This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Russell Brand - class warrior or complete bell end
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
Part Time James 17 Dec 14 11.18am |
|
Quote Pawson Palace at 17 Dec 2014 11.11am
Quote Part Time James at 17 Dec 2014 10.53am
Love the open letter. As somebody who works for a bank (and doesn't get a massive bonus, just like the chap in the letter) this rang some bells for me.
Taking away all my vitriol for Brand, this is a common (deliberate) misconception of the British media over the last few years. It's very convenient for high earning panel members on news quizzes to lump all bankers in together in a big evil money grabber pot and tar us all with the same brush.
As one of my colleagues in the bank often says "When people ask me what I do for a living I don't tell them I work for a bank, I say I am an estate agent that sells used cars on the side". Thanks to lazy journalism, that's how bank employees feel now.
I used to work part time for RBS whilst at uni.
95% are just average Joes earning a crust in the branch like the rest of us, it's a shame that some people feel the need to lie about it now. I know when I was looking for a grad scheme some 7 years ago it really did carry an element of prestige to it.
I earn an ok wage. I earn more than people in some professions and situations. But at no point am I rolling in cash that I personally have exploited somebody to come by. In fact, it allows me to provide a decent enough living for me and my girlfriend and frees up some spare cash to put into charities and such. I can't complain about my life or anything, but I work fork for a bank, not for the devil as some would have society believe.
|
Kermit8 Hevon 17 Dec 14 11.19am |
|
|
'bankers' and 'bank employees' are seen as two different groups, surely?
The former have got a lot to answer for. Billions, in fact.
Big chest and massive boobs
[Link]
|
Part Time James 17 Dec 14 11.20am |
|
Quote Kermit8 at 17 Dec 2014 11.18am
Quote Part Time James at 17 Dec 2014 11.14am
Quote Kermit8 at 17 Dec 2014 11.12am
The cynic in me thinks, good as that letter is, that that has been penned by someone who does words for a living - a journalist/writer? - and not by someone associated with RBS. It is just too well written.
It gives it more clout with the RBS link, of course.
Edited by Kermit8 (17 Dec 2014 11.13am)
Quite possibly true, but given that I don't expect Brand will ever see it as it's an open letter, it sort of doesn't matter. It makes some salient points that a few people might take on board. I don't expect at any point this letter will constitute an epiphany for Brand or his followers, but I still like it.
It is superb. Be even better if it were someone working for RBS. I just don't think it is.
Could be Russell himself 
You know, that thought even crossed my mind. Part of me thinks that he's had more success with his campaign as a result of the vitriol against him than from the people that agree. The people that agree with him are probably a fair bit quieter. Those that don't like him (myself included) are probably keeping this guy in business!
|
Part Time James 17 Dec 14 11.22am |
|
Quote Kermit8 at 17 Dec 2014 11.19am
'bankers' and 'bank employees' are seen as two different groups, surely?
The former have got a lot to answer for. Billions, in fact.
I think they should be, but they aren't. To the astute people that have been on this thread, the difference is probably very transparent. To the gawping idiot watching Have I Got News For You and reading "Revolution" I'm not sure it's made obvious enough.
|
| Hoof Hearted 17 Dec 14 11.25am |
|
|
My Mrs is employed by Lloyds Banking Ltd.
She started work as a PA/Secretary for Clerical Medical who were bought by HBOS and then merged with Lloyds.
A banker she is not, and gets a very modest bonus in march of a few hundred pounds.
Her final salary pension has effectively been frozen as any future pay increases will now not count towards her final pension accrual....... tell that to the firemen, teachers and any other public sector worker moaning about their pension benefits!
She hasn't complained as she feels she is lucky to have a full time job.
|
Part Time James 17 Dec 14 11.39am |
|
Quote Hoof Hearted at 17 Dec 2014 11.25am
My Mrs is employed by Lloyds Banking Ltd.
She started work as a PA/Secretary for Clerical Medical who were bought by HBOS and then merged with Lloyds.
A banker she is not, and gets a very modest bonus in march of a few hundred pounds.
Her final salary pension has effectively been frozen as any future pay increases will now not count towards her final pension accrual....... tell that to the firemen, teachers and any other public sector worker moaning about their pension benefits!
She hasn't complained as she feels she is lucky to have a full time job.
I joined the bank I work for a year too late for a final salary pension! Damn!
|
ghosteagle 17 Dec 14 11.45am |
|
Quote Hoof Hearted at 17 Dec 2014 11.25am
My Mrs is employed by Lloyds Banking Ltd.
