This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by The Dolphin
Talk means nothing. That's because Starmer has completely cast out the left of the party - deselected popular candidates, rolled back popular policies and completely distanced himself from any sort of Corbyn legacy, as he sees this as important to winning an election. Labour are nothing close to a left-wing party in their current form - Starmer's speech today is unveiling a 'Take Back Control' bill for goodness sake.
|
|
|
Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow
That's because Starmer has completely cast out the left of the party - deselected popular candidates, rolled back popular policies and completely distanced himself from any sort of Corbyn legacy, as he sees this as important to winning an election. Labour are nothing close to a left-wing party in their current form - Starmer's speech today is unveiling a 'Take Back Control' bill for goodness sake. You say all that as if it is a bad thing.
|
|
|
Originally posted by georgenorman
You say all that as if it is a bad thing. Of course it is - a democratic process where we pick between two different shades of the same s*** is not good for anyone.
|
|
| MrWhyNot |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by HKOwen
Sunak's five pledges make it clear he is prepared to be gloves off against Starmer in platitudes Looking at the pledges, many of these are things that are naturally going to happen worldwide next year anyway such an inflation dropping, the economy growing following basically a couple of terrible years. So it's quite clever to say judge me of these. To my mind the pleges he could truly change minds with are falling waiting list, and cutting illegal immigration. The fallout from covid definitely massively ramped up the former and again 2024 looks like the year where that may start to fall so that could be to his advantage if an election is called then. Sunak should take a realistic look at nurses pay, as if anyone is going to get a halfway fair wage in life it should be those tasked with keeping us healthy during a health crisis. The illegals point could be a vote winner if Sunak finds an answer, I don't have a scooby what that could be though. Peter Hitchens on QT seemed to think that we ought to take a more serious approach with working with the French as its their beaches where this problem manifests. When push comes to shove it's out of sight out of mind, and if it's made tough enough that these people choose somewhere else it's a win politically. The bigger issues would be why the tories and clearly massively gungho about allowing legal immigration in huge numbers, despite stating otherwise. That's what the numbers reveal, even post Brexit. Granted Labour would be no better, but it's still something that could be easily fixed but is not. Cheap labour and all that. A fixed, fair and low annual number would be a workable and fair approach, to both the us and those wanting to make a better life. That won't happen though of course. The tories have felt no threat for a decade plus because 'at least we're not labour'. Beyond a point that does become a rather compelling reason to let them know that they shouldn't take voted for granted.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Badger11
Quite a balanced article from the BBC on NHS funding issues. "Labour - despite previous big increases in funding - were promising less for the health service than the Tories in the 2010 election, while in 2015 there was little between the two parties." Of course what is more important is where do we go from here. The Tories can't even dream of remodelling the NHS because all the usual Lefty morons will accuse them of trying to destroy it. As I have said before. Until the NHS stops being a political football, it is doomed to crumble under the weight of a rapidly increasing, ageing and largely unhealthy population.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
The Tories can't even dream of remodelling the NHS because all the usual Lefty morons will accuse them of trying to destroy it. As I have said before. Until the NHS stops being a political football, it is doomed to crumble under the weight of a rapidly increasing, ageing and largely unhealthy population. That's completely untrue. When an overhaul is so obviously required dreaming of it isn't an option. Action is what is required, and before you can do that you need a clear, unequivocal vision of the future which is underwritten by a commitment accepted by all the major strands of political opinion. Is that too much to expect? Probably, but with the crisis we are witnessing it's the only practical way forward. It also depends on what is meant by "remodelling". So long as the fundamental principle of health care freely available to all at the time of delivery is not undermined I think most other things can be reviewed. Like how it is funded, and what is covered by the meaning of "health care". We need a long term strategy with staged goals because any meaningful changes are going to take a very long time to fully implement and whilst doing so the service needs to be maintained and both us, the users, and the staff need to be fully on board. There look to be some short term fixes which will inevitably have to be applied, but I would like to see them given on the condition that a Royal Commission be established which all the major parties are invited to participate in and commit to respecting the result. Who should chair such a vital Commission, and it's time frame are open questions, but it would be essential that it is not seen anywhere as kicking the can down the road. It would need its findings and recommendations to have teeth which could not be politically extracted by a future government. That's hard to arrange but short term political expediency at the expense of long term planning is what has got us into the current mess. Edited by Wisbech Eagle (07 Jan 2023 11.06pm)
