You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Topic
November 16 2026 12.16pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Coronavirus (LOCKED)


Page 240 of 753 < 236 237 238 239 240 241 242 243 244 >
Teddy Eagle Flag 22 May 20 10.00am

Originally posted by DanH

Why haven’t you guys on here stepped up and replaced them having to come here?

Why haven’t you? You could do a job swap with some needy individual.

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 22 May 20 10.03am

Originally posted by DanH

Why haven’t you guys on here stepped up and replaced them having to come here?

My son tried but was told he was not suitable because:
He had no previous experience:
He had to live on site sharing a caravan with 3-4 others ( wonder if they will have been tested):
Would have to pay towards lodging ( out of minimum wage).
Check out how many Brits applied and how many were offered jobs. This is about farmers, basically, promoting slave labour.
It really annoys me that it has been put about that Brits are too lazy.
Do you agree that these people should not be quarantined but you would have to be?

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 22 May 20 10.04am

[Link]

Here we go from the Guardian!! Not even the Mail

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 22 May 20 10.11am

Originally posted by Spiderman

My son tried but was told he was not suitable because:
He had no previous experience:
He had to live on site sharing a caravan with 3-4 others ( wonder if they will have been tested):
Would have to pay towards lodging ( out of minimum wage).
Check out how many Brits applied and how many were offered jobs. This is about farmers, basically, promoting slave labour.
It really annoys me that it has been put about that Brits are too lazy.
Do you agree that these people should not be quarantined but you would have to be?

We should stop a lot of this and all just accept a few pence more on our fruit and veg. Problem is the supermarkets set the price and everyone has to work around that. Supermarkets are fear too powerful. Regulation is necessary.

 


COYP

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards SW19 CPFC Flag Addiscombe West 22 May 20 10.43am

Originally posted by Spiderman

[Link]

Here we go from the Guardian!! Not even the Mail

I don't see anything new here.

Pay is low and conditions are less than appealing to keep prices low. As has been mentioned, increase the price of the product – fine, but sales will decrease, farms will move away from growing but along with regulation you'll be able to improve the working conditions. Or make more profit...

It's not as simple as improve conditions, hire more british workers and ban migrant labour. That would have significant negative effects and actually reduce availability of jobs and british produce.

It's unfair to say people are 'lazy' but 'picky?' (no pun intended) – certainly. Students work like this in Australia to get by all the time, but mature british workers are so used to being in non-labour based jobs that require such high levels of exertion as sitting in chairs and walking to get a tea that they simply cannot bring themselves to do these kind of jobs. Until they lose their corona payouts...

If people weren't being furloughed, the fields would be full of british workers. As always, it's unappealing until it's not. There is still a choice being made here – it's not like they're not being offered jobs, they just come with conditions that most british workers would turn their noses up at. And that has always been the issue.

'Nick Marston, the chair of British Summer Fruits, said the business model of fruit farming had been “structured around a non-UK workforce for many years” because UK workers had shunned the work: “Farms are receiving large numbers of applications and I think it would be unfair to say the industry is not accommodating local workforce.”


Edited by SW19 CPFC (22 May 2020 10.45am)

Edited by SW19 CPFC (22 May 2020 10.45am)

 


Did you know? 98.0000001% of people are morons.

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 22 May 20 10.57am

Originally posted by SW19 CPFC

I don't see anything new here.

Pay is low and conditions are less than appealing to keep prices low. As has been mentioned, increase the price of the product – fine, but sales will decrease, farms will move away from growing but along with regulation you'll be able to improve the working conditions. Or make more profit...

It's not as simple as improve conditions, hire more british workers and ban migrant labour. That would have significant negative effects and actually reduce availability of jobs and british produce.

It's unfair to say people are 'lazy' but 'picky?' (no pun intended) – certainly. Students work like this in Australia to get by all the time, but mature british workers are so used to being in non-labour based jobs that require such high levels of exertion as sitting in chairs and walking to get a tea that they simply cannot bring themselves to do these kind of jobs. Until they lose their corona payouts...

If people weren't being furloughed, the fields would be full of british workers. As always, it's unappealing until it's not. There is still a choice being made here – it's not like they're not being offered jobs, they just come with conditions that most british workers would turn their noses up at. And that has always been the issue.

'Nick Marston, the chair of British Summer Fruits, said the business model of fruit farming had been “structured around a non-UK workforce for many years” because UK workers had shunned the work: “Farms are receiving large numbers of applications and I think it would be unfair to say the industry is not accommodating local workforce.”


