This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Israel / Palestine
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
Stirlingsays 20 Jul 14 12.26pm |
|
Quote nickgusset at 20 Jul 2014 11.59am
What is it that, to my mind at least, makes Israel untouchable?
You would have to define what 'untouchable' meant.
Israel, or more accurately this government and its supporters are rightly exposed to criticisms for their actions.
I don't know of anyone who supports the west bank land grabs.
I don't know of anyone who supports this particular action as a particularly effective one in terms of getting anywhere.
Edited by Stirlingsays (20 Jul 2014 12.56pm)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)
|
Stirlingsays 20 Jul 14 12.28pm |
|
Quote nickgusset at 20 Jul 2014 12.20pm
You are of course right that both sides are in the wrong. However I feel that Israel 'started it' (for want of a better phrase) with the illegal settlements. One analogy I heard about the Israeli attacks on Gaza was that of a child being beaten to death for kicking someone in the shin.
The illegal settlements are in the west bank, not Gaza.
They may have performed this recent ill fitting one government nonsense (which will soon fall apart) but the reality is Hamas or Fatah have little influence outside their strongholds.
Though it would be interesting to see who Gaza would vote for if .....after a period of peace.....they were given a chance to vote again.
Edited by Stirlingsays (20 Jul 2014 12.30pm)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)
|
legaleagle 20 Jul 14 12.30pm |
|
|
...
Edited by legaleagle (20 Jul 2014 12.31pm)
|
Stirlingsays 20 Jul 14 12.35pm |
|
Quote nickgusset at 20 Jul 2014 12.20pm
You are of course right that both sides are in the wrong. However I feel that Israel 'started it' (for want of a better phrase) with the illegal settlements. One analogy I heard about the Israeli attacks on Gaza was that of a child being beaten to death for kicking someone in the shin.
'You kill one of mine, I kill three of yours'.
That's a basic of proportional response in the real world.
You hit me, I hit you harder......It's a normal human reaction to conflict.
If Hamas could hit back harder they would.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)
|
legaleagle 20 Jul 14 12.37pm |
|
Quote nickgusset at 20 Jul 2014 12.20pm
You are of course right that both sides are in the wrong. However I feel that Israel 'started it' (for want of a better phrase) with the illegal settlements. One analogy I heard about the Israeli attacks on Gaza was that of a child being beaten to death for kicking someone in the shin.
Fair point and not an unfair analogy. Though the only reason the person kicked in the shin hadn't instead been murdered in the first place was lack of means to kill rather than only deliver a kick in the shin.Each side will quote "starting points" going back well before the settlements...The insane cycle of violence needs to end. That will require (which I am not hopeful of) a serious and concerted effort by the international community led by the USA (with the USA actually becoming a force for ending the cycle of violence, not standing by and letting it carry on and on.)
Edited by legaleagle (20 Jul 2014 12.38pm)
|
nickgusset Shizzlehurst 20 Jul 14 1.37pm |
|
|
[Link]
Words fail me.
|
legaleagle 20 Jul 14 2.00pm |
|
|
Likud MP. Nutter.Words fail me too, just like they failed me when I read the HAMAS Charter for the first time this week with its insane talk of the Jews being responsible for the French Revolution, World War 2, and being bent upon taking over the world. So, now we know....the situation has some "extremists" in influential positions with some bonkers views.
Edited by legaleagle (20 Jul 2014 2.05pm)
|
Stirlingsays 20 Jul 14 2.06pm |
|
Quote legaleagle at 20 Jul 2014 2.00pm
Likud MP. Nutter.Words fail me too, just like I am sure they failed you when you read the HAMAS Charter. So, now we know....the situation has some "extremists" with some bonkers views.
While this bloke's views are unrealistic and unacceptable they do not compare with Hamas's.
I read the article.
Do Hamas offer emigration compensation for Jews when they take back Israel?.....Errrr no....They offer a bullet in the head.
Do Hamas offer Palestinian citizenship to Jews who would wish to live in a Palestinian state?....no....They offer a bullet in the head.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)
|
nickgusset Shizzlehurst 20 Jul 14 2.07pm |
|
Quote legaleagle at 20 Jul 2014 2.00pm
Likud MP. Nutter.Words fail me too, just like I am sure they failed you when you read the HAMAS Charter. So, now we know....the situation has some "extremists" with some bonkers views.
