This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Should we sell Benteke in Jan...?
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
Tipp_Eagle Tipperary 17 Dec 17 6.38pm |
|
|
after watching his post match interview with wilf , he didnt say sorry at all and said he will keep on trying for the team and himself ,big sam seemingly is readying a 32 mill bid for him in jan , tough call wether to sell him or not . on one hand he is not a very frequent scorer and i thought we looked a better team without him when wilf and andros were up front , and more solid in defence and mid field , on the other hand he is still the only fit striker we have and is very good in the air and i dont think we are getting crosses in quick enough to utilise his strengths , he is also still a young player, but in my honest opinion, if we can sell for 32 mill and get niasse ( the diving fool from everton ) and cenk or tenk whatever his name is id go with that.
oh yeah ,fcuk off brighton.
|
thegreatlardino crawley/selsey 17 Dec 17 6.44pm |
|
|
yeah feck it sell him, cos we have loads of international strikers interested in coming to us, including tunk, cunk or whatever his name is from turkey who nobody has ever seen, to take his place! even if we get a bid in excess of 30 mill from BFS who would we get to replace him? if the moons had aligned he could have had about 5 yesterday.
Edited by thegreatlardino (17 Dec 2017 6.45pm)
Sometimes I set out for Ludlow Sometimes I end up in Chepstow
|
Tipp_Eagle Tipperary 17 Dec 17 6.57pm |
|
|
and if dishes were wishes id be a millionaire, 1 goal does not a season make .
oh yeah ,fcuk off brighton.
|
Kermit8 Hevon 17 Dec 17 7.00pm |
|
|
Took me 3 hours but I just got that
Big chest and massive boobs
[Link]
|
Welsh Eagle 17 Dec 17 7.34pm |
|
|
According to Willo's contacts Big Ben will be joining the Toffees for a fee in the region of £25m in June.
|
thegreatlardino crawley/selsey 17 Dec 17 7.40pm |
|
Originally posted by Tipp_Eagle
and if dishes were wishes id be a millionaire, 1 goal does not a season make .
very true but my question is still there who replaces him??
Sometimes I set out for Ludlow Sometimes I end up in Chepstow
|
thegreatlardino crawley/selsey 17 Dec 17 7.41pm |
|
Originally posted by thegreatlardino
very true but my question is still there who replaces him?? and also unless he gets a offer that gives him a pay rise why would he go?
Sometimes I set out for Ludlow Sometimes I end up in Chepstow
|
rattus2002 17 Dec 17 7.44pm |
|
Originally posted by Tipp_Eagle
after watching his post match interview with wilf , he didnt say sorry at all and said he will keep on trying for the team and himself ,big sam seemingly is readying a 32 mill bid for him in jan , tough call wether to sell him or not . on one hand he is not a very frequent scorer and i thought we looked a better team without him when wilf and andros were up front , and more solid in defence and mid field , on the other hand he is still the only fit striker we have and is very good in the air and i dont think we are getting crosses in quick enough to utilise his strengths , he is also still a young player, but in my honest opinion, if we can sell for 32 mill and get niasse ( the diving fool from everton ) and cenk or tenk whatever his name is id go with that.
He scored circa 15 premier league goals for us last year.....for palace in the premier league, that is frequent. It’s also more frequent than Niasse and a guy from the Turkish league who doesn’t have any premier league experience. It doesn’t matter if we looked better without him, we’ve picked up more points since he has been back in the team. What happened last week was a shocker and shouldn’t have happened but it would be a foolish gamble to sell Benteke in January.
|
PalazioVecchio south pole 17 Dec 17 11.06pm |
|
|
a 'question mark' is better than a dud. Big Sam can have Benteke for 10 million. fair enough. Pardew was mad to sell muzza and jedinak.
the arrogance of benteke on that tv interview was the last straw. sell sell sell
Edited by PalazioVecchio (17 Dec 2017 11.24pm)
Kayla did Anfield & Old Trafford
|
dp Tunbridge Wells 17 Dec 17 11.31pm |
|
|
We would be mad to sell him. Can’t believe that anyone is even thinking about it. We are in a relegation fight, and Benteke has a record for helping keep poor teams in the top division.
Roy is no mug, he will have a plan for the window and, I hope that the partnership between Parish and Hodgson will get us some key people in over the early weeks of January.
The number of scapegoats over the last few months have been dreadful, but it is the squad that is too brittle, we don’t have a full squad and there are too many squad members who are not able to do a job in the first team. We need three or four decent additions who are actually going to add something, and to relieve the pressure on the rest.
Anyone who thinks that selling Benteke for £15 million is going to solve anything really needs to think again.
