You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Rugby world cup 2015
November 22 2026 1.18am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Rugby world cup 2015


Page 23 of 26 < 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 >
ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 20 Oct 15 8.04pm

Quote sydtheeagle at 20 Oct 2015 6.34pm

Quote ASCPFC at 20 Oct 2015 5.19pm

Doubt I'm the first to think it, but this is the first world cup where I am genuinely little interested in the semi-finals. May gain some interest if Argentina get to the final, which is something I never thought I would say - well since 1982 at least.
Seems like an Australia v NZ final now and I only recently watched 'The Rugby Championship' - which I believe is its official name now.
Anti-climax is not really a strong enough word for a Six Nations/Northern Hemisphere fan.

I don't know. If you had said this before the tournament, I'd probably have agreed with you. But the SH nations have played such demonstrably better and, furthermore, vastly more thrilling rugby than their NH counterparts that I probably no longer agree. I know there is the issue of having a "local team" to support but really, which of the four would you replace? None of the NH teams came even close to the level of the four semi-finalists (possibly except South Africa at times) and none were nearly as entertaining to watch. And from a neutral perspective, can rugby be any better than the two games this weekend? I still do get what you're saying but I can't persuade myself that I'd be more excited to see how things unfolded if a home nation was still around. The ABs vs. the Bokke is pretty much the classic rugby match; a contrast of history, style, mentality and tactics. And Argentina haven't just crashed the party; they've arrived. From nowhere (more or less) to better than any NH team in little over a decade. I, too, would love to see the Argies reach the final but in spite of the failure of the NH teams, this has been a great World Cup for rugby.

There has been great rugby in this tournament, although alternatively I have seen no figures to suggest that this has been a great world cup for rugby. I wouldn't be sure if rugby has spread itself further afield or become more popular worldwide - which is something I would like to see.
From a home nations perspective it has simply been disappointing - which was my main point. It is mainly a personal viewpoint as firstly, I support England and seeing how I have lived in Ireland for over a decade now I tend to support them second. I also always give a nod to Scotland as my Grandfather was Scottish.
It is Scotland I feel sorriest as they were robbed at the death, although it has to be suspected that they wouldn't have gone any further. Wales should have won as well - but only have themselves to blame.
I always get my hopes up about the chances of the six nations sides only to have my hopes blown away by the reality (excepting 2003). Guess I should have just expected this, again.

 


Red and Blue Army!

johnno42000 Flag 20 Oct 15 8.52pm

Quote ASCPFC at 20 Oct 2015 8.04pm

Quote sydtheeagle at 20 Oct 2015 6.34pm

Quote ASCPFC at 20 Oct 2015 5.19pm

Doubt I'm the first to think it, but this is the first world cup where I am genuinely little interested in the semi-finals. May gain some interest if Argentina get to the final, which is something I never thought I would say - well since 1982 at least.
Seems like an Australia v NZ final now and I only recently watched 'The Rugby Championship' - which I believe is its official name now.
Anti-climax is not really a strong enough word for a Six Nations/Northern Hemisphere fan.

I don't know. If you had said this before the tournament, I'd probably have agreed with you. But the SH nations have played such demonstrably better and, furthermore, vastly more thrilling rugby than their NH counterparts that I probably no longer agree. I know there is the issue of having a "local team" to support but really, which of the four would you replace? None of the NH teams came even close to the level of the four semi-finalists (possibly except South Africa at times) and none were nearly as entertaining to watch. And from a neutral perspective, can rugby be any better than the two games this weekend? I still do get what you're saying but I can't persuade myself that I'd be more excited to see how things unfolded if a home nation was still around. The ABs vs. the Bokke is pretty much the classic rugby match; a contrast of history, style, mentality and tactics. And Argentina haven't just crashed the party; they've arrived. From nowhere (more or less) to better than any NH team in little over a decade. I, too, would love to see the Argies reach the final but in spite of the failure of the NH teams, this has been a great World Cup for rugby.

