You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Crystal palace v Bright*n match thread
November 16 2026 5.41am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Crystal palace v Bright*n match thread


Page 21 of 23 < 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 >
EddieMac Flag 20 Oct 20 10.41am

Man to man I reckon we have a better team than Brighton but on Sunday they got their tactics spot on and we just couldn’t cope. Every team in the division knows how we play now so it is so easy to prepare for us. Brighton played White (a defender) in midfield on Sunday and he just sat back when we countered and mopped everything up while Roy just watched on and changed absolutely nothing.

The whole game their main tactic was to get Lamptey on the ball and attack down the right so a simple solution would have been to get Schlupp off for Eze and let him play Zaha’s free role then get Zaha back on the left wing which would have pinned Lamptey back.

Disgraceful tactics and game management by Roy and he deserves every inch of the criticism he is receiving.

 

EverybodyDannsNow Flag SE19 20 Oct 20 11.04am

Originally posted by EddieMac

Man to man I reckon we have a better team than Brighton but on Sunday they got their tactics spot on and we just couldn’t cope. Every team in the division knows how we play now so it is so easy to prepare for us. Brighton played White (a defender) in midfield on Sunday and he just sat back when we countered and mopped everything up while Roy just watched on and changed absolutely nothing.

The whole game their main tactic was to get Lamptey on the ball and attack down the right so a simple solution would have been to get Schlupp off for Eze and let him play Zaha’s free role then get Zaha back on the left wing which would have pinned Lamptey back.

Disgraceful tactics and game management by Roy and he deserves every inch of the criticism he is receiving.

It’s certainly close, and that’s why I just can’t accept the narrative that this the best we can do.

Brighton also have managed to integrate Dunk, White, March, Connolly, Alzate and most recently Moloumby, from their academy into the first team.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 20 Oct 20 11.52am

Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow

It’s certainly close, and that’s why I just can’t accept the narrative that this the best we can do.

Brighton also have managed to integrate Dunk, White, March, Connolly, Alzate and most recently Moloumby, from their academy into the first team.

Alzate was signed from L.Orient having been in their academy and Connolly was signed from a team in the Republic Of Ireland. Solly March was signed from Lewes.

Edited by Willo (20 Oct 2020 11.53am)

 

EverybodyDannsNow Flag SE19 20 Oct 20 12.22pm

Originally posted by Willo

Alzate was signed from L.Orient having been in their academy and Connolly was signed from a team in the Republic Of Ireland. Solly March was signed from Lewes.

Edited by Willo (20 Oct 2020 11.53am)

Yes, and Brighton have managed to integrate them from their academy into first team, as I said.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 20 Oct 20 12.30pm

Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow

Yes, and Brighton have managed to integrate them from their academy into first team, as I said.

I'm not entirely sure how much time these players spent in their academy.
Point I was making is that they were not players who joined their academy at a very young age like Zaha who joined our club aged 12.

 

EddieMac Flag 20 Oct 20 12.42pm

Originally posted by Willo

Alzate was signed from L.Orient having been in their academy and Connolly was signed from a team in the Republic Of Ireland. Solly March was signed from Lewes.

Edited by Willo (20 Oct 2020 11.53am)

Connolly was not signed from an Irish club. He played schoolboy football in Ireland then worked his way through the Brighton academy.

 

Den1923 Flag 20 Oct 20 12.50pm

I think I really want to forget this match, I am usually a very good supporter and appreciative of Roy but on this occasion I think the criticism is valid and especially after his post match interview when he was full of praise for the way we defended whereas as far as I'm concerned it was fairly desperate defending that you would be more appropriate and is what you would expect from a lower league side player a cup tie against a higher league team. The last two games have been awful with a goal tally of 7 against and 2 scored. As bad as the tactics were from Roy, the players also have to accept responsibility for the performance, the BBC gave us an average rating of 4.81 compared to B&HA 6.36. The last two games Wilf has been useless and he really need to start setting examples for the others to follow!

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 20 Oct 20 12.51pm

Originally posted by EddieMac

Connolly was not signed from an Irish club. He played schoolboy football in Ireland then worked his way through the Brighton academy.