Alas it seems that the extremists are pulling the strings on both sides. Which is why I posed the earlier question about a lack of intervention from the leaders of the rest of the world. I'd almost argue that by doing nothing, they too are complicit in this genocide. And yes it is genocide because the killing is indiscriminate.
|
nickgusset Shizzlehurst 20 Jul 14 2.08pm |
|
Quote Stirlingsays at 20 Jul 2014 2.06pm
Quote legaleagle at 20 Jul 2014 2.00pm
Likud MP. Nutter.Words fail me too, just like I am sure they failed you when you read the HAMAS Charter. So, now we know....the situation has some "extremists" with some bonkers views.
While this bloke's views are unrealistic and unacceptable they do not compare with Hamas's.
I read the article.
Do Hamas offer emigration compensation for Jews when they take back Israel?.....Errrr no....They offer a bullet in the head.
Do Hamas offer Palestinian citizenship to Jews who would wish to live in a Palestinian state?....no....They offer a bullet in the head.
Because they are under occupation. Until that ends... Well you can't really blame them.
|
Stirlingsays 20 Jul 14 2.11pm |
|
Quote nickgusset at 20 Jul 2014 2.08pm
Because they are under occupation. Until that ends... Well you can't really blame them.
Now that is an excuse for Hamas right there.
Also, their manifesto calls for the killing of all Jews...It doesn't say....When we are no longer occupied we'll ease off a bit.
Utter utter b*llocks.
So presumably Fatah in the west bank just aren't quite doing enough.
Amazing.
Edited by Stirlingsays (20 Jul 2014 2.13pm)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)
|
nickgusset Shizzlehurst 20 Jul 14 2.16pm |
|
Quote Stirlingsays at 20 Jul 2014 2.11pm
Quote nickgusset at 20 Jul 2014 2.08pm
Because they are under occupation. Until that ends... Well you can't really blame them.
Now that is an excuse for Hamas right there.
Also, their manifesto calls for the killing of all Jews...It doesn't say....When we are no longer occupied we'll ease off a bit.
Utter utter b*llocks.
So presumably Fatah in the west bank just aren't quite doing enough.
Amazing.
Edited by Stirlingsays (20 Jul 2014 2.13pm)
So the Palestinians should welcome the 'settlers' with open arms?
|
legaleagle 20 Jul 14 2.23pm |
|
Quote nickgusset at 20 Jul 2014 2.07pm
Quote legaleagle at 20 Jul 2014 2.00pm
Likud MP. Nutter.Words fail me too, just like I am sure they failed you when you read the HAMAS Charter. So, now we know....the situation has some "extremists" with some bonkers views.
Alas it seems that the extremists are pulling the strings on both sides. Which is why I posed the earlier question about a lack of intervention from the leaders of the rest of the world. I'd almost argue that by doing nothing, they too are complicit in this genocide. And yes it is genocide because the killing is indiscriminate.
Nick, this is crazy to be arguing about because I think there is more that unites us than divides us.But it is not genocide . It is, however, in my view, brutal oppression. See prior postings by others. What "we" did in Iraq involved some indiscriminate killings (more than some).Bloody Sunday involved indiscriminate killing on a small scale. Shooting down the plane in Ukraine was indiscriminate killing; it wasn't genocide. If we use terms like "genocide" or "holocaust" all the time, it devalues the words.
Edited by legaleagle (20 Jul 2014 2.26pm)
|
Stirlingsays 20 Jul 14 2.23pm |
|
Quote nickgusset at 20 Jul 2014 2.16pm
Quote Stirlingsays at 20 Jul 2014 2.11pm
Quote nickgusset at 20 Jul 2014 2.08pm
Because they are under occupation. Until that ends... Well you can't really blame them.
Now that is an excuse for Hamas right there.
Also, their manifesto calls for the killing of all Jews...It doesn't say....When we are no longer occupied we'll ease off a bit.
Utter utter b*llocks.
So presumably Fatah in the west bank just aren't quite doing enough.
Amazing.
Edited by Stirlingsays (20 Jul 2014 2.13pm)
So the Palestinians should welcome the 'settlers' with open arms?
What are you talking about? Once again.
The settlers are in the west bank.....Not Gaza.
Hamas does not control the west bank.
