This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by jamiemartin721
The greater good, being what? Its not most people think that every police shooting is unjustified or indefensible, they just want the ones that are properly handled. Because the greater good, isn't going to be achievable when people respond to the police as being a threat to their lives, rather than the people who are supposed to protect them. As for 'other issues'. Really, because the issue of gangs and urban failure in the US seems pretty prevalent to me: its not like the war on drugs isn't covered, or the problems of addiction, gangs and poverty in failed towns and cities isn't well documented and known. I think we agree that state police have to be subject to proper discipline for criminal behaviour but with the understanding of the limits of the human condition when faced with threat. All the training in the world won't prepare you for a real situation, especially if you are a rookie. The rotten apples have to be removed without killing the tree because a lot of police effectivenes relies on morale. THat is the greater good and one that effects the vast majority. Edited by Hrolf The Ganger (29 Sep 2017 1.54pm)
|
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
The sort of antagonism they project just alienates those who might be sympathetic. Across the US in 2015, 134 police officers died in the line of duty, of which 64 were shot and killed (53 died in road traffic accidents). There are around 900,000 police officers in the US. This was a ten year high, because it involved the Baton Rouge and Dallas shooting / ambushes, including those ambushes, a total of 21 police officers were killed in premeditated incidents (up from 8 the previous year due to the Dallas and Baton Rouge 'revenge attacks' At least two were shot and killed by other police officers in accidents. I couldn't find any details on Officers shot and killed by black males. However in the previous year, of the 41 officers killed in criminal actions, 29 were white. But realistically, police deaths from criminal actions are remarkably low, given in most years they're more at risk from driving a car. Which doesn't really justify a basis of 'shoot on sense of threat'
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
I think we agree that state police have to be subject to proper discipline for criminal behaviour but with the understanding of the limits of the human condition when faced with threat. All the training in the world won't prepare you for a real situation, especially if you are a rookie. The rotten apples have to be removed without killing the tree because a lot of police effectivenes relies on morale. THat is the greater good and one that effects the vast majority. Edited by Hrolf The Ganger (29 Sep 2017 1.54pm) The problem with metaphors about rot, is that if you don't, it spreads to everything. Morale of police officers shouldn't be lowered by holding police officers accountable for criminal actions or properly investigating them. Take body cameras, the police officers in generally are very pro camera, its the officers and authority that aren't. How good is morale, when everyone hates you, and first thought is that your going to kill them. 'The good of morale' doesn't justify turning a blind eye of negligence or criminality - its just continuing to allow a problem to get worse, to the point that we now experience. Arguably 21 police officers were murdered in 2016 because of the failures of police accountability and oversight that sprung up in the cases that sparked the BLM protests. How's that for morale.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
When you have so many guns in the culture this trigger happy reality is going to be there. Black criminals will shoot at Police, who are two thirds white and vice versa. Those with agendas will shout about it. Those speaking rationally about what could be done better will be drowned out....no one wants to listen to moderation when they can watch people beating their chests or virtue signalling instead. If we had a situation where the vast majority of people going around with guns were only the armed response section of the Police then we could have realities like we have here....not perfect but a hell of a lot better. But they have the second amendment and it isn't going to change. Edited by Stirlingsays (29 Sep 2017 1.52pm) How common is that though, or how much of that stems from media fiction? Bearing in mind that usually when the police turn up, criminals tend to flee, ditch weapons or escape. There were, in 2015, 8 police officers in the US, killed in deliberate police ambushes. 29 White police officers in total were shot and killed in 2015. Either all these black men shooting at police are terrible shots, or they're not all that prevalent. Of note in 2016 British police fired 7 shots, in total, including Northern Ireland.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
|
Originally posted by jamiemartin721
Across the US in 2015, 134 police officers died in the line of duty, of which 64 were shot and killed (53 died in road traffic accidents). There are around 900,000 police officers in the US. This was a ten year high, because it involved the Baton Rouge and Dallas shooting / ambushes, including those ambushes, a total of 21 police officers were killed in premeditated incidents (up from 8 the previous year due to the Dallas and Baton Rouge 'revenge attacks' At least two were shot and killed by other police officers in accidents. I couldn't find any details on Officers shot and killed by black males. However in the previous year, of the 41 officers killed in criminal actions, 29 were white. But realistically, police deaths from criminal actions are remarkably low, given in most years they're more at risk from driving a car. Which doesn't really justify a basis of 'shoot on sense of threat' Had it occured to you that their tactics when dealing with suspects has keep the number of police deaths down?
