You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Southern Rail Strike - right or wrong
November 22 2026 12.40am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Southern Rail Strike - right or wrong


Page 23 of 44 < 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 >
Tim Gypsy Hill '64 Flag Stoke sub normal 13 Dec 16 10.31pm

Originally posted by pefwin

I thought they were all over paid, should be taught a lesson and retired on gold plated pensions to the Bahamas or similar.

Many are.

 


Systematically dragged down by the lawmakers

Tim Gypsy Hill '64 Flag Stoke sub normal 13 Dec 16 10.39pm

Originally posted by gambler

Aslef want to eradicate drivers working overtime. It's the companies that love it as it's far cheaper than employing more staff. But that means it's the company's fault so I doubt it will fit many people's agenda. Carry on blaming the workers.

The unions will do everything they can to preserve jobs, whatever the cost. The companies will obviously offer overtime if it's cheaper. People (workers) will work as many hours that life/rules permit them. That is all a given. The problem here is not to do with that though. It's about who pushes a button!

And it's only the public who lose out.

 


Systematically dragged down by the lawmakers

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 13 Dec 16 11.28pm

Originally posted by Y Ddraig Goch

Link is earlier in thread. No mention of a threat, your interpretation me thinks

that was a link to a different interview wasn't it?

EDIT from the aslef site.


12 Dec 2016

Mick Whelan, general secretary of ASLEF, the train drivers’ union, spoke out this afternoon after claims made by Chris Grayling, the Secretary of State for Transport, in a letter released by the DfT.

‘The Transport Secretary is being less than honest on all counts,’ said Mick.‘Earlier this year Peter Wilkinson, the £265,000 a year director of rail passenger services, said on a public platform that the aim of the DfT is to force train drivers – men and women he derisively referred to as ‘muppets’ –‘out of my industry.’ Mr Wilkinson said he was determined to provoke industrial confrontation and, indeed, was looking forward to ‘punch ups’ with trade unions. The strikes this week are not, whatever Mr Grayling tries to suggest,politically motivated. We have a trade dispute with GTR / Southern, and only a poor government would seek to spin it any other way. I think their motives are clear.’

Mick added: ‘The Transport Secretary is also being less than honest – and utterly selective – about a private meeting I had with him held, in good faith, under Chatham House rules. We said there could potentially be issues, in the future,on GTR/Southern following his refusal to entertain the serious safety concerns we raised and given the complete breakdown in trust between the union and the company.That loss of trust now extends to Mr Grayling and the government of which he is a part.

‘I am not sure how Mr Grayling has been made party to private and confidential conversations that took place but, in the interest of fairness, he might have said that we were willing to go to ACAS last week but GTR Southern refused because they wanted to go to court. These conversations finished yesterday evening and,logistically, could not have been concluded before we had to meet with our legal teams and was not a genuine offer.

‘I am more concerned, than either the minister or the company, about the safety of our members and the travelling public, but today we will find out whether a fully or partly-owned foreign company can deny British workers the right to strike.

Edited by nickgusset (13 Dec 2016 11.31pm)

 

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 13 Dec 16 11.29pm

[quote=Tim Gypsy Hill '64;3092877]

The unions will do everything they can to preserve jobs, whatever the cost. The companies will obviously offer overtime if it's cheaper. People (workers) will work as many hours that life/rules permit them. That is all a given. The problem here is not to do with that though. It's about who pushes a button!

And it's only the public who lose out.


Ok lets have a 1:1000 staff : passenger ratio on 12 carriage trains. See how that pans out.

 

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 13 Dec 16 11.56pm

From RMT press office
Immediate

Rail union RMT has confirmed that General Secretary Mick Cash will be attending talks at ACAS at ten am tomorrow morning on the Southern Rail dispute.

Ends


Let's hope something positive comes out of this.

 

Helmet46 Flag Croydon 14 Dec 16 6.56am

Originally posted by nickgusset

From RMT press office
Immediate

Rail union RMT has confirmed that General Secretary Mick Cash will be attending talks at ACAS at ten am tomorrow morning on the Southern Rail dispute.

Ends


Let's hope something positive comes out of this.


