You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Topic
November 16 2026 11.15am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Coronavirus (LOCKED)


Page 220 of 753 < 216 217 218 219 220 221 222 223 224 >
Jimenez Flag SELHURSTPARKCHESTER,DA BRONX 14 May 20 3.55pm

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

The government and media have scared people half to death and given them the idea that a vaccine will solve this......the 'stay at home' message has been a disaster...The using of Police to intimate people using their gardens...totally mad.

The media, in particular, are very very responsible for doubling up the fear and celebrities were used to amplify the message.

I still can't believe that we had people being called idiots for being outside and sitting in the park!. I honestly think some of us have watched way too many movies....and I'm the prepper on here.....I'm the one who thinks you need a permanent month's supply!

This thread has been dominated by those supporting the idea of full lockdown, despite the resultant mess and widespread misery and death that is going to cause. I believe that time will show that these decisions achieved little and that government folded on herd immunity when the reality was it was the only show in town.

I back humanity to eventually create a vaccine for a coronavirus......but it has to be said, it has never been achieved before.

H1N1 which caused the 1918 Spanish flu, which killed tens of millions is still around and is regarded as seasonal flu. The Hong Kong flu of 69 (H3N2) which killed over a million worldwide is still around and is part of seasonal flu. There are no vaccines only treatments. They exist mainly, but not always, as their weaker strains because obviously lethal versions kill the host quicker and so gradually die out quicker....whereas the virus that doesn't kill the host and survives within the host and continues on without successfully attacking the host. Many people don't realise that most of us have been walking around with viruses inside us most of our lives and our immune system is constantly evolving.

People who think that they can sit inside until there is a vaccine need to realise how unlikely that is anytime soon and that only herd immunity reduces their risks of catching flu or viruses.....that and time ending with only weaker versions remaining and with a very infectious strain like this.....I'd imagine that would take a longer time than usual.

Edited by Stirlingsays (14 May 2020 2.24pm)

 


Pro USA & Israel

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 14 May 20 4.00pm

Can you post the wooded clearing sh&gging scene.

Oh and the torture.

 


COYP

Stirlingsays Flag 14 May 20 4.16pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

If those hibernating forever eventually die from Covid then will that mean all union heads will die?


They are determined to stay inside until nobody dies of anything ever.

And they are going to scream and scream until they're sick.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

DanH Flag SW2 14 May 20 5.34pm

We've been asked to stay inside for 7 weeks. 7 weeks. It's hardly Anne Frank.

 

Stirlingsays Flag 14 May 20 5.59pm

Originally posted by DanH

We've been asked to stay inside for 7 weeks. 7 weeks. It's hardly Anne Frank.

You said you had a degree in economics?

What was it? The economics of Venezuela?

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

DanH Flag SW2 14 May 20 6.08pm

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

You said you had a degree in economics?

What was it? The economics of Venezuela?

We know there's a recession coming, along with pretty much every country in the world. It will be painful, but we will recover as long as measures are put in place to stimulate demand quickly once we are out the other side of this. I've been quietly impressed with how Rishi has been going about things and hasn't been afraid to take bold moves so far - he will need to hold his nerve.

The government are trying to get people back to work when we are nowhere near over the worse of this and will prolong both the actual pain (and you know, actual deaths) and the economic pain.

If we had taken quick and decisive action right back at the beginning of this to control and limit the spread such as your South Korea's and New Zealand's we would not be in the position we are now where we are very realistically sending people out to to work to contract the virus and die because we need to get the economy going again.

It's been a clusterf*ck right from the start and continues to be.

 

Stirlingsays Flag 14 May 20 6.20pm

Originally posted by DanH

We know there's a recession coming, along with pretty much every country in the world. It will be painful, but we will recover as long as measures are put in place to stimulate demand quickly once we are out the other side of this. I've been quietly impressed with how Rishi has been going about things and hasn't been afraid to take bold moves so far - he will need to hold his nerve.

The government are trying to get people back to work when we are nowhere near over the worse of this and will prolong both the actual pain (and you know, actual deaths) and the economic pain.

If we had taken quick and decisive action right back at the beginning of this to control and limit the spread such as your South Korea's and New Zealand's we would not be in the position we are now where we are very realistically sending people out to to work to contract the virus and die because we need to get the economy going again.

It's been a clusterf*ck right from the start and continues to be.


Well I certainly hope you're right about an economic recovery......As for stimulating demand in the era of 'social distancing' and numbskulls crying about 'no risk' lives I seriously doubt your optimism over just how easy that could be.

On the government's actions....it has done exactly what it was told to do by its 'experts'.....Which would have been exactly what any other government would do.....because none of them have balls to face up the media and the whiny scared types.

You keep banging on about other countries and South Korea didn't lockdown of course....and New Zealand's economy will also pay the price for its lockdown.