I had heard he played for a youth team in Ireland before joining Brighton.

I will take your word that he worked his way through the Brighton academy - I don't tend to concentrate my efforts on expanding my knowledge to include Brighton players !

 

silvertop Flag Portishead 20 Oct 20 3.37pm

Originally posted by BlueJay

People have short memories. I've seen worse and we got something from it.

Quite. Bats been onside and the ball not deflected and we would have been laughing at how we won 2 0 and got dunk sent off without shifting out of 2nd.

 

Jacey Flag 20 Oct 20 4.02pm

Something positive to emerge from the fixture.

[Link]

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 20 Oct 20 4.07pm

Originally posted by Jacey

Something positive to emerge from the fixture.

[Link]

I could not agree more.
Riedewald was a revelation but I suspect had McCarthy been fit he would not have started.

 

Ginger Pubic Wig Flag Wickham de L'Ouest 20 Oct 20 4.12pm

Originally posted by silvertop

Quite. Bats been onside and the ball not deflected and we would have been laughing at how we won 2 0 and got dunk sent off without shifting out of 2nd.

The problem with Sunday was not Sunday. It was the pattern that emerged in games before Sunday over a long period.

If Sunday had been an unfortunate misfire amid a sea of dazzling attacking displays, this would not be being discussed.

So a better question might be: can you remember such a prolonged period of low-ambition negativity since we came up? The fact it culminated in such a poor performance against our main rival had merely added to the piquancy.

 


If you want to live in a world full of kindness, respect and love, try to show these qualities.

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 20 Oct 20 4.24pm

Originally posted by Ginger Pubic Wig

The problem with Sunday was not Sunday. It was the pattern that emerged in games before Sunday over a long period.

If Sunday had been an unfortunate misfire amid a sea of dazzling attacking displays, this would not be being discussed.

So a better question might be: can you remember such a prolonged period of low-ambition negativity since we came up? The fact it culminated in such a poor performance against our main rival had merely added to the piquancy.

We are an abysmal watch and I have assumed a repose of semi-paralysis at witnessing us churning our turgid,negative dross.

A look of instant gaseous nausea falls on my face as I see us squandering possession and just retreating into 'Shape' whilst the opponents play the ball around us.We make us much progress up the pitch as a plastic pedalo in a Force Nine gale.

Indeed a prolonged period of low-ambition negativity.We are ploughing the same acres until the rhetorical soil has acquired the texture of badly prepared mince.

 

steeleye20 Flag Croydon 20 Oct 20 4.38pm

Originally posted by Willo

We are an abysmal watch and I have assumed a repose of semi-paralysis at witnessing us churning our turgid,negative dross.

A look of instant gaseous nausea falls on my face as I see us squandering possession and just retreating into 'Shape' whilst the opponents play the ball around us.We make us much progress up the pitch as a plastic pedalo in a Force Nine gale.

Indeed a prolonged period of low-ambition negativity.We are ploughing the same acres until the rhetorical soil has acquired the texture of badly prepared mince.

Well Bats had a good goal disallowed by a fractional offside by the iniquitous VAR and that would have been 2-0 then things would have looked very different.

We would all be declaring how satisfied we were with three points and how Hodgson's tactics were spot on!!

The problem Hodgson has is are they good enough for a more adventurous approach.

I don't think we will be seeing that until we are nearly safe, that is the most teams like us can achieve against the mega-rich.

And the weed were very good, give them give credit.


 

EverybodyDannsNow Flag SE19 20 Oct 20 4.41pm

Originally posted by BlueJay

People have short memories. I've seen worse and we got something from it.

It’s the only time since Opta started recording stats (03/04 season) that a team has only had one shot in a game and that shot be a penalty.

So unless 20 years is a short memory.. it was that bad.

 

EverybodyDannsNow Flag SE19 20 Oct 20 4.49pm

Originally posted by Ginger Pubic Wig

The problem with Sunday was not Sunday. It was the pattern that emerged in games before Sunday over a long period.

