This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
When do we let the traffickers in? They'll be fleeing eventually and are obviously caring types helping people escape. They're not to know the boats will sink.
|
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote johnny the eagle at 03 Sep 2015 9.18am
Not being sarcastic,but how many of the migrants are the likes of Russia, China, U.S.A. Japan, Saudi Arabia and a lot of other U.N. member states taking in. In my mind this ain't really just a europe problem. Most of the people fleeing are not from europe are they ? So really this is a global problem the U.N. should really take control of this. Maybe they need to build centers where these family's can be looked after in safe countries bordering the unsafe countries. When the conflict is over then they can be repatriated, I know it all sounds very simple and I know it ain't but the U.N. should be involved cos it ain't just a europe problem, is it. Well you couldn't send refugees to China, Russia or Saudi Arabia, given their human rights records or the risk to individuals (both Russian and China have very political ties to the Assad Regime, whilst Saudi Arabia is a long term political enemy of Syria). As for Japan god knows probably not. The US has recently committed to taking 8000 Syrian refugees, and the UNHCR is in discussions for more allocations going forwards (for obvious reasons Syria is a bit of a hot potato for the US).
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote stateside at 02 Sep 2015 7.59pm
There are 50 % young men escaping the war in Syria, why are they not fighting for there country and way of life.We would all be marching to the jack boot if our grandperents had just run away. Our grand parents weren't fighting in a civil war. The realities of which are very different to fighting in a conventional war. Which side would you choose Assad Loyalists and Hezbollah, The Al-Nasu Islamist groups aligned with Al-Qaeda, the Kurdish alliances, the Free Syrian Army (ironically allied to five different Islamist militias) or IS. Note that the Free Syrian Army is massively outmanned, outgunned and out supplied by the Assad Loyalist forces and IS, and the Kurdish forces are really only an option if you live in those regions near the Turkish Border. For a lot of Syrians the options if they're not in the Damascus Region or Kurdish regions are the Al-Qaeda, IS or the Assad loyalists.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote stateside at 02 Sep 2015 7.59pm
There are 50 % young men escaping the war in Syria, why are they not fighting for there country and way of life. We would all be marching to the jack boot if our grandperents had just run away. Yes, because that's exactly the same. Which faction would you join. IS, Al-Nasru, the Assad Loyalists, The Kurds, or the Free Syrian Army (doomed, as they're outgunned, outnumbered and out supplied). If you're lucky enough to live in the Kurdish regions...
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote Percy of Peckham at 03 Sep 2015 11.09am
Quote stateside at 02 Sep 2015 7.59pm
There are 50 % young men escaping the war in Syria, why are they not fighting for there country and way of life.We would all be marching to the jack boot if our grandperents had just run away. Millions have fought for causes in the past but they did not have the alternative of packing their rucksack and moving on. If we keep accommodating migrants then inevitably more will follow. Surely, the only option is to take them back to their country of origin to sort out their own problems? Not a kind thing to do but it may help to provide a longer-term solution? In the past, the capacity of military destruction (really prior to WWII) to affect areas outside of the main battle fields was minimal - even in civil wars and rebellions. WWII really brought the technological shift required that meant that conventional warfare was no longer limited to battle fields, but to entire nations. Even during WW2 the capacity to target civilan population centers was limited. In a civil war, on a modern conventional level, its an omnipresent experience across a whole nation. The reality of a civil war is that its fought locally, first with different factions in local regions fighting for dominance (usually by extermination of non-allied factions and sympathisers), before becoming a conflict between different allied regions and groups on an national scale. Syria appears to be moving towards being a 'show down' between IS and its allies against the Syrian Loyalist factions with the Kurdish regions looking to secure autonomy. The Secular Free Syrian Army is sat more or less in the middle, between these two major factions.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
|
For me the issue isn't wether we let immigrants in...its how we do it. I hear all those bleat on saying Germany have taken x, Turkey y and Italy z...but if you look at the head of population per kilometre we have a higher concentration than most of these countries...which means we cant simply accept anyone in...we cant expand our borders or build more land. [Link] As it is there are already pressures on housing (of which there's already a lack), the NHS (which is seriously underfunded), Social Services (which is at breaking point). Its easy to make glib statements and jump on the righteous cause when your sat at home in your comfy chair or at work in your air con office at your computer. How many of those calling for us to let more in would willingly offer up their spare room...or have them living in your street or next door?...very very FEW. What I'd like to see happen is that the EU countries get together to open camps in Syria etc and only allow people in from there...whether its based on skills, height, weight...I don't care. What it would do is help address the issue with trafficking (though clearly not entirely). It would help prevent those clambering to get to the likes of Greece etc and above all...allow people to find a better life in various parts of Europe. Edited by Lyons550 (03 Sep 2015 3.21pm)