I could bang on about Sweden and how they will pay a far lesser price than the hair shirt that you insist we should actually be wearing for longer.

Indeed, how exactly much longer do you think the bond markets will just continue buying up debt? We are at WW2 levels now.....All over a virus that will kill far less than the Hong Kong flu of 69.

We had the bank crises in 08, we have had this shower in 20.....Don't you realise just how close we are to disaster? You can't treat the economy like it's your nanny....if people don't think they are going to profit we are fecked.

Edited by Stirlingsays (14 May 2020 6.23pm)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 14 May 20 7.18pm

There’s no chance of an immediate recovery. There so many reasons why not. The usual recession reasons plus restrictions on activity and the mental state of the people. The only recovery will be in crime, and in a big way. Keep your wits about you.

The more I think of it the more I think the people need to be told that now is the time for this war time attitude while they’re shown the consequences of not facing up to the situation, waiting for some safety measures that may never arrive.

 


COYP

BlueJay Flag UK 14 May 20 7.37pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

There’s no chance of an immediate recovery. There so many reasons why not. The usual recession reasons plus restrictions on activity and the mental state of the people. The only recovery will be in crime, and in a big way. Keep your wits about you.

The more I think of it the more I think the people need to be told that now is the time for this war time attitude while they’re shown the consequences of not facing up to the situation, waiting for some safety measures that may never arrive.

I think you're broadly right. The government's primary failing, with one eye on keeping their voter base happy, is to largely refuse to appropriately state the very low risk to the young compared to the old. Therefore everything grinds to a standstill rather than taking a smart approach to protecting the elderly and vulnerable. As we see from care homes, the opposite has happened.

Don't get me wrong, it's clearly worse than the flu and very likely to kill millions worldwide which is horrendous, but with no quick fix in place we do have to muddle along and keep businesses going. I wouldn't blame those in at risk groups from keeping a low profile, but struggle to find an argument against say the under 60's or definitely the under 50s taking sensible steps to stay healthy, but returning to a sense of normalcy in the coming weeks.

The economy can probably bounce back quicker than we realise if we get a focus on living back in place, but if we lurch into another lockdown rather than gradually open up, whatever damage is currently done will take longer and longer to move beyond.


Edited by BlueJay (14 May 2020 7.48pm)

 

cryrst Flag The garden of England 14 May 20 8.13pm

Originally posted by BlueJay

I think you're broadly right. The government's primary failing, with one eye on keeping their voter base happy, is to largely refuse to appropriately state the very low risk to the young compared to the old. Therefore everything grinds to a standstill rather than taking a smart approach to protecting the elderly and vulnerable. As we see from care homes, the opposite has happened.

Don't get me wrong, it's clearly worse than the flu and very likely to kill millions worldwide which is horrendous, but with no quick fix in place we do have to muddle along and keep businesses going. I wouldn't blame those in at risk groups from keeping a low profile, but struggle to find an argument against say the under 60's or definitely the under 50s taking sensible steps to stay healthy, but returning to a sense of normalcy in the coming weeks.

The economy can probably bounce back quicker than we realise if we get a focus on living back in place, but if we lurch into another lockdown rather than gradually open up, whatever damage is currently done will take longer and longer to move beyond.


Edited by BlueJay (14 May 2020 7.48pm)

I pick one word from that ...sensible.
Not goner happen as some dont care about their own safety. Why would they give monkeys about anyone else's. That fundamentally is what needs to be the slogan. Dont protect yourself,protect others.
A twist on be aware I suppose. Good psychology though.

 

matthau Flag South Croydon 14 May 20 8.32pm

[Link]

 

BlueJay Flag UK 14 May 20 8.40pm

Originally posted by cryrst

I pick one word from that ...sensible.
Not goner happen as some dont care about their own safety. Why would they give monkeys about anyone else's. That fundamentally is what needs to be the slogan. Dont protect yourself,protect others.
A twist on be aware I suppose. Good psychology though.

Sad but true Cryrst, there will always be those who are anything but sensible or community minded. I saw a clip from China where someone was smearing their spit on products in a supermarket. Warped stuff.

Thankfully there are vast numbers of people looking out for themselves and others though. As you rightly say protecting others is the name of the game, when combined with making sensible decisions based on your own risk level.

 

silvertop Flag Portishead 14 May 20 9.02pm

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

The government and media have scared people half to death and given them the idea that a vaccine will solve this......the 'stay at home' message has been a disaster...The using of Police to intimate people using their gardens...totally mad.

The media, in particular, are very very responsible for doubling up the fear and celebrities were used to amplify the message.

I still can't believe that we had people being called idiots for being outside and sitting in the park!. I honestly think some of us have watched way too many movies....and I'm the prepper on here.....I'm the one who thinks you need a permanent month's supply!