What happens to the settlements will eventually be decided not by what is happening now.....It's a non issue in terms of this Israel-Hamas fight.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)
|
nickgusset Shizzlehurst 20 Jul 14 2.28pm |
|
Quote Stirlingsays at 20 Jul 2014 2.23pm
Quote nickgusset at 20 Jul 2014 2.16pm
Quote Stirlingsays at 20 Jul 2014 2.11pm
Quote nickgusset at 20 Jul 2014 2.08pm
Because they are under occupation. Until that ends... Well you can't really blame them.
Now that is an excuse for Hamas right there.
Also, their manifesto calls for the killing of all Jews...It doesn't say....When we are no longer occupied we'll ease off a bit.
Utter utter b*llocks.
So presumably Fatah in the west bank just aren't quite doing enough.
Amazing.
Edited by Stirlingsays (20 Jul 2014 2.13pm)
So the Palestinians should welcome the 'settlers' with open arms?
What are you talking about? Once again.
The settlers are in the west bank.....Not Gaza.
Hamas does not control the west bank.
What happens to the settlements will eventually be decided not by what is happening now.....It's a non issue in terms of this Israel-Hamas fight.
The settlers are in Palestinian territory. The Palestinians are one people. I bet you opposed the Argentine occupation of the Falklands. Regardless of this, Israeli military actions in Gaza are barbaric and inhumane. They are murdering innocents. Bottom line. Anyone who supports this is complicit.
|
Stirlingsays 20 Jul 14 3.01pm |
|
Quote nickgusset at 20 Jul 2014 2.28pm
Quote Stirlingsays at 20 Jul 2014 2.23pm
Quote nickgusset at 20 Jul 2014 2.16pm
Quote Stirlingsays at 20 Jul 2014 2.11pm
Quote nickgusset at 20 Jul 2014 2.08pm
Because they are under occupation. Until that ends... Well you can't really blame them.
Now that is an excuse for Hamas right there.
Also, their manifesto calls for the killing of all Jews...It doesn't say....When we are no longer occupied we'll ease off a bit.
Utter utter b*llocks.
So presumably Fatah in the west bank just aren't quite doing enough.
Amazing.
Edited by Stirlingsays (20 Jul 2014 2.13pm)
So the Palestinians should welcome the 'settlers' with open arms?
What are you talking about? Once again.
The settlers are in the west bank.....Not Gaza.
Hamas does not control the west bank.
What happens to the settlements will eventually be decided not by what is happening now.....It's a non issue in terms of this Israel-Hamas fight.
The settlers are in Palestinian territory. The Palestinians are one people. I bet you opposed the Argentine occupation of the Falklands. Regardless of this, Israeli military actions in Gaza are barbaric and inhumane. They are murdering innocents. Bottom line. Anyone who supports this is complicit.
Your reading of the situation is far removed from what motivates the different mindsets of Hamas and Fatah.
Please understand that Hamas aren't firing rockets because of what Israel are doing to Fatah controlled west bank. They are fighting Israel because of the blockage and these tit for tat murders......Their listed demands for a cease fire should make that clear.
If they were one people Israel would be bombing the west bank right now.
Edited by Stirlingsays (20 Jul 2014 3.02pm)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)
|
nickgusset Shizzlehurst 20 Jul 14 3.11pm |
|
Quote Stirlingsays at 20 Jul 2014 3.01pm
Quote nickgusset at 20 Jul 2014 2.28pm
Quote Stirlingsays at 20 Jul 2014 2.23pm
Quote nickgusset at 20 Jul 2014 2.16pm
Quote Stirlingsays at 20 Jul 2014 2.11pm
Quote nickgusset at 20 Jul 2014 2.08pm
Because they are under occupation. Until that ends... Well you can't really blame them.
Now that is an excuse for Hamas right there.
Also, their manifesto calls for the killing of all Jews...It doesn't say....When we are no longer occupied we'll ease off a bit.
Utter utter b*llocks.
So presumably Fatah in the west bank just aren't quite doing enough.
Amazing.
Edited by Stirlingsays (20 Jul 2014 2.13pm)
So the Palestinians should welcome the 'settlers' with open arms?
What are you talking about? Once again.
The settlers are in the west bank.....Not Gaza.
Hamas does not control the west bank.
What happens to the settlements will eventually be decided not by what is happening now.....It's a non issue in terms of this Israel-Hamas fight.
