You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Topic
November 16 2026 7.42am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Holmesdale Singing Section (LOCKED)


Page 21 of 71 < 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 >
Dannyh.V2 Flag Stone lickers 30 Oct 18 11.08am

Originally posted by bicycle repair man

You have enforced my view that it is pointless to argue with a bigot.

You have further enforced my view that you have no debating skills what so ever, have no point to make other than a jingoistic outlook to your little piece of red plastic that you don't even own. You have not (can't) argue any of my points. You have resorted to name calling the last bastion of a child like mind, You accuse me of being a bigot, well look up the meaning sunshine because trust me on this one, if anyone is bigoted round here and displaying a pathetic little englander attitude it's you.

It's almost comical how you are blinkered by your own " towel on sun lounger" mentality ( or just mental I can't decide ).

I will sign off from this now as you clearly can't see the wood for the tree's.

The singing section will happen whether you like it or not.

You will have to move whether you like it or not, the club is bigger than you

The HF will be back as will the atmosphere. no one will miss you if you don't turn up, nor me or anyone else.

That's not me being nasty it's just a fact.


 

timbob Flag 30 Oct 18 11.19am

Originally posted by timbob

I can’t hear the singing section sing noooo noooo

I can’t hear a b*#*y thing noooo nooooo

I’m starting a new singing section called the palace pirates watch out for t shirts , silly hats , political propaganda ,badly spelt banners and I’ll wear all black and copy other euro ‘ultra’ supporters n bang a drum loud out of tune .....

Come on you palace pirates
Come on you palace pirates
Come on you palace pirates

We rob you of your points
We drink all your beer
In Wilf we have no fear
We don’t care if you can’t cheer

Come on you palace pirates
Come on you palace pirates
Come on you palace pirates

Palace pirates formed 2018 when the heart n singing of the Holmesdale was sadly dead

R.i.p dear staffie


 

Ginger Pubic Wig Flag Wickham de L'Ouest 30 Oct 18 11.30am

Originally posted by bicycle repair man

You have enforced my view that it is pointless to argue with a bigot.

Cobblers

(Please mods, please. I was being ironic.)

 


If you want to live in a world full of kindness, respect and love, try to show these qualities.

PZ Eagle Flag Penzance 30 Oct 18 11.33am

Parish is a hypocrite where the HF are concerned. The club state they can relocate season ticket holders but only under certain conditions (see below) Nothing about moving fans out to accommodate another group of
fans.
See also 11.1.2 of the T&C regarding a serious breach.
Seems the HF can flout these T&C and get rewarded for doing so with better seats. Will the club take action if the HF flout the no standing rule next season? Flying pigs come to mind!!


2.8 The Club may from time to time relocate a Season Ticket Holder from their usual allocated seat to
an alternative seat within the Ground where this is required for operational reasons (such as and
not limited to assisting the redevelopment or refurbishment of any parts of the Ground),
to comply with any requirements of any Football Authority in relation to any Match, or (c) the Club,
the police or any other applicable authority considers a relocation is required for safety or public order.

Without prejudice to the general nature of the above the following actions shall constitute serious breach
of the Terms & Conditions of Entry:

11.1.2 persistent standing in seated areas whilst the Match is in progress;

 


Conjunctivitis.com - A site for sore eyes.

bicycle repair man 30 Oct 18 11.36am

Originally posted by Dannyh.V2

You have further enforced my view that you have no debating skills what so ever, have no point to make other than a jingoistic outlook to your little piece of red plastic that you don't even own. You have not (can't) argue any of my points. You have resorted to name calling the last bastion of a child like mind, You accuse me of being a bigot, well look up the meaning sunshine because trust me on this one, if anyone is bigoted round here and displaying a pathetic little englander attitude it's you.

It's almost comical how you are blinkered by your own " towel on sun lounger" mentality ( or just mental I can't decide ).

I will sign off from this now as you clearly can't see the wood for the tree's.

The singing section will happen whether you like it or not.

You will have to move whether you like it or not, the club is bigger than you

The HF will be back as will the atmosphere. no one will miss you if you don't turn up, nor me or anyone else.

That's not me being nasty it's just a fact.


Before we finish our little dialogue i must say your use of the word jingoistic and phrases like "towel on sun lounger",are most peculiar.
You berate me for supposedly calling you names,then contradict yourself by doing exactly the same thing you accuse me of.
And a little bit of information for you.
I sit no where near Block E,but I can see the outrageous injustice being imposed on those that do,and they deserve the support of genuine Palace supporters who are disgusted at their treatment.
Anyway farewell......oh,and enjoy singing in the choir.