This thread has been dominated by those supporting the idea of full lockdown, despite the resultant mess and widespread misery and death that is going to cause. I believe that time will show that these decisions achieved little and that government folded on herd immunity when the reality was it was the only show in town.

I back humanity to eventually create a vaccine for a coronavirus......but it has to be said, it has never been achieved before.

H1N1 which caused the 1918 Spanish flu, which killed tens of millions is still around and is regarded as seasonal flu. The Hong Kong flu of 69 (H3N2) which killed over a million worldwide is still around and is part of seasonal flu. There are no vaccines only treatments. They exist mainly, but not always, as their weaker strains because obviously lethal versions kill the host quicker and so gradually die out quicker....whereas the virus that doesn't kill the host and survives within the host and continues on without successfully attacking the host. Many people don't realise that most of us have been walking around with viruses inside us most of our lives and our immune system is constantly evolving.

People who think that they can sit inside until there is a vaccine need to realise how unlikely that is anytime soon and that only herd immunity reduces their risks of catching flu or viruses.....that and time ending with only weaker versions remaining and with a very infectious strain like this.....I'd imagine that would take a longer time than usual.

I had to read this twice just be sure.

Stirling I agree every word!

The job of politicians is to remain in power. They fear the backlash of body bags even though most of the deaths are not additional but will have died this year anyway.

The job of civil servants is allocation of scarce resources. Lockdown serves one practical purpose. To prevent the health service being overrun. The civil service have led lockdown to fulfill their function of preventing resource overload.

In combination they have destroyed the economy and arrested the natural processes leading to herd immunity

Edited by Stirlingsays (14 May 2020 2.24pm)

 

DanH Flag SW2 14 May 20 9.18pm

Would love to know just how many deaths you ‘herd immunity’ disciples would have been fine with.

 

Teddy Eagle Flag 14 May 20 9.29pm

Originally posted by DanH

Would love to know just how many deaths you ‘herd immunity’ disciples would have been fine with.

By the same token how many months lockdown every year would people be fine with?

 

cryrst Flag The garden of England 14 May 20 9.35pm

[Link]

 

cryrst Flag The garden of England 14 May 20 9.44pm

Not everyone with underlying issues would have died within a year. Recent reports are saying many would have 5 to 10 years without covid. It's not hard for historic records on health issues and life span to be checked and that's where those reports are composed from. Still never mind they paid their tax, now they're a burden so bye bye old people.

 

Wisbech Eagle Flag Truro Cornwall 14 May 20 10.43pm

I have supported, and continue to support, the government's handling of this crisis. Of course in a world where we all know everything, all the time, and "hindsight" wasn't in the dictionary, no mistakes would have been made. Eyes wouldn't have been on the 31st Jan Brexit deadline and we would have had enough PPE to last for a few years in stock. Life though isn't like that.

Those arguing that the lockdown has caused more problems than it solves seem to me to be ignoring some basic facts.

Very little was known about this virus at the start, and although we know more now it seems there is still more we don't know than we do. For instance, I heard yesterday that it seems that a significant proportion of those requiring respiration are suffering kidney failure. Initially, that was thought to be as a consequence of dehydration but pms have shown that the kidneys are full of virus, presumably because the receptors they use are present in the kidneys in large numbers. Those suffering kidney failure are dialysed and the machines are clogging up quickly because of the way a patient's blood is thickening. They don't know why yet. There is just so much they are still finding out about how the virus attacks us.

It's known that the transmission rate is about 3 times greater than flu so if it were just left to spread and ultimately create the herd immunity that some want asap, and will eventually be the case, the numbers falling ill would have quickly overwhelmed the NHS.

So we took the drastic steps we did because we had no other realistic choice that would have been acceptable to most people. We bought ourselves some time to learn and get those things in place that needed to be organised. We "flattened the peak". What we did was replicated, with various changes of emphasis, all around the world, depending on the local circumstances.

Those who argue that only the elderly and vulnerable should have been expected to isolate miss another fundamental point. Whilst the younger you are the less impact catching the virus seems to have, that doesn't mean you cannot catch and transmit it. Indeed that makes them more dangerous carriers as they may show no, or only mild, unrecognised, symptoms.

Why does that matter? Keeping the schools open for instance, means that the children of medical and care workers would be mixing with everyone else's children. Everyone else, who were still working and unable to socially distance, would have been under greater exposure and infected more of their children. Who would, in turn, infect the children of the medical and care workers and then those workers themselves. It's a circle that cannot be squared.

Without adequate supplies of PPE, especially in care homes and domiciliary care, the impact can only be imagined. It's been pretty bad as it is, and that's when we have kept the schools closed except for the children of key workers so that with lower numbers a better degree of social distancing can be managed.

