This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
| Brentmiester_General |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Midlands Eagle
In the vast majority of clubs you are correct that the chairman isn't part of the management team or playing side but we seem to have a chairman that likes to get far more involved in the footballing side of the club than most other chairmen. It seems that our chairman is the one that dictates the style of play that we are going to adopt and hires a new manager accordingly. When the style doesn't work he changes his mind on the playing style, sacks the manager and brings in another that will manage to the new / old style. If rumours are to be believed our players have a direct line to the chairman and he makes decisions based on their complaints and he also seems to be heavily involved in which players we buy and sell so it seems to me that he is very much a part of the management team I think you'll find all chairman/owners dictate the style now days.
"We love you Palace, we f@cking hate Man U, We love you Palace, we hate the brighton too, We love you Palace we play in red 'n' blue, so f@ck you, and you ... |
|
|
Originally posted by Midlands Eagle
In the vast majority of clubs you are correct that the chairman isn't part of the management team or playing side but we seem to have a chairman that likes to get far more involved in the footballing side of the club than most other chairmen. It seems that our chairman is the one that dictates the style of play that we are going to adopt and hires a new manager accordingly. When the style doesn't work he changes his mind on the playing style, sacks the manager and brings in another that will manage to the new / old style. If rumours are to be believed our players have a direct line to the chairman and he makes decisions based on their complaints and he also seems to be heavily involved in which players we buy and sell so it seems to me that he is very much a part of the management team What does that mean though, 'a direct line'? If players had concerns about de Boer, then who else would they raise it with? Would you prefer they had been more public? Things clearly weren't right under FDB, above any issues with Parish. It wasn't Parish who insisted on playing a formation we weren't suited to, or suddenly introducing Joel Ward as a wing back? Parish sees this on a daily basis and if the players were looking as confused in training as they did on the pitch then I'm not surprised he decided to make a change. Likewise, in terms of players we have bought and sold, by the sounds of it the two he has worked hardest to bring in have been Zaha and Sakho, and I think most Palace fans would say they were worth it and wanted them to happen? Was he 'interfering' when he backed managers to bring in players like Mandanda or Riederwald?
Employee of the month is a good example of how someone can be both a winner and a loser at the same time. |
|
|
Originally posted by Username
Things clearly weren't right under FDB, above any issues with Parish. It wasn't Parish who insisted on playing a formation we weren't suited to, or suddenly introducing Joel Ward as a wing back? Parish sees this on a daily basis and if the players were looking as confused in training as they did on the pitch then I'm not surprised he decided to make a change. It was Parish that wanted to change the formation to a more passing game and the only reason that Joel Ward was playing as a wing back was because Parish didn't buy a proper one. If Parish sees the players looking confused on the training pitch every day then that just proves my point as he shouldn't have been anywhere near the training ground. Originally posted by Username
Likewise, in terms of players we have bought and sold, by the sounds of it the two he has worked hardest to bring in have been Zaha and Sakho, and I think most Palace fans would say they were worth it and wanted them to happen? What about the players who were released like Campbell and whilst I agree that most fans wanted Sakho I think that most of us would have preferred the money pot divvied up slightly differently to include a couple of strikers and a left wing back as well as a goalkeeper
|
|
|
Originally posted by Willo
The only striker WBA had on the bench was Salomon Rondon and I think he has only scored 1 goal in the last 25 league games for them ! Edited by Willo (26 Sep 2017 4.36pm) They played 2 on the pitch in Rodriguez anf Kanu, they had Rondon on the bench, so I was incorrect in my assumption that they were on the bench. TWO of their THREE strikers were on the pitch, and one on the bench. So 3 fit strikers which is 3 more than us...silly me.
"It's not the bullet that's got my name on it that concerns me; it's all them other ones flyin' around marked 'To Whom It May Concern.'" |
|
|
Originally posted by Midlands Eagle
What about the players who were released like Campbell and whilst I agree that most fans wanted Sakho I think that most of us would have preferred the money pot divvied up slightly differently to include a couple of strikers and a left wing back as well as a goalkeeper ME Parish said he should of kept Frazier but listened to the Manager.