 

Painter Flag Croydon 30 Oct 18 12.21pm

Originally posted by Dannyh.V2

You have further enforced my view that you have no debating skills what so ever, have no point to make other than a jingoistic outlook to your little piece of red plastic that you don't even own. You have not (can't) argue any of my points. You have resorted to name calling the last bastion of a child like mind, You accuse me of being a bigot, well look up the meaning sunshine because trust me on this one, if anyone is bigoted round here and displaying a pathetic little englander attitude it's you.

It's almost comical how you are blinkered by your own " towel on sun lounger" mentality ( or just mental I can't decide ).

I will sign off from this now as you clearly can't see the wood for the tree's.

The singing section will happen whether you like it or not.

You will have to move whether you like it or not, the club is bigger than you

The HF will be back as will the atmosphere. no one will miss you if you don't turn up, nor me or anyone else.

That's not me being nasty it's just a fact.


Your whole argument is based on some supporters being better than others, which is fundamentally wrong.
A season ticket is sold on the basis, that it can be renewed at the end of the period for the seat allocated. If you look at big clubs that have waiting lists for season tickets, they don’t refuse to renew on the basis that other fans now want them. It’s done on a wait until the current occupiers no longer want them.
This has been the way football clubs have operated for years.
The creation of a superior fan that can have any seat they want, would not be entertained by 99% of football clubs as it is a dangerous route to take.

 

Lumsdero Flag 30 Oct 18 12.59pm

Originally posted by Painter

Your whole argument is based on some supporters being better than others, which is fundamentally wrong.
A season ticket is sold on the basis, that it can be renewed at the end of the period for the seat allocated. If you look at big clubs that have waiting lists for season tickets, they don’t refuse to renew on the basis that other fans now want them. It’s done on a wait until the current occupiers no longer want them.
This has been the way football clubs have operated for years.
The creation of a superior fan that can have any seat they want, would not be entertained by 99% of football clubs as it is a dangerous route to take.

The difference between the example you have given above and the reality of the situation is that SP and the board wish to introduce a singing section directly behind the goal.
What is the likelihood that those who have sat there for a decade or more suddenly wish to give up their seats? Slim at best.
Stating that "it's how football clubs have always operated" is not looking to the future. Things often have to change to avoid stagnating. Clearly home atmosphere across all clubs in the Premier League is poor and stagnant, at least SP and the board have the balls to break the mould and are trying to address that.

Edited by Lumsdero (30 Oct 2018 1.03pm)

 

PZ Eagle Flag Penzance 30 Oct 18 1.22pm

Originally posted by Lumsdero

The difference between the example you have given above and the reality of the situation is that SP and the board wish to introduce a singing section directly behind the goal.
What is the likelihood that those who have sat there for a decade or more suddenly wish to give up their seats? Slim at best.
Stating that "it's how football clubs have always operated" is not looking to the future. Things often have to change to avoid stagnating. Clearly home atmosphere across all clubs in the Premier League is poor and stagnant, at least SP and the board have the balls to break the mould and are trying to address that.

Edited by Lumsdero (30 Oct 2018 1.03pm)

So the club's own T & C is not worth the paper it's written on then!!

 


Conjunctivitis.com - A site for sore eyes.

Lumsdero Flag 30 Oct 18 1.30pm

Originally posted by PZ Eagle

So the club's own T & C is not worth the paper it's written on then!!

That's being slightly pedantic, this is a unique situation, I wouldn't have a hope in hell of ringing up the box office and demanding that I sit an existing ST holders seat.

 

Painter Flag Croydon 30 Oct 18 1.41pm

Originally posted by Lumsdero

That's being slightly pedantic, this is a unique situation, I wouldn't have a hope in hell of ringing up the box office and demanding that I sit an existing ST holders seat.

Then, why should others be able too!

 

Lumsdero Flag 30 Oct 18 1.49pm

Originally posted by Painter

Then, why should others be able too!

To create a singing section so we can really make the Selhurst atmosphere something special!!

 

bicycle repair man 30 Oct 18 2.54pm

Originally posted by Ginger Pubic Wig

Cobblers

(Please mods, please. I was being ironic.)

Yellow card ref !!

 

eagleman13 Flag On The Road To Hell & Alicante 30 Oct 18 4.58pm

Originally posted by Lumsdero

To create a singing section so we can really make the Selhurst atmosphere something special!!

