You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > High immigration levels prevent 'cohesive society'
November 21 2026 9.56pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

High immigration levels prevent 'cohesive society'


Page 1 of 15 1 2 3 4 5 > Last >>
leggedstruggle Flag Croydon 06 Oct 15 8.18am

[Link]

Many people have been telling the government this for many years. The response has always been to deny it and to tell us to 'celebrate' the situation. Inevitably realty kicks in and they have to accept what has been obvious. What are they going to do about it? Leaving the EU would be the first major step - along with discouraging divisive multi-culturalism.

 


mother-in-law is an anagram of woman hitler

serial thriller Flag The Promised Land 06 Oct 15 9.05am

I can't help but see this as an opportunistic response to the new rhetoric of the opposition. By once more pushing immigration to the front of political debate, Cameron is able to disregard the fact that we are seeing the largest fall in living standards in a century, a further cut in income for the poorest in society via cuts to tax credits, house prices at an all-time high while house building is at a 50 year low.

For Teresa May to have the cheek to come out and blame migration on issues from transport to low pay is an astonishing piece of calculated deceit. What's playing a bigger role in the highest train fares in Europe, some Syrian asylum seekers or the fact that private railway firms' shareholders are walking away with the hundreds of billions of profits they make instead of reinvesting it? Is it the extra 30 000 extra migrants' fault that we are the most unequal and least socially mobile country in Europe, or is it perhaps due to governments like ours who have overseen an economy where the majority of people in poverty are actually in work?

I look forward to the Tory split on the EU referendum that hopefully spells the beginning of the end for Osbourne and co.

 


If punk ever happened I'd be preaching the law, instead of listenin to Lydon lecture BBC4

leggedstruggle Flag Croydon 06 Oct 15 9.11am

Quote serial thriller at 06 Oct 2015 9.05am

I can't help but see this as an opportunistic response to the new rhetoric of the opposition. By once more pushing immigration to the front of political debate, Cameron is able to disregard the fact that we are seeing the largest fall in living standards in a century, a further cut in income for the poorest in society via cuts to tax credits, house prices at an all-time high while house building is at a 50 year low.

For Teresa May to have the cheek to come out and blame migration on issues from transport to low pay is an astonishing piece of calculated deceit. What's playing a bigger role in the highest train fares in Europe, some Syrian asylum seekers or the fact that private railway firms' shareholders are walking away with the hundreds of billions of profits they make instead of reinvesting it? Is it the extra 30 000 extra migrants' fault that we are the most unequal and least socially mobile country in Europe, or is it perhaps due to governments like ours who have overseen an economy where the majority of people in poverty are actually in work?

I look forward to the Tory split on the EU referendum that hopefully spells the beginning of the end for Osbourne and co.

Unlimited immigration has been a leading factor in low wages and the housing crisis. All parties will be split on the EU (except the half a dozen members of the Lib Dems.)


Edited by leggedstruggle (06 Oct 2015 9.15am)

 


mother-in-law is an anagram of woman hitler

sydtheeagle Flag England 06 Oct 15 10.08am

I would suggest that people's response to immigration rather than the fact of immigration is what determines the nature of society.

 


Sydenham by birth. Selhurst by the Grace of God.

leggedstruggle Flag Croydon 06 Oct 15 10.11am

The Tories are partly taking this line to elicit a tearful response from Corbyn of "immigration is an unmitigated benefit and we should encourage more of it". Double winner for the Tories - panders to the overwhelming anti-immigration feeling in the country and makes Labour take untenable positions. Of course neither the Tories or Labour will do bugger all about the actual problem though.

 


mother-in-law is an anagram of woman hitler

sydtheeagle Flag England 06 Oct 15 10.27am

Multi-culturalism is not divisive. That has been as often proven as the counter argument. People's response to it (which differs from country to country) is what is divisive. There may be compelling reasons why multi-culturalism works less well in some places than it does in others (over-population, shortage of jobs, etc.) but to simply say that multi-culturalism is divisive is both wrong and untrue. When you have national leaders who fan the flames by articulating ignorant positions and making ill-considered statements, it only makes the inherent prejudice of the assertion a). worse, and b). simultaneously, more believable in the eyes of those who don't think for themselves.

 


Sydenham by birth. Selhurst by the Grace of God.

leggedstruggle Flag Croydon 06 Oct 15 11.07am

Quote sydtheeagle at 06 Oct 2015 10.08am

I would suggest that people's response to immigration rather than the fact of immigration is what determines the nature of society.

So our society would have mosques and Islamic extremism here even if there had been no immigration?

