This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Israel / Palestine
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
Stirlingsays 20 Jul 14 8.36pm |
|
Quote nickgusset at 20 Jul 2014 8.27pm
Call me a cynic in me old age, but I don't actually think it would make a difference to the current lot in power in Israel who was in charge in Palestine. They want their holy land.
Sure........Though Fatah and Israel aren't fighting you know...Haven't for years.
But that country you dislike so much.....It happens to hold elections.
Edited by Stirlingsays (20 Jul 2014 8.38pm)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)
|
coulsdoneagle London 20 Jul 14 8.37pm |
|
|
Obviously dialogue and a less bloody solution is the dream here, but I fear there is little point in trying to talk to Hamas when part of their founding ideology is to eventually wipe out the state of Israel. When they talk about a ceasefire, they talk about it as if it's a short term thing saying basically "we could have a few years of peace, if we get a Palestinian state along the 1967 border lines".
1. This is never going to be agreed with by Israel who would have to give up Jerusalem 2. The ceasefire would end the moment Hamas believed they had the strength to attack their neighbouring Jewish state.
They (Hamas) are treating this not as a civic dispute but a Jihad against Judaism, that's why it is a problem and however much we all despise the collateral damage Hamas must be destroyed. Whether it's possible, I doubt.
Edited by coulsdoneagle (20 Jul 2014 8.38pm)
|
nickgusset Shizzlehurst 20 Jul 14 8.42pm |
|
Quote Stirlingsays at 20 Jul 2014 8.36pm
But that country you dislike so much.....It happens to hold elections.
Edited by Stirlingsays (20 Jul 2014 8.38pm) Yes you did. At 8.38
Edited by nickgusset (20 Jul 2014 8.50pm)
|
legaleagle 20 Jul 14 8.44pm |
|
|
See link below.The relevance to Gaza is at the end. The writer queries whether the killing of the 3 Israeli youths was perhaps down to ISIS to set in chain the current horror and take the spotlight off ISIS' offensive in Syria.300 plus killed in ISIS-related fighting in the past few days. I had read previously that the rogue cell that allegedly killed the three Israeli youths had links with ISIS, but then again, I had also read that Mossad was behind ISIS originally!
The Gazan Ministry of the Interior advice (if accurate) reproduced in the comments below the article is interesting.
[Link]
Edited by legaleagle (20 Jul 2014 8.45pm)
Edited by legaleagle (20 Jul 2014 9.09pm)
Edited by legaleagle (20 Jul 2014 9.09pm)
|
nickgusset Shizzlehurst 20 Jul 14 8.45pm |
|
Quote coulsdoneagle at 20 Jul 2014 8.37pm
Obviously dialogue and a less bloody solution is the dream here, but I fear there is little point in trying to talk to Hamas when part of their founding ideology is to eventually wipe out the state of Israel. When they talk about a ceasefire, they talk about it as if it's a short term thing saying basically "we could have a few years of peace, if we get a Palestinian state along the 1967 border lines".
1. This is never going to be agreed with by Israel who would have to give up Jerusalem 2. The ceasefire would end the moment Hamas believed they had the strength to attack their neighbouring Jewish state.
They (Hamas) are treating this not as a civic dispute but a Jihad against Judaism, that's why it is a problem and however much we all despise the collateral damage Hamas must be destroyed. Whether it's possible, I doubt.
Edited by coulsdoneagle (20 Jul 2014 8.38pm)
Which makes one wonder why Israel supported them previously if this has been their intention.
|
Stirlingsays 20 Jul 14 8.47pm |
|
Quote nickgusset at 20 Jul 2014 8.42pm
Putting words in my mouth, which loses you all credibility. I haven't said I dislike Israel. What I have said is I do think their government's actions in Gaza is inhumane, barbaric, disproportionate and wrong.
Edited by nickgusset (20 Jul 2014 8.43pm)
How does it lose me credibility I didn't claim you said it?
It's my opinion of your attitude. Am I allowed to have an opinion?
I based it upon you supporting Hamas killing Jews.....I regarded that as a rather big hint.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)
|
Stirlingsays 20 Jul 14 8.48pm |
|
Quote nickgusset at 20 Jul 2014 8.45pm
Which makes one wonder why Israel supported them previously if this has been their intention.
Where is the evidence they supported the creation of Hamas we have now?
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)
|
nickgusset Shizzlehurst 20 Jul 14 8.53pm |
|
Quote Stirlingsays at 20 Jul 2014 8.47pm
Quote nickgusset at 20 Jul 2014 8.42pm
Putting words in my mouth, which loses you all credibility. I haven't said I dislike Israel. What I have said is I do think their government's actions in Gaza is inhumane, barbaric, disproportionate and wrong.