There has been great rugby in this tournament, although alternatively I have seen no figures to suggest that this has been a great world cup for rugby. I wouldn't be sure if rugby has spread itself further afield or become more popular worldwide - which is something I would like to see.
From a home nations perspective it has simply been disappointing - which was my main point. It is mainly a personal viewpoint as firstly, I support England and seeing how I have lived in Ireland for over a decade now I tend to support them second. I also always give a nod to Scotland as my Grandfather was Scottish.
It is Scotland I feel sorriest as they were robbed at the death, although it has to be suspected that they wouldn't have gone any further. Wales should have won as well - but only have themselves to blame.
I always get my hopes up about the chances of the six nations sides only to have my hopes blown away by the reality (excepting 2003). Guess I should have just expected this, again.

That's a bit harsh. We were playing with a lot of injuries to some good players and it took a score in the last 10 minutes to get the Boks in front.

Saying that it has been very disappointing results wise from all of the 6 Nations sides.

I can't believe it is purely playing against the big 3 SH sides that has made Argentina such a good side, although I cannot think of any other reason why

 


'Lies to the masses as are like fly's to mollasses...they want more and more and more'

sydtheeagle Flag England 20 Oct 15 8.59pm

Quote ASCPFC at 20 Oct 2015 8.04pm

There has been great rugby in this tournament, although alternatively I have seen no figures to suggest that this has been a great world cup for rugby. I wouldn't be sure if rugby has spread itself further afield or become more popular worldwide - which is something I would like to see.

It's hard to say, but I think it has been a great World Cup on both counts. Certainly, the attendance figures are the highest ever by some margin, although that mainly points to interest in a country already interested in the sport.

Where I think it has been great for rugby is:

1. There really are no 110-0 score lines anymore, and they used to be commonplace. Yes, there are still big defeats but even at 52-10 or the like, Namibia are scoring points off the ABs and remaining competitive through 60 minutes. There is still a gap, but it is narrowing.

2. There are far fewer walkovers. Apart from Japan, Fiji, Canada, Georgia and the USA were all clearly competitive even against better sides. Fiji now has a pack to go with its backs; Canada's half backs were excellent; Georgia's 8 and 9 in particular were sensational, the latter only a teenager. All had at least one or two players who could appear in a Six Nations side. Gorgodze was among the best 8s at the tournament.

3. Japan. The impact of their team in a market that's massively important commercially to the future of the sport cannot be underestimated. And Japan has a Super Rugby franchise starting in 2016 which will further speed their development. And then the World Cup itself in 2019.

The biggest problem rugby has isn't that the tier 2 nations aren't getting up to speed -- they clearly are. It's that the Tier 1 nations will, as usual, do nothing to help them hasten the progression, at least in the Northern Hemisphere. While the ABs, Australia and South Africa have seen fit to bring first Argentina and now Japan into the fold by entering them in their major tournaments, what are we doing for Georgia or Romania? Precisely nothing. It's tempting to say Italy is a failed experiment which is continued largely because the blazers like an annual weekend in Rome but the real future of European rugby lies to the east of the continent. Where there is less immediate commercial advantage.

I think we'd all like to see rugby broaden its borders and it has taken a step in that direction with this World Cup although, no doubt, progress is and will continue to be slow at least in this part of the world. Something needs to be done to ensure the momentum built by this World Cup isn't lost.

 


Sydenham by birth. Selhurst by the Grace of God.

The Sash Flag Now residing in Epsom - How Posh 21 Oct 15 8.25am

I have thoroughly enjoyed this World Cup to be honest and Argentina apart, 3 of the 4 Semi-Finalists are exactly who I (and probably most) would have expected to make the last 4 so no real surprises.

New Zealand, love them or loathe them, continue to play a different sport to the rest of the world.

Their entire team, including even their 3rd choice prop, as we saw against France, are such accomplished all round players they can break and side step like wingers and slip one handed passes round their backs in contact like the most girly of backs.

I cant see a Dan Cole or Joe Marler doing the same can you ?

What this WC should be is a massive wake up call for the old guard from the North and their stuffy unions, especially England - The SH are not just still way ahead but the lesser nations are catching the North - using that 'Southern' way of playing as a template.

This game is won or lost at the breakdown, its won or lost by keeping the ball moving, its won or lost on the intensity levels you play at - England's trundling forwards, hitting contact, slowly recycling to the scrum half, only to do it all again is almost prehistoric. We have some genuinely exciting players but as demonstrated with JJ, a coaching team that would rather play limited tacklers (BB, OF etc) than give any hint of the maverick or dynamic.