The Voice of Reason In An Otherwise Mediocre World |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote dannyh at 03 Sep 2015 3.32pm
Quote johnfirewall at 03 Sep 2015 3.17pm
Maybe ask those who refused to go to the camp in Hungary exactly what they expect from their destination country, then we can collectively decide whether it's reasonable or possible. People argue that's no life for them, but then many here say the same about a council flat. Edited by johnfirewall (03 Sep 2015 3.19pm) Surely if they are running for their lives from muderous factions in their home country then any form of safe haven with shelter and food should be fine ? It's an horrible situation to find yourself in, however beggers can't be chosers as the saying goes. Edited by dannyh (03 Sep 2015 3.33pm) Yeah, but how long can you live in a 'tent' in a refugee camp, with your family? They're hardly the kind of places designed for people and their families to function long term and tend to be quite dangerous places (esp as time goes on) and with more and more refugees turning up, they tend not to get better but worse. Some of them could have been there now for up to four years.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote johnfirewall at 03 Sep 2015 3.17pm
Maybe ask those who refused to go to the camp in Hungary exactly what they expect from their destination country, then we can collectively decide whether it's reasonable or possible. People argue that's no life for them, but then many here say the same about a council flat. Edited by johnfirewall (03 Sep 2015 3.19pm) I think they're looking for something most people take for granted, stability and security of belonging and being somewhere; being able to see a future for themselves and especially their children and get on with their lives. In transit or camps, you're only even on 'hold' waiting on the remote chance that it can get better. Maybe this way they feel that they're taking charge of their future. I'd hazard a guess that the reason so many youngish males are prevalent, is that they've left their families in the camps, whilst they try to get into a country, obtain asylum and then can arrange for their wife and children to join them.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote dannyh at 03 Sep 2015 4.05pm
Quote jamiemartin721 at 03 Sep 2015 3.47pm
Quote dannyh at 03 Sep 2015 3.32pm
Quote johnfirewall at 03 Sep 2015 3.17pm
Maybe ask those who refused to go to the camp in Hungary exactly what they expect from their destination country, then we can collectively decide whether it's reasonable or possible. People argue that's no life for them, but then many here say the same about a council flat. Edited by johnfirewall (03 Sep 2015 3.19pm) Surely if they are running for their lives from muderous factions in their home country then any form of safe haven with shelter and food should be fine ? It's an horrible situation to find yourself in, however beggers can't be chosers as the saying goes. Edited by dannyh (03 Sep 2015 3.33pm) Yeah, but how long can you live in a 'tent' in a refugee camp, with your family? They're hardly the kind of places designed for people and their families to function long term and tend to be quite dangerous places (esp as time goes on) and with more and more refugees turning up, they tend not to get better but worse. Some of them could have been there now for up to four years. 1. You can live in a tent quite safely and cleanly for an indefinite period of time, ask the native Americans, Inuit’s, Aborigines’, Mongols, and thousands of other indigenous peoples that live in tents and huts and the like the world over. 2. They are only dangerous because of the people in them. If they are full of dangerous types, (as you insinuated) who if you farted would cut your throat to nick it, then quite frankly why do we want them introduced into our society ? 3. If they are alive, fed, watered, warm and clean how can it be worse than where they came from ? And if they do become dangerous places to live, it is only down to their own kith and kin’s behaviour and selfishness, problems I don't see as ours to solve, when we have our own problems that are not inherited from elsewhere. Next .....
In truth, most of those groups don't live in tents and ramshackle shacks. Obviously you can live in the worst of situations, look at SA townships, but no one in those situations is thinking they don't want better. Any situation where you put large numbers of people who are desperate, homeless and insecure into a large group of equally desperate homeless and insecure, is going to result in trouble. Environments shape people's personalities far more than ideals do. As always it only takes a small percentage to make it hell for the majority. Its quite surprising how quickly people 'degenerate' when placed in dehumanizing and desperate situations. Those with nothing, are the kinds of people with nothing to lose. I think you have a rather cheeky optimistic view of how humanity works Mr H, people are never satisfied with just having their basic needs met, they want to actually have something a bit more. Actually I'd say most people are craven, self driven and self serving up to the point where not being that serves their best interest. We'd all fight for scraps of food if hungry, but what civilizes us, is that we don't have to worry too much, and its in the best interests of our desires and wants to co-operate. The problem is when you start taking away that aspect of 'benefit of co-operation over self interest' increasingly people become more 'selfishly motivated towards their own needs rather than others'. Also I doubt there is much in the way of law enforcement in refugee camps. There is probably only so much s**ting in a bucket most people can take before they want something more.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.