Palace 13th 2017/18. |
|
| Brentmiester_General |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Midlands Eagle
What about the players who were released like Campbell and whilst I agree that most fans wanted Sakho I think that most of us would have preferred the money pot divvied up slightly differently to include a couple of strikers and a left wing back as well as a goalkeeper If we can gather enough points to be on track for safety come Jan, then spend the reported £40 mill we have on a striker and goalie, then we will be hailing it as one of the cleverest moves made by any chairman we've ever had.
"We love you Palace, we f@cking hate Man U, We love you Palace, we hate the brighton too, We love you Palace we play in red 'n' blue, so f@ck you, and you ... |
|
|
Originally posted by Midlands Eagle
What about the players who were released like Campbell and whilst I agree that most fans wanted Sakho I think that most of us would have preferred the money pot divvied up slightly differently to include a couple of strikers and a left wing back as well as a goalkeeper Haven't we enough left wing backs for your liking. Nobody complained when Campbell went, he was regularly slated on here. You need to stop posting so much and clear your head.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Rachid Rachid Rachid
This thread is full of conjecture about what SP has and hasn't done without much fact really being known. He's certainly been involved in a couple of poor decisions with regard to de Boer's appointment and the lack of forwards although personally I'd rather see a kid put in over Fraizer Campbell and think that RLC would be decent. A couple of recent things come to mind about his supposed interference in team matters. One being that Allardyce made a point of saying he'd been backed "big time" in the January window. The other that Allardyce was happy enough to let him into the dressing room after the Sunderland game to rinse the overpaid and underperforming players. A manager will establish targets and transfer policy / funds discuss with the Chairman and / or recruitment personnel. One or both will then engage with agents. I think Allardyce himself said Defoe was too much money. If the Guardian is to be believed de Boer had little or no idea of the transfer market. With regard to the Twitter stuff, although perhaps unwise who really cares ? Just tried to defend himself a bit when he was getting battered on forums and social media. Agreed good post.
Palace 13th 2017/18. |
|
|
Originally posted by alaneagle1
ME Parish said he should of kept Frazier but listened to the Manager. If you want more possession, which is what Parish said, then that means a more passing game. It doesn't specify style but it's definitely more passing to keep possession. That whole wing back issue was a complete insult to our intelligence. Well I speak for myself. Not sure how anyone else viewed it. I would've had Frank answering what he's doing the moment he muttered 3-4-3. That was just stupid beyond belief and against 'gradual'. Thinking Campbell is good enough as a back up for an injured Benteke is stupid and reckless. If parish thinks Campbell is good enough to cover for Benteke for anything up to 4 months because of an injury until January then we have serious problems. The judgement there is so poor it's not worth going any further. And then there's this talk of £40 million, which I don't believe. But if it is true, why is he aiming to keep Campbell? Is it because the wad comes out in January windows when we're desperate and get overcharged, or is it because like all the ex pros employed at the club, its the norm to have a flick through that list first? To think and value Campbell at £8mil or 9 is so desperate for a reason for this it's untrue. Then finally the more modest sensible bids did come out. Just so late we were there to be taken advantage of.
COYP |
|
|
Originally posted by Brentmiester_General
If we can gather enough points to be on track for safety come Jan, then spend the reported £40 mill we have on a striker and goalie, then we will be hailing it as one of the cleverest moves made by any chairman we've ever had. No. We'll be saying he's been yet again incredibly lucky after taking liberties with this league. I don't think he will be that lucky again, but if he is, it'll be because Roy's excellence in dealing with this shower he's having to use and not because of any 'clever' move by Parish. Make no mistake, having one striker in any league, especially the richest and most competitive leagues over the whole season, is not clever. Negligent is what it is.
