You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Who’s at fault - Hodgson or the board?
November 16 2026 7.58am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Who’s at fault - Hodgson or the board?


Page 22 of 44 < 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 >
hellzdoms Flag London 11 Dec 18 8.46am

Originally posted by Painter

I wouldn't have Puncheon anywhere near the team, if I had a choice, he isn't up to it without his mate Pardew.

I am not anti Reideweld, but something isn't right about him. Maybe the rigours of Premier football aren't for him and just cant produce at that level on a consistent basis. There is an interesting interview with Jach on his page on HOL, saying the step up from where he came from was too much.

I think with any player moving to any league t will always be a step up. The polish ekstraklasa is definitely not the highest rated in the world but some top talent has emerged from there in recent years. Lewandowski is a prime example but more recently the Genoa polish striker is leading the scores compared to world class players. And he arrived not so long ago. I feel reideweld has not been given a fair chance to prove himself. Look at awb. He came along during possibly the worse time for palace and went from playing for the youth team to playing against the best club in the prem. defending like a mad man.

I think the other problem is that Roy has a different play style compared to others, not all players fit that style. But to start punchon over reideweld is like starting speroni over Guaita

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 11 Dec 18 8.47am

Originally posted by Spiderman

Exactly. Willo how can you say this when SP on numerous occasions has used FFP/constraints as a reason for not buying the players we need

To be honest I have not witnessed any extended promulgation by Parish, proferring a mantra pertaining to financial constraints hampering our recruitment process.Certainly no liturgical chant to convince the masses.Perhaps I have not read the words, nor heard the mellifluous voice of Steve Parish in the media as much as some on here !

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 11 Dec 18 10.06am

Originally posted by Willo

To be honest I have not witnessed any extended promulgation by Parish, proferring a mantra pertaining to financial constraints hampering our recruitment process.Certainly no liturgical chant to convince the masses.Perhaps I have not read the words, nor heard the mellifluous voice of Steve Parish in the media as much as some on here !

For the sake of those that speak normal English and not the mangled version preferred by Willo he is trying to say:-

To be honest I haven’t heard Parish mentioning financial constraints causing a potential problem with recruitment but there again I haven’t been following the media as closely as some others have


 

Midlands Eagle Flag 11 Dec 18 10.09am

Originally posted by Painter

I am not anti Reideweld, but something isn't right about him. Maybe the rigours of Premier football aren't for him and just cant produce at that level on a consistent basis. There is an interesting interview with Jach on his page on HOL, saying the step up from where he came from was too much.

I seem to recall that the general opinion on this forum about another player was that coming from an inferior league he just wasn't up to Premiership standards but Jedinak turned out OK

 

Jacey Flag 11 Dec 18 10.26am

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

I seem to recall that the general opinion on this forum about another player was that coming from an inferior league he just wasn't up to Premiership standards but Jedinak turned out OK

Good point.

Jedinak??

Perhaps we should get him back to put some fight,backbone and leadership to help get us out of our current crisis.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 11 Dec 18 10.30am

Originally posted by Jacey

Good point.

Jedinak??

Perhaps we should get him back to put some fight,backbone and leadership to help get us out of our current crisis.

Not getting a look-in at A.Villa.He hasn't played since September,besides he is not what we require at the present time.

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 11 Dec 18 10.40am

Originally posted by Painter

Your defence of Reideweld is misplaced. He is a professional footballer and very well paid, the least Palace are entitled to expect is that he is fit and at playing weight recommended. He may of had one good game, but is obviously not consistent, like say McArthur.

Coming from Ajax doesn't automatically mean your good, Dutch football has been on the decline for years.

Not all players can step up to a higher level and in a foreign country. This is the case with Sorloth, there have been many players come from aboard and sink without a trace as they cant produce. We know about Sorloth as he is here, I expect every club has their own version, but we don't hear about them.

With all due respect, how can he become consistent if he doesnt get game time?

 

taylors lovechild Flag 11 Dec 18 10.43am

I may be wrong, but wasn't Jairo injured, hence his lack of involvement recently? He has looked neat and tidy when I've seen him, but not a game changer. I think our midfield has looked good in that regard this season with our inter play very good with high possession and a high number of chances created. Goals scored, this is the problem. I don't seem Jairo changing this. In fact, I don't see anyone who is fit and outside the first XI who will change that. Despite some issues at the back, we have kept five clean sheets this season, which puts us only behind the top four in this area.