 


mother-in-law is an anagram of woman hitler

mezzer Flag Main Stand, Block F, Row 20 seat 1... 06 Oct 15 11.08am

Quote serial thriller at 06 Oct 2015 9.05am

I can't help but see this as an opportunistic response to the new rhetoric of the opposition. By once more pushing immigration to the front of political debate, Cameron is able to disregard the fact that we are seeing the largest fall in living standards in a century, a further cut in income for the poorest in society via cuts to tax credits, house prices at an all-time high while house building is at a 50 year low.

For Teresa May to have the cheek to come out and blame migration on issues from transport to low pay is an astonishing piece of calculated deceit. What's playing a bigger role in the highest train fares in Europe, some Syrian asylum seekers or the fact that private railway firms' shareholders are walking away with the hundreds of billions of profits they make instead of reinvesting it? Is it the extra 30 000 extra migrants' fault that we are the most unequal and least socially mobile country in Europe, or is it perhaps due to governments like ours who have overseen an economy where the majority of people in poverty are actually in work?

I look forward to the Tory split on the EU referendum that hopefully spells the beginning of the end for Osbourne and co.


Do you honestly believe that? Honestly? It's worse now than at any time since 1915 to include between the 1st and 2nd world wars, during the 2nd WW, the period after the 2nd WW, the 3 day week of the 70s and so on? Really?

Or do you mean since the start of this century? In which case you'd still be wrong.

 


Living down here does have some advantages. At least you can see them cry.

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 06 Oct 15 11.57am

Trickle immigration is a good thing for the gene pool but the kind of numbers we have seen in the last 20 years have been insanely large. Shame on the decision makers for putting money before people.
My personal theory on this is that the pill is largely responsible for this. A rapidly declining birth rate in the last century plus two world wars has caused politicians to panic and encourage large numbers of tax paying, cheap labour from abroad. The EU free movement laws have made everything worse.
It's simple. We need to restrict immigration and encourage people to have more children.
Unfortunately, it is probably to late to mend the cultural schisms that we have created. Only extreme measures can change that.

 

OldFella Flag London 06 Oct 15 12.04pm

Quote serial thriller at 06 Oct 2015 9.05am

I can't help but see this as an opportunistic response to the new rhetoric of the opposition. By once more pushing immigration to the front of political debate, Cameron is able to disregard the fact that we are seeing the largest fall in living standards in a century, a further cut in income for the poorest in society via cuts to tax credits, house prices at an all-time high while house building is at a 50 year low.

For Teresa May to have the cheek to come out and blame migration on issues from transport to low pay is an astonishing piece of calculated deceit. What's playing a bigger role in the highest train fares in Europe, some Syrian asylum seekers or the fact that private railway firms' shareholders are walking away with the hundreds of billions of profits they make instead of reinvesting it? Is it the extra 30 000 extra migrants' fault that we are the most unequal and least socially mobile country in Europe, or is it perhaps due to governments like ours who have overseen an economy where the majority of people in poverty are actually in work?

I look forward to the Tory split on the EU referendum that hopefully spells the beginning of the end for Osbourne and co.

Nurse! Nurse! Come and help this deluded soul


 


Jackson.. Wan Bissaka.... Sansom.. Nicholas.. Cannon.. Guehi.... Zaha... Thomas.. Byrne... Holton.. Rogers.. that should do it..

Hoof Hearted 06 Oct 15 12.04pm

Can anyone argue against the fact that uncontrolled immigration puts undue pressure on Housing, Schools, GP's, Hospitals and Travel networks?

Forget the economy... one expert says it's good for competition and start ups, another says it's bad cause it drives down wages and prevents indigenous workers getting jobs.

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 06 Oct 15 12.05pm

Quote leggedstruggle at 06 Oct 2015 11.07am

Quote sydtheeagle at 06 Oct 2015 10.08am

I would suggest that people's response to immigration rather than the fact of immigration is what determines the nature of society.

So our society would have mosques and Islamic extremism here even if there had been no immigration?

Whilst I do think mass immigration, especially temporary economic migration, is detrimental to the UK as a whole, its important to distinguish that mass immigration's impact on society and the impact of immigration are two entirely different scenarios.

Its worth noting that migration to the UK of people with Islamic faith has been going on since the 60s at least, and the UK only has had a problem with Islamic terrorism since 2001, and notably as a real threat since 2003.

Prior to 2001 the UK had no notable incidences of Islamic terrorism. Its almost as if there might be other factors involved, rather than just migration and a myopic view of Islam.

