This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by Nicholas91
You’re flirting with insanity Wisbech. The tweet says things like ‘I f**king hate them’, talking about women, from a bloke wanting to be one. Hates them for being women, nothing else. Does not mention any interaction with them, just about a women who stood him up as he was not a woman despite saying he is and therefore expressing extreme hate towards other women with no valid reasoning. It’s a bit like me wanting to be recognised as a palace player, believing I am or being encouraged to believe I am and then demonstrating extreme hostility when sat next to Wilf, Marc and Joachim somewhere. I can recognise you choose not to believe this, which I too wish not to ‘get into’ but I would suggest that if you push an ideological reality and narrative that does not align with actual reality you can see the hate, as articulated in the tweet, and possible consequences that may arise as a result of this. It must all be very confusing and mind bending to the individual least of all extremely distressing. "Flirting "? That's generous. This is the usual contrarian nonsense peddled by the poster.
Responsibility Deficit Disorder is a medical condition. Symptoms include inability to be corrected when wrong, false sense of superiority, desire to share personal info no else cares about, general hubris. It's a medical issue rather than pure arrogance. |
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
If Goddard is assaulting people then I have no issue, if that's an honest description of what happened. When you talk about 'inciting violence' (if these descriptions are a fair and not biased assessment) I'd also agree, however let's not forget the subjective example I gave in my last post on how these rules seem to be selectively applied. Anyway all 'assault' and 'inciting violence' offences are already covered under separate long existing laws and have never needed the communications act. And let's remind ourselves that was what I was posting on not about a specific person. Sure, we could talk about Goddard's situation specifically as he's quite a public figure when you look into him. However, this wasn't what I was talking about. Edited by Stirlingsays (08 Jan 2023 11.41pm) I had no idea who Goddard was, but I still think it points to a broken police service
Responsibility Deficit Disorder is a medical condition. Symptoms include inability to be corrected when wrong, false sense of superiority, desire to share personal info no else cares about, general hubris. It's a medical issue rather than pure arrogance. |
|
|
Originally posted by Nicholas91
You’re flirting with insanity Wisbech. The tweet says things like ‘I f**king hate them’, talking about women, from a blok e wanting to be one. Hates them for being women, nothing else. Does not mention any interaction with them, just about a women who stood him up as he was not a woman despite saying he is and therefore expressing extreme hate towards other women with no valid reasoning. It’s a bit like me wanting to be recognised as a palace player, believing I am or being encouraged to believe I am and then demonstrating extreme hostility when sat next to Wilf, Marc and Joachim somewhere. I can recognise you choose not to believe this, which I too wish not to ‘get into’ but I would suggest that if you push an ideological reality and narrative that does not align with actual reality you can see the hate, as articulated in the tweet, and possible consequences that may arise as a result of this. It must all be very confusing and mind bending to the individual least of all extremely distressing. . As I said I know we don’t agree on this but when they say they hate them I am pretty sure that’s a cry of frustration and not a statement of fact. They feel they are a woman. What you or I think is an irrelevance. What matters are their feelings. That whole tweet is frustration on fire. What I am suggesting is that we all need to be sensitive to the way others perceive themselves and stop trying to impose our own beliefs on them. We wouldn’t like to be regarded as something we don’t believe we are. Why expect it of others?
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by HKOwen
I had no idea who Goddard was, but I still think it points to a broken police service Indeed, it's about the communications act and not about some activist the left don't like.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
I don’t want to get into another long disagreement with you on this as I recognise we see this situation very differently but could I encourage you to read the tweet again? What is being said is not that they are spending time and money trying to ”be” anything but they are trying to be recognised and accepted as something. They already believe they are that something, even if you and the 3 girls don’t yet agree. If those feelings are sincere then respecting them seems a kindness to me. If you Google this individual you might want to hold back on the respect and kindness.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Nicholas91
You’re flirting with insanity Wisbech. The tweet says things like ‘I f**king hate them’, talking about women, from a bloke wanting to be one. Hates them for being women, nothing else. Does not mention any interaction with them, just about a women who stood him up as he was not a woman despite saying he is and therefore expressing extreme hate towards other women with no valid reasoning. It’s a bit like me wanting to be recognised as a palace player, believing I am or being encouraged to believe I am and then demonstrating extreme hostility when sat next to Wilf, Marc and Joachim somewhere. I can recognise you choose not to believe this, which I too wish not to ‘get into’ but I would suggest that if you push an ideological reality and narrative that does not align with actual reality you can see the hate, as articulated in the tweet, and possible consequences that may arise as a result of this. It must all be very confusing and mind bending to the individual least of all extremely distressing. I had to read that tweet several times before I understood it, very confusing like the tweeter. The comment about hating women is interesting. It may have been Jenni Murray certainly a well know feminist who pointed out that there is a strong whiff of misogyny amongst the Trans community they want to be women but hate women and hate lesbians who wont date Trans women. As for the rest of us normies sigh.
