This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
The good thing about this is that it is time measurable. So like your continual and insistent claims about Russia-gate on these forums we also get to see this prediction on the GOP's direction also fail. The common sense reality of the next GOP leader is that they can't afford to be anti Trump.....They will try to move on and take his base with them. That's why you mentioning Romney was so laughable....Those who hold the knife don't get to stay as leaders. Edited by Stirlingsays (14 Jan 2021 11.27am) Well you finally got something right! It is "time measurable". As will be the final outcome of the Mueller enquiry into the Russian interference which, in case you have conveniently forgotten, isn't over yet. Mueller handed many of his files onto other authorities, notable those in New York, as he was aware that action could not be taken during Trump's time in office. The fat lady has her costume back on and is in the wings waiting. Who-ever the next leader of the GOP is they will surely try to take Trump's "base" with them. That though doesn't preclude them being "anti-Trump"! They will distance themselves from his behaviour whilst claiming support, and credit, for some of the policies. A skilful politician can do that. The truth is that the "base" has no-where else to go unless a new party is formed and the stark reality of that is that it would split the conservatives so badly that they would have no chance of gaining power. Trump's behaviour both in the run-up to the election and subsequently, has ruined any realistic prospect of him controlling the GOP again. Whether his "base" has sufficient wisdom to recognise that is another question though. Romney didn't "hold a knife" did he, though that is undoubtedly how Trump and his supporters would see it. Trump expected personal loyalty above everything else and relentlessly dumped all over those who failed to give it. Some though value truth, honesty, duty, legality and the constitution higher than loyalty to a wanna be dictator. Romney did and he showed integrity and honour and no knife at all. Romney is no Brutus. The only one with a knife is Trump himself as has cut down those who dared speak against him and terrorised others. How Romney is now regarded by the others will be interesting but he is likely to see his stock rising fast. Other than with the die-hards of course. Which might explain your opinion.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
Well you finally got something right! It is "time measurable". As will be the final outcome of the Mueller enquiry into the Russian interference which, in case you have conveniently forgotten, isn't over yet. Mueller handed many of his files onto other authorities, notable those in New York, as he was aware that action could not be taken during Trump's time in office. The fat lady has her costume back on and is in the wings waiting. Who-ever the next leader of the GOP is they will surely try to take Trump's "base" with them. That though doesn't preclude them being "anti-Trump"! They will distance themselves from his behaviour whilst claiming support, and credit, for some of the policies. A skilful politician can do that. The truth is that the "base" has no-where else to go unless a new party is formed and the stark reality of that is that it would split the conservatives so badly that they would have no chance of gaining power. Trump's behaviour both in the run-up to the election and subsequently, has ruined any realistic prospect of him controlling the GOP again. Whether his "base" has sufficient wisdom to recognise that is another question though. Romney didn't "hold a knife" did he, though that is undoubtedly how Trump and his supporters would see it. Trump expected personal loyalty above everything else and relentlessly dumped all over those who failed to give it. Some though value truth, honesty, duty, legality and the constitution higher than loyalty to a wanna be dictator. Romney did and he showed integrity and honour and no knife at all. Romney is no Brutus. The only one with a knife is Trump himself as has cut down those who dared speak against him and terrorised others. How Romney is now regarded by the others will be interesting but he is likely to see his stock rising fast. Other than with the die-hards of course. Which might explain your opinion.
