|
Been thinking more about this.
Any solicitors or barristers on here please correct me.
It seems to me that Freedman only had the responsibility to raise the issue if it appeared something criminal had been undertaken. In any case that is surely the first point, did Moody do something criminal in which case the Courts would have jurisdiction.
Assuming he did not, it looks possible he is in breach of his Settlement Agreement. In that case, if what has been said earlier in this thread is correct, Cardiff can take him to civil court and I would think the Premier League couldn't stop an employer taking its ex employee to court.
So the next threshold to cross is to prove he breached his confidentiality or non-compete clause(s). If that is done successfully, I would expect Cardiff to be able to reclaim what was paid to Moody in his Settlement Agreement, especially as he probably mitigated much of his loss when he left Cardiff as he joined Palace pretty quickly. I would also expect Cardiff to try to obtain damages. Here there would be a big burden of proving the loss and I doubt they would have any success.
Presumably Cardiff can't join Palace to any civil case as it says above that one Premier team can't sue another. So then the Premier League has to act in place of the courts.
If Cardiff can prove a wrong and prove the amount of loss suffered, the Premier League may then take some action. Many hills to climb before getting to that point and it's arguable they suffered no loss at all. I can't for one minute believe the Premier League would impute that Cardiff would have won had none of this happened, so I just don't see a points deduction or a replay. Maybe a fine to slap us on the wrist and some small damages to Cardiff for the hassle factor.
Edited by Mapletree (19 Apr 2014 10.47am)
|