Not sure how it suddenly turns from migration to Islam.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 06 Oct 15 12.10pm

Quote Hrolf The Ganger at 06 Oct 2015 11.57am

Trickle immigration is a good thing for the gene pool but the kind of numbers we have seen in the last 20 years have been insanely large. Shame on the decision makers for putting money before people.
My personal theory on this is that the pill is largely responsible for this. A rapidly declining birth rate in the last century plus two world wars has caused politicians to panic and encourage large numbers of tax paying, cheap labour from abroad. The EU free movement laws have made everything worse.
It's simple. We need to restrict immigration and encourage people to have more children.
Unfortunately, it is probably to late to mend the cultural schisms that we have created. Only extreme measures can change that.

I'd agree with this, more or less. The problem isn't really with migration, refugees etc, that's all more or less sustainable.

The problem is that around 500,000 migrate to the UK each year, and around 225,000 emigrate each year. That's an unsustainable increase, and needs to be curbed. 42% of that figure comes from inside the EU, 58% from outside - and the vast majority is for work.

The problem is that migration to the UK has been adapted by successive governments to fulfill the demands of corporate interests, rather than society, and consequently, this undermines social cohesion (rapid, large scale change, rather than gradual).


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

sydtheeagle Flag England 06 Oct 15 12.16pm

Quote leggedstruggle at 06 Oct 2015 11.07am

Quote sydtheeagle at 06 Oct 2015 10.08am

I would suggest that people's response to immigration rather than the fact of immigration is what determines the nature of society.

So our society would have mosques and Islamic extremism here even if there had been no immigration?

I'm not really clear how your response relates to my point. I presume what you're saying is that mosques and extremism, which are divisive (well, the former is not but the latter certainly is) would not be here without immigration and therefore immigration is divisive. But the same point holds...and you make it for me. Mosques are not divisive...they are simply buildings. But people's response to Mosques, in the form of extremism on either side...is divisive. There have been synagogues and orthodox churches in the UK as a result of immigration since time immemorial. None have led to extremism of the sort we're experiencing now. Therefore, look to something other than the simple fact of immigration if you want to understand why.

 


Sydenham by birth. Selhurst by the Grace of God.

Hoof Hearted 06 Oct 15 12.18pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 06 Oct 2015 12.10pm

Quote Hrolf The Ganger at 06 Oct 2015 11.57am

Trickle immigration is a good thing for the gene pool but the kind of numbers we have seen in the last 20 years have been insanely large. Shame on the decision makers for putting money before people.
My personal theory on this is that the pill is largely responsible for this. A rapidly declining birth rate in the last century plus two world wars has caused politicians to panic and encourage large numbers of tax paying, cheap labour from abroad. The EU free movement laws have made everything worse.
It's simple. We need to restrict immigration and encourage people to have more children.
Unfortunately, it is probably to late to mend the cultural schisms that we have created. Only extreme measures can change that.

I'd agree with this, more or less. The problem isn't really with migration, refugees etc, that's all more or less sustainable.

The problem is that around 500,000 migrate to the UK each year, and around 225,000 emigrate each year. That's an unsustainable increase, and needs to be curbed. 42% of that figure comes from inside the EU, 58% from outside - and the vast majority is for work.

The problem is that migration to the UK has been adapted by successive governments to fulfill the demands of corporate interests, rather than society, and consequently, this undermines social cohesion (rapid, large scale change, rather than gradual).



Don't forget also that immigrants have children which can double/triple the effect on population.

 

leggedstruggle Flag Croydon 06 Oct 15 12.20pm

Quote sydtheeagle at 06 Oct 2015 12.16pm

Quote leggedstruggle at 06 Oct 2015 11.07am

Quote sydtheeagle at 06 Oct 2015 10.08am

I would suggest that people's response to immigration rather than the fact of immigration is what determines the nature of society.

So our society would have mosques and Islamic extremism here even if there had been no immigration?

I'm not really clear how your response relates to my point. I presume what you're saying is that mosques and extremism, which are divisive (well, the former is not but the latter certainly is) would not be here without immigration and therefore immigration is divisive. But the same point holds...and you make it for me. Mosques are not divisive...they are simply buildings. But people's response to Mosques, in the form of extremism on either side...is divisive. There have been synagogues and orthodox churches in the UK as a result of immigration since time immemorial. None have led to extremism of the sort we're experiencing now. Therefore, look to something other than the simple fact of immigration if you want to understand why.

BNP Offices are simply buildings too.

Do you think immigration should be limited in any way? If so, why?


Edited by leggedstruggle (06 Oct 2015 12.27pm)

 


mother-in-law is an anagram of woman hitler

bright&wright Flag 06 Oct 15 12.29pm

If high immigration worked so well why don't people go to West Croydon for a weekend away instead of Cornwall?