Ok boomer.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Lombardinho
There's nothing violent about saying the election was stolen. Yet the voices that say this are being suppressed. Correct. Nothing violent at all in the way you say it there. But obviously it depends how you say it. If you say it as opinion, eg. 'I think', fine. If you claim it to be fact, 'I know' etc. you've got a problem, especially when you dress it up as journalism and put it on a site with millions of hits. And then if you go further and say 'This election was stolen, I know it was, look at all the evidence, these people are paedos, rapists, child killers.' Then you've really got a problem. What platform is going to look at that and go, yeah, that's fine. No legal or libel issues there at all. Carry on. This isn't specific to any group, BTW. It's just how it is. People don't seem to understand that is an issue – as I said earlier, these days it's a 'well if I think it is it's true' attitude. Like before, if you can't see the issue with that then you're going to be disappointed. If the internet didn't allow for anonymity we would not be in such a severe situation... people would think twice about what they post, just like they think twice before speaking in a public place. Just like normal. If you want to answer the points I made in my previous post re. Twitter, Gab etc. I'll then happily discuss the BBC. Edited by SW19 CPFC (14 Jan 2021 2.53pm)
Did you know? 98.0000001% of people are morons. |
|
|
Originally posted by SW19 CPFC
Correct. Nothing violent at all in the way you say it there. But obviously it depends how you say it. If you say it as opinion, eg. 'I think', fine. If you claim it to be fact, 'I know' etc. you've got a problem, especially when you dress it up as journalism and put it on a site with millions of hits. And then if you go further and say 'This election was stolen, I know it was, look at all the evidence, these people are paedos, rapists, child killers.' Then you've really got a problem. What platform is going to look at that and go, yeah, that's fine. No legal or libel issues there at all. Carry on. This isn't specific to any group, BTW. It's just how it is. People don't seem to understand that is an issue – as I said earlier, these days it's a 'well if I think it is it's true' attitude. Like before, if you can't see the issue with that then you're going to be disappointed. If the internet didn't allow for anonymity we would not be in such a severe situation... people would think twice about what they post, just like they think twice before speaking in a public place. Just like normal. If you want to answer the points I made in my previous post re. Twitter, Gab etc. I'll then happily discuss the BBC. Edited by SW19 CPFC (14 Jan 2021 2.53pm) By it's inherent nature, free speech cannot be contained within the rules you have set up above. And as Eaglecoops pointed out those rules are one sided. Why can I not come down on you like a tonne of bricks because you refuse to accept the election's fraud?
|
|
|
Originally posted by Badger11
I read an article yesterday (sorry can't remember where) I am never a fan of banning people and you have to ask why Facebook etc. are so offended by the idiot Trump and yet allow real dictators airtime and for those countries to censor social media. These guys said the same thing last night.
|
|
| BlueJay |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Lombardinho
His point is that with such a huge backlog of flagged posts they are either in the business of intentionally not removing troubling or illegal content, or they are ill-equipped to do so. And both lead to the same kind of outcome. The result is certainly freedom of expression, but it will have a biased towards being skewing towards illegality (endless person specific death threats, illegal uploads and so on) over time if people know they can get away with it. Pr-0nhub recently had a similar situation [Link] Hopefully that shines a light on naive takes on what happens when platforms are not appropriately moderated and some of the inevitable consequences of it.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Lombardinho
By it's inherent nature, free speech cannot be contained within the rules you have set up above. And as Eaglecoops pointed out those rules are one sided. Why can I not come down on you like a tonne of bricks because you refuse to accept the election's fraud? No it can't entirely, but it does operate under some boundaries, always has done. You don't say some things in public that you'd say in private now do you? Why do you expect to be able to say things on a public forum, anonymously, that you know you wouldn't risk saying in a public space? No different. The 'rules' have always been one sided. It's nothing new... People need to be led and power structures need to exist in order for some semblance of civilisation to operate. It's human need and nature. So complaining about that beyond the realms of realism is a little rich. Also – define 'you' re. 'tonne of bricks'. You're free to do so, but if you come to that party spewing vitriol without credible facts or evidence then don't be disappointed when you get swatted away, sued or worse. Even now you're still talking in absolutes despite the simple fact that nothing significant has been upheld in a court of law. If you then decide to set up a website posting faux journalistic articles that have no traceability in fact and begin aggressively marketing it to drive income... then expect to be challenged. If you have nothing behind those articles other than 'well I think it's true so there' then what, exactly, do you think is going to happen? I mean, even a child would understand that. Everyone is being played or playing the system at any point in time – it's just that some don't realise it or know how to, and then they lash out when they fail at life looking for something or someone to blame. Always winners, always losers. Blame whoever you want, but ultimately it won't change anything. It'll just take up valuable time you could be spending doing something of worth/enjoyment.
