited by Rudi Hedman (04 Jan 2017 12.17am)

I really, honestly, seriously can not believe I'm reading this!! I know you desperately wanted Pardew out, but to hang on blaming him for basic poor managing (Wilf and Ward on the left) from the current chap is unbelievable. Ward is a weak link when he plays on the right and for premier league standards really poor as a LB. Kelly is just not good enough, you perhaps can blame AP for having him in the squad altogether but he certainly can not be blamed for him not being able to pass a ball over 10 yards.

 

The Dolphin Flag 04 Jan 17 6.27am

Originally posted by Kermit8

Last one out turn the lights off please to Palace's latest Premiership adventure.

The way the team operate they will struggle in The Championship too.

Four years in the moneybags Prem and if we leave it we will have achieved fvck all. Same ground, very few youth coming through and 40% of the club owned by some blokes based in America.

G'night.

Unless something dramatic happens and soon then I have to agree with you sadly.
How has it come to this. There is so much wrong where do you start.
My worry is that even with a good window it will be too late given the end of season fixtures.
I looked last night and reckon that even if we improve we are not likely to get more than 34 points and that will see us down.
We are as bad as the teams around us and despite everyone saying we will stay up with our squad I just can't see it.
Our best player is away for the next few games; our injury list is impressive; to buy we need to sell or give players away; the team spirit of yesteryear is a distant memory - thanks Alan Pardew for selling Jedinak, Gayle and Yala.
We are in the s***e and I am not sure that even Fat Sam can extricate us from it.
Very sad.

 

The Dolphin Flag 04 Jan 17 6.31am

Oh - and the purchase of Townsend has to be right up there with the worst buys of the Century.
How he has ever got an England cap I will never know - when Sako looks better than you then you should really worry!
Fat Sam finally realised that Wilf on the right is the best solution - whilst he is at it then play Ward at right back - at least one full back will know what they are doing then.
Finally - Frazier Campbell - a player I have never rated - worked his socks off for 45 minutes last night - give him a few games I say (did I really say that?)

 

The Dolphin Flag 04 Jan 17 6.39am

Originally posted by robdave2k

On the bright side we conceded 3 less than last time we played Swansea.

This sits firmly at Pardew's door, though questions have to be asked why he was allowed to carry on for so long.

No wonder the players look like they wanted Pardew, the fitness levels are shocking.

Major surgery required, I know which of Pardew and Big Sam I'd hand my money too and expect them to sign a decent player (ignoring comments about skimming)

To all those doubting BFS there is a reason he has never been relegated and a reason Palace never seemed to beat his teams. They tend to be well setup, but Christ knows he has inherited a mess.

Jedi out not replaced
Bolasie out replaced with a lazy, sulking prima Donna
Murray out with replacement
Gayle out without replacement

Granted Benteke has come in, but neither he nor Cabaye have set the world alight.

This isn't Sam's team. Underperforming, on a bad run, unfit, lacking confidence - these are all hallmarks of how Pardew leaves a club.

Will never forget with Pardew the playoff year and him having "the academy" stamped all over the West Ham staff tops. All about the image, whereas Neil Shipperly wasn't overly concerned with image and had reputation as dour, but I know which one i would want in the trenches with me. Same as with Pardew or BFS

With BFS will be no comments or decisions like

Bringing on a striker with 5 mins to go against United when you have just equalised.
No picking a keeper based on distribution rather than ability to stop the ball.
No playing Zaha in the middle and Mcarthur on the right.
No stupid comments about "clean sheets not being overly important"
No Patrick Sanogo.

Apart from Tony Pulis there is no one better for this situation, it's a dog fight, it doesn't suit a Mancini style, it's a war to stay up.

I just posted on the thread where the poster said we should never have sacked Pardew.
Our problem is we kept him too long - he should have gone at the end of last season!
I posted when Jedinak left that this would prove to be Pardew's single biggest error and I think I am right.
We miss leadership and organisation on the field. We miss someone winning those headers and putting their foot in and taking one for the team.
Yes - his detractors will say he had his faults but his plus points far outweighed them.
With him went the team spirit and more and last night really showed what we are missing.
If Fat Sam can get a midfield dynamo - amongst others - then we have a faint chance of turning it around.
We need to become difficult to beat very quickly but based on last night we could be called Capitulation Palace FC!

 

The Dolphin Flag 04 Jan 17 6.43am

Steve Parish has some really tough to decisions to make now.
I am afraid I don't know the rules but can you keep a layer and pay his wages but leave him out of the squad and it not count in the fair play rules?
If we can then to save our skins we need to just drop a few people so that we can buy.
It will cost us a fortune but might mean survival.
Being ignorant on this might mean the above is not possible?
On a positive note - CPFC are never better than when our backs are against the wall - and our back is definitely against a large wall!
On a negative note we don't appear to have any team spirit now to exercise that!

 

bexleydave Flag Barnehurst 04 Jan 17 7.00am

Originally posted by Cucking Funt

Makes you wonder if the problems at the club weren't just Pardew.

I've been thinking that for a while. Perhaps something is rotten in the state of Selhurst that we don't know about?

 


Bexley Dave

Can you hear the Brighton sing? I can't hear a ******* thing!

"The most arrogant, obnoxious bunch of deluded little sun tanned, loafer wearing mummy's boys I've ever had the misfortune of having to listen to" (Burnley forum)

slubglurge Flag welling 04 Jan 17 7.07am

What Sam said last night was telling. "I've been here 10 days and need to assess the players. I'm learning things very quickly' In other words i've got more junk here than i thought

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards robdave2k Flag 04 Jan 17 7.14am

Originally posted by DutchEagleJohan

Well he plays Wilf on the left, thats f***ing worse then anything else.... And still plays Ward on the wrong side too with Kelly starting, so don't give me the "he knows how to manage" s***e

So you put Kelly and Townsend on the left.

