You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > isis
November 22 2026 2.42am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

isis


Page 24 of 51 < 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 >
legaleagle Flag 14 Sep 14 11.12am

Quote Kermit8 at 14 Sep 2014 11.05am

Quote legaleagle at 14 Sep 2014 11.01am

RIP David Haines and thoughts with his family.

Will UK muslim groups like "Cage" (formerly Caged Prisoners) , who campaign against human rights abuses against prisoners in the "war on terror" stand up and condemn it out of hand? If a group like them (who are rooted in former Al Muhajiroun members and ex Guantanamo prisoners like Moazzam Begg) had issued strong statements calling for his release, it would have had an impact in UK ISIS-supporting circles and, who knows, PR -wise maybe even on ISIS.

Or do they only campaign against the human rights abuses that suit them?


From BBC. Not CAGE but still worth posting;

"Senior UK imams and British Muslim community leaders have also condemned the killing, including Shuja Shafi of the Muslim Council of Britain.

He said: "David Haines went out to the region to help the people of the region. That extremists chose to murder him only shows once again the depravity of their warped ideology.

"These extremists in Iraq and Syria claim to be acting in the name of Islam. But there is nothing in our faith that condones such behaviour.

"These extremists wish to draw attention and recruits to their cause by sowing division and fear between people here in Britain. Let us deny them that luxury. The best way to defeat their extremism is to build even stronger bonds between communities here in Britain."


Absolutely. But they are mainstream and their criticisms no less valid or important for that in showing the vast majority of the community abhor ISIS.

Cage represent the equivalent of Sinn Fein's support groups for Provo prisoners....ie they don't condemn the general ideology or desirability of the caliphate idea etc but don't engage in "armed struggle". I frequently come into contact with people affiliated with them seeking support. They have real influence amongst the sectors of the community who promote the validity of ideas that are stage 1 along the path to solidarity with/joining ISIS...and at times like this their sanctimonious one sided waffle leaves me feeling a little sick...

Edited by legaleagle (14 Sep 2014 11.16am)

 

legaleagle Flag 14 Sep 14 11.45am

Looks like another aid worker may be next in line

[Link]

 

Y Ddraig Goch Flag In The Crowd 14 Sep 14 12.29pm

There has been a lot of groundwork done over the past month or so. Time to take out large swathes of them and quickly.

 


the dignified don't even enter in the game

cornwalls palace Flag Torpoint 14 Sep 14 3.48pm

Quote Y Ddraig Goch at 14 Sep 2014 12.29pm

There has been a lot of groundwork done over the past month or so. Time to take out large swathes of them and quickly.


..like pouring Domestos over a turd.

 


.......has our coach driver done a Poo'yet, without thinking about Gus!

GlaziersCPFC Flag Tooting 14 Sep 14 3.55pm

What A Joke. Say in March I'd never heard of "ISIS". Another USA funded group, I'm guessing.

 

RainhamEagle Flag Bermondsey 14 Sep 14 4.27pm

Quote GlaziersCPFC at 14 Sep 2014 3.55pm

What A Joke. Say in March I'd never heard of "ISIS". Another USA funded group, I'm guessing.


Yeah, they (thought at the time as civilians) were supported by the US against Assad and the Syrian government.

We're in a tough place now though, it's a very dangerous situation, especially for ourselves. We can aid/support these innocent people getting executed by this barbaric group and attempt to take them out whilst it's somewhat doable and controllable, but also risk suicide missions on our own land. Or, we can sit back, let this barbaric group expand at the rate they already are and still have a good chance of suicide missions happening on our own land.

 

Y Ddraig Goch Flag In The Crowd 14 Sep 14 5.15pm

The problem is we think differently to them.

We can't play fair with these people.

 


the dignified don't even enter in the game

cornwalls palace Flag Torpoint 14 Sep 14 10.10pm

Quote Y Ddraig Goch at 14 Sep 2014 5.15pm

The problem is we think differently to them.

We can't play fair with these people.


..yeah, we think.

 


.......has our coach driver done a Poo'yet, without thinking about Gus!

legaleagle Flag 15 Sep 14 9.12am

[Link]

21 year old Briish medical student tweets severed head picture.