Did you know? 98.0000001% of people are morons. |
|
|
Originally posted by BlueJay
His point is that with such a huge backlog of flagged posts they are either in the business of intentionally not removing troubling or illegal content, or they are ill-equipped to do so. And both lead to the same kind of outcome. The result is certainly freedom of expression, but it will have a biased towards being skewing towards illegality (endless person specific death threats, illegal uploads and so on) over time if people know they can get away with it. Pr-0nhub recently had a similar situation [Link] Hopefully that shines a light on naive takes on what happens when platforms are not appropriately moderated and some of the inevitable consequences of it.
No one elected the far left in Silicon Valley to police free speech on the Internet. And your framing of why censorship is happening is extremely kind.....This isn't about death threats or anything else, it's about censoring conservative voices and competition. Which left wing silicon valley company has had to build its own servers and infrastructure? It's been happening for years and this is just the latest purge. I'll say again, when the Internet laws were draw up and protections and advantages given. It was not for create an Internet one message political landscape. On the topic of death threats, there are plenty of them on Twitter.....It's fine if they agree with who they are aimed at. Oh and the CEO of Parler had to leave his house of because of death threats......conservatives get them all the time.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
| BlueJay |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
No one elected the far left in Silicon Valley to police free speech on the Internet. And your framing of why censorship is happening is extremely kind.....This isn't about death threats or anything else, it's about censoring conservative voices and competition. Which left wing silicon valley company has had to build its own servers and infrastructure? It's been happening for years and this is just the latest purge. I'll say again, when the Internet laws were draw up and protections and advantages given. It was not for create an Internet one message political landscape. On the topic of death threats, there are plenty of them on Twitter.....It's fine if they agree with who they are aimed at. Oh and the CEO of Parler had to leave his house of because of death threats......conservatives get them all the time.
As for death threats, people of all political stripes receive them. Parler was a convey belt of direct death threats. Did it matter to you then or just when it shuts down and the CEO gets them too? Here from just yesterday is a story about one of your Proud Boys using Parler to theaten and encourage the death of a Senator [Link] Sure these things can happen on any platform, but it's routine on these alternatives for obvious reasons and the routine lack of action is an encouragement of more of the same. Edited by BlueJay (14 Jan 2021 5.07pm)
|
|
|
Originally posted by BlueJay
As for death threats, people of all political stripes receive them. Parler was a convey belt of direct death threats. Did it matter to you then or just when it shuts down and the CEO gets them too? Here from just yesterday is a story about one of your Proud Boys using Parler to theaten and encourage the death of a Senator [Link] Sure these things can happen on any platform, but it's routine on these alternatives for obvious reasons and the routine lack of action is an encouragement of more of the same. Edited by BlueJay (14 Jan 2021 5.07pm) No, I addressed the point you 'really made' with my first sentence. And once again, which left wing silicon valley companies have been booted off? You wish to highlight Proud boys being violent but so what? these left wing companies host the same violence from groups they approve of....antifa, and there are tons of death threats on Twitter. Which again, was a point I'd already made in my previous post....did you even read it? I suppose you must have because you highlighted the last sentence....but still it didn't stop you making points I'd already answered. Edited by Stirlingsays (14 Jan 2021 5.14pm)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
| BlueJay |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
No, I addressed the point you 'really made' with my first sentence. And once again, which left wing silicon valley companies have been booted off? You wish to highlight Proud boys being violent but so what? these left wing companies host the same violence from groups they approve of....antifa, and there are tons of death threats on Twitter. Which again, was a point I'd already made in my previous post....did you even read it? I suppose you must have because you highlighted the last sentence....but still it didn't stop you making points I'd already answered. Edited by Stirlingsays (14 Jan 2021 5.14pm) You don't really get to tell other people what point they're 'really' making. The point they are actually making will do just fine. It was a comment about what often happens when where is a lack of moderation, rather than as could be argued, too much of it. That was perfectly clear.
|
|
|
Originally posted by BlueJay
You don't really get to tell other people what point they're 'really' making. The point they are actually making will do just fine. It was a comment about what often happens when where is a lack of moderation, rather than as could be argued, too much of it. That was perfectly clear. Oh for crying out loud!
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by cryrst
If they have managed to bring 15k troops to DC in 4 days why couldnt they bring 5k in 2 days to ring the Capitol building. This seems more and more like a plan from the left to set trump up for impeachment. I'm beginning to fear for american people if this is the mindset of the top democrats.
