You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Confederate Statues
November 22 2026 12.00am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Confederate Statues


Page 24 of 30 < 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 >
wordup Flag 25 Aug 17 6.55pm

Originally posted by hedgehog50

Are you saying Putin's Russia is as bad as Stalin's Russia? In what way is Trump on his knees to Russia by the way?

Edited by hedgehog50 (25 Aug 2017 6.50pm)

Of course I'm not, it's chalk and cheese. I'm suggesting that the US relationship with Russia is possibly not a great example to give right now all things considered.

'On his knees' as in he's the one person Trump appears to not want to say anything bad about, and wanting to remove consequences of their electoral interference.

Edited by wordup (25 Aug 2017 6.58pm)

 

Stirlingsays Flag 25 Aug 17 7.26pm

Originally posted by wordup

- The Russians did attempt to interfere with the election. Every intelligence agency agrees.

- Trump did try to overturn sanctions - and indeed a bipartisan vote had to take place to stop him doing so.

- When there are increased tensions between left and right, it does create opportunities to exploit. How exactly do you think Fox News and Msnbc make their money?

You said 'progressives' were a mirror image of the 'ultra right' the other day. If your dials are set with that type of thinking, you're of course going to notice something wrong with my post and let the ludicrous post aimed at Jamie have a free pass.

Edited by wordup (25 Aug 2017 7.05pm)

No, I said 'antifa' were an mirror image of the 'far right'. Some progressives sensibly don't support 'antifa' so I don't remember saying that.

I don't disagree with any of the three points you make at the start. That's not what I moaned about.

You had just complained about 'over the top' comments and then you write, 'Trump getting on his knees for a Russian government'...That's over the top......Besides...Obama got on his knees for China....poor old Tibet eh...who on the left moaned about that?

Now don't get me wrong....I'm not complaining about this style of writing.....But I do moan if you do it yourself after complaining about it in others.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

wordup Flag 25 Aug 17 9.25pm

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

No, I said 'antifa' were an mirror image of the 'far right'. Some progressives sensibly don't support 'antifa' so I don't remember saying that.

I don't disagree with any of the three points you make at the start. That's not what I moaned about.

You had just complained about 'over the top' comments and then you write, 'Trump getting on his knees for a Russian government'...That's over the top......Besides...Obama got on his knees for China....poor old Tibet eh...who on the left moaned about that?

Now don't get me wrong....I'm not complaining about this style of writing.....But I do moan if you do it yourself after complaining about it in others.

Well, you said "'progressives' and the ultra right are kind of mirror images of themselves. As manipulation of narratives and 'winning' is more important to them anything else. For them there isn't the same level of balance that can normally be found by people not buying into agendas as much as they have a keen attachment to accuracy."

It's very much presented as a like for like comparison, not a mention of antifa - which of course would've been a rational comparison - and is similar to the type of extreme skew I criticised so it's no wonder you came barreling in .

So you're telling me that you don't disagree with what I've written but you picked me up on it anyway, apparently because I neglected to mention that Obama was bad too when he was in power?! Come on.. So nothing was even 'over the top' about my comment anyway?

Indeed my post and those around it mocked the partisan 'good' and 'bad' view of political sides rather than contributed to it. I quite often criticise both sides. I find that not doing so negates the point of contributing. If someone says one political persuasion 'hate america' and blatantly makes up OTT stuff about what someone else has said, I'm happy to point that out though where I see it.

Edited by wordup (25 Aug 2017 9.32pm)

 

wordup Flag 25 Aug 17 9.27pm

Originally posted by .TUX.

This.

At least you march to the beat of your own drum on here.

When a nation's people are drifting further and further apart, there are plenty of opportunities, whether for foreign nations, TV networks offering warped one sides commentary, or others, to take advantage of this situation or to inflame further if they have the will and the means.

What's funny is that people will always have more in common than not when you really think about it. A cross party ticket of two moderates would make sense, but in the current environment I can't see that happening.