One more point |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
. As I said I know we don’t agree on this but when they say they hate them I am pretty sure that’s a cry of frustration and not a statement of fact. They feel they are a woman. What you or I think is an irrelevance. What matters are their feelings. That whole tweet is frustration on fire. What I am suggesting is that we all need to be sensitive to the way others perceive themselves and stop trying to impose our own beliefs on them. We wouldn’t like to be regarded as something we don’t believe we are. Why expect it of others? You mention the word 'believe' several times and that we 'must be sensitive to the way others perceive themselves'. I do not believe they are women, nor do I believe they are men. I have accepted scientific fact based upon biological metrics about them. I will pass on your sentiments however to the Ballon D'or committee and hopefully they will accelerate my application for attendance and nomination on the basis of, and sensitivity towards, my belief I am the greatest footballer in the world. I can only imagine the anger that might arise from me not being accepted as a result of others not indulging in my fantasy, god forbid I then take action upon this, or action against those who actually are footballers. I may even assault one of them, sexually or otherwise. I believe all people should get behind me and reinforce this imagined 'belief' that I have. I will pass on your HoL details to France Football and perhaps you can back up my case?
Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!! |
|
|
Originally posted by Nicholas91
You mention the word 'believe' several times and that we 'must be sensitive to the way others perceive themselves'. I do not believe they are women, nor do I believe they are men. I have accepted scientific fact based upon biological metrics about them. I will pass on your sentiments however to the Ballon D'or committee and hopefully they will accelerate my application for attendance and nomination on the basis of, and sensitivity towards, my belief I am the greatest footballer in the world. I can only imagine the anger that might arise from me not being accepted as a result of others not indulging in my fantasy, god forbid I then take action upon this, or action against those who actually are footballers. I may even assault one of them, sexually or otherwise. I believe all people should get behind me and reinforce this imagined 'belief' that I have. I will pass on your HoL details to France Football and perhaps you can back up my case? . You identify the gulf in attitude that divides the way the two groups think about this very effectively. Yours is based in simple biology and is constrained by it. The other acknowledges that biology can make mistakes and that there is more to sexuality than just physically. Science backs both view points. The biology is unarguable. The doctors specialising in gender dysphoria are psychologists, which is also a scientifically based discipline. I find just as hard as you to understand this. It is counter intuitive. I have though witnessed it at first hand so know that it’s very real and something that’s not wanted.It just is. Maybe we should leave it there.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
I don’t want to get into another long disagreement with you on this as I recognise we see this situation very differently but could I encourage you to read the tweet again? What is being said is not that they are spending time and money trying to ”be” anything but they are trying to be recognised and accepted as something. They already believe they are that something, even if you and the 3 girls don’t yet agree. If those feelings are sincere then respecting them seems a kindness to me. Where does it say the women ( they are not girls) do not agree? There is no mention of any interaction between the parties, so is this just your take?
|
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
. You identify the gulf in attitude that divides the way the two groups think about this very effectively. Yours is based in simple biology and is constrained by it. The other acknowledges that biology can make mistakes and that there is more to sexuality than just physically. Science backs both view points. The biology is unarguable. The doctors specialising in gender dysphoria are psychologists, which is also a scientifically based discipline. I find just as hard as you to understand this. It is counter intuitive. I have though witnessed it at first hand so know that it’s very real and something that’s not wanted.It just is. Maybe we should leave it there. I think I have failed to really stamp my case on this by too often resorting to facetious remarks/posts. What you have articulated there is fine as far as I am concerned. It's all very grey and very hard to distinctly and categorically pin down. Psychology only ever really exists as a hypothetical science however and is very, very often treated as scientific fact where it can never, 100%, infallibly be. Where my grievance lies is not with the exploration, investigation or, what I would deem to be appropriate, a humanistic approach to 'transgenderism'. My grievance is with the ideological and active promotion of this as some sort or alternative, cultural movement. I think firstly in obfuscates, detracts and seriously harms any scientific investigation but also has very severe consequences for individuals who get drawn into or indoctrinated by this ideological approach. There is a shocking and appalling suicide rate aligned to transgenderism which is falsely attributed to societal rejection of the 'ism' and has seriously ignored the possibility of individuals being led to believe they are 'transgender' when actually their issues, which as stated often lead to suicide, lie elsewhere and go untreated and exacerbated through being hijacked by ideologues or idiots. Transgenderism often suits a narrative for a course of action some individuals are looking to pursue as opposed to being of genuine concern as a stand alone entity to them. Those looking for 'acceptance' I can, even if I don't understand, certainly make room for as a human being. What I reject is having the fabric and laws of society changed and being constantly bombarded with ideological propaganda by a 'movement' which, as far as I am concerned, is seeking to achieve that which lies separately to it's smokescreen, purported ideals - treating people with dignity and understanding them. The end result of my aforementioned scenario would be an infringement on the likes of freedom of speech, suppression of individual thought and a very severe disturbance in the mindset of some, you know, to the extent they actively and very publicly start expressing their hatred for almost half of peoples due to nothing else than their, 100% scientifically backed, biological categorisation or start killing themselves if not others. This does not bode well at all and given enough momentum could result in severe consequences for human beings en masse if we are not seeing it in small scale or individual instances already.
Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!! |
|
|
Originally posted by Nicholas91
Where my grievance lies is not with the exploration, investigation or, what I would deem to be appropriate, a humanistic approach to 'transgenderism'. My grievance is with the ideological and active promotion of this as some sort or alternative, cultural movement. I think firstly in obfuscates, detracts and seriously harms any scientific investigation but also has very severe consequences for individuals who get drawn into or indoctrinated by this ideological approach. There is a shocking and appalling suicide rate aligned to transgenderism which is falsely attributed to societal rejection of the 'ism' and has seriously ignored the possibility of individuals being led to believe they are 'transgender' when actually their issues, which as stated often lead to suicide, lie elsewhere and go untreated and exacerbated through being hijacked by ideologues or idiots. Transgenderism often suits a narrative for a course of action some individuals are looking to pursue as opposed to being of genuine concern as a stand alone entity to them.
That's awfully intellectual for a footie forum Don't tell anyone but I didn't understand a word of it
|
|
|
Originally posted by Midlands Eagle
That's awfully intellectual for a footie forum Don't tell anyone but I didn't understand a word of it Midlands your troubles lie far deeper I am afraid if you are referring to anything I post as 'intellectual' Just call it 'rambling' and we can all breathe a little easier until we go back to Palace Talk and face that reality!
Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!! |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
. You identify the gulf in attitude that divides the way the two groups think about this very effectively. Yours is based in simple biology and is constrained by it. The other acknowledges that biology can make mistakes and that there is more to sexuality than just physically. Science backs both view points. The biology is unarguable. The doctors specialising in gender dysphoria are psychologists, which is also a scientifically based discipline. I find just as hard as you to understand this. It is counter intuitive. I have though witnessed it at first hand so know that it’s very real and something that’s not wanted.It just is. Maybe we should leave it there. There isn't one form of man, just as there isn't one form of woman. It's commentary like yours which refuses to recognise mental illness and gender dysphoria. It is not a kindness.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Nicholas91
Midlands your troubles lie far deeper I am afraid if you are referring to anything I post as 'intellectual' Just call it 'rambling' and we can all breathe a little easier until we go back to Palace Talk and face that reality! I think you pretty much nailed it.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Midlands Eagle
That's awfully intellectual for a footie forum Don't tell anyone but I didn't understand a word of it Wouldn’t you be suicidal if someone cut your nuts off !
|
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
There isn't one form of man, just as there isn't one form of woman. It's commentary like yours which refuses to recognise mental illness and gender dysphoria. It is not a kindness. I suppose that could be regarded as progress! When you have spent as much time in SE Asia as I have you will understand just what that really means. There are people there who are .. stunningly beautiful ladies in every way except one tiny detail. They would turn the head’s of most men, are shapely, well dressed and sexy. They just happen to pee like you and I do. These people are completely accepted in their society and don’t face the same level of rejection their equivalents do here. Most times you simply wouldn’t know unless you got yourself into an intimate situation. No doubt some have developed their appearance with hormones, which I don’t believe is done here so easily as it is there. These aren’t gay or mentally ill men. They are women who have been born with part of their body out of tune with their sexuality. All the time people like you remain determined to impose your ignorance on others, our society’s progress is hampered.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
| MrWhyNot |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Nicholas91
There is a shocking and appalling suicide rate aligned to transgenderism which is falsely attributed to societal rejection of the 'ism' and has seriously ignored the possibility of individuals being led to believe they are 'transgender' when actually their issues, which as stated often lead to suicide, lie elsewhere and go untreated and exacerbated through being hijacked by ideologues or idiots. Transgenderism often suits a narrative for a course of action some individuals are looking to pursue as opposed to being of genuine concern as a stand alone entity to them. Those looking for 'acceptance' I can, even if I don't understand, certainly make room for as a human being. What I reject is having the fabric and laws of society changed and being constantly bombarded with ideological propaganda by a 'movement' which, as far as I am concerned, is seeking to achieve that which lies separately to it's smokescreen, purported ideals - treating people with dignity and understanding them.