COYP |
|
|
Originally posted by Rudi Hedman
If you want more possession, which is what Parish said, then that means a more passing game. It doesn't specify style but it's definitely more passing to keep possession. That whole wing back issue was a complete insult to our intelligence. Well I speak for myself. Not sure how anyone else viewed it. I would've had Frank answering what he's doing the moment he muttered 3-4-3. That was just stupid beyond belief and against 'gradual'. Thinking Campbell is good enough as a back up for an injured Benteke is stupid and reckless. If parish thinks Campbell is good enough to cover for Benteke for anything up to 4 months because on injury until January then we have serious problems. The judgement there is so poor it's not worth going any further. And then there's this talk of £40 million, which I don't believe. But if it is true, why is he aiming to keep Campbell? Is it because the wad comes out in January windows when we're desperate and get overcharged, or is it because like all the ex pros employed at the club, its the norm to have a flick through that list first? To think and value Campbell at £8mil or 9 is so desperate for a reason for this it's untrue. Then finally the more modest sensible did come out. Just so late we were there to be taken advantage of. Again I cannot recall Parish saying he wanted more possession.
Palace 13th 2017/18. |
|
| Brentmiester_General |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Rudi Hedman
No. We'll be saying he's been yet again incredibly lucky after taking liberties with this league. I don't think he will be that lucky again, but if he is, it'll be because Roy's excellence in dealing with this shower he's having to use and not because of any 'clever' move by Parish. Make no mistake, having one striker in any league, especially the richest and most competitive leagues over the whole season, is not clever. Negligent is what it is. The way I see it, Parish did what had to be done, being blatantly obvious to anyone who saw us with Sakho in the team last season. He went out and got Sakho on a permanent deal. That had to be done as the most important piece of transfer business. He did that at the expense of getting a striker and goalie in the summer transfer window and that to me, again, is obviously the right move to make. Had he left Sakho in favour of a new striker and goalie then we would have lost Sakho to another club and that would be the end of that. So he's seen to the most important piece of business first. Then he'll see to the other areas(hopefully) in the Jan transfer window. Yes it's a gamble, but it was a gamble that had to be taken one way or another, and it was the only logical way that I can see for him to have done it. And now he's getting slaughtered for executing the first bit of a very tricky, but potentially brilliant plan. All in the name of bettering our squad and furthering our club.
"We love you Palace, we f@cking hate Man U, We love you Palace, we hate the brighton too, We love you Palace we play in red 'n' blue, so f@ck you, and you ... |
|
|
Originally posted by Brentmiester_General
The way I see it, Parish did what had to be done, being blatantly obvious to anyone who saw us with Sakho in the team last season. He went out and got Sakho on a permanent deal. That had to be done as the most important piece of transfer business. He did that at the expense of getting a striker and goalie in the summer transfer window and that to me, again, is obviously the right move to make. Had he left Sakho in favour of a new striker and goalie then we would have lost Sakho to another club and that would be the end of that. So he's seen to the most important piece of business first. Then he'll see to the other areas(hopefully) in the Jan transfer window. Yes it's a gamble, but it was a gamble that had to be taken one way or another, and it was the only logical way that I can see for him to have done it. And now he's getting slaughtered for executing the first bit of a very tricky, but potentially brilliant plan. All in the name of bettering our squad and furthering our club. So you're saying he can sign Sakho but not a striker at the same time? But he can sign a striker in January now the Sakho deal has already been done? He tried to sign a striker. He just left it too late. There was no plan of leaving it until January. He just, like always, left it too late. There is no excuse for this. It's an unforgiving league and there are no let offs for 1 striker. It was left too late, that's it, so as a result we could have paid another big transfer and wage on another player before we get relegated.
COYP |
|
|
Originally posted by Rudi Hedman
If you want more possession, which is what Parish said, then that means a more passing game. It doesn't specify style but it's definitely more passing to keep possession. That whole wing back issue was a complete insult to our intelligence. Well I speak for myself. Not sure how anyone else viewed it. I would've had Frank answering what he's doing the moment he muttered 3-4-3. That was just stupid beyond belief and against 'gradual'. Thinking Campbell is good enough as a back up for an injured Benteke is stupid and reckless. If parish thinks Campbell is good enough to cover for Benteke for anything up to 4 months because of an injury until January then we have serious problems. The judgement there is so poor it's not worth going any further. And then there's this talk of £40 million, which I don't believe. But if it is true, why is he aiming to keep Campbell? Is it because the wad comes out in January windows when we're desperate and get overcharged, or is it because like all the ex pros employed at the club, its the norm to have a flick through that list first? To think and value Campbell at £8mil or 9 is so desperate for a reason for this it's untrue. Then finally the more modest sensible bids did come out. Just so late we were there to be taken advantage of.
