This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by kev64
Not much to add other than the obvious Roy needs to go . Rot started 12 months ago , new contracts to garbage players , zero ambition. Rotten from the top down. My choice of drink tonight maybe we should rename the team Its good stuff the old brewdog isn't it? I spent my 20's bemoaning the poor quality pisswater on offer across Croydon and South London (Fosters etc), so it's nice to have better options now. Mind you, I've now started drinking at the start of games rather than the end!
|
|
|
Originally posted by palace chick
We have a chance if Hodgson has walked or been asked to go and interim managers have taken over. If Hodgson plays the same way against Brighton we are screwed. Alas he will play the same way with a couple of player changes that will make no difference :-( Opponents have little to worry about when playing us on the pitch apart from when they approach our goal where we always steal the show.
|
|
|
Originally posted by TheBigToePunt
Its good stuff the old brewdog isn't it? I spent my 20's bemoaning the poor quality pisswater on offer across Croydon and South London (Fosters etc), so it's nice to have better options now. Mind you, I've now started drinking at the start of games rather than the end!
|
|
|
Originally posted by mattteo
That's too harsh on PVA. I'd like him to stay, he has done a lot of great things for Palace and is one of the best left backs IN THE HISTORY OF THE PREMIER LEAGUE, not just of Palace. And yes, he was absolutely dredful today at all 3 goals, but let's be real, it happens that one can trip and fall and the first one was definitely Dann's ball. Same for Batshuayi, let's just wait for the entire season. The line is drawn at the end. After his performances, it doesn-t look like he will be a permanent signing, but he has it in him, he has quality. He was good at Chelsea (when he came on), Borussia Dortmund, first spell with Crystal Palace, national team, everywhere. There are plenty matches left. He might score 5-6 more goals (hopefully). Him and Mateta both have time to prove where our money should go in the summer. Benteke was once really quite good.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Tickled pink
TheBigToePunt's post made good reasonable sense, yours is of a fan who's just witnessed his team having their pants pulled down and against a team with no better players then us apart from the Eleven we played today. Sorry, but you are so entrenched in your views that you cannot see past your nose. We have just been out thought, out played and thoroughly demoralised by a bang average team. But it’s probably the players fault I’m guessing?
|
|
|
Originally posted by mattteo
That's too harsh on PVA. I'd like him to stay, he has done a lot of great things for Palace and is one of the best left backs IN THE HISTORY OF THE PREMIER LEAGUE, not just of Palace. And yes, he was absolutely dredful today at all 3 goals, but let's be real, it happens that one can trip and fall and the first one was definitely Dann's ball. Same for Batshuayi, let's just wait for the entire season. The line is drawn at the end. After his performances, it doesn-t look like he will be a permanent signing, but he has it in him, he has quality. He was good at Chelsea (when he came on), Borussia Dortmund, first spell with Crystal Palace, national team, everywhere. There are plenty matches left. He might score 5-6 more goals (hopefully). Him and Mateta both have time to prove where our money should go in the summer. Not sure I follow you re PVA. Where would you place him amongst Pearce, Irwin, Cole, Evra, Robertson etc? For me he is more of a novelty than anything. He gets goals from the centre forward position sometimes, which is odd, funny, thrilling and of some value. Against which, he defends like he's on ecstasy. I make you right about judging players on the whole season, and Batshuyi is only as good as the chances he gets. His play outside the box is awful, but we didn't get him in for that. When he was here before, we were making chances but missing them (I'm looking at YOU Benteke), but now we just aren't making them.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Texas Eagle
A team who before today were struggling score this season beat us comfortably at HOME. And did the double over us. Just let that sink in! Yet they remain some distance below us in the table and would gladly swap. Not saying we shouldn't be utterly furious with today, and with a few other s*** shows this season, but context should not be lost either.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Eaglecoops
Sorry, but you are so entrenched in your views that you cannot see past your nose. We have just been out thought, out played and thoroughly demoralised by a bang average team. But it’s probably the players fault I’m guessing? No, my past actually agreed with you and big toes.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Tickled pink
Benteke was once really quite good. He was ok, never quite good, and it was a really long time ago. He scored 15 in a season where he was on the pitch more than 3000 minutes and forced even if he was playing bad, 13 from open play and 2 which were penalties. Decent, not great.
|
|
|
Originally posted by TheBigToePunt
Yet they remain some distance below us in the table and would gladly swap. Not saying we shouldn't be utterly furious with today, and with a few other s*** shows this season, but context should not be lost either. They are 3 points behind us with a game in hand.
