This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by derby eagle
Just for the record what is your exact definition of British and how does it differ from the legal definition? I said it within the post. It's the home countries and a few islands. I'm not referring to the ridiculous claim that because you're in the commonwealth you're British. It's a technicality and always was.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
I said it within the post. It's the home countries and a few islands. I'm not referring to the ridiculous claim that because you're in the commonwealth you're British. It's a technicality and always was. But I'm still confused as you said come from the British isles. What does "come from" mean?
|
|
|
Originally posted by derby eagle
But I'm still confused as you said come from the British isles. What does "come from" mean? The isle of Ireland is a part of the British isles. It's not the same as being British. It's a description of the geographical location. It was a nod to the cultural similarity of the Irish to the British generally. Edited by Stirlingsays (09 Jun 2018 2.47pm)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
The isle of Ireland is a part of the British isles. It's not the same as being British. It's a description of the geographical location. It was a nod to the cultural similarity of the Irish to the British generally. Edited by Stirlingsays (09 Jun 2018 2.47pm) You appear to be quite evasive by answering a different question to the one I am asking and using vague comparisons. For a simpleton like can you give your definition, in one sentence of what you believe the definition of being British is?
|
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
They were in an empire, they aren't British. The most common way people from the commonwealth become British was via naturalisation. And the extent of that immigration has been a disaster. The Irish are a part of the British Isles. It's culturally far less of a leap than what's happened.
I'm no good at quoting, so can't forensically and fancily do what you did, but let's still break down what you've said. Britain is, apparently, the exclusive realm of those from the four nations who compose it. But Ireland too, according to you, is also some kind of honorary member of Britain, an opinion I would love to hear you put forward in a Dublin pub on a Friday night and see how it went down. It is 'culturally similar', so culturally similar that we felt the need to colonise it, subject it to a devastating famine, and then, when it pushed for the same autonomy and home rule that England enjoys, was brutally repressed by the military. 'There was an Empire but they're not British'. Well, legally 'they' were imbued with citizenship, so the British state would disagree with you on that one. That the Scots only joined this empire several years after Jamaica did in 1655 I suppose doesn't refute your attribution of Britishness on Scots. If you went back to the Victorian period, or even to the late 40s, you would see maps in schools showing the 'British territories', with Queen Victoria and her predecessors reigning over British subjects from Malaysia to the Carribean. The wealth of those nations was harvested by Britain, and helped to pay for not only the grandiose lives of the wealthy, but also for the state services which we on this island enjoy today. Many were even forcibly migrated in after the war by the British government to provide cheap labour, not only in the NHS, but in every area of the domestic economy, from farming to construction. So given all this, it seems peculiar that these people are not considered British by you, even though many have lived in British territory, drunk tea, played cricket etc for generations. What could it possibly be that lies behind this? Could it possibly be that these people happen to have been born with a different skin colour to, say, the Irish that you are comfortable calling Britons?
What is Englishness then? You are terrified of demographic change, but most of the people who are causing this are happy being called British, English, Scousers, Cockneys and the like. They and their forefathers have contributed as much as we and our forefathers have to the economy, and probably have all intentions to live and die on English soil. Yet you find the need to claim that they, consciously or uncosciously, are 'engaged in the destruction of a homeland for the English'. This follows a very similar train of argument from the 17th century onnwards in this country, which was keen to keep the island white. Sometimes this came in the form of explicit racist arguments, such as the pseudo-science of phrenology which we introduced. Other times, like your post, it simply coated itself in nationalistic arguments around citizenship, even though as I say, we were very keen to push citizen status on to those we conquered to promote obedience. But all this is beside the point to you, clearly, as you 'don't give a crap about the past'. Well, you really should. If you have any desire to know why many non-white people are in 'your' country, you should read a book or two. May I suggest anything by Pankaj Mishra, David Olusoga, or even Akala's new book 'Natives: Race and Class in the Ruins of Empire' which will do a better job assuaging your paranoia than I ever could. Were you to read them, you would find out that, though we are not alone in our imperialist credentials, we were - not 'the best' - but the most savage, bloodthirsty and ruthless of any nation in history. We were fond of genocide - see Churchill's oft forgotten quote ' I am strongly in favour of using poison gas against uncivilised tribes'. We were deaf to any demands of democratic decision making, such as the slaves in our plantations often rebelled for. We weren't against pushing addiction on to other countries in order to plunder them, or sending war boats in to their capital when that nation tried to ban the drugs, or bombing their parliament for its resistance, as we did in China. We are now a nation on the decline, and mercifully, we are yet to be subjected by any off those newly independent nations to vengeance. Your views, however, shows how little we have learnt from our own mistakes, and how deeply ingrained racial paranoia is in parts of our society. Unless we understand ourselves, and acknowledge how and why other countries in the world see us in a bad light, we will make no progress, will become less and less compassionate and humble, and will slip further and further off the map of political relevance.