Fingers crossed. However that is, of course, the conductors union who's strike has, over time, started to become somewhat pointless. Southern have been able to run more and more trains and the conductors continuing to strike is now just proving Southerns point, that they can run trains without them. Also, as a lot of the conductors on the trains throughout these strikes do not appear safety trained - the strike has allowed Southern to showcase the new conductor role to the travelling public.

In my opinion ASLEF joining this strike may also have been a strategically poor move from the unions and perhaps not a good thing for the RMT and the Conductors, for it then lost them a lot of their remaining public sympathy

Edited by Helmet46 (14 Dec 2016 7.32am)

 

Hoof Hearted 14 Dec 16 11.02am

Originally posted by Stuk

They'll have to learn new skills that are required and change jobs. Automation will take existing roles, but it will create new ones around it.

Back in the 1950's "Wheeltappers" had to be retrained when Steam locomotives were replaced by diesel/electric trains.

Southern have publicly stated that they are not going to sack Guards/Conductors, nor impose any loss of earnings.

The Rail Regulator has confirmed DOO is safe.

This strike is 'much ado about nothing' methinks and now is 'the winter of our discontent'.

 

Stuk Flag Top half 14 Dec 16 1.24pm

Originally posted by nickgusset


Shall I put you in the 'shrug your shoulders and do nothing camp' then?

What are you going to do since teachers can also be replaced, and already are being.

[Link]

 


Optimistic as ever

Stuk Flag Top half 14 Dec 16 1.24pm

Originally posted by Hoof Hearted

Back in the 1950's "Wheeltappers" had to be retrained when Steam locomotives were replaced by diesel/electric trains.

Southern have publicly stated that they are not going to sack Guards/Conductors, nor impose any loss of earnings.

The Rail Regulator has confirmed DOO is safe.

This strike is 'much ado about nothing' methinks and now is 'the winter of our discontent'.

It's a farce, that's what it is.

 


Optimistic as ever

npn Flag Crowborough 14 Dec 16 1.34pm

Something from Southern's school of logic - I struggled in last Tuesday, despite no service on the Uckfield line due to guards' action. I could do this because Southern laid on a coach from Crowborough (Southern) to Tunbridge Wells (South Eastern).

Wanted to go in today, but apparently there are no replacement buses on driver strike days, only guard strike days (why the **** do I care who's on strike or why, all I care about is a total lack of trains)

 

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 14 Dec 16 2.14pm

Originally posted by Stuk

It's a farce, that's what it is.

As is the fact that the RMT weren't allowed into talks at ACAS this morning.

 

npn Flag Crowborough 14 Dec 16 2.17pm

Originally posted by nickgusset

As is the fact that the RMT weren't allowed into talks at ACAS this morning.

Isn't that because the discussions were with ASLEF?

 

Stuk Flag Top half 14 Dec 16 2.28pm

Originally posted by nickgusset

As is the fact that the RMT weren't allowed into talks at ACAS this morning.

It's more productive to deal with one stroppy child at a time.

RMT should never have tried to gatecrash, they weren't invited. "GTR said Aslef represented nearly 1,000 Southern drivers, while the RMT represented only 12."

and they were offered this:
Nick Brown, chief operating officer of Southern's parent company, Govia Thameslink Railway (GTR), said he had told Mr Cash they would be happy to meet him at Acas later in the day.

 


Optimistic as ever

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 14 Dec 16 2.35pm

Originally posted by Stuk

It's more productive to deal with one stroppy child at a time.

RMT should never have tried to gatecrash, they weren't invited. "GTR said Aslef represented nearly 1,000 Southern drivers, while the RMT represented only 12."

and they were offered this:
Nick Brown, chief operating officer of Southern's parent company, Govia Thameslink Railway (GTR), said he had told Mr Cash they would be happy to meet him at Acas later in the day.


None of which Cash said happened on an interview on Lbc earlier.

What did Acas say?

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 14 Dec 16 2.43pm

It's like the 1970's never happened.
There is no justification for this strike whatso ever and the unions know this.
If ever there was a good reason to reduce union power by introducing more automation, this is it.

 

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 14 Dec 16 2.45pm

Originally posted by npn

Isn't that because the discussions were with ASLEF?

Mick Brown said he thought he was invited. The RMT even made a press release last night.

Aslef should have said they wanted RMT in attendance. Both unions grievances.

