You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Who’s at fault - Hodgson or the board?
November 16 2026 7.58am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Who’s at fault - Hodgson or the board?


Page 24 of 44 < 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 >
Bangell Flag Oxford 11 Dec 18 11.39pm

Originally posted by chateauferret

Yes and so there's f*** all excuse for not using Sørloth like that. He may not be Harry Kane but he is at least a proper unit, and it's better than playing five men in the wrong positions, pissing off the players who should be getting a proper chance, and pardewing everyone all over again.

Edited by chateauferret (11 Dec 2018 10.15pm)

Have you seen Sorloth play? He may look like a proper unit but he's got as much physical presence as Jonny Williams.

 

meatpienz Flag brisbane 11 Dec 18 11.46pm

The biggest mistake this season was letting Bakary Sako go.

 


Zaha has some green grass in front of him here. Finds Ambrose
not a bad effort ooooooooooh! what a goal by Darren Ambrose absolutely stunning strike!!! And, Crystal Palace lead @ Old Trafford.

Rachid Rachid Rachid Flag 11 Dec 18 11.54pm

Originally posted by meatpienz

The biggest mistake this season was letting Bakary Sako go.

Spent most of his time tossing it off. Injured or overweight. Made a bit of an effort in his last season when he was playing for a contract but not featured much for West Brom.

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards grumpymort Flag US/Thailand/UK 12 Dec 18 12.06am

Originally posted by meatpienz

The biggest mistake this season was letting Bakary Sako go.


We didn't let him go

He chose to leave once his contract expired then later on wanted to come back but it was too late (Had Punch gone on final transfer day Sako would of been back but we hit squad limit)

 


(VPN) - [Link]
(Alt VPN) - [Link]

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 12 Dec 18 9.19am

Originally posted by Rachid Rachid Rachid

Been glaring from early in the season. Too much attention to us “just” needing a striker.

Not so sure it’s all Roy’s doing. We’ve got a Director of Football constantly referred to as “Doug” Freedman. Don’t think Meyer and Kouyate are what we needed at all much as they’re ok players.

I think we just buy just who’s available, or known to be available if you see what I mean. That’s another reason why Parish likes deadline day purchases that are like a tombola with regards to fitting the team, in addition to price and saving wages up until deadline day, regardless of whether the team and manager benefit from them training together earlier.

 


COYP

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 12 Dec 18 9.35am

Originally posted by Maine Eagle

Honestly it is both.

You have to ask yourself, after 6 seasons of this, do you really believe we can suddenly and utterly change the narrative of Crystal Palace FC, without making a cultural change to the very fabric of how the club is run?

Every year it is basically the same story, and what was it Einstein said about doing the same thing over and over?

If we fire RH, and get a new manager in, it will be a stop gap type appointment I would imagine. It could last a year or 2, then it will probably turn sour, and we repeat the cycle again.

We need someone to come in and build something at this club, RH may not be the one simply down to how old he was when we signed him. If he is going to be fired anyway then Parish and the Yanks must be decisive and take action before the January transfer window, and back the new manager. If we need to sell to do that, then we need to sell, as we are drifting out of the league at the moment.

I hear people saying that recruitment isn't the issue, and that Roy needs to work his squad more and manage better, and so on. Some others say our recruitment, specifically of attacking talent, has been abysmal for most of the cpfc2010 tenure, and Roy isn't to blame. There is truth in all of that.

Parish has come a long way since that first Prem transfer window under Holloway but in many ways he still is, and perhaps will always be out of his depth as a Premier League chairman.

After last season it was plain to see we had 3 major areas of concern re the playing staff. We were losing RLC/Cabaye, we needed a keeper (long overdue), and we needed a striker (long overdue) after Benteke's fall from grace and Wickham questionnable to return to former levels.

We really only addressed 1 of those 3 areas, and we are now paying the price. Roy for his part is at fault for seeming to think we can play the same way with half our midfield missing.

We needed to properly replace Cabaye and RLC, and sign a striker, and we did neither.

If we are constrained so much by FFP that we cannot do better than a net spend under 10 mil last summer then this is a total failure of Parish and the board for sanctioning the Sakho signing. Sakho should have never been signed if it meant we could not bring in adequate replacements for RLC/Cabaye and also sign a striker which would add value.

Instead we bring in Sorloth and Ayew to solve the striker problem, and get in Max Meyer (good signing) and Kouyate (good signing) but in neither one do we have an RLC type player.

