This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by Badger11
Whilst we miss Zaha does anyone think that he would have stopped the first 2 goals today? Zaha would have kept them busy with trying to foul him.
|
|
|
Originally posted by taylors lovechild
When Tomkins returned we instantly looked so much better (Man City aside). I don't think any of our other centre-backs are still PL quality. Cahill was Player of the Season last year imo and in many others. He has at least 3-4 more years in him.
|
|
|
Originally posted by mattteo
Cahill was Player of the Season last year imo and in many others. He has at least 3-4 more years in him. Not at this level.
Red and Blue Army! |
|
|
Originally posted by PZ Eagle
It wouldn't take a lot to work out though/ Are you saying you watched our last home game against them with him at his house and you left a calling card? lol
|
|
|
Originally posted by alwyn
I'd swap Burnley's back 5 for ours in a hearbeat. And they would swap their entire offensive for Zaha, Eze, Mateta, Ayew and Batshuayi. I prefer it like this. Their back 5 isn't all that great either, the right defender Lowton didn't have another Premier League goal for like 8 years, it just happened to have a good day. I think Clyne edges him at individual quality. And I don't like their left back Pieters at all, he was slow back when he was at Stoke and that was years ago. Yes, their 2 central defenders are better and arguably the goalkeeper too. So that's 3. I wouldn't trade anything for that squad. They have no players for the future. Only NcNeil who is so-so for attack. And of course their central defenders are better than playing with Kouyate and Dann there, but if Tomkins and Cahill were fit...
|
|
|
Originally posted by mattteo
Cahill was Player of the Season last year imo and in many others. He has at least 3-4 more years in him. Mate he's 35 now - he simply doesn't have another 3 or 4 years left him in at this level - 1 at best..!!
|
|
|
Originally posted by TheBigToePunt
Originally posted by mattteo
Lower than Robertson, Cole, Evra, of course, but you named 3 of the very best. Higher than Stuart Pearce, I think he was overrated, seems great cause he scored a lot of penalty kicks at club level. I would also rank him below than Leighton Baines, Ian Harte, Riise, Kolarov, maybe even Danny Rose (who had some great seasons), but he still makes Top 10. So even with his defensive faults, PVA has actually done something in football and should be respected by us. Edited by mattteo (13 Feb 2021 6.58pm)[/quo PVA ranks higher than Stuart Pearce? I'm struggling with that, but I do agree that not only PVA, but all our senior players should be afforded the proper respect to their abilities. Very few human beings are able to hold their ground over the course of a premier league season, a point I make every time someone suggests that we should bin the lot of them and put the youth team in. That said, if PVA were anything other than an average top flight player, I think it would have revealed itself by now. If it walks like a duck etc... Edited by TheBigToePunt (13 Feb 2021 7.15pm) Surely the point is not where PVA fits in the list of great full backs but the fact that currently he isn’t even the best at Palace! Mitchell isn’t world class but he’s better defensively than PVA and with our ageing defence we need full backs who can defend.
|
|
|
Originally posted by ASCPFC
Not at this level. ..and definitely not amongst his team mates.
|
|
| jeeagles |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Plaistow Eagle
Mate he's 35 now - he simply doesn't have another 3 or 4 years left him in at this level - 1 at best..!! I really like him, especially how he comes across in interviews. But, signing a 34 year old going as cover when he's not going to be available for large portions of the season isn't the smartest move.
|
|
|
Originally posted by mattteo
That's too harsh on PVA. I'd like him to stay, he has done a lot of great things for Palace and is one of the best left backs IN THE HISTORY OF THE PREMIER LEAGUE, not just of Palace Really? According to the whoscored.com avg ratings, he's performing as the joint 3rd worst left back in the league. Chilwell, Cole, Winterburn, Irwin, Le Saux, Evra, Cresswell, Robertson, Baines, Clichy, Riise, Harte, Shaw, Bridge, Staunton, Rose, Tierney, Mendy, Alonso, Pearce... All of those players are absolutely streets ahead of him. It'd have to be well argued to say PVA is in the best 40 left backs to have played in the Premier League. If so, a lot of it would be based on longevity (similar to Joel Ward), rather than a particularly high level of talent or performance. He's only ever looked par in Palace and Sunderland teams.
26th January 2010 - Enter Administration |
|
|
Originally posted by mattteo
And they would swap their entire offensive for Zaha, Eze, Mateta, Ayew and Batshuayi. I prefer it like this. Their back 5 isn't all that great either, the right defender Lowton didn't have another Premier League goal for like 8 years, it just happened to have a good day. I think Clyne edges him at individual quality. And I don't like their left back Pieters at all, he was slow back when he was at Stoke and that was years ago. Yes, their 2 central defenders are better and arguably the goalkeeper too. So that's 3. I wouldn't trade anything for that squad. They have no players for the future. Only NcNeil who is so-so for attack. And of course their central defenders are better than playing with Kouyate and Dann there, but if Tomkins and Cahill were fit... Their normal left back is Charlie Taylor who is better than PVA and Mitchell put together
|
|
|
Originally posted by jeeagles
I really like him, especially how he comes across in interviews. But, signing a 34 year old going as cover when he's not going to be available for large portions of the season isn't the smartest move. Garu Cahill doesn't have to be unavailable. He has never had injury problems at any other ppint in his career besides this season.
|
|
|
Originally posted by ambrose7
All of those players are absolutely streets ahead of him. Edited by ambrose7 (13 Feb 2021 8.25pm) Tierney has what....? 20 Premier League matches?? I am not disputing that he may become a Premier League great in 10 years, when he will be PVA's age, but why put him on that list? Le Saux? You mean that guy who couldn't defend well and by whose fault my national team kicked England's ass in the World Cup and he was ostracized by an entire nation in 1998? You easily forget.
|
|
|
Originally posted by slubglurge
Their normal left back is Charlie Taylor who is better than PVA and Mitchell put together PVA after his horrible injury has not returned the same, he has always had a bad pass in him or a bad AWOL in position, but since his injury he's gone downhill considerably much with practically anything he attempts, having said all that his team mates are not helping him in the slightest.
|
|
|
Burnley weren't that good but they didn't have to be. It was like taking candy from a baby.
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.