Mick Cash of the RMT clarified when interviewed earlier that the issue wasn't really about who opens and closes the doors but that southern won't guarantee that all trains won't have a trained guard (with all the skills listed by 7mins earlier in the thread)
We've seen the ratio of staff: passengers would be 1:1800 on twelve carriage trains. Is that really safe?
Do you trust a company on safety that says they won't guarantee a safety person (aka Guard) on busy routes.

In the train crash in Watford a while back the driver was trapped in the cab. It was the guard that made the train safe, stopped people from getting off and reassured passengers. Imagine if he wasn't there.

 

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 14 Dec 16 2.47pm

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

It's like the 1970's never happened.
There is no justification for this strike whatso ever and the unions know this.
If ever there was a good reason to reduce union power by introducing more automation, this is it.

Absolute bollocks.

Hrolf why don't you think workers should have a voice?

 

Stuk Flag Top half 14 Dec 16 2.48pm

Originally posted by nickgusset


None of which Cash said happened on an interview on Lbc earlier.

What did Acas say?

Well it's in every article on it, without a denial from that moron which he would be sure to have got in, were it the case. But you claim to have heard it on the radio, like you did with the other t*** yesterday despite me providing a link to a TV clip of him saying it in person.

 


Optimistic as ever

Only 10 a year!! Flag 14 Dec 16 2.52pm

Originally posted by nickgusset

Mick Brown said he thought he was invited. The RMT even made a press release last night.

Aslef should have said they wanted RMT in attendance. Both unions grievances.

Mick Cash of the RMT clarified when interviewed earlier that the issue wasn't really about who opens and closes the doors but that southern won't guarantee that all trains won't have a trained guard (with all the skills listed by 7mins earlier in the thread)
We've seen the ratio of staff: passengers would be 1:1800 on twelve carriage trains. Is that really safe?
Do you trust a company on safety that says they won't guarantee a safety person (aka Guard) on busy routes.

In the train crash in Watford a while back the driver was trapped in the cab. It was the guard that made the train safe, stopped people from getting off and reassured passengers. Imagine if he wasn't there.

Can we at least get some clarity on this figure. Even on this thread it has ranged between 1:1000 to 1:1400.

Not sure how much safer I would feel with one staff member looking after 500 or 1400 passengers. Where is the cut off line on safety? Surely if there is an issue it just needs an announcement over the tannoy? What else could one person do in relation to co-ordinating that many?

By the way I have been enjoying the Thameslink train from Redhill to London Blackfriars during the strike rather than my usual (more convenient) train. Am I right thinking this does not have a guard?

 

npn Flag Crowborough 14 Dec 16 2.55pm

Originally posted by nickgusset

Mick Brown said he thought he was invited. The RMT even made a press release last night.

Aslef should have said they wanted RMT in attendance. Both unions grievances.

Mick Cash of the RMT clarified when interviewed earlier that the issue wasn't really about who opens and closes the doors but that southern won't guarantee that all trains won't have a trained guard (with all the skills listed by 7mins earlier in the thread)
We've seen the ratio of staff: passengers would be 1:1800 on twelve carriage trains. Is that really safe?
Do you trust a company on safety that says they won't guarantee a safety person (aka Guard) on busy routes.

In the train crash in Watford a while back the driver was trapped in the cab. It was the guard that made the train safe, stopped people from getting off and reassured passengers. Imagine if he wasn't there.

1. if Brown thinks he was invited but he wasn't, that's a bit of a worry for how capable he is

2. have you ever tried to have a 3-way negotiation? It's far harder to reach an agreement than a 2-way one. RMT have a dispute with GTR - discuss it between you. ASLEF have a dispute with GTR - discuss it between you. Don't turn it into a debate between multiple parties, that's doomed to failure as they will likely each have different red lines

3. I have no idea what the 'safe' ration of passengers to crew is if, indeed, there is one. If we are saying 1:1800 is unsafe, are you saying 1:900 (with a guard) IS safe, or just safER? If that's the case, then what is the minimum safety threshold? I don't know, but I suspect nobody does - you can't trust the company because they will say what it takes to reduce staff and expense, and you can't trust the unions because they will say what it takes to secure jobs for their members indefinitely

Edited by npn (14 Dec 2016 2.58pm)

 

Page 23 of 44 < 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Southern Rail Strike - right or wrong