England, with its money and talent pool are the best placed of any NH team to push and genuinely compete with the South. The key is the coaching and where that coach comes from. England require a progressive coach who can mould a side to play with that speed at breakdown, that intensity level and encourage and coach every player to be able to offload and quickly...otherwise in another 20 years it wont just be Argentina beating them but Japan as well.

Edited by The Sash (21 Oct 2015 8.27am)

 


As far as the rules go, it's a website not a democracy - Hambo 3/6/2014

sydtheeagle Flag England 21 Oct 15 11.20am

Really well worth reading: [Link]

 


Sydenham by birth. Selhurst by the Grace of God.

The Sash Flag Now residing in Epsom - How Posh 21 Oct 15 11.52am

Quote sydtheeagle at 21 Oct 2015 11.20am

Really well worth reading: [Link]

Interesting that and I do agree (kinda) as I do with Chieka. Its a f*** up but f*** ups happen..my issue with it though is still this and something that Greenwood alludes to

But I watched it over and over on replay this morning and I still could not tell if it was a penalty or not, so it was incredibly difficult for Joubert with one look in the heat of the moment.

I still cannot believe that Joubert could have any certainty with it being a penalty, replays don't show it clearly so real time certainly wouldn't. Before TMO's if there was a mass bundle of bodies pushing the ball over the line and a mass of bodies trying to stop them, and the ref and touch judges couldn't decide they erred on the side of caution...surely that's what Joubert should have done here ?

On the 'spirit of the game' side of things then surely as well Joubert should receive some level of stick from simply running from the field at the end ????


Oh and I love this bit

Scott Quinnell tells a great story about one time he got into a bit of a ding dong with his brother Craig in a match between Llanelli and Cardiff a few years back. Nigel Owens chided them: ‘What would your mother say?’Completely defused the situation.


Edited by The Sash (21 Oct 2015 11.54am)

 


As far as the rules go, it's a website not a democracy - Hambo 3/6/2014

Monty the Eagle Flag Lima 21 Oct 15 12.28pm

Quote The Sash at 21 Oct 2015 11.52am

Quote sydtheeagle at 21 Oct 2015 11.20am

Really well worth reading: [Link]

Interesting that and I do agree (kinda) as I do with Chieka. Its a f*** up but f*** ups happen..my issue with it though is still this and something that Greenwood alludes to

But I watched it over and over on replay this morning and I still could not tell if it was a penalty or not, so it was incredibly difficult for Joubert with one look in the heat of the moment.

I still cannot believe that Joubert could have any certainty with it being a penalty, replays don't show it clearly so real time certainly wouldn't. Before TMO's if there was a mass bundle of bodies pushing the ball over the line and a mass of bodies trying to stop them, and the ref and touch judges couldn't decide they erred on the side of caution...surely that's what Joubert should have done here ?

On the 'spirit of the game' side of things then surely as well Joubert should receive some level of stick from simply running from the field at the end ????


Oh and I love this bit

Scott Quinnell tells a great story about one time he got into a bit of a ding dong with his brother Craig in a match between Llanelli and Cardiff a few years back. Nigel Owens chided them: ‘What would your mother say?’Completely defused the situation.


Edited by The Sash (21 Oct 2015 11.54am)

Another interesting quote was "I don’t know if the Samoans are making a list about the little knock-on Scotland scored before the end".

I appreciate due to the importance of the game it gets more attention but potentially if this knock on had been picked up then Scotland wouldn't have been in the quarter finals in the first place.

I personally don't want the TMO to be used for everything otherwise rugby will turn into American Football. Like in all sports part of the attraction is that errors can be made. What the hell would we all talk about if no mistakes were ever made due to replays being used to ensure every decision was correct. A game of football or rugby would all of a sudden take over three hours!

 

The Sash Flag Now residing in Epsom - How Posh 21 Oct 15 12.32pm

Quote Monty the Eagle at 21 Oct 2015 12.28pm

Quote The Sash at 21 Oct 2015 11.52am

Quote sydtheeagle at 21 Oct 2015 11.20am

Really well worth reading: [Link]

Interesting that and I do agree (kinda) as I do with Chieka. Its a f*** up but f*** ups happen..my issue with it though is still this and something that Greenwood alludes to

But I watched it over and over on replay this morning and I still could not tell if it was a penalty or not, so it was incredibly difficult for Joubert with one look in the heat of the moment.

