You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Cardiff complaint - Could we face problems if true?
November 16 2026 12.39pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Cardiff complaint - Could we face problems if true?


Page 22 of 25 < 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 >
SloveniaDave Flag Tirana, Albania 18 Apr 14 11.19pm

Quote Mapletree at 18 Apr 2014 11.12pm

Quote Bitter at 18 Apr 2014 10.34pm

The whole sorry episode not only reflects badly on Cardiff, but also the tw@s of a BBC reporter and the BBC Sports Editor who decided it was a big news story.
I think Steve Parish hit the nail on the head when he said why give the issue the oxygen to sustain life?
Wouldn't it be great if the PL have the balls to fine Tan for bringing the game into disrepute?


I beg to differ

Great journalism. Got lots of attention for a story that was relatively BBC centred. Just because it's a load of old tosh doesn't mean the journalists haven't done their job. Since when did the truth become an important part of attracting viewers/readers/listeners. A bit of outrage certainly sells.

In terms of journalism in general, I agree. But the sports editor of the BBC had 'found' his own personal exclusive and decided to lead his own sports page with it. I expect the BBC to behave a little better than the Daily Mail, at least on its news pages.

If this story proves to be the farce it looks like and the Sports Editor, David Bond, is shown to have pushed his own agenda instead of managing his own news pages, then both he and the BBC should be brought to account.

 


Just because I don't care doesn't mean I don't understand!

My opinions may have changed, but not the fact that I am right.

(Member of the School of Optimism 1969-2016 inclusive)

norwayeagle Flag Trondheim 18 Apr 14 11.33pm

Was banned from their forum for stating that their clubs nonsense behaviour just will make them look stupid. And laughing out loud when some of them said we should be punished by deducting of 20 points.

 

Detroit Eagle Flag Detroit Area Since 1998 18 Apr 14 11.50pm

I don't want to read 36 pages of thread.....

Has it been pointed out that the BBC Sports Editor in question, who has sensationalized this whole thing, is a Millwall supporter?

FFS.

 


Detroit area Since 1998
and still a Season Ticket Holder

Seth Flag On a pale blue dot 18 Apr 14 11.53pm

Quote SloveniaDave at 18 Apr 2014 11.19pm

Quote Mapletree at 18 Apr 2014 11.12pm

Quote Bitter at 18 Apr 2014 10.34pm

The whole sorry episode not only reflects badly on Cardiff, but also the tw@s of a BBC reporter and the BBC Sports Editor who decided it was a big news story.
I think Steve Parish hit the nail on the head when he said why give the issue the oxygen to sustain life?
Wouldn't it be great if the PL have the balls to fine Tan for bringing the game into disrepute?


I beg to differ

Great journalism. Got lots of attention for a story that was relatively BBC centred. Just because it's a load of old tosh doesn't mean the journalists haven't done their job. Since when did the truth become an important part of attracting viewers/readers/listeners. A bit of outrage certainly sells.

In terms of journalism in general, I agree. But the sports editor of the BBC had 'found' his own personal exclusive and decided to lead his own sports page with it. I expect the BBC to behave a little better than the Daily Mail, at least on its news pages.

If this story proves to be the farce it looks like and the Sports Editor, David Bond, is shown to have pushed his own agenda instead of managing his own news pages, then both he and the BBC should be brought to account.


Have to agree with Dave here. The Cardiff letter was clearly given to Bond, who got a massive hard-on about it and wrote his great long piece quoting extensively, and even with the rogue Dougie text word-for-word (where did that come from?), which was followed up by all the BBC outlets - 5Live's leading sports item all day and even on the Today show for f*ck's sake!

Everybody else either ignored it or reported it in a much more proportionate way than the BBC and Bond, who appeared to swallow the Cardiff view hook line & sinker. They went full speed ahead on a non-story and now look stupid. Even on 5Live tonight they led on "Cardiff and Palace at WAR over spygate!" then when it actually came to the story all the ex-players and journo's on there said it was a load of tosh & embarrassing for Cardiff & Tan.

Tan is now even more of a laughing stock than he was, and David Bond looks an amateurish tw*t for giving it the biggun as if it was Watergate.

Let's not let it take the shine off what has been an incredible and historic season which we will all remember for a very long time to come.

 


"You can feel the stadium jumping. The stadium is actually physically moving up and down"
FA Cup MOTD 24/4/16

Seth Flag On a pale blue dot 18 Apr 14 11.56pm

Quote Detroit Eagle at 18 Apr 2014 11.50pm

I don't want to read 36 pages of thread.....

Has it been pointed out that the BBC Sports Editor in question, who has sensationalized this whole thing, is a Millwall supporter?

FFS.


Yes. Several times. For whatever reason (in the pocket of Tan, thick & Millwall, or both), Bond has massively misjudged this issue. He's made himself look a right amateurish tw@t by the weight he's given this non-story.