Edited by nickgusset (20 Jul 2014 8.43pm)
How does it lose me credibility I didn't claim you said it?
It's my opinion of your attitude. Am I allowed to have an opinion?
I based it upon you supporting Hamas killing Jews.....I regarded that as a rather big hint.
You wrote 'that country you hate so much' You have also now said I support Hamas killing Jews. Where? Are you posting under 2 user names? Reveal yourself.
|
Stirlingsays 20 Jul 14 9.08pm |
|
Quote nickgusset at 20 Jul 2014 8.53pm
Quote Stirlingsays at 20 Jul 2014 8.47pm
Quote nickgusset at 20 Jul 2014 8.42pm
Putting words in my mouth, which loses you all credibility. I haven't said I dislike Israel. What I have said is I do think their government's actions in Gaza is inhumane, barbaric, disproportionate and wrong.
Edited by nickgusset (20 Jul 2014 8.43pm)
How does it lose me credibility I didn't claim you said it?
It's my opinion of your attitude. Am I allowed to have an opinion?
I based it upon you supporting Hamas killing Jews.....I regarded that as a rather big hint.
You wrote 'that country you hate so much' You have also now said I support Hamas killing Jews. Where? Are you posting under 2 user names? Reveal yourself.

At your post at 2:08 You supported the killing of Jews until the occupation ended.
Yeah, me saying you hate Israel is an opinion.....Kind of based upon things like that.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)
|
nickgusset Shizzlehurst 20 Jul 14 9.12pm |
|
Quote Stirlingsays at 20 Jul 2014 9.08pm
Quote nickgusset at 20 Jul 2014 8.53pm
Quote Stirlingsays at 20 Jul 2014 8.47pm
Quote nickgusset at 20 Jul 2014 8.42pm
Putting words in my mouth, which loses you all credibility. I haven't said I dislike Israel. What I have said is I do think their government's actions in Gaza is inhumane, barbaric, disproportionate and wrong.
Edited by nickgusset (20 Jul 2014 8.43pm)
How does it lose me credibility I didn't claim you said it?
It's my opinion of your attitude. Am I allowed to have an opinion?
I based it upon you supporting Hamas killing Jews.....I regarded that as a rather big hint.
You wrote 'that country you hate so much' You have also now said I support Hamas killing Jews. Where? Are you posting under 2 user names? Reveal yourself.

At your post at 2:08 You supported the killing of Jews until the occupation ended.
Yeah, me saying you hate Israel is an opinion.....Kind of based upon things like that.
I said living under occupation, you can't blame them. That is not the same as saying I supported them.
|
Palacetinian Surrey Fam 20 Jul 14 9.17pm |
|
Quote Stirlingsays at 20 Jul 2014 8.18pm
Quote Palacetinian at 20 Jul 2014 4.58pm
Dialogue with Hamas is needed - Nick is right - not the massacre currently taking place. Israel helped to create Hamas as an opposition to secular leader Yasser Arafat who they didn't want to deal with until 1993 - this article gives some background.
[Link]
Yeah Nick is right.....You couldn't be biased about that could you? You know considering your Hol name and all that.
Tell me, what is in it for Israel with having a dialogue with Hamas?
Hamas's constitution makes it clear that it will accept nothing but the wiping of Israel from the map. All ceasefires or truces are but stop gaps to that aim.
All attempts to get them to change this have failed....Their leader calls recognizing Israel a 'red line'.
Tell me, what on earth could Israel gain from dialogue with Hamas?
Hamas seeks to wipe them out.
Edited by Stirlingsays (20 Jul 2014 8.19pm)
Stirling, you need to understand that Hamas and Israel are not equal. This picture may help explain...
Attachment: Repression.jpg (73.21Kb)
Supporting Crystal Palace since 19.45 on 29th August 1972 (approximately)!
|
Stirlingsays 20 Jul 14 9.20pm |
|
Quote nickgusset at 20 Jul 2014 9.12pm
I said living under occupation, you can't blame them. That is not the same as saying I supported them.
Nope....Don't get that.
If you say killing Jews is ok that's supporting the practice of killing Jews.
Hamas make the distinction of 'living under occupation' as the whole of Israel.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)
|
Stirlingsays 20 Jul 14 9.23pm |
|
Quote Palacetinian at 20 Jul 2014 9.17pm
Stirling, you need to understand that Hamas and Israel are not equal. This picture may help explain...
So if a midget kicks you in the bollocks you support falling on your knees and arguing.
Yeah...Makes a lot of sense.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)
|
Palacetinian Surrey Fam 20 Jul 14 9.26pm |
|
Quote Stirlingsays at 20 Jul 2014 9.23pm
Quote Palacetinian at 20 Jul 2014 9.17pm
Stirling, you need to understand that Hamas and Israel are not equal. This picture may help explain...