I still cannot believe that Joubert could have any certainty with it being a penalty, replays don't show it clearly so real time certainly wouldn't. Before TMO's if there was a mass bundle of bodies pushing the ball over the line and a mass of bodies trying to stop them, and the ref and touch judges couldn't decide they erred on the side of caution...surely that's what Joubert should have done here ?

On the 'spirit of the game' side of things then surely as well Joubert should receive some level of stick from simply running from the field at the end ????


Oh and I love this bit

Scott Quinnell tells a great story about one time he got into a bit of a ding dong with his brother Craig in a match between Llanelli and Cardiff a few years back. Nigel Owens chided them: ‘What would your mother say?’Completely defused the situation.


Edited by The Sash (21 Oct 2015 11.54am)

Another interesting quote was "I don’t know if the Samoans are making a list about the little knock-on Scotland scored before the end".

I appreciate due to the importance of the game it gets more attention but potentially if this knock on had been picked up then Scotland wouldn't have been in the quarter finals in the first place.

I personally don't want the TMO to be used for everything
otherwise rugby will turn into American Football. Like in all sports part of the attraction is that errors can be made. What the hell would we all talk about if no mistakes were ever made due to replays being used to ensure every decision was correct. A game of football or rugby would all of a sudden take over three hours!

Totally agree - The England v Fiji opener was an utter farce.

 


As far as the rules go, it's a website not a democracy - Hambo 3/6/2014

dannyh Flag wherever I lay my hat....... 21 Oct 15 3.01pm

Quote The Sash at 21 Oct 2015 12.32pm

Quote Monty the Eagle at 21 Oct 2015 12.28pm

Quote The Sash at 21 Oct 2015 11.52am

Quote sydtheeagle at 21 Oct 2015 11.20am

Really well worth reading: [Link]

Interesting that and I do agree (kinda) as I do with Chieka. Its a f*** up but f*** ups happen..my issue with it though is still this and something that Greenwood alludes to

But I watched it over and over on replay this morning and I still could not tell if it was a penalty or not, so it was incredibly difficult for Joubert with one look in the heat of the moment.

I still cannot believe that Joubert could have any certainty with it being a penalty, replays don't show it clearly so real time certainly wouldn't. Before TMO's if there was a mass bundle of bodies pushing the ball over the line and a mass of bodies trying to stop them, and the ref and touch judges couldn't decide they erred on the side of caution...surely that's what Joubert should have done here ?

On the 'spirit of the game' side of things then surely as well Joubert should receive some level of stick from simply running from the field at the end ????


Oh and I love this bit

Scott Quinnell tells a great story about one time he got into a bit of a ding dong with his brother Craig in a match between Llanelli and Cardiff a few years back. Nigel Owens chided them: ‘What would your mother say?’Completely defused the situation.


Edited by The Sash (21 Oct 2015 11.54am)

Another interesting quote was "I don’t know if the Samoans are making a list about the little knock-on Scotland scored before the end".

I appreciate due to the importance of the game it gets more attention but potentially if this knock on had been picked up then Scotland wouldn't have been in the quarter finals in the first place.

I personally don't want the TMO to be used for everything
otherwise rugby will turn into American Football. Like in all sports part of the attraction is that errors can be made. What the hell would we all talk about if no mistakes were ever made due to replays being used to ensure every decision was correct. A game of football or rugby would all of a sudden take over three hours!

Totally agree - The England v Fiji opener was an utter farce.


Afer all the analyisis the only conclusion can be that he favoured the Aussies, it has been proven on TV time and time again that to call it a dead cert of a penalty was impossible, so how, and why did he give it, when it was clear to everyone else in the known universe that it was not a clear penalty.

I know you rugger buggers are all jolly decent fellows, but I'm 70/30 split in footballs favour, and I'm calling him a CHEAT, DIRY, ROTTEN, STINKING. And a fcking coward legging it off the pitch like that, what a w***er.