Anyway, I've kind of drifted off topic I know so I'll get back on track!


Edited by wordup (25 Aug 2017 9.37pm)

 

Stirlingsays Flag 25 Aug 17 10.13pm

Originally posted by wordup

Well, you said "'progressives' and the ultra right are kind of mirror images of themselves. As manipulation of narratives and 'winning' is more important to them anything else. For them there isn't the same level of balance that can normally be found by people not buying into agendas as much as they have a keen attachment to accuracy."

I do remember writing something like that....on what page is this by the way? If I used the word, 'progressive' then that was a mistake because....as I say, not all progressives agree with the use of violence as antifa do.

I'm very susceptible to mistakes and it's right to criticise me if I make them.

Originally posted by wordup

It's very much presented as a like for like comparison, not a mention of antifa - which of course would've been a rational comparison - and is similar to the type of extreme skew I criticised so it's no wonder you came barreling in .

Yep, it was a mistake if I typed that, but an understandable one as many progressives are protecting antifa tactics....but it's certainly true that plenty on the left, including some progressives don't.

Originally posted by wordup

So you're telling me that you don't disagree with what I've written but you picked me up on it anyway, apparently because I neglected to mention that Obama was bad too when he was in power?! Come on.. So nothing was even 'over the top' about my comment anyway?

I thought I had been clear in what I meant here.

I criticised how you characterised one of these points in particular because you were indeed over the top, to paraphrase you....'Trump being on his knees to Russia'. As you had just criticised a poster for being over the top I then see you instantly committing the same 'crime'. Trump isn't 'on his knees'....it's very Nick of you.

As I said, I don't personally have a problem with this style but if you criticise it in others then if you do it yourself straight away then you are going to suffer the slings and arrows.

I've noticed you have a thin skin so I knew you'd react but nevertheless I considered the point valid to make.....sue me.

Originally posted by wordup

Indeed my post and those around it mocked the partisan 'good' and 'bad' view of political sides rather than contributed to it. I quite often criticise both sides. I find that not doing so negates the point of contributing. If someone says one political persuasion 'hate america' and blatantly makes up OTT stuff about what someone else has said, I'm happy to point that out though where I see it.


Edited by wordup (25 Aug 2017 9.32pm)

Yes, I personally find you one of the more even handed posters despite us disagreeing on plenty.

I agree with criticising what you find, regardless of what perspective it comes from. While I'm a massive defender of free speech, even offensive speech I'm likewise a defender of the free freedom to criticise it...hopefully in an orderly way. The marketplace of non violent ideas must be heard.

As for your comment that people on general talk are reluctant to criticise the excesses of those on their side of the aisle....well you have a point there....it appears to be a character flaw that most of us on Hol exhibit......People don't tend to respond well to criticism, accurate or otherwise....yourself perhaps being a case in point. So I guess it's a case of people picking their battles and keeping their allies by letting the sleeping dogs lie.

But I agree with the general thrust of your point....a debating forum would ideally be free of egos and we should all view ourselves as independent thinkers rather than defenders of 'sides'....though it's a sure way of being hated by plenty.

Edited by Stirlingsays (25 Aug 2017 10.14pm)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

wordup Flag 25 Aug 17 10.21pm

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

Yes, I personally find you one of the more even handed posters despite us disagreeing on plenty.

I agree with criticising what you find, regardless of what perspective it comes from. While I'm a massive defender of free speech, even offensive speech I'm likewise a defender of the free freedom to criticise it...hopefully in an orderly way. The marketplace of non violent ideas must be heard.

As for your comment that people on general talk are reluctant to criticise the excesses of those on their side of the aisle....well you have a point there....it appears to be a character flaw that most of us on Hol exhibit......People don't tend to respond well to criticism, accurate or otherwise....yourself perhaps being a case in point. So I guess it's a case of people picking their battles and keeping their allies by letting the sleeping dogs lie.

