Quote The White Horse at 11 May 2014 8.13pm
Quote Johnny Eagles at 11 May 2014 2.20pm
3. Given the unprecedented scale of the latest wave of immigration (ie, the last ten to fifteen years) how likely is it that these immigrants will integrate into the host culture and what will this integration look like?
I think integration is inevitable over time, since it's pretty difficult to spend time within a society without being influenced by social norms, language and so on. Obviously there will be some exceptions, but I'd imagine any community that closes itself off from the rest of society will start to suffer over time.
In a crude multicultural melting pot analogy, imagine someone's making a nice chocolate mousse and throws in a few extra ingredients. A lump of sugar, some milk, a marshmallow. Practically speaking it may take a while, but at the end of the process the mousse isn't radically different from how it was at the start because 99% of the ingredients remained the same.
Quote Johnny Eagles at 11 May 2014 2.20pm
4. If immigration were to continue on a similar scale, how likely do you think that "integration" will actually mean a radical transformation of the prevailing culture within a generation or two?
I think prevailing cultures are always changing, so it's difficult to define what constitutes radical change, but I think it's unlikely that an "external culture" would be able to affect the original culture profoundly unless there were significant parallels to begin with.
Look at the resistance to Islam in the UK, for example. There are pretty strong parallels between Islam and Christianity and Muslims have been here for decades, so you'd think it might get some traction. But people are livid that someone's prayed at a cow before it ended up on their pizza.
To avoid it turning into an absolute waffle-fest, I'll concentrate my reply on just the points above.
I think we actually broadly agree. We differ essentially only on one point. You think it "unlikely that an "external culture" would be able to affect the original culture profoundly". I disagree.
To borrow your melting pot analogy, I see the recent wave of immigration (ie, all the Eastern Europeans) if it continues at a similar pace as much more than a few extra ingredients. I think it will completely change the recipe.
I'm not claiming certainty, but I do think it likely given the scale over the last few years and the changes which have already happened in a relatively short space of time. I've yet to see anything which convinces me otherwise. I think AT BEST the politicians who unleashed this wave of immigration have simply no idea what the long-term effects will be.
I therefore think it likely that the prevailing culture will be radically altered and many things which are "traditionally British" (I know this is an incredibly slippery term to use, but I don't want to get bogged down in long definitions) will disappear or alter beyond recognition.
Which isn't to foretell doom, necessarily. He he who rejects change is the architect of decay and all that. And I love a curry as much as the next person. But it will be sad to see some things go. And, most importantly, it's absolutely fair enough for some people to be concerned and even angry about it. It's going to have a massive effect on them and their children and they've not been given any choice in the matter whatsoever.
...we must expand...get more pupils...so that the knowledge will spread...
|