|
|
|
Originally posted by TheBigToePunt
Not sure I follow you re PVA. Where would you place him amongst Pearce, Irwin, Cole, Evra, Robertson etc? For me he is more of a novelty than anything. He gets goals from the centre forward position sometimes, which is odd, funny, thrilling and of some value. Against which, he defends like he's on ecstasy. I make you right about judging players on the whole season, and Batshuyi is only as good as the chances he gets. His play outside the box is awful, but we didn't get him in for that. When he was here before, we were making chances but missing them (I'm looking at YOU Benteke), but now we just aren't making them. I agree with you on PVA. Until our forwards are given decent service however I refuse to totally slag off Batshuyai, Benteke or Mateta. Having said that, you can’t just be a traditional centre forward any more and it looks like we potentially have three of them. The game has moved on I’m afraid and we see our CFs just watching the game instead of getting properly involved. Perhaps Mateta will surprise us, I hope so.
|
|
|
Originally posted by EddieMac
They are 3 points behind us with a game in hand. Fair point well made! I still think context is key. We are miles clear, and our points per game is loads better than the bottom three team, all of whom have not chance to improve their squads now. And Burnley would swap with us. Their points per game doesn't suggest they will win the game in hand.
|
|
|
Originally posted by TheBigToePunt
That's why I scrubbed a post I had just done at half time. I totally understand the anger, and today is probably not the time for the likes of me to try and put the managers performance in its proper context. I'm not saying (and never have) that it's wrong to conclude that Roy should go. I just think the grounds on which he should be assessed are misjudged far too often. We let players off a tad too lightly, but more to the point, we lose track of where we are in the bigger scheme of things far too easily. If only you could sit down and talk to our players ...and manager. Armed with a mask.
|
|
|
Originally posted by TheBigToePunt
Not sure I follow you re PVA. Where would you place him amongst Pearce, Irwin, Cole, Evra, Robertson etc? Lower than Robertson, Cole, Evra, of course, but you named 3 of the very best. Higher than Stuart Pearce, I think he was overrated, seems great cause he scored a lot of penalty kicks at club level. I would also rank him below than Leighton Baines, Ian Harte, Riise, Kolarov, maybe even Danny Rose (who had some great seasons), but he still makes Top 10. So even with his defensive faults, PVA has actually done something in football and should be respected by us. Edited by mattteo (13 Feb 2021 6.58pm)
|
|
|
Originally posted by Eaglecoops
I agree with you on PVA. Until our forwards are given decent service however I refuse to totally slag off Batshuyai, Benteke or Mateta. Having said that, you can’t just be a traditional centre forward any more and it looks like we potentially have three of them. The game has moved on I’m afraid and we see our CFs just watching the game instead of getting properly involved. Perhaps Mateta will surprise us, I hope so. I'm struggling to think of a midfield combination at our disposal that would provide 'service'. The closest thing we have to an old school supply line is Townsend, who is punching above his weight to be called 'average'. I know football has moved on, but I always compare Palace sides to the Wright and Bright team. That team was set up to avoid defeat, then service the front two. Everything else was not so much a bonus as an unwelcome indulgence. You wouldn't want to be Salako, Barber or McGoldrick most days - anything other than constant good service was going to get both barrels. I don't think Zaha and Eze are anything like Salako et al. The current two are really skillful, but very individualistic, and thats not the same as supplying service to a forward. We'd do better to produce a poundland version of the Real Madrid forward line, where Benzema worked hard to get Bale and Ronaldo in the game. I doubt we'll see a 20 goal forward at Palace in the forseable.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Eaglecoops
I agree with you on PVA. Until our forwards are given decent service however I refuse to totally slag off Batshuyai, Benteke or Mateta. Having said that, you can’t just be a traditional centre forward any more and it looks like we potentially have three of them. The game has moved on I’m afraid and we see our CFs just watching the game instead of getting properly involved. Perhaps Mateta will surprise us, I hope so. Mateta is of a preferable age and has time to settle down with Eze and a few of our other younger players if our club decides he could be of use, What I found the most irritating toady was not so much the result but the refusal to allow Mateta the game time which is required to bond together with the players around him. I need a whole day to get over this because otherwise I may say something silly about our manager.
|
|
|
Originally posted by mattteo
Lower than Robertson, Cole, Evra, of course, but you named 3 of the very best. Higher than Stuart Pearce, I think he was overrated, seems great cause he scored a lot of penalty kicks at club level. I would also rank him below than Leighton Baines, Ian Harte, Riise, Kolarov, maybe even Danny Rose (who had some great seasons), but he still makes Top 10. So even with his defensive faults, PVA has actually done something in football and should be respected by us. Edited by mattteo (13 Feb 2021 6.58pm)[/quo PVA ranks higher than Stuart Pearce? I'm struggling with that, but I do agree that not only PVA, but all our senior players should be afforded the proper respect to their abilities. Very few human beings are able to hold their ground over the course of a premier league season, a point I make every time someone suggests that we should bin the lot of them and put the youth team in. That said, if PVA were anything other than an average top flight player, I think it would have revealed itself by now. If it walks like a duck etc... Edited by TheBigToePunt (13 Feb 2021 7.15pm)
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.