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
The Tories have had 12 years to repeal section 127 of the Communications Act 2003. Any actual conservative party would have done this with immediate effect of taking the reigns. Instead of overturning Blaire's insidious shifting of the UK towards socially liberal thought and authoritarianism they instead embraced it and became the new Blaire party. Hitchens was right. [Tweet Link]
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
The Tories have had 12 years to repeal section 127 of the Communications Act 2003. Any actual conservative party would have done this with immediate effect of taking the reigns. Instead of overturning Blaire's insidious shifting of the UK towards socially liberal thought and authoritarianism they instead embraced it and became the new Blaire party. Hitchens was right. [Tweet Link]I suspect that is because they are "actual" conservatives and not those that some on the hard right would like them to be. The Tories have always had a noisy minority hard right fringe element, but the bulk are just people who support the standard conservative values of family, self-reliance, fiscal prudence, respect for others and our heritage. Such people gradually move with the times, slowly at first maybe but they get there. So trying to eliminate hate speech is not something they are going to be very interested in overturning. Tidying up any obvious anomalies, maybe, but repeal? Nope. If you want a party to do that it won't be the Tories. Reform might promise it, but delivering it? I wouldn't risk a £1 at 100 to 1! The world has changed. You either come to terms with that fact, or your head is going to get very sore banging on closed doors.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
I suspect that is because they are "actual" conservatives and not those that some on the hard right would like them to be. The Tories have always had a noisy minority hard right fringe element, but the bulk are just people who support the standard conservative values of family, self-reliance, fiscal prudence, respect for others and our heritage. Such people gradually move with the times, slowly at first maybe but they get there. So trying to eliminate hate speech is not something they are going to be very interested in overturning. Tidying up any obvious anomalies, maybe, but repeal? Nope. If you want a party to do that it won't be the Tories. Reform might promise it, but delivering it? I wouldn't risk a £1 at 100 to 1! The world has changed. You either come to terms with that fact, or your head is going to get very sore banging on closed doors. Like you with Brexit? Like you when Trump was in power? So sorry but I'll respect opinions from people who live their principles not people only interested in winning like you. Like you I have the right to both say what I believe and campaign for it. Both Brexit and Trump were evidence that your myth making that the world has changed are nothing but gaslighting. All that has changed is what the bulk of elite money is funding and what they want for the future. Currently if I vote I'll vote Reform. Something you'd love because the split in the right is precisely what you want. As for what you say conservative values are, well yes I'd agree with that....though tellingly you miss out freedom of speech. However, what you describe is the cornerstone of social conservativism not social liberalism and social liberalism has brought us precisely the opposite of those values and all the social metrics are evidence of it. You believe and advocate for precisely what destroys those values. Edited by Stirlingsays (07 Jan 2023 11.45pm)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
| MrWhyNot |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
I suspect that is because they are "actual" conservatives and not those that some on the hard right would like them to be. The Tories have always had a noisy minority hard right fringe element, but the bulk are just people who support the standard conservative values of family, self-reliance, fiscal prudence, respect for others and our heritage. Such people gradually move with the times, slowly at first maybe but they get there. So trying to eliminate hate speech is not something they are going to be very interested in overturning. Tidying up any obvious anomalies, maybe, but repeal? Nope. If you want a party to do that it won't be the Tories. Reform might promise it, but delivering it? I wouldn't risk a £1 at 100 to 1! The world has changed. You either come to terms with that fact, or your head is going to get very sore banging on closed doors. Governments left and right both gradually strip rights away from the population through policy, because their main priority is always flexing their own power and shutting people down when they become 'a problem'. Sometimes that is due to people being an actual problem, other times a percieved one. Governments haven't been about elevating Joe Public for many decades. What makes this approach work is that the population is generally - and intentionally - split down the middle politically and so all policies of one restrictive shade or another go through as each perceived 'side' views it as thumbing the eye of their imagined opponents - with a blind spot or zero concern to those on the receiving end. Whether it's done out under a puritanical guise, a 'hate legislation lens, a terror stance, look around the world and it takes all of five seconds to realise that regardless of political persuasion it's different flavours of the exact same thing. Consequently a vote to 'fix' things in the other direction, typically just bulks up another aspect of the same apparatus. This is a general point, not