Edited by SW19 CPFC (22 May 2020 10.45am)

Edited by SW19 CPFC (22 May 2020 10.45am)

I think you’re being a tad harsh on people not wanting to stay in the caravan on the farm because the recruiter makes money back off that. (I have feelings on 15-20 in a house working elsewhere)

I’d be interested to know how little the price would have to rise for better pay seeing as they pick thousands an hour and it seems the supermarket takes most of the profit. Looks like there’s room for more regulation than you think before people stop buying.

 


COYP

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards SW19 CPFC Flag Addiscombe West 22 May 20 11.17am

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

I think you’re being a tad harsh on people not wanting to stay in the caravan on the farm because the recruiter makes money back off that. (I have feelings on 15-20 in a house working elsewhere)

I’d be interested to know how little the price would have to rise for better pay seeing as they pick thousands an hour and it seems the supermarket takes most of the profit. Looks like there’s room for more regulation than you think before people stop buying.

Perhaps. But the general point stands, and the irony of that is inescapable. If it's not a caravan it will be a dorm. Can't see it making much difference to the average British workers motivation

I would also be interested to know the fallout in terms of prices and more importantly viability of enterprise but the rose tinted simplicity of some on here of 'just get british workers to do it and it will all be fine' is ridiculous

 


Did you know? 98.0000001% of people are morons.

SavoyTruffle Flag 22 May 20 11.52am

Is anyone even surprised at this point?

[Link]

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 22 May 20 12.05pm

Originally posted by SW19 CPFC

Perhaps. But the general point stands, and the irony of that is inescapable. If it's not a caravan it will be a dorm. Can't see it making much difference to the average British workers motivation

I would also be interested to know the fallout in terms of prices and more importantly viability of enterprise but the rose tinted simplicity of some on here of 'just get british workers to do it and it will all be fine' is ridiculous

Why should anyone have to take accommodation with a job? It is the supermarkets that take virtually all of the profit and set the price artificially low competing against each other. It’s unnecessary. As the farmers take such a small cut you could’ve looking at a 2 pence price increase.

 


COYP

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 22 May 20 12.07pm

Originally posted by SavoyTruffle

Is anyone even surprised at this point?

[Link]

The whole thing is becoming so corrupt from different parties and angles we need to get back to normal life apart from the vulnerable.

 


COYP

BlueJay Flag UK 22 May 20 12.47pm

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

There's a difference here between environments that contain confined spaces....as in care homes and a ship comprised of young men working together, also in confined spaces, than the general population.

When the results come back from testing done in states and regions I don't think I've seen an infection rate above New York's that was in the twenties I think.

Primarily I'm trying to convey that, since Levitt used the fact that only 20% of the most vulnerable people tested positive on a cruise ship as central to his thesis, there being a ship where 50% of fit and healthy younger people tested positive does not support that view. An argument about how and how many people are asymptomatic might be better, or what is different about the immune response in younger compared to older, because it appears very likely that the majority of people are at least able to contract covid-19.

A rate of 20% in New York is already high really. Not everyone will have come into contact with the virus yet plus social distancing measures have kept the number down. It seems unlikely that the rest of the population is immune.


Edited by BlueJay (22 May 2020 1.23pm)

 

BlueJay Flag UK 22 May 20 12.54pm

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

Can you really see that happening as you only have to look at the photographs of people crowding on to the beaches yesterday to see that far too many couldn't care less

I must admit I was taken aback by those beach scene in Southend. But then again at many other beaches and parks people were far more sensible. Broadly I would wager that people act in line with perceived risk. That's good in one way, but there is of course a big lag from infection to hospital admission to death, and so people won't really be able to appropriately judge risk levels anyway. Anything we see is always about 15-20 days behind the reality. If I was 70 plus I'd definitely keep a low profile in the coming months.


 

BlueJay Flag UK 22 May 20 12.58pm

Originally posted by cryrst

This test with a 20 minute result if it works will be very useful. If it's a goer then it really will depend on our ability to take one for the team if results on ourselves come back positive. Maybe a certain legality on either isolation and/ or reporting a positive test needs adding.

Yes this would be a real game changer. Tragically too late to unwind what has happened in almost 50% of care homes, but likely a god send for the rest of them, and for hospitals and other at risk environments. Then hopefully available for the rest of us. A really positive development.

We're in a needs must situation so I'm hopeful that we'll see other advances like improved treatments over the coming months. Too late for many unfortunately and for part of the economic hit, but welcome all the same.