 

Y Ddraig Goch Flag In The Crowd 15 Sep 14 9.54am

Quote legaleagle at 15 Sep 2014 9.12am

[Link]

21 year old Briish medical student tweets severed head picture.


Hopefully she will be dead soon

 


the dignified don't even enter in the game

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 15 Sep 14 10.12am

Unfortuanately there isn't actually much we can do, a full scale military deployment is unlikely, and by the time its complete the issue of IS in Iraq will need to have been resolved, or they'll be solidly entrenched.

Even if we engaged heavily, we could only force them back into Syria, actually crossing the border would likely create far more serious long term problems.

Realistically the only option is to reinforce, equip and support military options available, ie Iraq forces, Kurdish Militias and Shia militias along with either the rebel forces or assad regime in Syria opposed to IS - The problem is all of these have future problems (particually rebels, assad and militia). Air support is a functional option, but limited, plus it risks hitting civilian targets in occupied areas, resulting in a Sunni backlash from those communities.

If the Iraq / shia or Kurd forces cross the border into Syria, then its likely to result in a much larger conflict, drawing Iraq into the on going civil war.

Problem is that the US has spent the best part of 12-13 years trying to impliment targeted (or vaguely targeted) assassination campaigns against Al-Queda and affliates with limited success - These groups just tend to melt into the background when necessary, restructure and reappear.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 15 Sep 14 10.12am

Quote Y Ddraig Goch at 15 Sep 2014 9.54am

Quote legaleagle at 15 Sep 2014 9.12am

[Link]

21 year old Briish medical student tweets severed head picture.


Hopefully she will be dead soon

Or spending 30 years in an Iraqi prison which is probably a less pleasant fate.


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Forest Hillbilly Flag in a hidey-hole 15 Sep 14 12.37pm

Guantanamo Bay.

No Holds Barred

 


I disengage, I turn the page.

Y Ddraig Goch Flag In The Crowd 15 Sep 14 12.58pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 15 Sep 2014 10.12am

Unfortuanately there isn't actually much we can do, a full scale military deployment is unlikely, and by the time its complete the issue of IS in Iraq will need to have been resolved, or they'll be solidly entrenched.

Even if we engaged heavily, we could only force them back into Syria, actually crossing the border would likely create far more serious long term problems.

Realistically the only option is to reinforce, equip and support military options available, ie Iraq forces, Kurdish Militias and Shia militias along with either the rebel forces or assad regime in Syria opposed to IS - The problem is all of these have future problems (particually rebels, assad and militia). Air support is a functional option, but limited, plus it risks hitting civilian targets in occupied areas, resulting in a Sunni backlash from those communities.

If the Iraq / shia or Kurd forces cross the border into Syria, then its likely to result in a much larger conflict, drawing Iraq into the on going civil war.

Problem is that the US has spent the best part of 12-13 years trying to impliment targeted (or vaguely targeted) assassination campaigns against Al-Queda and affliates with limited success - These groups just tend to melt into the background when necessary, restructure and reappear.

The political strategy aside (that seems to change on a weekly basis), militarily there is a lot that can be done. As mentioned before there is a role for troops on the ground primarily SF as you wouldn't want allies in full scale battles. There is already a significant presence and together with air strikes, would go a long way to assisting the Kurds, Iraqis etc. in turning the tide.

Unlike Al Qaeda, there is an extremely large part of IS that operate as an army. Some of whom are operating under a flag of convenience. By targeting them and obviously where possible the leaders, we can in the short term defeat them.

Of course a lot of the leaders will disappear and emerge under another name but this will at least buy time for the longer game which everyone needs as it is all together far more complicated and ever changing.

 


the dignified don't even enter in the game

Seth Flag On a pale blue dot 15 Sep 14 1.34pm

Quote legaleagle at 15 Sep 2014 9.12am

[Link]

21 year old Briish medical student tweets severed head picture.


She calls herself "Bint". How appropriate.

 


"You can feel the stadium jumping. The stadium is actually physically moving up and down"
FA Cup MOTD 24/4/16

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 15 Sep 14 3.03pm

Quote Seth at 15 Sep 2014 1.34pm

Quote legaleagle at 15 Sep 2014 9.12am

[Link]

21 year old Briish medical student tweets severed head picture.