aimed at your politics specifically, and yes it certainly means that hate laws are very unlikely beyond lip service, to ever get rowed back. In the case of the featured police letter, often laws are used as a shot across the bow to those realistically looking to get arrested. This Goddard figure has previously been convicted of assault, physically confronted and harrassed a politician, attempted to force another, Corbyn, out of his car to confront him - on both occasions in a rage calling them traitors. We live in an age where someone physically confronting a politician as a traitor while in a rage immediately went on to stab her to death. And let's not forget the David Amess religious radical situation. Authorities focus on extreme types confronting and theatening government figures as if someone then goes on to take it a step further, 'who could've seen this coming' rings hollow.. Benefit of the doubt evaporates. He has no zero tolerance for others to the point of actual violence, and physical intimidation of them then complains that his conduct is not tolerated.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
The Tories have had 12 years to repeal section 127 of the Communications Act 2003. Any actual conservative party would have done this with immediate effect of taking the reigns. Instead of overturning Blaire's insidious shifting of the UK towards socially liberal thought and authoritarianism they instead embraced it and became the new Blaire party. Hitchens was right. [Tweet Link]This is yet another example of a broken police service
Responsibility Deficit Disorder is a medical condition. Symptoms include inability to be corrected when wrong, false sense of superiority, desire to share personal info no else cares about, general hubris. It's a medical issue rather than pure arrogance. |
|
|
Originally posted by HKOwen
The current mess in the NHS is IMO caused by changing demographics and cost of treatment, rubbish procurement processes, wasted resources on employing for positions that don't contribute to the medical process, too much management. We don't need a Royal Commission, we need action on easy fixes first. Who would have thought that importing millions of low paid workers who pay little tax (not their fault) and claims lots of benefits would ever have an impact on public services. That plus the aging and unhealthy population is why we are in a mess.
One more point |
|
|
Originally posted by HKOwen
This is yet another example of a broken police service Indeed, unacceptable but enabled via bad law.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
Like you with Brexit? Like you when Trump was in power? So sorry but I'll respect opinions from people who live their principles not people only interested in winning like you. Like you I have the right to both say what I believe and campaign for it. Both Brexit and Trump were evidence that your myth making that the world has changed are nothing but gaslighting. All that has changed is what the bulk of elite money is funding and what they want for the future. Currently if I vote I'll vote Reform. Something you'd love because the split in the right is precisely what you want. As for what you say conservative values are, well yes I'd agree with that....though tellingly you miss out freedom of speech. However, what you describe is the cornerstone of social conservativism not social liberalism and social liberalism has brought us precisely the opposite of those values and all the social metrics are evidence of it. You believe and advocate for precisely what destroys those values. Edited by Stirlingsays (07 Jan 2023 11.45pm) That you would even think of conflating Brexit and Trump with the way the world has changed demonstrates how completely out of touch with reality you are. Brexit is reversible. Trump, who really was only interested in "winning", is a symptom of the malaise in the USA. That you then introduce your standard bogeyman myth of the "elites" torpedoes anything else you try to say. Whilst you are obsessed with such imaginary beings you will always remain in a cul-de-sac. Then you jump onto another obsession. Freedom of speech is not freedom at all unless it exists under the law. What people like you advocate for would result in anarchy, not in a democracy where we all give up a little personal freedom for the common good. You sound like Andrew Torba, who is a first class nutcase if ever there was one,
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
That you would even think of conflating Brexit and Trump with the way the world has changed demonstrates how completely out of touch with reality you are. Brexit is reversible. Trump, who really was only interested in "winning", is a symptom of the malaise in the USA. That you then introduce your standard bogeyman myth of the "elites" torpedoes anything else you try to say. Whilst you are obsessed with such imaginary beings you will always remain in a cul-de-sac. Then you jump onto another obsession. Freedom of speech is not freedom at all unless it exists under the law. What people like you advocate for would result in anarchy, not in a democracy where we all give up a little personal freedom for the common good. You sound like Andrew Torba, who is a first class nutcase if ever there was one, Nothing but the usual opinionated waffle with nothing to back it. You are called out on your blatant hypocrisy. In your previous post stating that people have to accept that society has somehow changed and that it can't revert to their politics when you yourself call for change for politics that you yourself don't like.....it's written claptrap with the self awareness of an NPC. It's the unaware emperor with no clothes, which in your case is embarrassingly apt. Edited by Stirlingsays (08 Jan 2023 11.01am)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.