You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Topic
November 16 2026 7.58am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Holmesdale Singing Section (LOCKED)


Page 22 of 71 < 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 >
Mapletree Flag Croydon 30 Oct 18 5.50pm

They were - apparently - made promises on which the club reneged.

I am told they have been looking at what makes Ultras successful elsewhere and their strategy is based on that

I have little doubt they are well thought through

It's not them that annoy me, it's the poor change management from the club.

 

est1905 Flag 30 Oct 18 5.57pm

Originally posted by Dannyh.V2

You have further enforced my view that you have no debating skills what so ever, have no point to make other than a jingoistic outlook to your little piece of red plastic that you don't even own. You have not (can't) argue any of my points. You have resorted to name calling the last bastion of a child like mind, You accuse me of being a bigot, well look up the meaning sunshine because trust me on this one, if anyone is bigoted round here and displaying a pathetic little englander attitude it's you.

It's almost comical how you are blinkered by your own " towel on sun lounger" mentality ( or just mental I can't decide ).

I will sign off from this now as you clearly can't see the wood for the tree's.

The singing section will happen whether you like it or not.

You will have to move whether you like it or not, the club is bigger than you

The HF will be back as will the atmosphere. no one will miss you if you don't turn up, nor me or anyone else.

That's not me being nasty it's just a fact.


I dont see how someone who does not wish to embrace change is a towel on the sun lounger little Englander. That kind of name calling (not to mention presumption of someone you dont know) makes you look the childish one.
Its not necessary hip, cool or trendy to change things all the time. If it aint broke, why fix it? I disagree with your belief that people will have to move. If they claim to want to join the singing section and suggest taking legal advise/media exposure if ageist, sexist, conforming criteria come into play to stop them I'd bet the club will back down.
The club is bigger than him? Of course it is. Its just as bigger than you too, you appear to have forgotten that because you think they are on your side of the arguement. They are not, they have their own reasons for the decisions they make. Yours and my feelings have little to do with those decisions. If you dont believe that go and ask everyone who currently sits in the top 16 rows of Block E lower Holmesdale.

HF will be back as will the atmosphere. Hmm. First of all the atmosphere Sunday was outstanding and it built from spirit and togetherness as it REALLY got going when we went 1 2 down. As far as the HF being back? Well, I'll repeat what I have said many times. If they were as true supporters as those of us who go every week, rain or shine, regardless of where we are allowed to stand they would not have thrown a hissy fit and stopped going to the game in the first place. For me, just the fact that they boycotted alone has massively damaged any credibility they may have built up to that point.

 

spartakev2 Flag Anerley 30 Oct 18 6.24pm

Just wondered. ...in his interview SP said they had to 'take note' of the HF (or words to that effect) because he uses their pictures all over their marketing stuff. Could the HF legally stop him doing this, and that's why he did an about turn?

 

.TUX. Flag 30 Oct 18 6.28pm

Originally posted by est1905

I dont see how someone who does not wish to embrace change is a towel on the sun lounger little Englander. That kind of name calling (not to mention presumption of someone you dont know) makes you look the childish one.
Its not necessary hip, cool or trendy to change things all the time. If it aint broke, why fix it? I disagree with your belief that people will have to move. If they claim to want to join the singing section and suggest taking legal advise/media exposure if ageist, sexist, conforming criteria come into play to stop them I'd bet the club will back down.
The club is bigger than him? Of course it is. Its just as bigger than you too, you appear to have forgotten that because you think they are on your side of the arguement. They are not, they have their own reasons for the decisions they make. Yours and my feelings have little to do with those decisions. If you dont believe that go and ask everyone who currently sits in the top 16 rows of Block E lower Holmesdale.

HF will be back as will the atmosphere. Hmm. First of all the atmosphere Sunday was outstanding and it built from spirit and togetherness as it REALLY got going when we went 1 2 down. As far as the HF being back? Well, I'll repeat what I have said many times. If they were as true supporters as those of us who go every week, rain or shine, regardless of where we are allowed to stand they would not have thrown a hissy fit and stopped going to the game in the first place. For me, just the fact that they boycotted alone has massively damaged any credibility they may have built up to that point.

''Outstanding''?????? I'm sorry but it wasn't, nowhere near tbf.........and this was against a top team.
Hmm.........

 


Buy Litecoin.