You may as well stamp "attack down the left at it"

Kelly is at least honest, looks like a Dalmatian chasing a balloon most of the time, but honest.

The last time Townsend did anything quickly and with a purpose it resulted in him getting a driving ban.

Ward and Wilf are better on the right, but they are also better on the left than our other options. The side needs some balance, if we had a decent left back and other winger who was performing then There is little doubt Ward and Wilf would be automatic on the right.

 

Brisbane Eagle Flag Brisbane 04 Jan 17 7.20am

Originally posted by slubglurge

What Sam said last night was telling. "I've been here 10 days and need to assess the players. I'm learning things very quickly' In other words i've got more junk here than i thought

So he's spent a month sneakily preparing a dossier on us and presumably watching all our games, then says 'We might need to go into the transfer market' and throws James Collins as a solution?

 

ParchmoreEagle Flag Belair 04 Jan 17 7.22am

This is Alan Pardew's mess. Especially his inability to have the insight to see the value of players like Jedinak, whose lack of presence IMO is a major problem. I like what I'm seeing from BFS, despite the disappointing results so far. But will he have enough time? Pardew has created a timid, unconfident, spoilt bunch of pansy losers, whose fitness levels have always been deficient because of an obviously third rate fitness and training regime managed by Pardew. I can imagine it. But with guys like Jedinak in the group the deficiencies would have been hidden, because his very presence demands toughness and 100% commitment - or he'll say something...with that steely look in his eye.

I hope BFS has enough time. Not looking forward to passing Brighton on the way down - that should be enough motivation, but probably not for these players.

 


[Link]

bexleydave Flag Barnehurst 04 Jan 17 7.25am

Originally posted by the silurian

No, we need to let Bolton win, we need a cup run like a hole in the head....Play all kids at Bolton, we can't afford injuries

In the circumstances I'm not sure that would be the best tactic. Allardyce has a fortnight without PL football to begin to really stamp his authority on the team and Bolton is the ideal match to really experiment with formation and tactics, because the result is unimportant. Play a whole load of bods who are never going to feature in the PL and he'll learn nothing. Far more productive to treat it as a training match.

 


Bexley Dave

Can you hear the Brighton sing? I can't hear a ******* thing!

"The most arrogant, obnoxious bunch of deluded little sun tanned, loafer wearing mummy's boys I've ever had the misfortune of having to listen to" (Burnley forum)

ParchmoreEagle Flag Belair 04 Jan 17 7.26am

Originally posted by bexleydave

I've been thinking that for a while. Perhaps something is rotten in the state of Selhurst that we don't know about?

No BALLS.

 


[Link]

Savagemushrooms Flag London 04 Jan 17 7.29am

Options running out.
Dann out. Benteke slow and ineffective and now "injured". Townsend lacking direction.
Tompkins looking to be at 70%. Mandanda? Back to France (who knows?) Kelly running around like a Dalmatian chasing a balloon (brilliant analogy).
Last night's first half performance was dire. Second half better, but what goes on in the minds of our players when we equalise? We become statues. This is "the winter of our discontent".

 

bexleydave Flag Barnehurst 04 Jan 17 7.34am

Originally posted by NickinOX

The collective loss of confidence of a year of poor results?

There was a spark with the new signings, but without fixing the team's structural problems which have been obvious for over a year, the summer's signings were never going to provide more than a temporary blip. We are where we are in the table because the team deserves to be there.

Unfit, lacking in confidence, defensively awful. Those problems will take Sam a while to sort out.

That pretty much sums it up for me and I don't think there's any question about the loss of confidence.

 


Bexley Dave

Can you hear the Brighton sing? I can't hear a ******* thing!

"The most arrogant, obnoxious bunch of deluded little sun tanned, loafer wearing mummy's boys I've ever had the misfortune of having to listen to" (Burnley forum)

bexleydave Flag Barnehurst 04 Jan 17 7.36am

Originally posted by ParchmoreEagle

No BALLS.

No, that's blindingly obvious

 


Bexley Dave

Can you hear the Brighton sing? I can't hear a ******* thing!

"The most arrogant, obnoxious bunch of deluded little sun tanned, loafer wearing mummy's boys I've ever had the misfortune of having to listen to" (Burnley forum)

n wales eagles Flag llandudno 04 Jan 17 7.39am

Originally posted by thechaddyboy

Aside from an occasional adequate save I'm at a loss as to why WH is preferred to Jules. WH doesn't seem to have any command of his area & very little else to be honest. Being the Welsh No.1 shows what little choice they have.


What the help does the fact that he's Welsh number one have anything to do with his ability as opposed to the Argentine number 3 or4th choice (a big fan of Jules though)
IMO his performances this season has been better than steves and certainly better than many outfield superstars oh and from memory did quite a good job in the Euros

Edited by n wales eagles (04 Jan 2017 7.45am)

 

slubglurge Flag welling 04 Jan 17 7.43am

Originally posted by Brisbane Eagle

So he's spent a month sneakily preparing a dossier on us and presumably watching all our games, then says 'We might need to go into the transfer market' and throws James Collins as a solution?

Preparing a dossier yes but he don't know the players characters and whether they will respond to the fight. I think he knows now though. I can see him trying to offload Townsend who seems to have poisoned the dressing room

 

Page 21 of 22 < 17 18 19 20 21 22 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Palace vs Swansea Match Thread