So if a midget kicks you in the bollocks you support falling on your knees and arguing.
Yeah...Makes a lot of sense.
Funny, but you miss the point. The only way the violence is going to end is if there is a comprehensive peace agreement. This is in the hands of the Israelis. There are loads of articles about the collapse of the latest round of US led peace talks which I can post here. I'm not sure you would find these of interest though.
Supporting Crystal Palace since 19.45 on 29th August 1972 (approximately)!
|
Stirlingsays 20 Jul 14 9.33pm |
|
Quote Palacetinian at 20 Jul 2014 9.26pm
Quote Stirlingsays at 20 Jul 2014 9.23pm
Quote Palacetinian at 20 Jul 2014 9.17pm
Stirling, you need to understand that Hamas and Israel are not equal. This picture may help explain...
So if a midget kicks you in the bollocks you support falling on your knees and arguing.
Yeah...Makes a lot of sense.
Funny, but you miss the point. The only way the violence is going to end is if there is a comprehensive peace agreement. This is in the hands of the Israelis. There are loads of articles about the collapse of the latest round of US led peace talks which I can post here. I'm not sure you would find these of interest though.
I haven't missed the point...I think you have.
Hamas's constitution only recognizes peace as a stop gap towards the destruction of Israel.....You can't make a 'comprehensive peace agreement' with Hamas.....Hamas make that plain themselves. They are only interested in temporary truces or cease fires.
You kind of just keep ignoring this stone cold fact.
So I kind of have to repeat my question.....What is in it for Israel in talking to Hamas?....What do they get our of it? There isn't any point.
This latest round of fighting will stop when Israel deem the latest round too costly, fiscally, politically or whatever....That's about it.
Edited by Stirlingsays (20 Jul 2014 9.34pm)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)
|
nickgusset Shizzlehurst 20 Jul 14 9.47pm |
|
Quote Stirlingsays at 20 Jul 2014 9.20pm
Quote nickgusset at 20 Jul 2014 9.12pm
I said living under occupation, you can't blame them. That is not the same as saying I supported them.
Nope....Don't get that.
If you say killing Jews is ok that's supporting the practice of killing Jews.
Hamas make the distinction of 'living under occupation' as the whole of Israel.
I didn't say it was OK for them to kill Israelis, what I was getting at was however, that I can understand why they might. There is a world of difference.
|
Kermit8 Hevon 20 Jul 14 9.48pm |
|
|
A simple solution: Change the spelling to Palestein.
Hamas will then start firing rockets at themselves and Israel will help the locals build loads of lovely houses and give them a decent education and future.
Big chest and massive boobs
[Link]
|
Stirlingsays 20 Jul 14 9.50pm |
|
Quote nickgusset at 20 Jul 2014 9.47pm
I didn't say it was OK for them to kill Israelis, what I was getting at was however, that I can understand why they might. There is a world of difference.
So you're saying you don't agree with Hamas killing Jews then?
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)
|
nickgusset Shizzlehurst 20 Jul 14 9.52pm |
|
Quote Palacetinian at 20 Jul 2014 9.26pm
Quote Stirlingsays at 20 Jul 2014 9.23pm
Quote Palacetinian at 20 Jul 2014 9.17pm
Stirling, you need to understand that Hamas and Israel are not equal. This picture may help explain...
So if a midget kicks you in the bollocks you support falling on your knees and arguing.
Yeah...Makes a lot of sense.
Funny, but you miss the point. The only way the violence is going to end is if there is a comprehensive peace agreement. This is in the hands of the Israelis. There are loads of articles about the collapse of the latest round of US led peace talks which I can post here. I'm not sure you would find these of interest though.
It's also in the hands of Hamas. Israel said they agreed with what Egypt had brokered in the last couple of weeks, however, Hamas felt that the terms of the settlement were too skewed in favour of Israel.
My main beef is with the disproportionate attacks on Gaza by Israel, the shooting of innocent children playing football on a beach being just one of many examples. How anyone can justify this is beyond my comprehension.
|
nickgusset Shizzlehurst 20 Jul 14 9.53pm |
|
Quote Stirlingsays at 20 Jul 2014 9.50pm
Quote nickgusset at 20 Jul 2014 9.47pm
I didn't say it was OK for them to kill Israelis, what I was getting at was however, that I can understand why they might. There is a world of difference.
So you're saying you don't agree with Hamas killing Jews then?
I don't agree with any of them killing each other. I haven't said that I do at any time. Which is why it pished me off that you claimed that I did.
You are misreading between the lines of my posts.
Edited by nickgusset (20 Jul 2014 9.55pm)
|