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 30 Oct 18 6.47pm

Originally posted by Palace in the Blood

They would be in a court of Law and I think Club would lose

You’re wrong.

 


COYP

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 30 Oct 18 6.51pm

Originally posted by stayloa

Am I missing something here? Do we want a singing section? Yes.

Does one improve Selhurst Park? Yes.

Did we have one already that functioned perfectly well? Yes.

So why are we moving people? Just because they want a better view? They asked, the club said no so they should have said "fair enough, back to block B we go". Instead they threw their toys out the pram and boycotted the place. They're not real fans...

1. It’s to make and spread a bigger and better atmosphere. If you don’t know that you should research before posting.

2. They haven’t ‘boycotted the place.’ They’re attending like everyone else that sits on their hands.

Toys out of pram? Maybe. We don’t know the talks had between HF and the club to say, do we?

Before anyone says it, the main stand could be 10 years away. The rumours don’t sound hopeful.

 


COYP

PZ Eagle Flag Penzance 30 Oct 18 7.00pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

You’re wrong.

So you are a lawyer are you!

 


Conjunctivitis.com - A site for sore eyes.

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 30 Oct 18 7.00pm

Originally posted by spartakev2

Just wondered. ...in his interview SP said they had to 'take note' of the HF (or words to that effect) because he uses their pictures all over their marketing stuff. Could the HF legally stop him doing this, and that's why he did an about turn?

The club can probably use any pictures taken inside the stadium, although I suppose if they started using individual people close up regularly there’d be a problem. If they were celebrities and had agents there’d probably be image rights to be negotiated but the HF as far as I know the club don’t need the HF’s permission via the HF’s solicitors.

 


COYP

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 30 Oct 18 7.07pm

Originally posted by PZ Eagle

So you are a lawyer are you!

The seats are never guaranteed the next season. Clubs have moved hundreds of thousands of people over decades because they can, and because they own the seats. They’re not rented or real estate, they’re just seats to watch sport in a stadium the fan doesn’t have any ownership of.

It’s one of the most stupid things in this thread and I wouldn’t want to be someone in block E trying this, whether it be public or not. I don’t condone the abuse on Sunday from one person but I can imagine it’s not going to be good if any try to block something that’s now inevitably happening. I’d have moved already with that standing further in front actually.

 


COYP

Mapletree Flag Croydon 30 Oct 18 7.08pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

The seats are never guaranteed the next season. Clubs have moved hundreds of thousands of people over decades because they can, and because they own the seats. They’re not rented or real estate, they’re just seats to watch sport in a stadium the fan doesn’t have any ownership of.

It’s one of the most stupid things in this thread and I wouldn’t want to be someone in block E trying this, whether it be public or not. I don’t condone the abuse on Sunday from one person but I can imagine it’s not going to be good if any try to block something that’s now inevitably happening. I’d have moved already with that standing further in front actually.

And for those of us that have pre-paid?

Moving further forward means you get wet by the way.

Edited by Mapletree (30 Oct 2018 7.08pm)

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 30 Oct 18 7.24pm

Originally posted by Mapletree

And for those of us that have pre-paid?

Moving further forward means you get wet by the way.

Edited by Mapletree (30 Oct 2018 7.08pm)

I said I would’ve moved because of the standing in the front half of block E. I didn’t say anything about moving to the first few rows where you get wet.

Not sure about the pre-paid holders but 2010 didn’t have to honour them anyway so they may be able to use that. If they couldn’t move the few pre-paid holders they could allow them to stay dotted about with the HF until they inevitably request to move.

 


COYP

becky Flag over the moon 30 Oct 18 7.55pm

Originally posted by Lumsdero

The difference between the example you have given above and the reality of the situation is that SP and the board wish to introduce a singing section directly behind the goal.
What is the likelihood that those who have sat there for a decade or more suddenly wish to give up their seats? Slim at best.
Stating that "it's how football clubs have always operated" is not looking to the future. Things often have to change to avoid stagnating. Clearly home atmosphere across all clubs in the Premier League is poor and stagnant, at least SP and the board have the balls to break the mould and are trying to address that.

Edited by Lumsdero (30 Oct 2018 1.03pm)


That may be because the majority of people go to watch the football, rather than to experience some so-called 'atmosphere' that is supposes to improve their 'match day experience'.