 


"You can feel the stadium jumping. The stadium is actually physically moving up and down"
FA Cup MOTD 24/4/16

Mapletree Flag Croydon 18 Apr 14 11.59pm

Quote SloveniaDave at 18 Apr 2014 11.19pm

Quote Mapletree at 18 Apr 2014 11.12pm

Quote Bitter at 18 Apr 2014 10.34pm

The whole sorry episode not only reflects badly on Cardiff, but also the tw@s of a BBC reporter and the BBC Sports Editor who decided it was a big news story.
I think Steve Parish hit the nail on the head when he said why give the issue the oxygen to sustain life?
Wouldn't it be great if the PL have the balls to fine Tan for bringing the game into disrepute?


I beg to differ

Great journalism. Got lots of attention for a story that was relatively BBC centred. Just because it's a load of old tosh doesn't mean the journalists haven't done their job. Since when did the truth become an important part of attracting viewers/readers/listeners. A bit of outrage certainly sells.

In terms of journalism in general, I agree. But the sports editor of the BBC had 'found' his own personal exclusive and decided to lead his own sports page with it. I expect the BBC to behave a little better than the Daily Mail, at least on its news pages.

If this story proves to be the farce it looks like and the Sports Editor, David Bond, is shown to have pushed his own agenda instead of managing his own news pages, then both he and the BBC should be brought to account.


Well yeh. As I was writing this it did occur to me that the BBC is supposed to be public service broadcasting so really should aim to be objective. But sadly it's schizofrenic on whether it is there to attract viewers and attention or to portray the news as accurately as possible.

 

Detroit Eagle Flag Detroit Area Since 1998 19 Apr 14 12.02am

Quote Seth at 18 Apr 2014 11.56pm

Quote Detroit Eagle at 18 Apr 2014 11.50pm

I don't want to read 36 pages of thread.....

Has it been pointed out that the BBC Sports Editor in question, who has sensationalized this whole thing, is a Millwall supporter?

FFS.


Yes. Several times. For whatever reason (in the pocket of Tan, thick & Millwall, or both), Bond has massively misjudged this issue. He's made himself look a right amateurish tw@t by the weight he's given this non-story.[/quote


Thanks Seth.
You saved me some reading.....
Yes, I agree, he's made himself look a right tw*t.


 


Detroit area Since 1998
and still a Season Ticket Holder

Joseph Paxton Flag Lancing 19 Apr 14 12.12am

Tan is an absolute cretin. Cardiff faithful must long to be well shot of him.First he changed The Blues to the (third rate) Reds. Then effectively constructively dismissed Malky Mackay and brought in Solskjaer who is, even talking charitably, well out of his depth managing a train-wreck of a club and now his board wants to claim we have gained massive advantage by learning their starting 11.

Absolute farce. Sympathy to the Cardiff fans.

 


Be where you are; otherwise you will miss your life.

Seth Flag On a pale blue dot 19 Apr 14 12.13am

Quote Mapletree at 18 Apr 2014 11.59pm

Quote SloveniaDave at 18 Apr 2014 11.19pm

Quote Mapletree at 18 Apr 2014 11.12pm

Quote Bitter at 18 Apr 2014 10.34pm

The whole sorry episode not only reflects badly on Cardiff, but also the tw@s of a BBC reporter and the BBC Sports Editor who decided it was a big news story.
I think Steve Parish hit the nail on the head when he said why give the issue the oxygen to sustain life?
Wouldn't it be great if the PL have the balls to fine Tan for bringing the game into disrepute?


I beg to differ

Great journalism. Got lots of attention for a story that was relatively BBC centred. Just because it's a load of old tosh doesn't mean the journalists haven't done their job. Since when did the truth become an important part of attracting viewers/readers/listeners. A bit of outrage certainly sells.

In terms of journalism in general, I agree. But the sports editor of the BBC had 'found' his own personal exclusive and decided to lead his own sports page with it. I expect the BBC to behave a little better than the Daily Mail, at least on its news pages.

If this story proves to be the farce it looks like and the Sports Editor, David Bond, is shown to have pushed his own agenda instead of managing his own news pages, then both he and the BBC should be brought to account.


Well yeh. As I was writing this it did occur to me that the BBC is supposed to be public service broadcasting so really should aim to be objective. But sadly it's schizofrenic on whether it is there to attract viewers and attention or to portray the news as accurately as possible.

Bond thought he had a big scoop and went all guns blazing on it. Huge misjudgement; nobody else gave it the time of day. I'm a big defender of the BBC but this time it's been badly let down by one of its top reporters and the rest of its sports staff who really should've noticed that this story was a huge pile of horseshi*t and spiked it before things got this embarrassing for them and their mole at Cardiff.

 


"You can feel the stadium jumping. The stadium is actually physically moving up and down"
FA Cup MOTD 24/4/16

phillanth Flag London 19 Apr 14 3.18am

Great journalism. Got lots of attention for a story that was relatively BBC centred. Just because it's a load of old tosh doesn't mean the journalists haven't done theirI beg to differ

Great job. Since when did the truth become an important part of attracting viewers/readers/listeners. A bit of outrage certainly sells.