Edited by Maine Eagle (11 Dec 2018 8.16pm)

Whilst I understand what you are saying and agree with a lot of it, the signing of Sakho pre-dates the replacement of RLC and Cabaye so is irrelevant unless you are saying we simply shouldn’t have signed Sakho in the first place. Finding a replacement for Cabaye was important, but difficult and RLC even more important/difficult. Despite the fact he doesn’t play that often at Chelsea, players of his ability are few and far between. He should be in their starting lineup every week, but their manager just doesn’t see it that way. If you could suggest a replacement who is available and affordable for either of those positions I would be interested in hearing it.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 12 Dec 18 10.04am

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

Whilst I understand what you are saying and agree with a lot of it, the signing of Sakho pre-dates the replacement of RLC and Cabaye so is irrelevant unless you are saying we simply shouldn’t have signed Sakho in the first place. Finding a replacement for Cabaye was important, but difficult and RLC even more important/difficult. Despite the fact he doesn’t play that often at Chelsea, players of his ability are few and far between. He should be in their starting lineup every week, but their manager just doesn’t see it that way. If you could suggest a replacement who is available and affordable for either of those positions I would be interested in hearing it.

This post just highlights your lack of understanding and maturity. If we signed CB’s and strikers that didn’t cost £25-£30 million and 75% of our net spend then we would have money, or room to spend in the 3 year FFP cycles, to buy other players that become the next priority. To achieve that you need good scouting and people with experience hired close to you.

We sign mega money signings because we don’t do these critical things and effectively hamstring ourselves within that 3 year FFP cycle if they’re never going to bend the rules as others do.

It’s do bl33ding obvious I can’t believe I’ve had to post it. Have a good day.

 


COYP

Ghostship Flag Norfolk 12 Dec 18 10.11am

Originally posted by taylors lovechild

That doesn't really make sense as Roy didn't sign most of the players in our first XI. We tried to find him a new club because I imagine it was a position we felt we had adequate cover for.

All the players signed by Allardyce were already established in the 1st team before Roy arrived so he wouldn't want to cause too much upheavel there. It just seems that with Jairo he was on a bit of a hiding to nothing sort of last in first out scenario and that the club wanted rid of anything to do with FDB at all cost

 

spartakev2 Flag Anerley 12 Dec 18 10.30am

Originally posted by Ghostship

All the players signed by Allardyce were already established in the 1st team before Roy arrived so he wouldn't want to cause too much upheavel there. It just seems that with Jairo he was on a bit of a hiding to nothing sort of last in first out scenario and that the club wanted rid of anything to do with FDB at all cost

Jairo had one good game against man city. Apart from that he's shown absolutely nothing to suggest he can make it in thd premiership. Not in thd odd appearance he's played for thd first team, cup games against inferior opposit in and even U23 games. Do you think if he showed anything at all I'm training he wouldn't be on the bench instead of puncheon. How on earth has he suddenly become the player we need to turn our season round?

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 12 Dec 18 10.43am

Originally posted by spartakev2

Jairo had one good game against man city. Apart from that he's shown absolutely nothing to suggest he can make it in thd premiership. Not in thd odd appearance he's played for thd first team, cup games against inferior opposit in and even U23 games. Do you think if he showed anything at all I'm training he wouldn't be on the bench instead of puncheon. How on earth has he suddenly become the player we need to turn our season round?

He’s too static for me, even for a defensive type midfielder, who aren’t just sitting in front anymore anyway. Not saying that I wouldn’t play him recently though. The squad is stretched and the performances and results very recently have been poor.

 


COYP

Ghostship Flag Norfolk 12 Dec 18 11.49am

Originally posted by spartakev2

Jairo had one good game against man city. Apart from that he's shown absolutely nothing to suggest he can make it in thd premiership. Not in thd odd appearance he's played for thd first team, cup games against inferior opposit in and even U23 games. Do you think if he showed anything at all I'm training he wouldn't be on the bench instead of puncheon. How on earth has he suddenly become the player we need to turn our season round?

Don't think I ever said he was the player to turn our season around. He has shown that he can actually find a team mate with the ball and is comfortable with the ball at his feet which can't be said for Luka who constantly losses possession.

We moan at Roy for not trying something different so here is a chance for him to do that and if it doesn't work out then fair enough but we paid a lot of money for Jairo so we should try and make it work.

 

spartakev2 Flag Anerley 12 Dec 18 1.12pm

Originally posted by Ghostship

Don't think I ever said he was the player to turn our season around. He has shown that he can actually find a team mate with the ball and is comfortable with the ball at his feet which can't be said for Luka who constantly losses possession.

