Quote Hoof Hearted at 19 Nov 2015 11.42am
Quote Mr Palaceman at 18 Nov 2015 5.10pm
Quote Hoof Hearted at 18 Nov 2015 3.52pm
Quote Mr Palaceman at 18 Nov 2015 3.45pm
Quote Hoof Hearted at 17 Nov 2015 4.07pm
Quote nickgusset at 17 Nov 2015 4.00pm
Quote Hoof Hearted at 17 Nov 2015 3.35pm
Quote Southampton_Eagle at 17 Nov 2015 11.32am
Quote Hoof Hearted at 17 Nov 2015 9.11am
Quote Southampton_Eagle at 16 Nov 2015 11.25am
Quote Hoof Hearted at 16 Nov 2015 10.38am
Quote serial thriller at 14 Nov 2015 2.30pm
But I'll end this post with one final remark. The rules on this forum state that any racist ethnically objectionable material will be punished. It is my belief that racism, and indeed all forms of prejudice, stem from ignorance, and what I hope I have proved is that from the almost exclusive ignorance of Hoof's post, conclusions have been reached which at best are ethnically objectionable (Not just a few religious zealots or fundamentalists but with Islam itself... the whole ideology!) and at worst advocating genocide (we need to bring in the experts to destroy the nest!). I'd like to see the mods adhere to the rules of their own forum and warn Hoof that such views aren't welcome on here, yet particularly considering one mod has actively supported his beliefs, I'd be surprised if any of them had the guts to do so.
I didn't bother to read Serial's posts on this topic, but I thank the fellow Hol'er that sent me this extract of his post by PM.
My reaction......... how childish and pathetic.... trying to get me banned because of my hard line views that oppose his liberal views and calling me racist AGAIN.
Not content with that.... comparing my use of an analogy to that of the Nazi propaganda spokesman Goebbels speech on the final solution!
Serial.... you and others on here need to stop playing the racist card and revert to trying to convince us your arguments are superior rather than underhand tactics to try and stifle our views.
I don't understand your last paragraph. You openly admit you don't read his posts and then you address him. Hardly respectful.
Your opinion is no more or less valid than anyone else even though you seem to think it is.
I avoided this thread all weekend because emotions were high. I'm not surprised to see the chest beating bravado of the usual suspects, those of, shall we say, an older generation with ingrained prejudices.
Hol clusterf*ck thread at it's finest.
You can't understand that I am concerned/annoyed that he has tried to get me banned from the site for stating my opinions.... that many on here agreed with and supported?
You've flounced away many times & reinvented yourself. Another occassion isn't really a problem is it?
Get a life.
What's this aggression all about......?
Anyways... from your tone it sounds like you should take a chill pill.
Meanwhile, my offending post continues to get accolades from the free thinkers.
Annoying isn't it?
I still think your 'intern all muslims' remark is ridiculous. But you are entitled to that view, just as I am mine.
I should have clarified that I only want those muslims interned that preach hate/incite others to fight for ISIL and/or are involved in plotting and/or carrying out acts of terrorism etc.
It would be impractical to intern them all anyway.
My main thrust was to endorse the right of the government/MI6 to monitor all forms of communication to identify those who wish us harm.
I have no problem with you airing your views nick...... none at all mate.
Regards.
That's not really a clarification, that is a move away from your original post but fair enough.
The thing is the circumstances you describe in your clarification, you would not and don't need to "intern" people for. Preaching hate, plotting terrorist acts, inciting others to commit terrorist acts are all criminal offences and you wouldn't intern someone for that, you would jail them.
The part of your post that stood out for me was that it was aimed at a particular religious group only.
As I said in a previous post that you ignored/missed, discrimination on the basis of religion is a criminal offence in this country, as would be inciting others to discriminate on the basis of religious belief.
How many people support your post or not and there are quite a few on both sides, matters not. What you were suggesting is against the law.
In regards to your argument that government and security agencies should be allowed to invade whoever's personal freedom as a matter of course, is not a silly argument. Striking a balance between freedom and security is always difficult, especially in these times of extremism and technology.
While I will always support any government that strives to keep the people safe, I don't not trust just any goverment not to use that power in order to control. For me that is just as great a threat to democracy and our general way of life as a potential attack.
The ability for the people to engage in free speech and to vote privately, is a fundamental right and an essential corners stone of any true democracy.
I am not a fan of any religion.
However right now it only appears to be Islam that is killing people.
If any other religion starts killing I will be on their case to.
...... oh and Atheists had better not start any terror campaigns!!!