So, its ok for others to displace existing ST holders to *Ahem* create a better atmosphere, but you wouldn't want to(or be able to) displace another ST holder in the seat you wanted.

Confused(. Com) . . .

 


This operation, will make the 'Charge Of The Light Brigade' seem like a simple military exercise.

timbob Flag 30 Oct 18 5.16pm

Handbags at dawn or centrecircle on the pitch half time entertainment for some posters on this thread...
Anyone have a song for them ?

 

Lumsdero Flag 30 Oct 18 5.16pm

Originally posted by eagleman13

So, its ok for others to displace existing ST holders to *Ahem* create a better atmosphere, but you wouldn't want to(or be able to) displace another ST holder in the seat you wanted.

Confused(. Com) . . .

So, its ok for others to displace existing ST holders to *Ahem* create a better atmosphere

In this scenario I believe so, I agree it's been handled very poorly which I have alluded to in the HF thread.

you wouldn't want to displace another ST holder in the seat you wanted.

When did I say that? I would love to be able to ring up and choose which seat I wanted on a bi-weekly basis.

(or be able to) displace another ST holder in the seat you wanted.

Correct, I am one, the HF are many. There is a massive difference there which I think you know but are choosing to ignore.

Hope that clears it up for you.

 

Palace in the Blood Flag 30 Oct 18 5.19pm

Originally posted by PZ Eagle

So the club's own T & C is not worth the paper it's written on then!!

They would be in a court of Law and I think Club would lose

 

stayloa Flag Beckenham 30 Oct 18 5.20pm

Am I missing something here? Do we want a singing section? Yes.

Does one improve Selhurst Park? Yes.

Did we have one already that functioned perfectly well? Yes.

So why are we moving people? Just because they want a better view? They asked, the club said no so they should have said "fair enough, back to block B we go". Instead they threw their toys out the pram and boycotted the place. They're not real fans...

 

RyWa Flag Beckenham 30 Oct 18 5.23pm

Originally posted by eagleman13

So, its ok for others to displace existing ST holders to *Ahem* create a better atmosphere, but you wouldn't want to(or be able to) displace another ST holder in the seat you wanted.

Confused(. Com) . . .

I think its a little different.. its clearly an issue Parish had considered prior to this season but decided against.
Then the Petition came out and got thousands of signatures so he acted on it.
Making a genuine singing section with a group that will be used to uphold it, is different to just giving someones seat to any tom dick or harry.

 

Jamesey Flag Wandsworth 30 Oct 18 5.25pm

Thanks

Originally posted by stayloa

Am I missing something here? Do we want a singing section? Yes.

Does one improve Selhurst Park? Yes.

Did we have one already that functioned perfectly well? Yes.

So why are we moving people? Just because they want a better view? They asked, the club said no so they should have said "fair enough, back to block B we go". Instead they threw their toys out the pram and boycotted the place. They're not real fans...

Perfectly summed up in a nutshell. Couldn’t have put it better.

 


Nothing is fool-proof - fools are too ingenious

Lumsdero Flag 30 Oct 18 5.43pm

Originally posted by stayloa

Am I missing something here? Do we want a singing section? Yes.

Does one improve Selhurst Park? Yes.

Did we have one already that functioned perfectly well? Yes.

So why are we moving people? Just because they want a better view? They asked, the club said no so they should have said "fair enough, back to block B we go". Instead they threw their toys out the pram and boycotted the place. They're not real fans...

The HF want to expand.

SP and the board want them to expand and have probably made promises in that respect, hence toys being thrown petulantly from the pram (poor form agreed).

Keeping the HF in the corner doesn't allow them or the atmosphere created to grow. Agreed, they could have moved existing ST holders out of the corner and introduce the singing section there instead but this would still lead to arguments like the ones taking place on this thread. Existing ST holders would still be being forced out of their long held seats in order for the expansion.

Clearly SP and the board (as well as the HF) would rather they be central, for branding reasons / Sky TV / having a wall of noise behind the goal, (for a better view of the pitch from the HF perspective i'm not so sure but cannot confirm or deny.)

The decision has been made to introduce a singing section, those making the decisions (SP & the board) see the value of this being directly behind the goal. I am sure they have weighed up the pros and cons of expanding the corner instead but have made a business decision for the benefit of the club.

That would be my reasoning as to why the decision has been made but feel free to shoot me down as I am sure will happen in due course

 

Page 21 of 71 < 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Topic