All the American dissentient right leaders have been calling for no violence: It's pointless. Edited by Stirlingsays (14 Jan 2021 5.43pm)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by cryrst
If they have managed to bring 15k troops to DC in 4 days why couldnt they bring 5k in 2 days to ring the Capitol building. This seems more and more like a plan from the left to set trump up for impeachment. I'm beginning to fear for american people if this is the mindset of the top democrats. This seems an implausible and illogical scenario to me. I cannot imagine those running Congress, who are both Republicans as well as Democrats, deliberating deciding to put themselves in harm's way just so they could impeach Trump. They could have done it anyway, with all he's been saying over the last 2 months. The reason Trump is being impeached is because of Trump. Nothing else required. Such an idea feels as unlikely as that the election was "stolen" when everything points to it being perfectly fine. Such ideas might appeal to those in Trump's base who believe anything that discredits the Democrats and nothing that discredits Trump but surely not an objective, dispassionate observer in the UK?
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
| BlueJay |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
Oh for crying out loud!
Discussions about moderation have multiple facets, not only those that matter to or impact you. My focus was very relevant as with the pr0n-hub example (which is not even political) as it still resulted in them taking the vast majority of their content offline aside from 'approved' uploaders, as various providers and advertisers were dropping them due to not wanting to be associated with their 'content'. Something that happens as result of these laissez faire attitudes when the reality of what that results in becomes apparent. As for platforms getting taken offline, I have already explained how alternative platforms, if they take the right approach, can fend off any attempts to take them offline anyway, using PirateBay as a good example of technical competency. The owner of Parler was 'Sunday League' in comparison. He even had such lax security that the entire sites content was downloaded prior to it being taken down (IDs and all). Very negligent in the face of what was an obvious risk. As long as an individuals aren't breaking them law I have no issue with what they say or do online, though the company that host them may also have their own terms of service. I would much rather people publicly post anything from ideas to threats to illegal content publicly. When it's pushed underground that doesn't really benefit anyone. When it's posted publicly it can be more easily argued against, addressed or dealt with. So I wasn't particularly against Parler or in favour of it being taken offline anyway.
|
|
| BlueJay |
|
|---|---|
|
It appears they've even commented on it Pirate Bay Founder Thinks Parler’s Inability to Stay Online Is ‘Embarrassing’ - [Link] "The pirate bay, the most censored website in the world, started by kids, run by people with problems with alcohol, drugs and money, still is up after almost 2 decades. Parlor and gab etc have all the money around but no skills or mindset. Embarrassing. The most ironic thing is that TPBs enemies include not just the US government but also many European and the Russian one. Compared to gab/parlor which is supported by the current president of the US and probably liked by the Russian one too. In all honesty, the reason we did TPB was to bring freedom and take back control from a centralised system. The reason that Gab et al will fail is because they're just whining b!tches that have only one ideology: egotism. Sharing is caring y'all."
|
|
|
Originally posted by SW19 CPFC
'According to the Washington Post, relations between Trump and Giuliani have dramatically cooled. Trump has instructed his aides not to pay Giuliani’s outstanding fees. The president is reportedly offended by Giuliani’s demand for ,000 a day – a figure the lawyer denies, but which is apparently in writing. White House officials have even been told not to put through any of Giuliani’s calls.' Imploding – Although I never understood Trumps infatuation with Rudy. Could have done a lot better for himself. 600 grand a month is a bit steep when you get nothing to show for it I suppose. One of Trump's issues was the disconnect between what he'd say to his supporters and the team he'd put together to bring those policies about. Early on he ditched Bannon....who was a believer and wrote the 'American Carnage' speech and swapped him for Jared Kushner, who seemed more interested in Israel than America.....in terms of shaping his administration and matching the words to actions it was a poor choice. Trump's picks for most positions were pretty poor most of the way through. Still, I never really got the impression that Trump really cared all that much and 2020 Trump was a pale version of 2016 Trump. That said he did some good work building confidence in the economy and in showing that America really was put into some very poor trade deals and wasn't holding its own. And the military liked him as he stopped using them as the world's Policeman and instead focused upon their development.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.