Locking down hard as we did, and now gradually easing back, as people get adapted to the situation, makes perfect sense in terms of risk management. Everyone knows that the economic hit is going to be hard and not easy to recover from very quickly, but some of the demand will still be there and available as the brakes come off.

Not to have done so, and just allowed the virus to run its course, could have resulted in creating a very much worse situation. Both in terms of the death rate, and the social impact. That could very easily have also caused an even greater economic disaster than we now face. That was just too big a risk to take when we knew so little at the time we needed to take it. Knowing what we do now proves to me that it was unquestionably the right decision, even with the benefit of hindsight.

The answer, unless, until and even when, we get a working vaccine, must be testing. Regularly, for everybody in contact in some way with the vulnerable. And that, I guess, is most of us.

 


For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally.

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 14 May 20 11.16pm

Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle

I have supported, and continue to support, the government's handling of this crisis. Of course in a world where we all know everything, all the time, and "hindsight" wasn't in the dictionary, no mistakes would have been made. Eyes wouldn't have been on the 31st Jan Brexit deadline and we would have had enough PPE to last for a few years in stock. Life though isn't like that.

Those arguing that the lockdown has caused more problems than it solves seem to me to be ignoring some basic facts.

Very little was known about this virus at the start, and although we know more now it seems there is still more we don't know than we do. For instance, I heard yesterday that it seems that a significant proportion of those requiring respiration are suffering kidney failure. Initially, that was thought to be as a consequence of dehydration but pms have shown that the kidneys are full of virus, presumably because the receptors they use are present in the kidneys in large numbers. Those suffering kidney failure are dialysed and the machines are clogging up quickly because of the way a patient's blood is thickening. They don't know why yet. There is just so much they are still finding out about how the virus attacks us.

It's known that the transmission rate is about 3 times greater than flu so if it were just left to spread and ultimately create the herd immunity that some want asap, and will eventually be the case, the numbers falling ill would have quickly overwhelmed the NHS.

So we took the drastic steps we did because we had no other realistic choice that would have been acceptable to most people. We bought ourselves some time to learn and get those things in place that needed to be organised. We "flattened the peak". What we did was replicated, with various changes of emphasis, all around the world, depending on the local circumstances.

Those who argue that only the elderly and vulnerable should have been expected to isolate miss another fundamental point. Whilst the younger you are the less impact catching the virus seems to have, that doesn't mean you cannot catch and transmit it. Indeed that makes them more dangerous carriers as they may show no, or only mild, unrecognised, symptoms.

Why does that matter? Keeping the schools open for instance, means that the children of medical and care workers would be mixing with everyone else's children. Everyone else, who were still working and unable to socially distance, would have been under greater exposure and infected more of their children. Who would, in turn, infect the children of the medical and care workers and then those workers themselves. It's a circle that cannot be squared.

Without adequate supplies of PPE, especially in care homes and domiciliary care, the impact can only be imagined. It's been pretty bad as it is, and that's when we have kept the schools closed except for the children of key workers so that with lower numbers a better degree of social distancing can be managed.

Locking down hard as we did, and now gradually easing back, as people get adapted to the situation, makes perfect sense in terms of risk management. Everyone knows that the economic hit is going to be hard and not easy to recover from very quickly, but some of the demand will still be there and available as the brakes come off.

Not to have done so, and just allowed the virus to run its course, could have resulted in creating a very much worse situation. Both in terms of the death rate, and the social impact. That could very easily have also caused an even greater economic disaster than we now face. That was just too big a risk to take when we knew so little at the time we needed to take it. Knowing what we do now proves to me that it was unquestionably the right decision, even with the benefit of hindsight.

The answer, unless, until and even when, we get a working vaccine, must be testing. Regularly, for everybody in contact in some way with the vulnerable. And that, I guess, is most of us.

I agree with what you’ve said apart from your cycle of infection of children of care workers and nhs staff, which is still a risk as you put it, unless you’re saying because the NHS isn’t overcome that it now isn’t a problem.

People want zero risk until a vaccine. I’ve just heard the record for a vaccine is 4 years, and there’s been no discovered vaccine for any Coronavirus yet.

 


COYP

Teddy Eagle Flag 14 May 20 11.24pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

I agree with what you’ve said apart from your cycle of infection of children of care workers and nhs staff, which is still a risk as you put it, unless you’re saying because the NHS isn’t overcome that it now isn’t a problem.

People want zero risk until a vaccine. I’ve just heard the record for a vaccine is 4 years, and there’s been no discovered vaccine for any Coronavirus yet.

But as previously stated the flu vaccine is only between 40 and 60% effective and there have been years of research into that.

 

Page 220 of 753 < 216 217 218 219 220 221 222 223 224 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Topic