The settlers are in Palestinian territory. The Palestinians are one people. I bet you opposed the Argentine occupation of the Falklands. Regardless of this, Israeli military actions in Gaza are barbaric and inhumane. They are murdering innocents. Bottom line. Anyone who supports this is complicit.
Your reading of the situation is far removed from what motivates the different mindsets of Hamas and Fatah.
Please understand that Hamas aren't firing rockets because of what Israel are doing to Fatah controlled west bank. They are fighting Israel because of the blockage and these tit for tat murders......Their listed demands for a cease fire should make that clear.
If they were one people Israel would be bombing the west bank right now.
Edited by Stirlingsays (20 Jul 2014 3.02pm)
Has it not occurred to you that the Israeli powers that be might also be after Palestine's gas reserves... [Link] [Link]
chunkymark's latest thoughts [Link] Edited by nickgusset (20 Jul 2014 3.11pm)
Edited by nickgusset (20 Jul 2014 3.13pm)
|
Stirlingsays 20 Jul 14 3.27pm |
|
Quote nickgusset at 20 Jul 2014 3.11pm
Quote Stirlingsays at 20 Jul 2014 3.01pm
Quote nickgusset at 20 Jul 2014 2.28pm
Quote Stirlingsays at 20 Jul 2014 2.23pm
Quote nickgusset at 20 Jul 2014 2.16pm
Quote Stirlingsays at 20 Jul 2014 2.11pm
Quote nickgusset at 20 Jul 2014 2.08pm
Because they are under occupation. Until that ends... Well you can't really blame them.
Now that is an excuse for Hamas right there.
Also, their manifesto calls for the killing of all Jews...It doesn't say....When we are no longer occupied we'll ease off a bit.
Utter utter b*llocks.
So presumably Fatah in the west bank just aren't quite doing enough.
Amazing.
Edited by Stirlingsays (20 Jul 2014 2.13pm)
So the Palestinians should welcome the 'settlers' with open arms?
What are you talking about? Once again.
The settlers are in the west bank.....Not Gaza.
Hamas does not control the west bank.
What happens to the settlements will eventually be decided not by what is happening now.....It's a non issue in terms of this Israel-Hamas fight.
The settlers are in Palestinian territory. The Palestinians are one people. I bet you opposed the Argentine occupation of the Falklands. Regardless of this, Israeli military actions in Gaza are barbaric and inhumane. They are murdering innocents. Bottom line. Anyone who supports this is complicit.
Your reading of the situation is far removed from what motivates the different mindsets of Hamas and Fatah.
Please understand that Hamas aren't firing rockets because of what Israel are doing to Fatah controlled west bank. They are fighting Israel because of the blockage and these tit for tat murders......Their listed demands for a cease fire should make that clear.
If they were one people Israel would be bombing the west bank right now.
Edited by Stirlingsays (20 Jul 2014 3.02pm)
Has it not occurred to you that the Israeli powers that be might also be after Palestine's gas reserves... [Link] [Link]
chunkymark's latest thoughts [Link] Edited by nickgusset (20 Jul 2014 3.11pm)
Edited by nickgusset (20 Jul 2014 3.13pm)
I answered your statement defending Hamas's approach against Israel. Now you are expanding the discussion to what seems to be silly ideas for why Israel are in Gaza right now.
You really do believe any old crap don't you Nick.
So to do this basically Israel have to boot Hamas out of Gaza forceably. Otherwise they can't control the oil fields.
These claims aren't realistic for Israel.
If you are going to make claims such as these you really need to stand by them. Hence for this to happen Israel will stay in Gaza.
So I expect you're standing by this claim then Nick?
Edited by Stirlingsays (20 Jul 2014 3.28pm)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)
|
corkery Cork City 20 Jul 14 3.33pm |
|
Quote Stirlingsays at 20 Jul 2014 11.46am
I'll say it again.
Gaza elected Hamas. Their manifesto is a document for continual war with ceasefires for tactical reasons.
Gaza voted for this. I only have sympathy for those that didn't.
No one.....let me repeat that, no one in the west or the middle east is going to get involved between Israel and Hamas.
Edited by Stirlingsays (20 Jul 2014 11.46am) That's like saying the UK voted for Tony Blair so there should be no complaints about Iraq.
We'll never die
|
legaleagle 20 Jul 14 3.33pm |
|
|
...
Edited by legaleagle (20 Jul 2014 3.35pm)
|