Game after game we see chances being wasted and I personally don't see what more Roy can do with the players at his disposal. They say the table generally reflects a clubs investment and perhaps our lack of investment in the last year is catching up on us. Ayew has proved to be a flop so far and despite my best efforts to support him Sorloth does not look ready to lead the line, plus when he does play the other players don't seem to want to pass to him.

If either Bentenke or Wickham come back all guns blazing, or we sign someone who knows where the net is, then I believe we'll be fine. Until then I can't help but think it will be a long winter with brief glimmers of hope dangled in front of us.

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 11 Dec 18 10.46am

Originally posted by Painter

I wouldn't have Puncheon anywhere near the team, if I had a choice, he isn't up to it without his mate Pardew.

I am not anti Reideweld, but something isn't right about him. Maybe the rigours of Premier football aren't for him and just cant produce at that level on a consistent basis. There is an interesting interview with Jach on his page on HOL, saying the step up from where he came from was too much.

Just maybe he is pi***d off with being overlooked week in week out. A good example was last season against Leicester, he was on the bench but Roy decided to bring on Souare and Lee (who was going and hardly warranted a massive send-off)...why not give JR some game time? It may be a massive step up but how many in our squad have played in a European final?

 

premier fan Flag BR4 11 Dec 18 10.59am

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

For the sake of those that speak normal English and not the mangled version preferred by Willo he is trying to say:-

To be honest I haven’t heard Parish mentioning financial constraints causing a potential problem with recruitment but there again I haven’t been following the media as closely as some others have


Ha Ha

I quite enjoyed reading Willo's response, very well put and nice to see some well written English.

I'd never criticise someone for having a skill like this. On the contrary, I applaud him.

 

premier fan Flag BR4 11 Dec 18 11.04am

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

I seem to recall that the general opinion on this forum about another player was that coming from an inferior league he just wasn't up to Premiership standards but Jedinak turned out OK

Yes and I was one of those that questioned Jedinaks ability in the early days.

However, the problem we have now is the premiership doesn't allow us enough time to bed in players who have a weakness.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 11 Dec 18 11.09am

Originally posted by premier fan

Ha Ha

I quite enjoyed reading Willo's response, very well put and nice to see some well written English.

I'd never criticise someone for having a skill like this. On the contrary, I applaud him.

That's very kind of you and I thank you for your generous sentiments.

 

Maine Eagle Flag USA 11 Dec 18 2.43pm

Originally posted by Willo

To be honest I have not witnessed any extended promulgation by Parish, proferring a mantra pertaining to financial constraints hampering our recruitment process.Certainly no liturgical chant to convince the masses.Perhaps I have not read the words, nor heard the mellifluous voice of Steve Parish in the media as much as some on here !

Must. Stop. Reading. Thesaurus....

 


Trump lost. Badly. Hahahahahahaha.

Maine Eagle Flag USA 11 Dec 18 2.46pm

Originally posted by Painter

I wouldn't have Puncheon anywhere near the team, if I had a choice, he isn't up to it without his mate Pardew.

I am not anti Reideweld, but something isn't right about him. Maybe the rigours of Premier football aren't for him and just cant produce at that level on a consistent basis. There is an interesting interview with Jach on his page on HOL, saying the step up from where he came from was too much.

What is not right about Jairo is how he has been treated IMHO.

But to be fair, you havent seen him enough in a Palace shirt and Premier League level, nor have any of us.

Something look decidedly right with him when he played a blinder versus Man City last year.

Until a player like Riedewald is actually given a run of games, how can he be judged fairly?

 


Trump lost. Badly. Hahahahahahaha.

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 11 Dec 18 2.54pm

Originally posted by Maine Eagle

What is not right about Jairo is how he has been treated IMHO.

But to be fair, you havent seen him enough in a Palace shirt and Premier League level, nor have any of us.

Something look decidedly right with him when he played a blinder versus Man City last year.

Until a player like Riedewald is actually given a run of games, how can he be judged fairly?