I'd say that societal reaction to trans people certainly rationally has always played into their mental health issues in a significant way. That is certainly not to say that everyone with gender issues should seek to physically alter themselves, though for some it is possibly the closest they're going to get to an answer. It's one of those issues that has become so hyper politicised in all directions, that if someone feels this way, at this point in time I can barely blame them for offing themselves due to others input or their own turmoil. There are genuinely people who are 'never' going to feel comfortable in their own body 'as is' regardless of any therapy. There's a F2M person in my extended family, who would be a good example of this. His life was hell prior and now he's well adjusted, but does not discuss this issue with most (on account that most do not know and specifically because their judgement of him would likely be damaging or surplus to requirement). I do see though that there are those who trivialise or jump on board with a kind of 'today I'm she/them/this/that' passing trend. As such laws to allow people to make quick decisions without scrutiny at a young age are bad in my view. It all gets thrown into the same pile and only the out there or politicised voices are heard, rather than personal stories that explain an individuals outlook and life. It all falls to a backdrop of serious and understandable concerns that womens spaces being treated as something anyone can dip into when they want regardless of motivation or medical history. A perfect storm really. As with most things in life, some thown in one angled views on a football forum, be it mine or others, may not be much of a fair, full, or reasoned answer to anything and it's always very easy to reduce the complexities of others challenges and experiences when they are not our own. Edited by MrWhyNot (09 Jan 2023 7.06pm)
|
|
|
Originally posted by MrWhyNot
I'd say that societal reaction to trans people certainly rationally has always played into their mental health issues in a significant way. That is certainly not to say that everyone with gender issues should seek to physically alter themselves though, though for some it is possibly the closest they're going to get to an answer. It's one of those issues that has become so hyper politicised in all directions, that if someone feels this way, at this point in time I can barely blame them for offering themselves due to others input. There are genuinely people who are 'never' going to feel comfortable in their own body 'as is' regardless of any therapy. There's a F2M person in my extended family, who would be a good example of this. His life was hell prior and now he's well adjusted, but does not discuss this issue with most (on account that most do not know and specifically because their judgement of him would likely be damaging or surplus to requirement). I also think though there are people who trivialise or jump on board with a kind of 'today I'm she/them/this/that' passing trend. As such laws to allow people to make quick decisions without scrutiny at a young age are bad in my view. It all gets thrown into the same pile and only the out there or politicised voices are heard, rather than personal stories that explain a persons oulook and life. It all falls to a backdrop of serious and understandable concerns that womens spaces being treated as something anyone can dip into when they want regardless of motivation of medical history. A perfect storm really. As with most things in life, some thown in one angled views on a football forum, be it mine or others, may not be much of a fair full, or reasoned answer to anything and it's always very easy to reduce the complexities of others challenges and experiences when they are not our own.
For clarity, that may be poor articulation on my behalf MWN and telling of my capacity to communicate succinctly on a football fans forum, or not in the majority of cases - a delusion I do not labour under. I mark you absolutely right as what I was criticising was indeed the hyper-politicisation, hijacking of, and absolutist approach to 'transgenderism'. There was a very good and insightful post a while ago (cannot remember whom) alluding to a situation of a colleague and very similar to the one you have described. I do not think it possible to absolutely dismiss an individual's claims of being 'transgender'. That we will never know at best but also I would be inclined to believe that there is significant evidence to at least constitute some validity. That would rule out an absolute dismissal of a 'psychological phenomena', if you will, however my opposition is directed primarily towards those who flirt or interfere with this assessment, angling from the other extreme of the spectrum. This is something I believe we are seeing play out in political society and I fear will be of detriment to us all, including those who may have a very genuine basis for finding solace in identifying as Transgender. It is, from my perspective (which I recognise is not an authority by any stretch of the imagination) being reduced to a political or cultural movement as opposed to anything remotely promoted with the interest of individuals at heart. This is seeing common sense fly out of the window, again, just IMO and I fear is on a downwards trajectory in terms of societal impact.
Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!! |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.