A quaint old fashioned idea, I know, but still true for a large number of football fans.

 


A stairway to Heaven and a Highway to Hell give some indication of expected traffic numbers

.TUX. Flag 30 Oct 18 8.18pm

Originally posted by becky


That may be because the majority of people go to watch the football, rather than to experience some so-called 'atmosphere' that is supposes to improve their 'match day experience'.

A quaint old fashioned idea, I know, but still true for a large number of football fans.

I'll bear that in mind the next time i see many thousands of fans, from many different clubs, from newbies to die-hards.............happily clapping their clappers.

 


Buy Litecoin.

PZ Eagle Flag Penzance 30 Oct 18 10.01pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

I said I would’ve moved because of the standing in the front half of block E. I didn’t say anything about moving to the first few rows where you get wet.

Not sure about the pre-paid holders but 2010 didn’t have to honour them anyway so they may be able to use that. If they couldn’t move the few pre-paid holders they could allow them to stay dotted about with the HF until they inevitably request to move.

Did you not read the clubs Terms and Conditions which clearly state that standing is a serious breach of those terms and can result in the removal of their season tickets.
11.1.2 persistent standing in seated areas whilst the Match is in progress;
Dos this not apply to the HF?

 


Conjunctivitis.com - A site for sore eyes.

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 30 Oct 18 10.12pm

Originally posted by PZ Eagle

Did you not read the clubs Terms and Conditions which clearly state that standing is a serious breach of those terms and can result in the removal of their season tickets.
11.1.2 persistent standing in seated areas whilst the Match is in progress;
Dos this not apply to the HF?

And? Have you not been to Selhurst in the last 6 years with regards to block E or many more years with regards to block B?

 


COYP

bicycle repair man 30 Oct 18 10.22pm

It's mob rule ,Parish doesn't realise what bad feeling he's caused among many long term Palace supporters,at what was one of the last true family clubs in the Premier League.
Sadly he's caved in to the aggressive minority,and allowed the whole situation to become a farce,and make Palace look ridiculous.
Talks about our manufactured "singing section" are just plain embarrassing,and treatment of some of our loyalest fans down right shameful.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 30 Oct 18 10.30pm

Originally posted by bicycle repair man

It's mob rule ,Parish doesn't realise what bad feeling he's caused among many long term Palace supporters,at what was one of the last true family clubs in the Premier League.
Sadly he's caved in to the aggressive minority,and allowed the whole situation to become a farce,and make Palace look ridiculous.
Talks about our manufactured "singing section" are just plain embarrassing,and treatment of some of our loyalest fans down right shameful.

They’ll be envious when we have the best looking and sounding atmosphere behind the goal.

It will still be a family club if that’s how you support. Moving 400 people won’t change that so don’t be so dramatic, petal.

Parish wanted this anyway so I’m not sure ‘caving in’ in to an aggressive minority is the best description. He was more asked if he wanted it or not, so follow through with it if you do, or we’ll all support how the ‘can’t be &rsed’ do I’ve read on here in the last few days or months.

 


COYP

Mapletree Flag Croydon 30 Oct 18 10.44pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

I said I would’ve moved because of the standing in the front half of block E. I didn’t say anything about moving to the first few rows where you get wet.

Not sure about the pre-paid holders but 2010 didn’t have to honour them anyway so they may be able to use that. If they couldn’t move the few pre-paid holders they could allow them to stay dotted about with the HF until they inevitably request to move.

Inevitably? On your bike sonny.

You get wet anywhere lower than Row 17.

 

glazedallover Flag Allier 30 Oct 18 10.50pm

Surely there must have been some ‘virtue signaling ‘ on this thread by now.......?

 

bicycle repair man 30 Oct 18 11.11pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

They’ll be envious when we have the best looking and sounding atmosphere behind the goal.

It will still be a family club if that’s how you support. Moving 400 people won’t change that so don’t be so dramatic, petal.

Parish wanted this anyway so I’m not sure ‘caving in’ in to an aggressive minority is the best description. He was more asked if he wanted it or not, so follow through with it if you do, or we’ll all support how the ‘can’t be &rsed’ do I’ve read on here in the last few days or months.

The so called "fanatics" have turned themselves in to a figure of fun,and are a laughing stock among football fans up and down the country.
They are an embarrassment.

 

Page 22 of 71 < 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Topic