 


"It's not the bullet that's got my name on it that concerns me; it's all them other ones flyin' around marked 'To Whom It May Concern.'"

johnno42000 Flag 25 Oct 15 4.13pm

Great start to the match. The Aussies really punishing the Argentinian mistakes.

 


'Lies to the masses as are like fly's to mollasses...they want more and more and more'

oldcodger Flag 25 Oct 15 4.33pm

Quote johnno42000 at 25 Oct 2015 4.13pm

Great start to the match. The Aussies really punishing the Argentinian mistakes.


I'm hoping Argentina pick things up a bit to make it competitive. Not a great first half from them so far.

 

johnno42000 Flag 25 Oct 15 5.22pm

Quote oldcodger at 25 Oct 2015 4.33pm

Quote johnno42000 at 25 Oct 2015 4.13pm

Great start to the match. The Aussies really punishing the Argentinian mistakes.


I'm hoping Argentina pick things up a bit to make it competitive. Not a great first half from them so far.

They've started to come back into it in the last 20 mins. Only 7 points in it now.

 


'Lies to the masses as are like fly's to mollasses...they want more and more and more'

Pete53 Flag Hassocks 25 Oct 15 7.12pm

I haven't got time to read all of the posts on this topic, and I expect someone has mentioned this already, but WHY oh WHY is the final on a Saturday at 4pm?

I want to watch the game on the box but will be at the Palace at that time next weekend. There must be thousands of football fans committed to watching their team play on Saturday who would like to see the game.
Surely a 7pm kick-off would have been reasonable and considerate.

 

oldcodger Flag 25 Oct 15 9.25pm

Quote Pete53 at 25 Oct 2015 7.12pm

I haven't got time to read all of the posts on this topic, and I expect someone has mentioned this already, but WHY oh WHY is the final on a Saturday at 4pm?

I want to watch the game on the box but will be at the Palace at that time next weekend. There must be thousands of football fans committed to watching their team play on Saturday who would like to see the game.
Surely a 7pm kick-off would have been reasonable and considerate.


It's a gripe with me too but as this is a world event maybe the kick off time was partially agreed based on that.

 

-TUX- Flag Alphabettispaghetti 25 Oct 15 10.14pm

Quote Pete53 at 25 Oct 2015 7.12pm

I haven't got time to read all of the posts on this topic, and I expect someone has mentioned this already, but WHY oh WHY is the final on a Saturday at 4pm?

I want to watch the game on the box but will be at the Palace at that time next weekend. There must be thousands of football fans committed to watching their team play on Saturday who would like to see the game.
Surely a 7pm kick-off would have been reasonable and considerate.

Are there any other great sporting events you'd like to re-schedule due to a clash of interests?

 


Time to move forward together.

Pete53 Flag Hassocks 25 Oct 15 11.47pm

Quote -TUX- at 25 Oct 2015 10.14pm

Quote Pete53 at 25 Oct 2015 7.12pm

I haven't got time to read all of the posts on this topic, and I expect someone has mentioned this already, but WHY oh WHY is the final on a Saturday at 4pm?

I want to watch the game on the box but will be at the Palace at that time next weekend. There must be thousands of football fans committed to watching their team play on Saturday who would like to see the game.
Surely a 7pm kick-off would have been reasonable and considerate.

Are there any other great sporting events you'd like to re-schedule due to a clash of interests?


None that I can think of at the moment thanks.

This is the rugby World Cup final and I would have thought that all involved, including ITV with an eye on viewing figures, would have wanted to maximise the audience, and in doing so expose the game to as many people as possible. Big matches like this can potentially sell the game to people who may not have previously been that interested in the sport.Seems a missed opportunity.

 

Y Ddraig Goch Flag In The Crowd 26 Oct 15 8.21am

Quote Pete53 at 25 Oct 2015 11.47pm

Quote -TUX- at 25 Oct 2015 10.14pm

Quote Pete53 at 25 Oct 2015 7.12pm

I haven't got time to read all of the posts on this topic, and I expect someone has mentioned this already, but WHY oh WHY is the final on a Saturday at 4pm?

I want to watch the game on the box but will be at the Palace at that time next weekend. There must be thousands of football fans committed to watching their team play on Saturday who would like to see the game.
Surely a 7pm kick-off would have been reasonable and considerate.