|
|
|
Originally posted by jamiemartin721
The problem with metaphors about rot, is that if you don't, it spreads to everything. Morale of police officers shouldn't be lowered by holding police officers accountable for criminal actions or properly investigating them. Take body cameras, the police officers in generally are very pro camera, its the officers and authority that aren't. How good is morale, when everyone hates you, and first thought is that your going to kill them. 'The good of morale' doesn't justify turning a blind eye of negligence or criminality - its just continuing to allow a problem to get worse, to the point that we now experience. Arguably 21 police officers were murdered in 2016 because of the failures of police accountability and oversight that sprung up in the cases that sparked the BLM protests. How's that for morale. They were killed by murdering b******s with no justification whatsoever. They were random police doing a job. There is an us and them culture among some officers dealing with hardened criminals I'm sure and this is probably recognised by the top brass. When an officer is killed, there is a sense of group loss ands I'm sure there is a mentality among some who have seen a lot of action that they would rather a suspect was shot than one of them no matter what . It ain't right but it is understandable. Given that, morale could be damaged if influencial officers feel that they can't protect themselves. Clearly some take that shoot first mentality too far but in the majority of cases I'm sure they act within the rules as can be applied practically.
|
|
|
Originally posted by wordup
Peaceful protest is of course outrageous and national news. With that in mind it's predictable that now even being 'very critical' of the current administration on facebook or being one of thousands to visit just a protest page gets the department of justice demanding your personal details. It ain't the protest, it is who is doing it and when. Edited by Hrolf The Ganger (29 Sep 2017 3.32pm)
|
|
| nickgusset |
|
|---|---|
|
|
|
| wordup |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
It ain't the protest, it is who is doing it and when. Edited by Hrolf The Ganger (29 Sep 2017 3.32pm) Just as you have to ask yourself the same thing about a president magnifying the issue massively for no good reason, and with inflammatory language in his Alabama speech. If we only ever judge the creation of a wedge as how minorities act, or how they respond to attacks, then that does not much help matters either. It is hard to imagine a different response based on the presidents input. Edited by wordup (29 Sep 2017 3.40pm)
|
|
|
Originally posted by nickgusset
Yeah some great comments by lovely people below the video. I'd say he thought the guy might have had a gun in the car. Easy to say he was a knob when you weren't there. He probably saw an in house video anout how to get yourself killed in the line of duty and this sort of scinario was in it. Just guessing.
|
|
|
Originally posted by wordup
Just as you have to ask yourself the same thing about a president magnifying the issue massively for no good reason, and with inflammatory language in his Alabama speech. If we only ever judge the creation of a wedge as how minorities act or respond, then that does not much help matters either. We need to balance the two.
|
|
| wordup |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
For someone who's spent the thread attacking NFL players protesting, it's not an especially thoughtful response to say 'he can do what he likes'. Yes, so can they, so can you, so can I. Point being? If you're the president, and you go to a somewhat.. racially unenlightened shall we say.. state like Alabama to start ranting about nfl sons of bitches, you are not out to unite. You are out to racially inflame and the response was likely what he expected and hoped for. Your argument seems to be 'who cares, he wons, he's appealing to his populist base', but that others outside of that need to explain their behaviour at every step or are wrong to act or react. To believe that NFL players have a responsibility to others but the president doesn't, goes to show what an unsustainable place we've found ourselves in. Edited by wordup (29 Sep 2017 4.25pm)
|
|
|
Originally posted by jamiemartin721
In some situations yes, that's reasonable. But the problem here isn't that 'some situations', its in situations where the threat is low (or over, and in some non-existent) and the response is lethal force. However, if your response to feeling in danger is to just shoot someone, in no way should you be a police officer. We wouldn't expect the police in the UK, when reacting to a call, to just steam straight in and start battering people who might be a threat with a truncheon - unless its all kicked off (and even then if you watch footage of how British police deal with armed suspects, you'll see that they tend to control the situation, and de-escalate it, rather than shoot someone). Sure the UK sees much less gun crime. But the UK firearms SO18 teams rarely have ever shot an unarmed person, and even then they've tended to be people that it was very reasonable to believe they possessed a firearm. F**k me, unarmed police officers in the UK are still the first usually on the scene when there is reports of a gun or shots fired, and still the number of police officers shot or killed in the line of duty is remarkably low. In no society should it be acceptable for police officers to be shooting unarmed people, without independent adjudication of their actions. Especially true when affecting or responding to very low level threat incidents. Cops who's instinct is to shoot first and then worry about it, shouldn't be working as police officers. The police has to be a highly trained, professional. Its not really about black or white, or culture - its about the standards and quality of the policing. I think I'd agree with all of that other than this point that you keep making....You make it for understandable reasons but I just don't how it's realistic for the US environment. 