We moan at Roy for not trying something different so here is a chance for him to do that and if it doesn't work out then fair enough but we paid a lot of money for Jairo so we should try and make it work.

Again.....with the situation we are in, if he had shown anything at all in training/under 23 do you not think he would not at least be on the bench? I Don't believe for a moment that roy would just leave him out to be stubborn. From what I've seen of him playing u23s he's making no effort to stake a claim. In fact in the laSt game he was given a rating of 5, the worst in the team. So roy is supposed to say, I know you're playing s**t and not making an effort but I think I'll stick you in thd first team anyway?....

 

Nobbybm Flag Dartford 12 Dec 18 1.14pm

Originally posted by ASCPFC

There seems to be quite a bit of complacency amongst the team. Who's to blame for that?: the manager, the coaches, or the players themselves. I'm very much looking at the latter.

I've a slightly different angle. A few years ago my local non-league team made it into the Conference/National League. After a few months it was clear they were playing as well as they could but results were just not going their way. Slowly, the performance levels started top drop off & many thought the manager had lost the dressing room.

Bumped into two of the players on a night out who both confessed that they'd actually just lost faith in what they were doing - no matter what the result/opposition/injury situation/home/away nothing changed from his plan A. They just felt by continuing to do exactly the same things week in week out nobody expected the end result to change.

Maybe the squad is at that point?

 


Will this be five? It's gonna be five! It IS five!

Painter Flag Croydon 12 Dec 18 2.21pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

I think we just buy just who’s available, or known to be available if you see what I mean. That’s another reason why Parish likes deadline day purchases that are like a tombola with regards to fitting the team, in addition to price and saving wages up until deadline day, regardless of whether the team and manager benefit from them training together earlier.

You can’t buy someone who isn’t available!

 

Jacey Flag 12 Dec 18 2.55pm

Tactics,poor substitutions among many criticisms levelled against Roy this quite disastrous season,as he appears to have lost his Midas touch.
Possible further losses against Leicester,Man City and Chelsea most likely see us near or at the bottom come the end of the year.
How on earth do we get out of this mess this time ???

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 12 Dec 18 2.57pm

Originally posted by Painter

You can’t buy someone who isn’t available!

Pedant Alert

pedant.jpg Attachment: pedant.jpg (26.63Kb)

 

HKOwen Flag Hong Kong 13 Dec 18 1.05am

Jairo is an example of where a poor decision by an ex manager long ago still haunts the club with expensive baggage no one else wants and denying a possibly better player a place in the squad

 


Responsibility Deficit Disorder is a medical condition. Symptoms include inability to be corrected when wrong, false sense of superiority, desire to share personal info no else cares about, general hubris. It's a medical issue rather than pure arrogance.

chateauferret Flag 13 Dec 18 1.50am

Originally posted by HKOwen

Jairo is an example of where a poor decision by an ex manager long ago still haunts the club with expensive baggage no one else wants and denying a possibly better player a place in the squad

Except that he's actually reasonably decent, or would be if he were allowed to play more than twice a season. Ridiculous.

 


============
The Ferret
============

dreamwaverider Flag London 13 Dec 18 5.18am

Originally posted by Jacey

Tactics,poor substitutions among many criticisms levelled against Roy this quite disastrous season,as he appears to have lost his Midas touch.
Possible further losses against Leicester,Man City and Chelsea most likely see us near or at the bottom come the end of the year.
How on earth do we get out of this mess this time ???

VERY good question. Let’s hope those in charge have the answers.

 

rikz Flag Croydon 13 Dec 18 11.40am

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

This post just highlights your lack of understanding and maturity. If we signed CB’s and strikers that didn’t cost £25-£30 million and 75% of our net spend then we would have money, or room to spend in the 3 year FFP cycles, to buy other players that become the next priority. To achieve that you need good scouting and people with experience hired close to you.

We sign mega money signings because we don’t do these critical things and effectively hamstring ourselves within that 3 year FFP cycle if they’re never going to bend the rules as others do.

It’s do bl33ding obvious I can’t believe I’ve had to post it. Have a good day.

Benteke and Sakho both had over 100 pages on here before they signed, the fans are just as bad demanding marquee signings every transfer window. The board would be getting slagged off now asking why we ain't showing the same ambition as other clubs if they hadn't been signed they're dammed if they do and dammed If they don't.

 

Page 24 of 44 < 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Who’s at fault - Hodgson or the board?