She started work as a PA/Secretary for Clerical Medical who were bought by HBOS and then merged with Lloyds.
A banker she is not, and gets a very modest bonus in march of a few hundred pounds.
Her final salary pension has effectively been frozen as any future pay increases will now not count towards her final pension accrual....... tell that to the firemen, teachers and any other public sector worker moaning about their pension benefits!
She hasn't complained as she feels she is lucky to have a full time job.
So, because your Mrs puts up with it everybody else should? Weak.
|
Palace_Guard Kyiv 17 Dec 14 12.38pm |
|
Quote Pawson Palace at 17 Dec 2014 10.40am
Quote dannyh at 17 Dec 2014 10.28am
That is pure class.
And afrims my previous opinion that the bloke is a massive c***.
Genius indeed proper good.
Fancy paella for lunch now too.
He answers most of the guys questions about "us all being part of the problem" in this video:
[Link]
Live in Melbourne or Victoria, Australia? Support Crystal Palace?
Well join the Crystal Palace Melbourne Supporters Club: [Link]
Adelaide, South Australia? Join here: [Link]
|
Palace_Guard Kyiv 17 Dec 14 12.43pm |
|
|
He should be blaming the RBS security company for not letting him through the doors (if he had a security pass) not Russell Brand 
Live in Melbourne or Victoria, Australia? Support Crystal Palace?
Well join the Crystal Palace Melbourne Supporters Club: [Link]
Adelaide, South Australia? Join here: [Link]
|
Palace_Guard Kyiv 17 Dec 14 12.46pm |
|
|
Im pretty sure Brand targets "Bankers" like the directors & owners of banks etc....not regular Joe employees like receptionists, call centre customer service or the cleaners 
Live in Melbourne or Victoria, Australia? Support Crystal Palace?
Well join the Crystal Palace Melbourne Supporters Club: [Link]
Adelaide, South Australia? Join here: [Link]
|
Pawson Palace Croydon 17 Dec 14 12.57pm |
|
Quote Palace_Guard at 17 Dec 2014 12.38pm
Quote Pawson Palace at 17 Dec 2014 10.40am
Quote dannyh at 17 Dec 2014 10.28am
That is pure class.
And afrims my previous opinion that the bloke is a massive c***.
Genius indeed proper good.
Fancy paella for lunch now too.
He answers most of the guys questions about "us all being part of the problem" in this video:
[Link]
Juat watched it.
I kind of feel he just rants and does not fully understand what he saying sometimes.
That said it is a joke with the tax loopholes.
Pride of South London Upper Holmesdale Block P
|
Part Time James 17 Dec 14 1.28pm |
|
|
Everyone seems to begrudge bankers getting bonuses but they are happy to accept that when Scrooge pays off Bob Cratchit's mortgage using profits he's made from banking it's a happy ending. People are so fickle.
|
elgrande bedford 17 Dec 14 1.55pm |
|
|
Brilliant letter,laughed ....Nearly bought a round.
always a Norwood boy, where ever I live.
|
Pawson Palace Croydon 17 Dec 14 1.56pm |
|
Quote Part Time James at 17 Dec 2014 1.28pm
Everyone seems to begrudge bankers getting bonuses but they are happy to accept that when Scrooge pays off Bob Cratchit's mortgage using profits he's made from banking it's a happy ending. People are so fickle.
I wouldn't say everyone, I certainly don't anyway.
I never could understand how people complain about a service they didn't even pay for to begin with. I think we are one of the few countries in Europe that actually offers a free service.
Pride of South London Upper Holmesdale Block P
|
Part Time James 17 Dec 14 2.00pm |
|
Quote Pawson Palace at 17 Dec 2014 1.56pm
Quote Part Time James at 17 Dec 2014 1.28pm
Everyone seems to begrudge bankers getting bonuses but they are happy to accept that when Scrooge pays off Bob Cratchit's mortgage using profits he's made from banking it's a happy ending. People are so fickle.
I wouldn't say everyone, I certainly don't anyway.
I never could understand how people complain about a service they didn't even pay for to begin with. I think we are one of the few countries in Europe that actually offers a free service.
No, not everyone, I was being light hearted. I think you are right. The banks have talked about charging here but they need to unite in bringing it in together or they'll obviously lose custom. It may still happen one day but I expect they'll include ways around it similar to existing reward or added value accounts (e.g.: pay X amount in each month and you don't have to pay).
|
Superfly The sun always shines in Catford 17 Dec 14 3.18pm |
|
Quote Pawson Palace at 17 Dec 2014 1.56pm
I never could understand how people complain about a service they didn't even pay for to begin with.