Pick a town/city with high immigration in the UK and I guarantee you - it's a sh*thole.

 


'We are going to make a little bit of history here’ Mr. J. Ertl.

sydtheeagle Flag England 06 Oct 15 12.31pm

Quote leggedstruggle at 06 Oct 2015 12.20pm

Quote sydtheeagle at 06 Oct 2015 12.16pm

Quote leggedstruggle at 06 Oct 2015 11.07am

Quote sydtheeagle at 06 Oct 2015 10.08am

I would suggest that people's response to immigration rather than the fact of immigration is what determines the nature of society.

So our society would have mosques and Islamic extremism here even if there had been no immigration?

I'm not really clear how your response relates to my point. I presume what you're saying is that mosques and extremism, which are divisive (well, the former is not but the latter certainly is) would not be here without immigration and therefore immigration is divisive. But the same point holds...and you make it for me. Mosques are not divisive...they are simply buildings. But people's response to Mosques, in the form of extremism on either side...is divisive. There have been synagogues and orthodox churches in the UK as a result of immigration since time immemorial. None have led to extremism of the sort we're experiencing now. Therefore, look to something other than the simple fact of immigration if you want to understand why.

BNP Offices are simply buildings too.

Do you think immigration should be limited in any way? If so, why?


Edited by leggedstruggle (06 Oct 2015 12.27pm)

Mosques are places of worship that have become sometimes misused but their intent is good. BNP offices exist solely to propagate hate. So while yes, in one sense they are both buildings your point is fatuous; they are not the same as each other.

With regard to your second question I will try to answer in due course but what I would say is that there is no blanket response to any question about society. "All immigration is unconditionally good" is as stupid a statement as "all immigration is unconditionally bad." I wouldn't let either everybody or nobody in. It's a question of where you draw the line.

 


Sydenham by birth. Selhurst by the Grace of God.

DanH Flag SW2 06 Oct 15 12.37pm

Quote bright&wright at 06 Oct 2015 12.29pm

If high immigration worked so well why don't people go to West Croydon for a weekend away instead of Cornwall?

Pick a town/city with high immigration in the UK and I guarantee you - it's a sh*thole.


One of the most ridiculous points ever made on here. Good work.

 

leggedstruggle Flag Croydon 06 Oct 15 12.41pm

Quote sydtheeagle at 06 Oct 2015 12.31pm

Quote leggedstruggle at 06 Oct 2015 12.20pm

Quote sydtheeagle at 06 Oct 2015 12.16pm

Quote leggedstruggle at 06 Oct 2015 11.07am

Quote sydtheeagle at 06 Oct 2015 10.08am

I would suggest that people's response to immigration rather than the fact of immigration is what determines the nature of society.

So our society would have mosques and Islamic extremism here even if there had been no immigration?

I'm not really clear how your response relates to my point. I presume what you're saying is that mosques and extremism, which are divisive (well, the former is not but the latter certainly is) would not be here without immigration and therefore immigration is divisive. But the same point holds...and you make it for me. Mosques are not divisive...they are simply buildings. But people's response to Mosques, in the form of extremism on either side...is divisive. There have been synagogues and orthodox churches in the UK as a result of immigration since time immemorial. None have led to extremism of the sort we're experiencing now. Therefore, look to something other than the simple fact of immigration if you want to understand why.

BNP Offices are simply buildings too.

Do you think immigration should be limited in any way? If so, why?


Edited by leggedstruggle (06 Oct 2015 12.27pm)

Mosques are places of worship that have become sometimes misused but their intent is good. BNP offices exist solely to propagate hate. So while yes, in one sense they are both buildings your point is fatuous; they are not the same as each other.

With regard to your second question I will try to answer in due course but what I would say is that there is no blanket response to any question about society. "All immigration is unconditionally good" is as stupid a statement as "all immigration is unconditionally bad." I wouldn't let either everybody or nobody in. It's a question of where you draw the line.

LOL. Their 'intent' is to peddle a 'faith' that is undemocratic, misogynist, anti-semitic, anti-gay, anti-apostate - basically intolerant of anything that opposes their dogmas, including death threats to authors and illustrators. Meanwhile you say the BNP exists solely to propagate hate - have they marched calling for the death of any writers?

(I look forward to reading your considered opinions as to why we need immigration controls.)

Edited by leggedstruggle (06 Oct 2015 12.54pm)

 


mother-in-law is an anagram of woman hitler

Page 1 of 15 1 2 3 4 5 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > High immigration levels prevent 'cohesive society'