In the final analysis, Hodgson doesn't believe that Riedewald fits into his side,rightly or wrongly, and it is he who is responsible for selection.

Riedewald has played as defensive midfielder but we have Milivojevic and Kouyate who can provide the defensive shield.Would you play Riedewald instead of either of them ?

Riedewald can play in central defence.Would one deploy him there in preference to Sakho,Tomkins or even Kelly ?

I don't support the argument that players have not been treated well if they haven't been selected.Some supporters might deem that individual players are worthy of selection above others but this is the judgement call of the manager.

 

Maine Eagle Flag USA 11 Dec 18 3.01pm

Originally posted by Willo

In the final analysis, Hodgson doesn't believe that Riedewald fits into his side,rightly or wrongly, and it is he who is responsible for selection.

Riedewald has played as defensive midfielder but we have Milivojevic and Kouyate who can provide the defensive shield.Would you play Riedewald instead of either of them ?

Riedewald can play in central defence.Would one deploy him there in preference to Sakho,Tomkins or even Kelly ?

I don't support the argument that players have not been treated well if they haven't been selected.Some supporters might deem that individual players are worthy of selection above others but this is the judgement call of the manager.

Agreed, But Hodgson is not always right.

Harry Kane taking corners springs to mind, the best goal poacher we have had since Lineker and he is taking corners. Would you have Harry Kane taking corners?

Kouyate was bought after Riedewald was already here. My contention is that Jairo Riedewald hasnt been given a fair chance to show what he can do, as RH has his favourites, usually to his detriment - we played Luka all season long and he was very poor at the start of the year in many games.

There is also a need as you have pointed out many times to move some players off of the wage bill and actually recoup some funds.

We wont get a lot of interest in a player rotting in the U23s.

 


Trump lost. Badly. Hahahahahahaha.

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 11 Dec 18 3.16pm

According to the interviews with Ray Lewington, Reidewald plays in Milivojevic ‘s position but is not considered as good as him hence why he has no game time. The reason why he doesn’t get on the bench is because he is not an all rounder like Kelly who can slot into a number of positions and Milivojevic is also one of our least injured players so not really needed. Before anyone jumps in this, it is our coach saying it is not an opinion.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 11 Dec 18 3.18pm

Originally posted by Maine Eagle

Agreed, But Hodgson is not always right.

Harry Kane taking corners springs to mind, the best goal poacher we have had since Lineker and he is taking corners. Would you have Harry Kane taking corners?

Kouyate was bought after Riedewald was already here. My contention is that Jairo Riedewald hasnt been given a fair chance to show what he can do, as RH has his favourites, usually to his detriment - we played Luka all season long and he was very poor at the start of the year in many games.

There is also a need as you have pointed out many times to move some players off of the wage bill and actually recoup some funds.

We wont get a lot of interest in a player rotting in the U23s.

I am in agreement that on occasions the decisions of managers can be somewhat perplexing but in the final analysis they make them and they live and die by them.

Managers see players in training they know all the facts that we supporters are not privy to and they make selections in good faith.At the end of the day, some players are "Not given a chance" because the manager believes that other options are preferable,rightly or wrongly.

In terms of our current team, I for one cannot fit Riedewald into the starting eleven but with his versatility he is a good option to have on the bench.Riedewald can play as defensive midfielder or in central defence but I accept that Kelly is a tad more versatile in that he can play in both full-back positions(Not that well!) as well as in central defence.

Edited by Willo (11 Dec 2018 3.20pm)

 

Ghostship Flag Norfolk 11 Dec 18 4.44pm

Jairo's Palace career came to an end the day FDB was sacked. Roy never signed him so basically is not interested hence why they tried to farm him out to Swansea. Feel sorry for Jairo really as he deserves some starts he can't do any worse than Luka is at the moment

 

Dean_CPFC Flag South london 11 Dec 18 5.22pm

Originally posted by Ghostship

Jairo's Palace career came to an end the day FDB was sacked. Roy never signed him so basically is not interested hence why they tried to farm him out to Swansea. Feel sorry for Jairo really as he deserves some starts he can't do any worse than Luka is at the moment

Unfortunately he didn't look the sharpest in that reserve match against Bristol

 

Page 22 of 44 < 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Who’s at fault - Hodgson or the board?