But I agree with the general thrust of your point....a debating forum would ideally be free of egos and we should all view ourselves as independent thinkers rather than defenders of 'sides'....though it's a sure way of being hated by plenty.

I'm off out so I can't really get too caught up in this, which probably isn't a bad thing! It was the trump thread the other day. Yes, we all make mistakes on here, it's part of the fun! And most react. I think it's partly the nature of football and rivalry and it feeds into perception of the world. That and a more typically male trait. I doubt they go at it like this on knitting fansites. I envy those who don't react and get caught up in, it's not all that helpful really.

 

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 25 Aug 17 10.28pm

I can't believe people still are using the look at them instead argument rather than the fact that gun toting white supremacists / fascists were marching through the streets.

Fascists marching through the streets and people who come out to stand against this are the ones some people on here want to put the spotlight on.

 

hedgehog50 Flag Croydon 25 Aug 17 10.41pm

Originally posted by nickgusset

I can't believe people still are using the look at them instead argument rather than the fact that gun toting white supremacists / fascists were marching through the streets.

Fascists marching through the streets and people who come out to stand against this are the ones some people on here want to put the spotlight on.

All bad, armed fascists on the streets - not as common of course as communists and anarchists with petrol bombs, masks, iron bars and placards printed by the Socialist Workers Party. Both sides need each other, they are like rival football 'fans'.

 


We have now sunk to a depth at which the restatement of the obvious is the first duty of intelligent men. [Orwell]

Stirlingsays Flag 25 Aug 17 10.54pm

Originally posted by wordup

I'm off out so I can't really get too caught up in this, which probably isn't a bad thing! It was the trump thread the other day. Yes, we all make mistakes on here, it's part of the fun! And most react. I think it's partly the nature of football and rivalry and it feeds into perception of the world. That and a more typically male trait. I doubt they go at it like this on knitting fansites. I envy those who don't react and get caught up in, it's not all that helpful really.

I hope you continue to contribute. Nothing wrong with throwing in your view. Seeing the opposite side of an debate is vital. We all benefit from being outside our echo chambers.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Stirlingsays Flag 25 Aug 17 11.01pm

Originally posted by nickgusset

I can't believe people still are using the look at them instead argument rather than the fact that gun toting white supremacists / fascists were marching through the streets.

Fascists marching through the streets and people who come out to stand against this are the ones some people on here want to put the spotlight on.

I think coming out to protest fascists is in fact a good thing.

As I was initially correctly reminded about Charlottesville, plenty of people did in fact do this. And I agree with those people and would have been one of them.

However.....

Also at Charlottesville were various forms of violent Marxist groups that didn't go to protest but to confront and fight.

Those neo nazis had a permit to march and so when....lets collectively call them antifa....when antifa line up and deliberately stand in the way of the march they are there for violence and video showed that.

Edited by Stirlingsays (25 Aug 2017 11.02pm)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 25 Aug 17 11.13pm

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

I think coming out to protest fascists is in fact a good thing.

As I was initially correctly reminded about Charlottesville, plenty of people did in fact do this. And I agree with those people and would have been one of them.

However.....

Also at Charlottesville were various forms of violent Marxist groups that didn't go to protest but to confront and fight.

Those neo nazis had a permit to march and so when....lets collectively call them antifa....when antifa line up and deliberately stand in the way of the march they are there for violence and video showed that.

Edited by Stirlingsays (25 Aug 2017 11.02pm)

Which is a handy deflection away from the fact that nazis are marching through the street.

 

Stirlingsays Flag 25 Aug 17 11.33pm

Originally posted by nickgusset

Which is a handy deflection away from the fact that nazis are marching through the street.

Well yeah...it's not a deflection but I agree what's happening is not good. It's not something I support...You know before the 'progressives' and the advancement of 'identity' politics to the mainstream the far right had been reducing in numbers decade upon decade.