So, people shouldn't complain about the global financial ruin they caused because they didn't charge us for it?
Lend me a Tenor
31 May to 3 June 2017
John McIntosh Arts Centre London Oratory School SW6 1RX
with Superfly in the chorus [Link]
|
Pawson Palace Croydon 17 Dec 14 3.22pm |
|
Quote Superfly at 17 Dec 2014 3.18pm
Quote Pawson Palace at 17 Dec 2014 1.56pm
I never could understand how people complain about a service they didn't even pay for to begin with.
So, people shouldn't complain about the global financial ruin they caused because they didn't charge us for it?
Eh?
I am talking about my experiences of working on the shop floor of a bank with people complaining about it, nothing more nothing less.
On a technicality, we as a society did pay for it as it was caused by toxic loans/mortgages...the interest is the charge. I also believe people who took loans knowing full well they could not afford them are as much to blame as the people who approved them. Greed is on both sides.
How much does your current account cost? Nothing. That was my point. If you pay nothing and don't like it, then go somewhere else if everywhere else is also charging nothing.
Edited by Pawson Palace (17 Dec 2014 3.25pm)
Edited by Pawson Palace (17 Dec 2014 3.30pm)
Pride of South London Upper Holmesdale Block P
|
Pawson Palace Croydon 17 Dec 14 3.22pm |
|
|
[Link]
Seems the person is a real RBS employee...makes it so much better.
Pride of South London Upper Holmesdale Block P
|
Superfly The sun always shines in Catford 17 Dec 14 3.37pm |
|
Quote Pawson Palace at 17 Dec 2014 3.22pm
Quote Superfly at 17 Dec 2014 3.18pm
Quote Pawson Palace at 17 Dec 2014 1.56pm
I never could understand how people complain about a service they didn't even pay for to begin with.
So, people shouldn't complain about the global financial ruin they caused because they didn't charge us for it?
Eh?
I am talking about my experiences of working on the shop floor of a bank with people complaining about it, nothing more nothing less.
On a technicality, we as a society did pay for it as it was caused by toxic loans/mortgages...the interest is the charge. I also believe people who took loans knowing full well they could not afford them are as much to blame as the people who approved them. Greed is on both sides.
How much does your current account cost? Nothing. That was my point. If you pay nothing and don't like it, then go somewhere else if everywhere else is also charging nothing.
Edited by Pawson Palace (17 Dec 2014 3.25pm)
Edited by Pawson Palace (17 Dec 2014 3.30pm)
Right, ok, I'm with you. I never really hear any complaints about the service though. Tends to get pipped by bonuses and economic meltdown
Lend me a Tenor
31 May to 3 June 2017
John McIntosh Arts Centre London Oratory School SW6 1RX
with Superfly in the chorus [Link]
|
Pawson Palace Croydon 17 Dec 14 3.42pm |
|
Quote Superfly at 17 Dec 2014 3.37pm
Quote Pawson Palace at 17 Dec 2014 3.22pm
Quote Superfly at 17 Dec 2014 3.18pm
Quote Pawson Palace at 17 Dec 2014 1.56pm
I never could understand how people complain about a service they didn't even pay for to begin with.
So, people shouldn't complain about the global financial ruin they caused because they didn't charge us for it?
Eh?
I am talking about my experiences of working on the shop floor of a bank with people complaining about it, nothing more nothing less.
On a technicality, we as a society did pay for it as it was caused by toxic loans/mortgages...the interest is the charge. I also believe people who took loans knowing full well they could not afford them are as much to blame as the people who approved them. Greed is on both sides.
How much does your current account cost? Nothing. That was my point. If you pay nothing and don't like it, then go somewhere else if everywhere else is also charging nothing.
Edited by Pawson Palace (17 Dec 2014 3.25pm)
Edited by Pawson Palace (17 Dec 2014 3.30pm)
Right, ok, I'm with you. I never really hear any complaints about the service though. Tends to get pipped by bonuses and economic meltdown
Sorry I didn't make it clear my mistake, we were talking about working for the bank and the public perception.
Haha NatWest where I was working was always getting complaints about long queues and crap online banking etc.
Where I found working for a bank opened doors for me, it seems it could be the opposite now which is a shame really.
Pride of South London Upper Holmesdale Block P
|