If Sunday had been an unfortunate misfire amid a sea of dazzling attacking displays, this would not be being discussed.

So a better question might be: can you remember such a prolonged period of low-ambition negativity since we came up? The fact it culminated in such a poor performance against our main rival had merely added to the piquancy.

Agree - I’ve been saying since the back end of last year I’ve never experienced a period of enjoying watching my club play less than I am at the moment... we’ve had worst teams, no doubt, but I’ve never found us as difficult to watch and just generally felt it’s not worth the time.

Anyone who thinks this is about one narrow offside decision is seriously deluding themselves.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 20 Oct 20 4.49pm

Originally posted by steeleye20

Well Bats had a good goal disallowed by a fractional offside by the iniquitous VAR and that would have been 2-0 then things would have looked very different.

We would all be declaring how satisfied we were with three points and how Hodgson's tactics were spot on!!

The problem Hodgson has is are they good enough for a more adventurous approach.

I don't think we will be seeing that until we are nearly safe, that is the most teams like us can achieve against the mega-rich.

And the weed were very good, give them give credit.


All rather hypothetical.

The fact is Batshuayi didn't score and we churned out an abysmal,dire performance which I suspect reduced our supporters to slack-jawed somnolence.

Apropos the Batshuayi offside goal, he received a lovely pass from Riedewald whom Hodgson has side-lined recently and who might not have started if McCarthy had been fit.

We signed a playmaker in Camarasa and we know what happened to him, Eze has been signed but he has been benched.I suspect Batshuayi would not have started if Ayew was available.

Brighton were allowed to have the 'Lion's share' of the game due to our abject negativity.

Edited by Willo (20 Oct 2020 5.07pm)

 

slubglurge Flag welling 20 Oct 20 4.53pm

I never saw one tweet about the game from any player which is unusual. I think they all knew it was utter garbage. The players should have a pow wow with Roy and tell him to stick his tactics up his a*se

 

JRW2 Flag Dulwich 20 Oct 20 5.22pm

Originally posted by Willo

We are an abysmal watch and I have assumed a repose of semi-paralysis at witnessing us churning our turgid,negative dross.

A look of instant gaseous nausea falls on my face as I see us squandering possession and just retreating into 'Shape' whilst the opponents play the ball around us.We make us much progress up the pitch as a plastic pedalo in a Force Nine gale.

Indeed a prolonged period of low-ambition negativity.We are ploughing the same acres until the rhetorical soil has acquired the texture of badly prepared mince.

Wonderful, Willo. In your golden years you're waxing ever more lyrical. I almost hope that this "negative dross" persists so that I can continue to look forward to reading your scathing and withering opinions - which, as someone posted on Sunday, are considerably more entertaining than the "football" we're served up.

 

Pierre Flag Purley 20 Oct 20 5.38pm

Playing like that for Palace in a game against Brighton would drive me nuts!
Sitting in banks of four getting deeper and deeper into our own half-first bank of 4 on the 5.5m line and the second bank of 4 on the 16.5m line with Wilf or Bats wandering about on their own in turn near the center circle.
No wonder Wilf always thinks about leaving Palace the only support he gets is around his shins!

Only once in 97 mins did we show we had a cutting edge and that was disallowed!
I am only glad that I haven't paid to watch this stuff live this year!
We really do need to give our attack something to do other than defending, our defence 15m further up the park, Reiderwald the freedom in midfield to hit a few decent passes. The whole team to pass to one another, instead of the opposition and at least get 4-5 passes in succession, surely not difficult for a bunch of professional footballers?
Palace's OPTA stats for possession, passing etc are crap.
So what are we practicing in training shooting from distance? Set pieces? corner routines?
defending deep in banks of 4 obviously. Must queue like that in the canteen at lunchtime as well.
Ray & Roy have to try and get around to be served first!
I want to see some attacking flair, pinpoint passing, possession football and above all some shots on goal from anywhere by anyone!!!!
Fancy our chances at Fulham anyone or twill this be another dire defend fest!!!!!

 

Page 21 of 23 < 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Crystal palace v Bright*n match thread