Fair enough, your not a fan of any religion, your not alone in that, I can respect that point of view.
But you then say it ".. only appears to be Islam that is killing people".
Islam can't kill anyone or anything, it's a notion, an idea, a religion or a way of life for some.
What kills people is when someone takes an idea or a notion and uses it to kill or oppress someone else.
Humans don't need the excuse of religion to kill for a notion. There are some extremely fanatical secularists, Christians, Buddhists (yes, them too), Nazis, Communists, Fascists I could go on.
If you look at Nazis and Communists only, people that practised those two ideologies have killed people in the hundreds of millions, if you look at Hitler, Stalin and Mao. Nothing to do with religion.
IMO humble opinion, I think that the main problem that those who oppose your posts have is that you show a level of discrimination that alarms people. They see echoes of what they believe is an extreme view, in order to combat what are without doubt the extreme views of those that attack our freedoms.
Some would say, fire with fire but IMO that just gets everyone burnt, we have to be smarter than that.
Incidentally, this is the first post of mine that you have directly replied to, even though many others have replied on your behalf.
Christians would say that Christmas must be coming.
Don't expect a present...
I think you read too much into my posts.
I oppose facism and communism etc etc.... all killings and acts of terrorism on any scale or for any reason is clearly not on but sh1t happens.
However... right now... those people calling themselves ISIS, ISIL, Jihadists, Al Qaeda, Boko Haram and any other similar group are all guided by Islamic teachings and purport to be acting in accordance with the Quaran's guidance to kill all infidels. (I know most muslims say this is not a literal instruction but many believe it to be true).
I don't happen to agree that this situation will go away with a handshake and diplomacy when you have people prepared to blow themselves up for their mistaken beliefs.
I respect your views, but I am not about to change mine because you or Jeremy Corbyn don't want conflict.
Corbyn and anyone else with similar views show a naivety that alarms me quite frankly.
But hey ho.... Lets agree to disagree on this matter.
In regards to reading too much into your posts, you post a lot on here and have done for a few years. So I base my remarks on what I have read but it's just my opinion, no biggy...
When you say, you or Corbyn, don't want conflict, you are SERIOUSLY mistaken.
I can't speak for Corbyn but I am no pacifist, I believe in a strong, state of the art military. I would get rid of Trident but only to replace it with a British system. There are technical issues with that, that's for another post.
I am like Corbyn in one sense and that is I believe in peace but I also believe that you "walk in peace with a very big stick". Because not everyone else is peaceful.
I don't get the Corbyn is the devil type rhetoric that some spout although I wouldn't vote for him, at the moment he seems to me to be wrong footed, although I like some things he has said, there are some things that I clearly do not agree with but I don't think a lot of what he has said has been reported, unless it's controversial.
I guess I am like him in another aspect and that is that I don't deal in personal insults (most of the time), I seem them as a sign of immaturity. Some don't mind it and I suppose they add the the colour of life but they are not for me, usually.
In regards to dealing with ISIS, in principle, I am not against sending in troops. I was against the invasion of Afghanistan and Iraq and what we did in Libya was nothing short of stupid.
However, the war in Syria is a civil war, the involvement of so many foreign powers in the conflict has caused more problems for Syrians on all sides and has allowed ISIS to grow. Before and if any troops are sent in from this country, I believe there needs to be, among other things;
1. Cross party support..
2. A proper coalition..
3. Very clear achievable objectives..
4. An exit strategy, with an achievable time scale..
5. Global funding for Syria to rebuild..
I don't believe that any of the above conditions can be met currently.
You don't fight a war unless you know you can achieve your goals and without all of the above, we would not achieve our goals.
I travel a lot and have a very global outlook and some of my favourite subjects are, among others; Comparative religion, History, Politics and.... Military Strategy. That's probably why I like this thread, although it's been crazy and messed up at times.
One of my all-time favourite books.. Sun Tsu - The Art of War. Very "un-Corbynesque"..
I know I will not change your views with a few posts but I suspect that the reason we come on here is to see what other Palace fans are thinking about the general topics of the day.
For all the long posts, opinion and counter opinion, there are some on here who have not once mentioned the victims or their families, I think for some, these are "sensational" times more than they are tragic. They are an excuse to spout whatever agenda they have. Just my opinion.
That's not aimed at you personally, it's just a very general observation..(Honestly).
Anyway, I've posted enough on this thread, I'll leave the rest to others..
"You can lead a horse to water but a pencil must be lead"
Stan Laurel
|