Edited by dp (17 Dec 2017 11.35pm)
|
Tipp_Eagle Tipperary 18 Dec 17 8.04am |
|
Originally posted by PalazioVecchio
a 'question mark' is better than a dud. Big Sam can have Benteke for 10 million. fair enough. Pardew was mad to sell muzza and jedinak.
the arrogance of benteke on that tv interview was the last straw. sell sell sell
Edited by PalazioVecchio (17 Dec 2017 11.24pm)
i agree 100 percent, lets see how many of the keep him clowns turn on him when he goes another 17 games with 1 goal.
oh yeah ,fcuk off brighton.
|
taylors lovechild 18 Dec 17 8.17am |
|
Originally posted by Tipp_Eagle
i agree 100 percent, lets see how many of the keep him clowns turn on him when he goes another 17 games with 1 goal.
The clowns who support players who play for Palace? I'd rather be a fan who supports the people who pull on a Palace shirt, than a fan who insults other fans for showing the audacity to support a Palace player who is out of form.
A 1 in 3 PL striker who has had a direct hand in (I think) 6 of our last 8 goals. Keep the faith 
|
dp Tunbridge Wells 18 Dec 17 9.20am |
|
Originally posted by Tipp_Eagle
i agree 100 percent, lets see how many of the keep him clowns turn on him when he goes another 17 games with 1 goal.
Happy to be a keep him clown.
I wonder how many of the people baying to get him sold for £10 million were champing at the bit to buy him for £30 million.
Wouldn’t selling him for a £20 million loss impact our ability to buy, given how the writing down of players as an asset works.
Edited by dp (18 Dec 2017 9.25am)
|
dp Tunbridge Wells 18 Dec 17 9.24am |
|
Originally posted by PalazioVecchio
the arrogance of benteke on that tv interview was the last straw. sell sell sell
Edited by PalazioVecchio (17 Dec 2017 11.24pm)
You do know that these guys go through media training don’t you? They say what they are told.
You could argue that his answer killed the debate about the penalty against Bournemouth stone dead, leaving nothing but our great performance against Leicester to fill column inches.
|
MonsterMunch Cambridge 18 Dec 17 9.56am |
|
|
I kinda get that feeling with him. Little bit torn with him. I want him to do well, I just don't think he will consistently do it to a high enough level for us. Also wasn't too enamoured with his finger in the ears celebration on Saturday. You've got one goal mate, bit too early to be given it back to us.
|
MKCPFC Spain/MK 18 Dec 17 10.10am |
|
|
Any of the bottom ten teams would want Benteke.
If we did not have him , we would be excited at the prospect of buying him in January.
If we sold him for what we bought him for we would not get anyone better.
Since he has returned from injury , ok he has missed some sitters, but has been involved in the lead up to a fair few of the goals we have scored and is improving and is as likely to get 10-15 goals in the rest of the season as anyone we may buy.
Mad to sell him.
|
Tyrelli London 18 Dec 17 10.11am |
|
|
We have to keep him, simple as that, he’s having a bad season definatly, but recent performances (bar the pen debacle) show that he’s getting his movement back, not looking so lazy has he has been for a while, plus he is class and for a practical point of view, we don’t have the money to go get two half decent strikers once we have sold him.
|
dreamwaverider London 18 Dec 17 10.24am |
|
|
Like Ive said before about Benteke, I don't know what is going on in his head, but against Leicester, he turned up. I wouldn't say he played a blinder, but he played really well and performed as a team player. If he keeps this up after Swansea, he is worth £30M all day long. We would be insane to sell him in January. My guess is he will score 10+ goals this season. On form the guy is international quality. I believe he has found his way back and will continue to improve. Most posters here want him gone. See sense in holding off till the summer. I believe the old Benteke is back.
|
Kermit8 Hevon 18 Dec 17 10.35am |
|
Originally posted by dreamwaverider
Like Ive said before about Benteke, I don't know what is going on in his head, but against Leicester, he turned up. I wouldn't say he played a blinder, but he played really well and performed as a team player. If he keeps this up after Swansea, he is worth £30M all day long. We would be insane to sell him in January. My guess is he will score 10+ goals this season. On form the guy is international quality. I believe he has found his way back and will continue to improve. Most posters here want him gone. See sense in holding off till the summer. I believe the old Benteke is back.
That's a 1 goal in two games ratio. Hope you are right.
Big chest and massive boobs
[Link]
|
phillanth London 18 Dec 17 10.51am |
|
|
He scored circa 15 premier league goals for us last year.....for palace in the premier league, that is frequent. It’s also more frequent than Niasse and a guy from the Turkish league who doesn’t have any premier league experience. It doesn’t matter if we looked better without him, we’ve picked up more points since he has been back in the team. What happened last week was a shocker and shouldn’t have happened but it would be a foolish gamble to sell Benteke in January.
Well said. Benteke is our only fit striker who has had a hand in three of our last seven goals. We are not going to get a replacement proven Premier quality striker like him in the January window. The best we are going to get is back up. I share everyone's frustrations with Benteke but he has shown a marked improvement in recent games, missed penalty excepted. We should calm down and be patient with him.
Edited by phillanth (18 Dec 2017 10.52am)
|