In terms of journalism in general, I agree. But the sports editor of the BBC had 'found' his own personal exclusive and decided to lead his own sports page with it. I expect the BBC to behave a little better than the Daily Mail, at least on its news pages.

If this story proves to be the farce it looks like and the Sports Editor, David Bond, is shown to have pushed his own agenda instead of managing his own news pages, then both he and the BBC should be brought to account.


 

phillanth Flag London 19 Apr 14 3.29am

Great journalism. Got lots of attention for a story that was relatively BBC centred. Just because it's a load of old tosh doesn't mean the journalists haven't done their job. Since when did the truth become an important part of attracting viewers/readers/listeners. A bit of outrage certainly sells.


Rubbish. Great journalism is about telling the truth not paddling a nasty little smear story. This is yellow journalism from the BBC usually associated with the Mail or Sun. They even had the story above the death of Gabriel Garcia Marquez on the 10 o'clock news last night. Their reputation for serious football coverage will take a hit from this.

 

black eagle. Flag south croydon. 19 Apr 14 4.08am

Cardiff are a disgrace,they should be in the Welsh league playing Total network solutions and carphilly town,going down,going down,going down.

 

thai-eagle Flag chiang mai 19 Apr 14 5.04am

1. U're in Shakespeare class, James, did not know u had that in u.
2. Wonder if this Tan-business had got started in the first place if all the spy facts was the same, but Cardiff had won 3-0? What a twit and a huge question mark over OGS as manager. He told a Norwegian newspaper that he "felt sick about the way Palace conducted themselves!"

 

norwayeagle Flag Trondheim 19 Apr 14 5.47am

Never liked OGS. Seems soooooo nice, but he's a cynical man.

 

james03 Flag Bangkok 19 Apr 14 8.48am

Quote thai-eagle at 19 Apr 2014 5.04am

1. U're in Shakespeare class, James, did not know u had that in u.
2. Wonder if this Tan-business had got started in the first place if all the spy facts was the same, but Cardiff had won 3-0? What a twit and a huge question mark over OGS as manager. He told a Norwegian newspaper that he "felt sick about the way Palace conducted themselves!"

Thanks, appreciated (you did know I write books and am a published author didn't you?). Took me five minutes from start to finish but I never bothered to check it!

I really do believe this is going to come back and bite Cardiff on the backside.

Had Cardiff won Tan would be giving it large about how we knew their team and they still beat us - but he would not be making complaints.

 


The secret of life is honesty and fair dealing. If you can fake that, you've got it made. Groucho Marx

Forest Hillbilly Flag in a hidey-hole 19 Apr 14 9.10am

What's all this about a leek in Wales ?
Tan begins the week breathing fire, like a dragon, and screaming from the hilltops.
I bet he and the journo are now feeling very sheepish

 


I disengage, I turn the page.

bromleysteve01 Flag Bromley 19 Apr 14 9.12am

I haven't read all the posts so this point may have been mentioned! If it is true that Cardiff knew about this insider information leak before the game and they seriously believed it was going to impact the game then why did they not raise the issue and get the game postponed. Of course they didn't as they expected to win and it is trivial. However to raise the issue retrospectively now contradicts themselves as if they truly think it serious they should have reported it before the game. In business to know of insider dealing and not report it is equally as guilty and penalised as the persos who act on the insider information......... I say Cardiff to be relegated to the Welsh League where they belong

 

Eagle_SA Flag Just outside Cape Town 19 Apr 14 9.25am

"League chiefs will decide whether the complaint should be taken forward - it is understood there remains uncertainty about whether any regulation would have been breached even if the allegation was proven." - BBC Sport

The point here is that cardiff would have to have some pretty solid evidence and even if they did it's not clear if any rules have been breached.

Also on the Beeb TP has stated quite clearly that: "I log every session that I do and I'll show that I picked my team on the Monday before". So given that he fielded the same starting XI that beat Chelsea this clearly is a storm in a teacup.

 


And I see signs of half remembered days, I hear bells that chime in strange familiar ways

bearsgrease Flag cornwall 19 Apr 14 9.26am

This is totally distracting me from worrying about Pulis staying now we''ve reached 40 points. Nevermind can concentrate on the football today.

 

slubglurge Flag welling 19 Apr 14 9.49am

The only punishments than can be handed out would be to individuals and not the club. If our board instructed Moody to do what he has supposedly done, then if there are rules broken we could be liable. I very much doubt this is the case though. The are only two instances of Prem teams being docked points, Pompey for their administration and Borough for failing to fulfill a fixture, in both instances the ownership of both clubs were involved. What can they do? confiscate Moody's phone. Storm in a tan cup.

 

Page 22 of 25 < 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Cardiff complaint - Could we face problems if true?