This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
| MrWhyNot |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Nicholas91
For clarity, that may be poor articulation on my behalf MWN and telling of my capacity to communicate succinctly on a football fans forum, or not in the majority of cases - a delusion I do not labour under. I mark you absolutely right as what I was criticising was indeed the hyper-politicisation, hijacking of, and absolutist approach to 'transgenderism'. There was a very good and insightful post a while ago (cannot remember whom) alluding to a situation of a colleague and very similar to the one you have described. I do not think it possible to absolutely dismiss an individual's claims of being 'transgender'. That we will never know at best but also I would be inclined to believe that there is significant evidence to at least constitute some validity. That would rule out an absolute dismissal of a 'psychological phenomena', if you will, however my opposition is directed primarily towards those who flirt or interfere with this assessment, angling from the other extreme of the spectrum. This is something I believe we are seeing play out in political society and I fear will be of detriment to us all, including those who may have a very genuine basis for finding solace in identifying as Transgender. It is, from my perspective (which I recognise is not an authority by any stretch of the imagination) being reduced to a political or cultural movement as opposed to anything remotely promoted with the interest of individuals at heart. This is seeing common sense fly out of the window, again, just IMO and I fear is on a downwards trajectory in terms of societal impact. Certainly, I do see changes such as fast tracking young people being able to make significant irreversible decisions at a young age (which logically if they are able to do quickly and without therapy has a greater chance of regret) as negative and political. Pushing through such changes without listening to all pertinent voices on the matter raises the temperature rather than makes the issue go away. The complete lack of compromise on issues contorts them to a point where balance is drowned out and appropriate steps bypassed. From there, those who would seek to live the quiet life then also have the spotlight placed upon their ever move against their will due to activist types, when this is likely the last thing many of them would've wanted either. Edited by MrWhyNot (09 Jan 2023 7.32pm)
|
|
|
Originally posted by MrWhyNot
Certainly, I do see changes such as fast tracking young people being able to make significant irreversible decisions at a young age (which logically if they are able to do quickly and without therapy has a greater chance of regret) as negative and political. Pushing through such changes without listening to all pertinent voices on the matter raises the temperature rather than makes the issue go away. The complete lack of compromise on issues contorts them to a point where balance is drowned out and appropriate steps bypassed. From there, those who would seek to live the quiet life then also have the spotlight placed upon their ever move against their will due to activist types, when this is likely the last thing many of them would've wanted either. Edited by MrWhyNot (09 Jan 2023 7.32pm) It is so frustrating that every thread on this site is completely full of opinion, yet devoid of data or actual case studies. Gender-based victimization, discrimination, bullying, violence, being rejected by the family, friends, and community; harassment by intimate partner, family members, police and public; discrimination and ill treatment at health-care system are the major risk factors that influence the suicidal behavior among transgender persons. Respondents who experienced discrimination or were a victim of violence were more likely to report suicide thoughts and attempts. Respondents who experienced family rejection were also more likely to report attempting suicide. Access to gender-affirming medical care is associated with a lower prevalence of suicide thoughts and attempts. Suicidality is associated with desiring gender affirming surgery in the future, gender based victimisation and institutionalised cissexism. Interventions to increase social inclusion, reduce transphobia and enable access to gender affirming care, particularly surgical interventions, are potential areas of intervention.
|
|
|
Originally posted by MrWhyNot
Certainly, I do see changes such as fast tracking young people being able to make significant irreversible decisions at a young age (which logically if they are able to do quickly and without therapy has a greater chance of regret) as negative and political. Pushing through such changes without listening to all pertinent voices on the matter raises the temperature rather than makes the issue go away. The complete lack of compromise on issues contorts them to a point where balance is drowned out and appropriate steps bypassed. From there, those who would seek to live the quiet life then also have the spotlight placed upon their ever move against their will due to activist types, when this is likely the last thing many of them would've wanted either. Edited by MrWhyNot (09 Jan 2023 7.32pm) I’m not going to bother adding to that but will state I fully agree. If you ever fancy some ‘care in the community’ work I’ll write to my local council for funding so you can convert my grunts and communications through a glottal stop into posts for me MYN!
Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!! |
|
|
Originally posted by Mapletree
It is so frustrating that every thread on this site is completely full of opinion, yet devoid of data or actual case studies. Gender-based victimization, discrimination, bullying, violence, being rejected by the family, friends, and community; harassment by intimate partner, family members, police and public; discrimination and ill treatment at health-care system are the major risk factors that influence the suicidal behavior among transgender persons. Respondents who experienced discrimination or were a victim of violence were more likely to report suicide thoughts and attempts. Respondents who experienced family rejection were also more likely to report attempting suicide. Access to gender-affirming medical care is associated with a lower prevalence of suicide thoughts and attempts. Suicidality is associated with desiring gender affirming surgery in the future, gender based victimisation and institutionalised cissexism. Interventions to increase social inclusion, reduce transphobia and enable access to gender affirming care, particularly surgical interventions, are potential areas of intervention. It’s an internet forum Maple that’s sort of the point. As for your sources, as with anything loosely within this field, it’s easy to poke holes in , scrutinise, cast doubt over etc. which it is too late in the evening for me to do even if I wanted to. It is also possible to site sources for just about any opinion these days, as it has been, where possible, throughout history. Doesn’t nullify any discussion, opinion of individuals on such things or categorically prove anything however. You know what, F-it I actually did! Any comment on this? There’s a lot of criticism of this group and a number of notable academics have endorsed, and in some cases been coerced into apologising, for supporting what seems like ‘the other end of the spectrum’. This group is supposedly comprised of academics, amongst others, however I am sceptical yet unaware of the truth in this. But whom to believe? Perhaps we could suggest that there is occasionally bias in academic research and no actual objectivity leading to an absolute, flawless conclusion of everything? Who’d of thought?
Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!! |
|
|
Originally posted by Mapletree
It is so frustrating that every thread on this site is completely full of opinion, yet devoid of data or actual case studies. Gender-based victimization, discrimination, bullying, violence, being rejected by the family, friends, and community; harassment by intimate partner, family members, police and public; discrimination and ill treatment at health-care system are the major risk factors that influence the suicidal behavior among transgender persons. Respondents who experienced discrimination or were a victim of violence were more likely to report suicide thoughts and attempts. Respondents who experienced family rejection were also more likely to report attempting suicide. Access to gender-affirming medical care is associated with a lower prevalence of suicide thoughts and attempts. Suicidality is associated with desiring gender affirming surgery in the future, gender based victimisation and institutionalised cissexism. Interventions to increase social inclusion, reduce transphobia and enable access to gender affirming care, particularly surgical interventions, are potential areas of intervention. So basically it’s everyone else’s fault when a trans swings !
|
|
| MrWhyNot |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Nicholas91
‘No child is born in the wrong body’ I must say I tend to agree. I think the question should more be, with some people is their view that they are in the wrong body, one that demonstrably is shown to be consistent and very unlikely to change over time. And where that is the case, and a physical intervention is made, is the outcome post that more often a positive one. Clouded in politics now, I'd say that the answer tends to be that it should be an option and that viewing it as universally wrong or negative isn't helpful or accurate. I don't though view the more modern 'respect my pronouns' activist take of these issues as at all helpful as it blurs more lines, and creates a more ephemeral idea of 'gender is nothing, i can look male but say i'm female'. It's more like tourism than a lived reality and creates concerns with womens spaces and the like.