She calls herself "Bint". How appropriate.

But would you?


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 15 Sep 14 3.14pm

Quote Y Ddraig Goch at 15 Sep 2014 12.58pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 15 Sep 2014 10.12am

Unfortuanately there isn't actually much we can do, a full scale military deployment is unlikely, and by the time its complete the issue of IS in Iraq will need to have been resolved, or they'll be solidly entrenched.

Even if we engaged heavily, we could only force them back into Syria, actually crossing the border would likely create far more serious long term problems.

Realistically the only option is to reinforce, equip and support military options available, ie Iraq forces, Kurdish Militias and Shia militias along with either the rebel forces or assad regime in Syria opposed to IS - The problem is all of these have future problems (particually rebels, assad and militia). Air support is a functional option, but limited, plus it risks hitting civilian targets in occupied areas, resulting in a Sunni backlash from those communities.

If the Iraq / shia or Kurd forces cross the border into Syria, then its likely to result in a much larger conflict, drawing Iraq into the on going civil war.

Problem is that the US has spent the best part of 12-13 years trying to impliment targeted (or vaguely targeted) assassination campaigns against Al-Queda and affliates with limited success - These groups just tend to melt into the background when necessary, restructure and reappear.

The political strategy aside (that seems to change on a weekly basis), militarily there is a lot that can be done. As mentioned before there is a role for troops on the ground primarily SF as you wouldn't want allies in full scale battles. There is already a significant presence and together with air strikes, would go a long way to assisting the Kurds, Iraqis etc. in turning the tide.

Unlike Al Qaeda, there is an extremely large part of IS that operate as an army. Some of whom are operating under a flag of convenience. By targeting them and obviously where possible the leaders, we can in the short term defeat them.

Of course a lot of the leaders will disappear and emerge under another name but this will at least buy time for the longer game which everyone needs as it is all together far more complicated and ever changing.

Pretty much agree. What needs to be done short term is blunt its capacity to hold its own against the ground forces, whilst utilising special forces groups to recon and identify targets. Problem is you can't really risk Special Force units operating with local Iraqi forces as the risk of being 'compromised' is fairly high (they'll be likely fighting against their current allies in a few years time).

What needs to be hit though is IS capacity to operate financially, as well as identifying and eliminating those who provide support, which there will be less support from, ie those trafficking in weapons, funds and oil for IS. Those accounts need to be seized and those directly running and supporting those operations need to be eliminated, turned or otherwise removed from 'play'.

As soon as the tide really turns, IS will withdraw into Syria, where they're relatively safe (without risking being dragged into an even bigger conflict)

Then the problem will likely be the Shia taking revenge on IS (ie read sunnis in the area) and the Kurds refusing to hand back Mosul. Possibly resulting in the whole thing flaring up and IS coming back.

What is more important, to the west, though is 'following the money', rather than military successes (which will end up in bigger and bigger problems).

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

legaleagle Flag 15 Sep 14 8.54pm

...and closer to home, working hard (in liaison with the mobilisation of the majority of the muslim community here) to try to deal effectively with:

1. Minority elements in the community successfully portraying ISIS to young and impressionable disaffected people as simply victims of a western "war on terror", and their ideology in terms of the society they want to see as admirable in essence (even if flawed in the means used), thus laying the groundwork for support for whatever emerges elsewhere than Iraq/Syria that's similar in ideology (and it likely will) and continued "jihadist radicalisation" of segments of youth here.

2.Effective moves against dodgy groups and financial/recruit support networks here

3.Not falling into the trap of demonising the whole muslim community or the entire religion of Islam

4.Trying to understand and reduce whatever legitimately makes people feel disaffected and thus more open to simplistic nonsense solutions, not excluding consideration of government policies.

Edited by legaleagle (15 Sep 2014 8.56pm)

 

derby eagle Flag Derby 15 Sep 14 9.38pm

Quote Forest Hillbilly at 15 Sep 2014 12.37pm

Guantanamo Bay.

No Holds Barred


Don't you mean "No Holes Barred"?

 

legaleagle Flag 15 Sep 14 9.43pm

not forgetting the Saudis...

[Link]

 

Page 24 of 51 < 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > isis