This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
How will any settlement with the nurses be paid for? There are not any opportunities to reform working practices and make productivity gains. How about an increase in NIC contributions
|
|
|
Originally posted by Midlands Eagle
How about an increase in NIC contributions Now that's a great idea why didn't the Tories think of that
One more point |
|
|
Originally posted by Midlands Eagle
How about an increase in NIC contributions That hot potato that was cancelled yup. Because 1.5% was such a huge amount but a 19% rise isn’t
|
|
|
Originally posted by cryrst
That hot potato that was cancelled yup. Because 1.5% was such a huge amount but a 19% rise isn’t I hope you are not suggesting that the public are in favour of big pay rises for the public sector but are against tax rises. That would be illogical and hypocritical.
One more point |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
Who said that? It's obviously untrue. My wife is a nurse, but I fundamentally disagree with them taking strike action at any time, but especially now. How will any settlement with the nurses be paid for? There are not any opportunities to reform working practices and make productivity gains. The nurses look for them all the time as they are so stretched. Give them more and others either get less or taxes rise. Inflation rises too. Give in to the nurses and a benchmark is set. Giving in to the train drivers would be even worse. So I think it is going to be resisted and then, after a few weeks a compromise reached whereby the pay review body will be asked to review their recommendation in the light of current inflation and a commitment made to raise money, in stages, after a plan to reduce reliance on agency staff has been implemented. I am not sure but Gary Neville went on a political rant about the UK, basically saying we criticise Qatar but… I suspect he is the culprit. He should not be used as a pundit again, if he insists on using it to mouth off. Looks like I was right. Oh sorry on,y the Mail! Edited by Spiderman (19 Dec 2022 9.13am)
|
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
Who said that? It's obviously untrue. My wife is a nurse, but I fundamentally disagree with them taking strike action at any time, but especially now. How will any settlement with the nurses be paid for? There are not any opportunities to reform working practices and make productivity gains. The nurses look for them all the time as they are so stretched. Give them more and others either get less or taxes rise. Inflation rises too. Give in to the nurses and a benchmark is set. Giving in to the train drivers would be even worse. So I think it is going to be resisted and then, after a few weeks a compromise reached whereby the pay review body will be asked to review their recommendation in the light of current inflation and a commitment made to raise money, in stages, after a plan to reduce reliance on agency staff has been implemented. It was Gary Neville so I will leave it at that. If the nurses have their claim met in full they will their position will still be worse than in 2010. What sort of society do you wish to live in?
|
|
|
Originally posted by HKOwen
As society where nasty anti semitic people like Corbyn and his fellow travellers can never get into a position of power.
The last 6 years have gone fantastically at least - Boris is clearly a more moral bloke.
|
|
|
Originally posted by steeleye20
It was Gary Neville so I will leave it at that. If the nurses have their claim met in full they will their position will still be worse than in 2010. What sort of society do you wish to live in? One that rewards people appropriately of course but also one that manages its finances responsibly. This is not the time to risk the consequences of failing to do the latter in the pursuit of the former. We need to prioritise.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Midlands Eagle
How about an increase in NIC contributions I don't think an increase is what is needed, a requirement for retired people to pay is absolutely needed. If they pay income tax they should pay NIC. It isn't as though money previously paid in has contributed sufficient to pay for their medical care in older age, that is a total fallacy. Unearned income generally should be subject to NIC or an equivalent. And Corporation Tax plus Dividends should amount to equal taxation as employment tax. There is no valid reason why they don't, other than the influence of the rich at Government level.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Mapletree
I don't think an increase is what is needed, a requirement for retired people to pay is absolutely needed. If they pay income tax they should pay NIC. It isn't as though money previously paid in has contributed sufficient to pay for their medical care in older age, that is a total fallacy. Unearned income generally should be subject to NIC or an equivalent. And Corporation Tax plus Dividends should amount to equal taxation as employment tax. There is no valid reason why they don't, other than the influence of the rich at Government level. For once I agree with you. There are far too many people not paying into the National Health Service and I include myself in that number. Where you draw the line is a matter of debate personally I think every adult should pay something but that's just me. I have no idea how much your idea will raise? As I mentioned in my previous post lots of people support the strikers but then moan when tax rises are mentioned, something has to give.
One more point |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
One that rewards people appropriately of course but also one that manages its finances responsibly. This is not the time to risk the consequences of failing to do the latter in the pursuit of the former. We need to prioritise. How has the last 12 years rewarded the nurses 'appropriately'? You mean managing its finances responsibly to prioritise wealthy asset holders and retired who do not make any contribution to anybody but themselves.
|
|
|
Originally posted by steeleye20
How has the last 12 years rewarded the nurses 'appropriately'? You mean managing its finances responsibly to prioritise wealthy asset holders and retired who do not make any contribution to anybody but themselves. But is not just nurses, the whole of the public sector are much worse off. In fact, nurses have been given more rises than, for example, BF Officers. Are you saying then, that all public sector workers should get 19%? If so, that’s ridiculous and totally unaffordable.
Edited by Spiderman (19 Dec 2022 3.20pm)
|
|
|
Originally posted by Mapletree
I don't think an increase is what is needed, a requirement for retired people to pay is absolutely needed. If they pay income tax they should pay NIC. It isn't as though money previously paid in has contributed sufficient to pay for their medical care in older age, that is a total fallacy. Unearned income generally should be subject to NIC or an equivalent. And Corporation Tax plus Dividends should amount to equal taxation as employment tax. There is no valid reason why they don't, other than the influence of the rich at Government level. Do agree with your points.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Spiderman
But is not just nurses, the whole of the public sector are much worse off. In fact, nurses have been given more rises than, for example, BF Officers. Are you saying then, that all public sector workers should get 19%? If so, that’s ridiculous and totally unaffordable.
Edited by Spiderman (19 Dec 2022 3.20pm) I think it would be 12/13 billions considering the additional tax revenue to the government, to redress the last 12 years effect on public service workers. Currently they cost 233 billions (wow) this would make it 245 billions. There are public service workers who are vital, like the nurses, but many not so much so it is a difficult one, just a blanket increase everywhere doesn't feel right. My personal view is that we should be taxing wealth much more and rewarding work, I don't see why working families should pay for this Mr.Sunak. More like the rich, namely yourself.
|
|
|
Originally posted by steeleye20
I think it would be 12/13 billions considering the additional tax revenue to the government, to redress the last 12 years effect on public service workers. Currently they cost 233 billions (wow) this would make it 245 billions. There are public service workers who are vital, like the nurses, but many not so much so it is a difficult one, just a blanket increase everywhere doesn't feel right. My personal view is that we should be taxing wealth much more and rewarding work, I don't see why working families should pay for this Mr.Sunak. More like the rich, namely yourself.
Sounds like the solution to me.....I mean no one's ever tried that one before. It's sure to bring us loads of tax. Eat the rich!! Up the revolution!! Power to the People!!
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by steeleye20
How has the last 12 years rewarded the nurses 'appropriately'? You mean managing its finances responsibly to prioritise wealthy asset holders and retired who do not make any contribution to anybody but themselves. It's not just the last 12 years. We have never rewarded nurses, or other key workers, appropriately. We are though where we are and now is just not the time to try to deal with a systemic issue.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
Hasn't the private sector fared much worse than the public? At least there is far more job security in the public and actual pensions worth the name if you can stick it out. I think you need to check the figures on pay rises. The pension is less attractive than it was, since 2015 (unless you were a protected employee) my understanding is that it is a DB scheme based on average earnings not final salary.
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.