That's what 'identity' politics gets you Nick. The opposite to will come out and also scream 'identity' politics.

The far right have seen an opportunity to tap into the grievances caused by the demonisation of their group and identity just for being white.

I deplore anyone for joining any group that advocates race supremacy. However, I can see what's happening under the surface.

The centralists and moderates on both sides in America seem to be on the backfoot.

Edited by Stirlingsays (25 Aug 2017 11.34pm)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 26 Aug 17 12.21am

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

Well yeah...it's not a deflection but I agree what's happening is not good. It's not something I support...You know before the 'progressives' and the advancement of 'identity' politics to the mainstream the far right had been reducing in numbers decade upon decade.

That's what 'identity' politics gets you Nick. The opposite to will come out and also scream 'identity' politics.

The far right have seen an opportunity to tap into the grievances caused by the demonisation of their group and identity just for being white.

I deplore anyone for joining any group that advocates race supremacy. However, I can see what's happening under the surface.

The centralists and moderates on both sides in America seem to be on the backfoot.

Edited by Stirlingsays (25 Aug 2017 11.34pm)

The old, it's the left's fault that nazi ism is on the rise line.

Do behave!

 

Stirlingsays Flag 26 Aug 17 12.25am

Originally posted by nickgusset

The old, it's the left's fault that nazi ism is on the rise line.

Do behave!

Well, 'identity politics'....that's pushed by a section of the left....'progressives' mostly. A lot of the traditional left who vote for them don't buy into it either.

So it's the far left's fault yeah....not the left as such. The far left and right end up just growing each other's numbers.

It will just lead to increased security laws....because at the end of the day the majority will always back the establishment over chaos.


Edited by Stirlingsays (26 Aug 2017 12.28am)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 26 Aug 17 12.49am

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

Well, 'identity politics'....that's pushed by a section of the left....'progressives' mostly. A lot of the traditional left who vote for them don't buy into it either.

So it's the far left's fault yeah....not the left as such. The far left and right end up just growing each other's numbers.

It will just lead to increased security laws....because at the end of the day the majority will always back the establishment over chaos.


Edited by Stirlingsays (26 Aug 2017 12.28am)

Nazis walking the streets 2 or 3 generations after the allies fought fascism and you're still saying but but those people over there, those ones who want to tell the Nazi scum what they can do with their warped ideology, look at them.

It's not far from being an apologist for white supremacists. Not far.

 

Stirlingsays Flag 26 Aug 17 1.04am

Originally posted by nickgusset

Nazis walking the streets 2 or 3 generations after the allies fought fascism and you're still saying but but those people over there, those ones who want to tell the Nazi scum what they can do with their warped ideology, look at them.

It's not far from being an apologist for white supremacists. Not far.

Ah Nick.

Yeah, It's about as far as calling you an apologist for Islamic extremists because you don't support reformists.

I just call you misguided.

Edited by Stirlingsays (26 Aug 2017 1.05am)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

wordup Flag 26 Aug 17 2.23am

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

Ah Nick.

Yeah, It's about as far as calling you an apologist for Islamic extremists because you don't support reformists.

I just call you misguided.

Edited by Stirlingsays (26 Aug 2017 1.05am)

Maybe you're both right. Maybe Nick does go above and beyond in diverting from islamic extremist incidents due to being overly concerned about protecting a group of people and missing part of the picture.

And maybe you go to extreme lengths to excuse or divert from the far right. You paint charlottesvile neo nazis as marchers with permits being attacked by violent marxists groups. It's a reach. For one groups of protesters 'and' counter protesters had permits that day. Secondly one of the racists ran over and killed someone and you're criticising people for standing in the way.

As for identity politics, it works both ways. If you honesty only see what the left is doing as identity related then you're either not seeing that part of the picture because it aligns with your views and comfort zone, or you don't want to acknowledge it.