Has he ever said that? He's said we need to have a different approach and he's right. We stayed up knicking away wins at Chelsea and Liverpool and beating Arsenal. That's not a recipe for success. To be an establish PL team, we need to be able to break down the likes of Swansea, Burnley, Bournemouth. Something we have failed to do too often and has left us with an abysmal home record. That's what he said he wants to change.
Employee of the month is a good example of how someone can be both a winner and a loser at the same time. |
|
| Brentmiester_General |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Rudi Hedman
So you're saying he can sign Sakho but not a striker at the same time? But he can sign a striker in January now the Sakho deal has already been done? He tried to sign a striker. He just left it too late. There was no plan of leaving it until January. He just, like always, left it too late. There is no excuse for this. It's an unforgiving league and there are no let offs for 1 striker. It was left too late, that's it, so as a result we could have paid another big transfer and wage on another player before we get relegated. We don't know how much is/was released at any given point in the season. Perhaps it is a case of the American's holding the purse strings until Jan to see if we can get to where we need to without the added expenditure. Maybe it's to do with FFP. Maybe the agents screwed things up. Maybe SP didn't think the players on offer represented good value for the money.
"We love you Palace, we f@cking hate Man U, We love you Palace, we hate the brighton too, We love you Palace we play in red 'n' blue, so f@ck you, and you ... |
|
|
Originally posted by Midlands Eagle
game and the only reason that Joel Ward was playing as a wing back was because Parish didn't buy a proper one. That is absolute nonsense. We spent the whole pre season playing Luka and Joel Ward in the back three. Then all of a sudden come the first game Luka is in a midfield four (who knows when the last time he played in that system, do Olympiakos and Serbia play that way?), and Joel Ward is suddenly at wing back where Townsend had been playing. That is nothing to do with Parish, and everything to do with a manager who had poorly prepared the team in pre-season.
Employee of the month is a good example of how someone can be both a winner and a loser at the same time. |
|
|
Originally posted by Username
Has he ever said that? He's said we need to have a different approach and he's right. We stayed up knicking away wins at Chelsea and Liverpool and beating Arsenal. That's not a recipe for success. To be an establish PL team, we need to be able to break down the likes of Swansea, Burnley, Bournemouth. Something we have failed to do too often and has left us with an abysmal home record. That's what he said he wants to change. That implies passing through or around teams, does it not? It certainly doesn't mean having less possession, or playing direct. So please, if it doesn't involve possession or more passing football, what does it involve, because it involves something, so what is it and how is it done?
COYP |
|
|
Originally posted by Brentmiester_General
We don't know how much is/was released at any given point in the season. Perhaps it is a case of the American's holding the purse strings until Jan to see if we can get to where we need to without the added expenditure. Maybe it's to do with FFP. Maybe the agents screwed things up. Maybe SP didn't think the players on offer represented good value for the money. We had £10 mil ready to use. It could've been used a day before, 2 days before, a week before.
COYP |
|
|
Originally posted by Rudi Hedman
That implies passing through or around teams, does it not? It certainly doesn't mean having less possession, or playing direct. So please, if it doesn't involve possession or more passing football, what does it involve, because it involves something, so what is it and how is it done? That's not the point and you know it. 'He wanted a different style' is being used as a stick to beat Parish with, as if he was just upset we weren't pretty enough to watch, when in reality it was an assessment that was 100% accurate. How that is achieved is down to a manager to execute. Parish hasn't ever said he wants us to be pretty to watch, or that we should play with a back three. He's probably just fed up of us not being able to beat sodding Bournemouth at home.
Employee of the month is a good example of how someone can be both a winner and a loser at the same time. |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.