Edited by BlueJay (22 May 2020 1.19pm)

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 22 May 20 1.59pm

Originally posted by BlueJay

I must admit I was taken aback by those beach scene in Southend. But then again at many other beaches and parks people were far more sensible. Broadly I would wager that people act in line with perceived risk. That's good in one way, but there is of course a big lag from infection to hospital admission to death, and so people won't really be able to appropriately judge risk levels anyway. Anything we see is always about 15-20 days behind the reality. If I was 70 plus I'd definitely keep a low profile in the coming months.


So would I keep a low profile, for a while.

More was made of those beach photos in Southend and Bournemouth. Taken at a higher angle they weren’t close to each other. And for a week the reported new cases have been extremely low. There is of course the argument that more people will then come, but those beaches are very long and I doubt anyone has seen a crowded English beach resort where you can’t avoid people for decades.

Unfortunately the vulnerable can’t enjoy any of this if they want to minimise their risk but that’s how it is. Some will argue that people should stay in so it’ll be safe for the vulnerable sooner. But that has flaws. It’ll mean no immunity built up in the community and it isn’t just about lefties pointing the finger at people sunbathing unnecessarily. There’s businesses that rely on seasonal trade, if they can adapt to no seating or sitting indoors.

 


COYP

croydon proud Flag Any european country i fancy! 22 May 20 2.03pm

Originally posted by SavoyTruffle

Is anyone even surprised at this point?

[Link]

Unfortunately the answer is no, nothing suprises me with the CONS, but i heard this a few weeks ago, so suprised anyone believed the numbers since!

 

BlueJay Flag UK 22 May 20 2.43pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

So would I keep a low profile, for a while.

More was made of those beach photos in Southend and Bournemouth. Taken at a higher angle they weren’t close to each other. And for a week the reported new cases have been extremely low. There is of course the argument that more people will then come, but those beaches are very long and I doubt anyone has seen a crowded English beach resort where you can’t avoid people for decades.

Unfortunately the vulnerable can’t enjoy any of this if they want to minimise their risk but that’s how it is. Some will argue that people should stay in so it’ll be safe for the vulnerable sooner. But that has flaws. It’ll mean no immunity built up in the community and it isn’t just about lefties pointing the finger at people sunbathing unnecessarily. There’s businesses that rely on seasonal trade, if they can adapt to no seating or sitting indoors.

Yes, to an extent it is what it is. For the sake of both health and the economy, it's a good thing that those in the most vulnerable groups are most often not economically active. That at least provides an option to many of the most vulnerable that most others do not have.

I appreciate the sentiment behind the government's we're all in this together message, but it obscures the reality that people should make decisions for themselves that are relative to their risk. Not doing so creates as many, if not more, problems than it solves.


 

BlueJay Flag UK 22 May 20 7.14pm

Stanford study says 42% of US job losses will result in permanent job loss.

Only some of roughly 36 million jobs lost since the beginning of the lockdowns designed to protect hospitals from surging cases of COVID-19 patients are not coming back in a V-shaped or a U-shaped recover. The University of Chicago estimates that 42% of the recent layoffs will result in permanent job losses.

“We find three new hires for every 10 layoffs caused by the shock and estimate that 42% of recent layoffs will result in permanent job loss,” writes Jose Maria Barrero, Nick Bloom and Steven Davis from the Becker Friedman Institute at the University of Chicago in a working paper titled “COVID-19 As A Reallocation Shock” published on May 5 [Link]

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 22 May 20 7.56pm

It’ll be worse in America, just like the ‘credit crunch’ and people living in caravans. The U.K. will be like the early ‘80s again, only the music will be shyte and the emptying football grounds will be all seated.

Quite sobering that things can get so sh1t unexpectedly. Be grateful your own life is good and it hasn’t been ruined by the fvckers unwilling to step out out of this earlier because it’ll look like they’ve made an error or two. The error I’m thinking of is the extended furlough to end of October with some tapering in July and August.

 


COYP

Teddy Eagle Flag 23 May 20 12.29am

[Link]

Dominic Cummings in trouble.

 

DanH Flag SW2 23 May 20 12.48am

Should have to resign. Especially after Neil Ferguson. But he won’t. And people won’t really care. Nothing sticks to this lot somehow, it’s like people take them being despicable w*nkers as part of the parcel.

 

Page 240 of 753 < 236 237 238 239 240 241 242 243 244 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Topic