Are there any other great sporting events you'd like to re-schedule due to a clash of interests?


None that I can think of at the moment thanks.

This is the rugby World Cup final and I would have thought that all involved, including ITV with an eye on viewing figures, would have wanted to maximise the audience, and in doing so expose the game to as many people as possible. Big matches like this can potentially sell the game to people who may not have previously been that interested in the sport.Seems a missed opportunity.


It's a WORLD CUP, scheduling tries to take into consideration the biggest global audience.

 


the dignified don't even enter in the game

Pete53 Flag Hassocks 26 Oct 15 2.27pm

Quote Y Ddraig Goch at 26 Oct 2015 8.21am

Quote Pete53 at 25 Oct 2015 11.47pm

Quote -TUX- at 25 Oct 2015 10.14pm

Quote Pete53 at 25 Oct 2015 7.12pm

I haven't got time to read all of the posts on this topic, and I expect someone has mentioned this already, but WHY oh WHY is the final on a Saturday at 4pm?

I want to watch the game on the box but will be at the Palace at that time next weekend. There must be thousands of football fans committed to watching their team play on Saturday who would like to see the game.
Surely a 7pm kick-off would have been reasonable and considerate.

Are there any other great sporting events you'd like to re-schedule due to a clash of interests?


None that I can think of at the moment thanks.

This is the rugby World Cup final and I would have thought that all involved, including ITV with an eye on viewing figures, would have wanted to maximise the audience, and in doing so expose the game to as many people as possible. Big matches like this can potentially sell the game to people who may not have previously been that interested in the sport.Seems a missed opportunity.


It's a WORLD CUP, scheduling tries to take into consideration the biggest global audience.


Where is the potential global audience? - presumably in rugby playing nations. Local KO time in, for example, Sydney is 3 am, Christchurch 5 am. I am sure that devotees will get up whatever the time but will the casual follower bother? With a 7pm start it would be 6am and 8am respectively and would I think pick up more viewers.

A 7pm KO would not be a problem in South Africa,2 hours ahead, Argentina 3 hours behind, the US 7 hours behind at most - all would take place during their daytime.

I am sure there must be a reason for a 4pm start but I still think a 7pm/7:30 KO would have more advantages than a 4pm start, particularly as I would be able to watch!

 

Stuk Flag Top half 26 Oct 15 2.45pm

Quote Y Ddraig Goch at 26 Oct 2015 8.21am

Quote Pete53 at 25 Oct 2015 11.47pm

Quote -TUX- at 25 Oct 2015 10.14pm

Quote Pete53 at 25 Oct 2015 7.12pm

I haven't got time to read all of the posts on this topic, and I expect someone has mentioned this already, but WHY oh WHY is the final on a Saturday at 4pm?

I want to watch the game on the box but will be at the Palace at that time next weekend. There must be thousands of football fans committed to watching their team play on Saturday who would like to see the game.
Surely a 7pm kick-off would have been reasonable and considerate.

Are there any other great sporting events you'd like to re-schedule due to a clash of interests?


None that I can think of at the moment thanks.

This is the rugby World Cup final and I would have thought that all involved, including ITV with an eye on viewing figures, would have wanted to maximise the audience, and in doing so expose the game to as many people as possible. Big matches like this can potentially sell the game to people who may not have previously been that interested in the sport.Seems a missed opportunity.


It's a WORLD CUP, scheduling tries to take into consideration the biggest global audience.


Yet they haven't. 2003, 2007 and 2011 all kicked off in the evening for the host time zone. 8 or 9pm.

It's daft, there must be some other reason for the kick off time.

 


Optimistic as ever

The Sash Flag Now residing in Epsom - How Posh 28 Oct 15 1.47pm

Was in Dublin this weekend for the semi-finals - shame that they never made it as the place would have been in chaos...

As for the final - agree that the timing is rubbish but it is what it is...

As for the game - really looking forward to it.

Still fancy the AB's but the Aussies will really make this a game..

The Sash 'Never-wrong-predict-o-meter' has

Saffers to beat the Puma's by 9 or more
AB's to beat the Aussies by 7 or less

 


As far as the rules go, it's a website not a democracy - Hambo 3/6/2014

Page 23 of 26 < 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Rugby world cup 2015