|
|
| MrWhyNot |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Mapletree
It is so frustrating that every thread on this site is completely full of opinion, yet devoid of data or actual case studies. Gender-based victimization, discrimination, bullying, violence, being rejected by the family, friends, and community; harassment by intimate partner, family members, police and public; discrimination and ill treatment at health-care system are the major risk factors that influence the suicidal behavior among transgender persons. Respondents who experienced discrimination or were a victim of violence were more likely to report suicide thoughts and attempts. Respondents who experienced family rejection were also more likely to report attempting suicide. Access to gender-affirming medical care is associated with a lower prevalence of suicide thoughts and attempts. Suicidality is associated with desiring gender affirming surgery in the future, gender based victimisation and institutionalised cissexism. Interventions to increase social inclusion, reduce transphobia and enable access to gender affirming care, particularly surgical interventions, are potential areas of intervention. That post is a snapshot of a perspective that says that rushing into something with fewer checks and balances is not always a universally good thing as there will always be pros and cons to that. Point being, where something becomes a political football it's not solely about the welfare of the individual anymore, or doing the right thing. It's subjective and we could look back on it differently in future. If you look to my first post on this page, you'll see that I acknowledge that social attitudes towards trans people very likely significantly play into how they feel about themselves. Considering perception of them it would be strange if not. This can then be used to further marginalise. I pointed to a family member who is certainly happier now. People on a genuinely tough journey doing their best deserve respect and support where their view of themselves is consistent and unchanged over time, not belittlement of their state of being. I was attemmpting to draw a distinction between said journey and a more modern interpretation of a pro noun centric gender view that if anything muddies the water of understanding and turns someone elses journey into their own pitstop. I don't see support of those who need it, vs a 'what does it all mean anyway' type default as the same thing. People have busy and full lives to lead. On a practical level it is easier to understand and empathise with those who demonstrate that their idea of themselves simply isn't going to change over time and they need help with better aligning it with the visual, than the more modern, fluid pronoun centric take where the physical doesn't even have to align with the pronouns in any way (as in not body dysmorphic), undermining the aforementioned struggles in a sense. Culturally it would be better for those people to just say that they feel especially masculine or feminine, because well.. they do. Things can only get so complex and personalised before others opt out mentally and we do not always give weight to the right stories. This is a football forum, it's often more wrecking balls from people who don't give a toss, or a need to be the loudest voice. Sometimes a pertinent point here or there that strikes a balance can make more of a positive impact going forward than people feeling that they are being asked to reconfigure their whole view of life. Edited by MrWhyNot (10 Jan 2023 6.38am)
|
|
|
Why has this thread turned into a trans-nonsense thread?
|
|
|
Originally posted by georgenorman
Why has this thread turned into a trans-nonsense thread? Instead of general nonsense you mean
|
|
|
Originally posted by MrWhyNot
I think the question should more be, with some people is their view that they are in the wrong body, one that demonstrably is shown to be consistent and very unlikely to change over time. And where that is the case, and a physical intervention is made, is the outcome post that more often a positive one. Clouded in politics now, I'd say that the answer tends to be that it should be an option and that viewing it as universally wrong or negative isn't helpful or accurate. I don't though view the more modern 'respect my pronouns' activist take of these issues as at all helpful as it blurs more lines, and creates a more ephemeral idea of 'gender is nothing, i can look male but say i'm female'. It's more like tourism than a lived reality and creates concerns with womens spaces and the like. I agree again MYN. I did try to infer that through the usage of the word 'tend' but perhaps not strong enough. Again, it's more opposition to one extreme than the endorsement of another.
Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!! |
|
|
Originally posted by georgenorman
Why has this thread turned into a trans-nonsense thread? I believe I have contributed significantly to this GN so apologise and take whatever share of responsibility is deemed necessary. You appear to be in a very general consensus, spearheaded by my wife, in suggesting I bear responsibility for discussion based around 'nonsense'.
Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!! |
|
|
Originally posted by Nicholas91
I believe I have contributed significantly to this GN so apologise and take whatever share of responsibility is deemed necessary. You appear to be in a very general consensus, spearheaded by my wife, in suggesting I bear responsibility for discussion based around 'nonsense'. Your self-awareness does you credit.
|
|
| MrWhyNot |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Midlands Eagle
Instead of general nonsense you mean About covers it
|
|
|
Originally posted by georgenorman
Your self-awareness does you credit.
Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!! |
|
| MrWhyNot |
|
|---|---|
|
Anti-strikes bill to be introduced to Parliament - In favour or not?
|
|
|
Originally posted by MrWhyNot
Anti-strikes bill to be introduced to Parliament - In favour or not? No. Workers rights should be protected.
|
|
|
Originally posted by MrWhyNot
Anti-strikes bill to be introduced to Parliament - In favour or not? It's not an anti strikes bill per se but it is supposed to be a requirement that certain public services maintain a minimum service level during strikes which is something that I agree with.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Teddy Eagle
No. Workers rights should be protected. So should the general public's.
|
|
|
Originally posted by georgenorman
So should the general public's. I must admit I think that when the trains aren't running or anything else inconveniences me personally but as a general principle strikes should be allowed.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Teddy Eagle
I must admit I think that when the trains aren't running or anything else inconveniences me personally but as a general principle strikes should be allowed. Yes I agree, but employers should also have the right to sack striking employees.
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.