If punk ever happened I'd be preaching the law, instead of listenin to Lydon lecture BBC4 |
|
|
Originally posted by derby eagle
You appear to be quite evasive by answering a different question to the one I am asking and using vague comparisons. For a simpleton like can you give your definition, in one sentence of what you believe the definition of being British is?
I told you I had already defined it previously. Here it is again just for you: 'Being British should and does mean you come from the four home countries and some islands we have around the world'. You appear to have an issue with 'come from'. Is it really that difficult? That means you are either born here to a British parent(s). You can be naturalized as well, which I support if enough genuine allegiance is proven.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by dannyboy1978
In South Africa and Zimbabwe white people are being targeted so black indiginas people can claim their so called land back. How does the left view this? Rascist? Or does it only work one way in their eyes. Of course, when Black people want to claim their land back it's liberation but when White people want their country back, it's racism.
|
|
|
All countries, whether black or white, belong to the super rich and they seek to divide the rest of us so that we are fighting each other instead of tackling their exploitation. Britain was never our country if you are talking about working class people. My grandparents worked hard all their lives and owned next to nothing. The Duke of Westminster and his mates did nothing and were (and are) sickeningly wealthy. It was not our country, it was is is their's. The rich might be white but I have more in common with a black bus driver or an Indian nurse than I do with these super rich, white millionaires.
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
Of course, when Black people want to claim their land back it's liberation but when White people want their country back, it's racism.
|
|
|
Originally posted by davidpercival
All countries, whether black or white, belong to the super rich and they seek to divide the rest of us so that we are fighting each other instead of tackling their exploitation. Britain was never our country if you are talking about working class people. My grandparents worked hard all their lives and owned next to nothing. The Duke of Westminster and his mates did nothing and were (and are) sickeningly wealthy. It was not our country, it was is is their's. The rich might be white but I have more in common with a black bus driver or an Indian nurse than I do with these super rich, white millionaires.
I agree. Immigration is part of the grand scheme to divide us and exploit us. The left fail to see this.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
I agree. Immigration is part of the grand scheme to divide us and exploit us. The left fail to see this. As is nationalism. Feel sympathy with the person 100 miles away but not the person 200 miles away. The right fail to see this.
If punk ever happened I'd be preaching the law, instead of listenin to Lydon lecture BBC4 |
|
|
Originally posted by serial thriller
As is nationalism. Feel sympathy with the person 100 miles away but not the person 200 miles away. The right fail to see this. I'm sure you know what this means. You will have to explain it to the rest of us.
|
|
|
Originally posted by serial thriller
This, I have to say, is the first time in all my years on this site where such openly racist and ethno-nationalist opinion has not only been expressed on these boards, but afforded this prominence and apparent seriousness. It seems depressingly symbolic. Edited by serial thriller (09 Jun 2018 6.51pm) I'm not a racist, but I honestly think you are. Tell me that you are pro white and pro English. I'm pro black, yellow or any other colour. However, I am very anti England not being lived in by a majority who call themselves English. I think that is madness, as it would be for any country....a literal suicide note. There are many people who aren't white who would agree with me. Let me introduce you to one of them, Redpill Phil. Phil is a great man and black. No, I think it's you who is the racist.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by braunstoneagle
its a sad inditement of the current state of society that a racist criminal like tommy robinson going to prison can cause a protest to have the police on the run in our capital city, lets face it, as they drink more im sure it will only get worse when the sun goes down. i cannot believe how a racist philistine can have so many desciples.
For years useful idiots ignored him and called him a racist....even though, Islam isn't a race. If he had been listened to many girls would not have gone through that experience. I think people who opposed him are the philistines......In effect they enabled the rapes by creating a fear of being called 'racist' in the professions. Edited by Stirlingsays (09 Jun 2018 7.47pm)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by davidpercival
All countries, whether black or white, belong to the super rich and they seek to divide the rest of us so that we are fighting each other instead of tackling their exploitation. Britain was never our country if you are talking about working class people. My grandparents worked hard all their lives and owned next to nothing. The Duke of Westminster and his mates did nothing and were (and are) sickeningly wealthy. It was not our country, it was is is their's. The rich might be white but I have more in common with a black bus driver or an Indian nurse than I do with these super rich, white millionaires. This isn't really true though is it. People do feel ownership to the land and culture they were raised in. The working class people of these countries fought for their country in two world wars. Most went with a sense of national need to 'do their bit'.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by braunstoneagle
its a sad inditement of the current state of society that a racist criminal like tommy robinson going to prison can cause a protest to have the police on the run in our capital city, lets face it, as they drink more im sure it will only get worse when the sun goes down. i cannot believe how a racist philistine can have so many desciples. Nah. It's nothing to do with Robinson the man. It's about people's frustration at what is happening in their country.
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.