Trump unnecessarily pardoning Arpaio tonight is obviously done partially for identity reasons due to his perceived stance on civil rights. Do you think pardoning him is a sensible move considering the last couple of weeks? Pointlessly banning trans people from entering the military, again tonight, is clearly also done to appeal to appeal to some at the detriment of others. It's all identity related.

Edited by wordup (26 Aug 2017 5.29am)

 

.TUX. Flag 26 Aug 17 7.10am

Originally posted by NickinOX

Well, they are a visible depiction of people who fought to preserve slavery. It is about time they came down. It is no different than pulling down statues of Soviet leaders in Estonia, or British ones in Ireland or India.

[Link]

For those who don't think it was about slavery, read the reasoning of the Confederate Vice President as to the causes of the war.

By the way, there have been loads of murders committed by the KKK for their cause so I am not sure what your point is.

(Apologies if it's already been posted) The Corwin Amendment, March 2 1861?
As with many many 'wars', this one also appears to be 'economically driven' (anyone surprised?).........

The North offered to preserve slavery irrevocably, but the North did not offer to give up the high tariffs and economic policies that the South saw as inimical to its interests.

[Link]


Edited by .TUX. (26 Aug 2017 7.11am)

 


Buy Litecoin.

hedgehog50 Flag Croydon 26 Aug 17 10.53am

Just as American towns are under pressure to remove statues of old 'problematic' white men, so the Institue of Psychiatry, Psychology and Neuroscience at King's College London has announced it will remove portraits and statues of its founders because ... well there're all white.

[Link]

It's pretty clear who are the intolerant, repressive party here with this historical cleansing - Goebbels would be proud of them - no doubt the usual suspects on here are.

 


We have now sunk to a depth at which the restatement of the obvious is the first duty of intelligent men. [Orwell]

Stirlingsays Flag 26 Aug 17 11.44am

Originally posted by wordup

Maybe you're both right. Maybe Nick does go above and beyond in diverting from islamic extremist incidents due to being overly concerned about protecting a group of people and missing part of the picture.

And maybe you go to extreme lengths to excuse or divert from the far right. You paint charlottesvile neo nazis as marchers with permits being attacked by violent marxists groups. It's a reach. For one groups of protesters 'and' counter protesters had permits that day. Secondly one of the racists ran over and killed someone and you're criticising people for standing in the way.

As for identity politics, it works both ways. If you honesty only see what the left is doing as identity related then you're either not seeing that part of the picture because it aligns with your views and comfort zone, or you don't want to acknowledge it.

Trump unnecessarily pardoning Arpaio tonight is obviously done partially for identity reasons due to his perceived stance on civil rights. Do you think pardoning him is a sensible move considering the last couple of weeks? Pointlessly banning trans people from entering the military, again tonight, is clearly also done to appeal to appeal to some at the detriment of others. It's all identity related.

Edited by wordup (26 Aug 2017 5.29am)

When I say, 'identity' politics I talking about the politics of 'skin colour'. When you widen that how to talk about political demographics....that's moving into different areas. That's fine of course and something to be discussed but it wasn't what I was referring to.

I don't accept that I have excused or diverted from the far right. Indeed I have explicitly criticised them. Where has Nick explicitly criticised Antifa? He hasn't, indeed he has supported them, whereas I haven't supported violence from whatever side. I don't believe the equivalency is there.

I have condemned the murder of a protester. I also condemn the violence from the left....for example, that Sanders supporter who shot at Republicans at that Baseball game. I hear a lot people condemning Trump for his language and suggesting it encourages the far right but if this indeed has any validity then it's just as true of the language of his opponents.

The Arpaio situation seems to be around the area of illegal immigrants. I don't know much about the rights or wrongs of what he did legally. I know Presidents often pardon in some iffy circumstances, maybe this is one of those or maybe not.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Page 24 of 30 < 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Confederate Statues