'The police has to be a highly trained, professional' Oh that money? For that number of required people? Doing that job? Well, for a normal job you can train someone to be a professional.....But when you bring in regular life and death situations due to guns, like as happens in the US......You can't really train that for that easily.....The ability to act calmly under high stress is to a certain extent genetic.....You need too many people in Policing for that level of expectation.....You want the top level to be the base line....Not possible. You have to be realistic. Where are the middle classes in the Police forces? They aren't sending their kids in are they? I wonder why. Now.....When they aren't facing a criminal that's likely to have a gun....The jobs easier because escalation starts at much lower levels of threat..So in the UK, fists and knifes can be countered to an extent via manpower and light wear armour....though Police die every year in this country as well. In the US with that number of guns about. I think you have to be realistic in what you expect once guns are being carried by everyone. Body cams will hopefully show where Police have....well literally murdered people and where they have cause....I'm just saddened that the tool they use is a gun....but that's because of the 2nd amendment as we know. People don't takes chances on whether they can go home to their kids and families.....There are plenty of videos on Youtube of cops being shot by criminals.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
I think I'd agree with all of that other than this point that you keep making....You make it for understandable reasons but I just don't how it's realistic for the US environment. 'The police has to be a highly trained, professional' Oh that money? For that number of required people? Doing that job? Well, for a normal job you can train someone to be a professional.....But when you bring in regular life and death situations due to guns, like as happens in the US......You can't really train that for that easily.....The ability to act calmly under high stress is to a certain extent genetic.....You need too many people in Policing for that level of expectation.....You want the top level to be the base line....Not possible. You have to be realistic. Where are the middle classes in the Police forces? They aren't sending their kids in are they? I wonder why. Now.....When they aren't facing a criminal that's likely to have a gun....The jobs easier because escalation starts at much lower levels of threat..So in the UK, fists and knifes can be countered to an extent via manpower and light wear armour....though Police die every year in this country as well. People don't takes chances on whether they can go home to their kids and families.....There are plenty of videos on Youtube of cops being shot by criminals. Edited by Stirlingsays (29 Sep 2017 3.56pm) Not many. One was killed so far this year (Westminister Bridge Terror attack). There was one in 2015 (run over by a police car) but the next homicide of a police officer was 2013 (run over by a suspect) and two were shot and killed in 2012 (another one died off duty, and one collapsed and died in a foot pursuit). But it had been five years since a UK police officer had been murdered in the line of duty (2007 - Stabbed) Its actually quite rare indeed for British Police Officers to be killed by criminals (except indirectly). Money - bingo. And here in lies the problem when you keep cutting taxes to win elections. You get a s**t police force, who have to take who they can get, and have minimal training. People are taking chances whether they can go home to their wives and kids, everytime the police ask them to pull over.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
Actually, no he can't. The president, cannot, for example, legally call on private companies to sack someone - There is quite a few things a president cannot do, that is protect speech for other people (he cannot endorse particular businesses for example).
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
|
Originally posted by wordup
For someone who's spent the thread attacking NFL players protesting, it's not an especially thoughtful response to say 'he can do what he likes'. Yes, so can they, so can you, so can I. Point being? If you're the president, and you go to a somewhat.. racially unenlightened shall we say.. state like Alabama to start ranting about nfl sons of bitches, you are not out to unite. You are out to racially inflame and the response was likely what he expected and hoped for. Your argument seems to be 'who cares, he wons, he's appealing to his populist base', but that others outside of that need to explain their behaviour at every step or are wrong to act or react. To believe that NFL players have a responsibility to others but the president doesn't, goes to show what an unsustainable place we've found ourselves in. Edited by wordup (29 Sep 2017 4.25pm) I agree that the President has a responsibility to all. He also recognises that a large part of the media is against him and very liberal in makeup. He resists that. Above all. You really can't keep comparing what a politician say with what a footballer says. That makes no sense. There is no comparison.
|
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
It ain't the protest, it is who is doing it and when. Edited by Hrolf The Ganger (29 Sep 2017 3.32pm) Black people, during a national anthem. In what way is that offensive. Taking a knee isn't disrespecting the anthem or the flag.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
|
Originally posted by jamiemartin721
Actually, no he can't. The president, cannot, for example, legally call on private companies to sack someone - There is quite a few things a president cannot do, that is protect speech for other people (he cannot endorse particular businesses for example). Accepted. I wasn't being literal. There are rules for everyone and until he breaks one, he can carry on.
|
|
|
Originally posted by jamiemartin721
Black people, during a national anthem. In what way is that offensive. Taking a knee isn't disrespecting the anthem or the flag. Really, again? This is about appropriate behaviour for sportsman who just happen to have mass exposure and use it for political ends. That is wrong in my book however many times you claim otherwise.
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.