This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by georgenorman
If you don't think a UK government's laws improve your lot , then you can vote for another potential government. When in the EU, if you didn't think their laws improved your lot, you could do nothing about it. Also, it is of course nonsense to say that US and EU law governs us as much as UK laws. But which actual laws have come in now that are different from EU laws and improve our lot?
|
|
|
Originally posted by georgenorman
If you don't think a UK government's laws improve your lot , then you can vote for another potential government. When in the EU, if you didn't think their laws improved your lot, you could do nothing about it. Also, it is of course nonsense to say that US and EU law governs us as much as UK laws. I didn’t say as much as uk laws. I said they are still just as influential on us as they were before we ‘took back control’.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Mapletree
I didn’t say as much as uk laws. I said they are still just as influential on us as they were before we ‘took back control’. Thank you for the clarification. However, it is clearly not true that EU laws 'govern us just as much now' as when we were in the EU.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Mapletree
But which actual laws have come in now that are different from EU laws and improve our lot? European Union (Withdrawal) Act 2018.
|
|
|
Originally posted by georgenorman
European Union (Withdrawal) Act 2018. Thank you, you make my point perfectly We had the ability from 2018 to prepare our own laws. Since then, nada, zilch, beggar all. A fantastic Brexit benefit don't you think. Leaving the EU was not a benefit in and of itself, you then had to make some hay, or at least prepare to make hay or - well - do anything. Not only are we struggling to make hay, you just try importing any.
|
|
|
Well, we were all told to strap our seatbelts on this year as we are in for a bumpy ride Except our great leader kind of forgot...
|
|
|
Originally posted by Mapletree
Thank you, you make my point perfectly We had the ability from 2018 to prepare our own laws. Since then, nada, zilch, beggar all. A fantastic Brexit benefit don't you think. Leaving the EU was not a benefit in and of itself, you then had to make some hay, or at least prepare to make hay or - well - do anything. Not only are we struggling to make hay, you just try importing any. Do I? You asked for a law that has come in that is different from EU law and improved our lot. I gave you an example, another is Sanctions and Anti-Money Laundering Act 2018
|
|
|
Originally posted by steeleye20
The world is giving up on Britain, warns CBI chief Global investors are shunning Britain because the Government has no coherent economic plan and is failing to keep up with volcanic policy changes in the US and Europe, the head of British industry has warned. What actual strategy does the UK have for brexit recovery, economic growth and investment. Its just a vacuum of 'things will get better maybe'.
Still you can join CP in any EU Country you desire, they are obviously a better option, as you do nothing but “slag off” the UK
|
|
|
Originally posted by Spiderman
Still you can join CP in any EU Country you desire, they are obviously a better option, as you do nothing but “slag off” the UK self-censored Edited by georgenorman (19 Jan 2023 7.34pm)
|
|
|
Originally posted by georgenorman
Do I? You asked for a law that has come in that is different from EU law and improved our lot. I gave you an example, another is Sanctions and Anti-Money Laundering Act 2018 Clearly it has not (yet???) improved our lot. It was simply an enabling law. If Sanctions and Anti-Money Laundering Act is the best you can do, you may want to take note that we didn't actually leave the EU until 11pm GMT 31 January 2020. So that Act was passed when we were still in the EU and certainly wasn't a Brexit benefit. It was actually passed to allow us to do what we already were able to do when in the EU, apply sanctions once we had left. It was only an enabling Act, again it had no content per se but was passed so that we could then pass further laws. The most amusing thing is that the UK transposed the 5th Anti-Money Laundering Directive into UK law and the government has not announced any proposals to deviate from those requirements. All it really did was change the definition of a “third country” to a country outside the UK, as opposed to outside the European Economic Area (EEA).
|
|
|
Originally posted by Mapletree
Clearly it has not (yet???) improved our lot. It was simply an enabling law. If Sanctions and Anti-Money Laundering Act is the best you can do, you may want to take note that we didn't actually leave the EU until 11pm GMT 31 January 2020. So that Act was passed when we were still in the EU and certainly wasn't a Brexit benefit. It was actually passed to allow us to do what we already were able to do when in the EU, apply sanctions once we had left. It was only an enabling Act, again it had no content per se but was passed so that we could then pass further laws. The most amusing thing is that the UK transposed the 5th Anti-Money Laundering Directive into UK law and the government has not announced any proposals to deviate from those requirements. All it really did was change the definition of a “third country” to a country outside the UK, as opposed to outside the European Economic Area (EEA). You have to keep moving the goal posts don't you! Here's one from 2021: Trade Act 2021
|
|
|
Originally posted by georgenorman
You have to keep moving the goal posts don't you! Here's one from 2021: Trade Act 2021 Edited by georgenorman (19 Jan 2023 10.20pm) I have moved no goal posts. It’s just that you are about as accurate as an Andy Gray free kick The Trade Act again is simply an enabler act so we can one day replace our EU trade deals with those massively lucrative deals we were promised. Such a shame about the Liz Truss deals with Australia and New Zealand. This from politico
Data from the U.K.'s trade department — shared with POLITICO and prepared for both deals ahead of the launch of negotiations in 2020 — for the first time details the relative losses and gains expected for each part of the British economy before Truss, then-trade secretary and now running to replace Boris Johnson as U.K. prime minister, forged ahead with pacts that have proven highly controversial with farmers. The disclosure has already sparked anger from the U.K.'s farming lobby, which has long argued the deals — held up as a key prize of Britain's freedom from the European Union — will hit its members hard, while campaigners argue it shows tighter scrutiny of those deals is needed.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Mapletree
I have moved no goal posts. It’s just that you are about as accurate as an Andy Gray free kick The Trade Act again is simply an enabler act so we can one day replace our EU trade deals with those massively lucrative deals we were promised. Such a shame about the Liz Truss deals with Australia and New Zealand. This from politico LONDON — Conservative leadership hopeful Liz Truss was given detailed warnings by her own officials in 2020 that post-Brexit trade pacts with Australia and New Zealand would shrink the country's farming and food sectors, newly obtained government figures reveal. Data from the U.K.'s trade department — shared with POLITICO and prepared for both deals ahead of the launch of negotiations in 2020 — for the first time details the relative losses and gains expected for each part of the British economy before Truss, then-trade secretary and now running to replace Boris Johnson as U.K. prime minister, forged ahead with pacts that have proven highly controversial with farmers. The disclosure has already sparked anger from the U.K.'s farming lobby, which has long argued the deals — held up as a key prize of Britain's freedom from the European Union — will hit its members hard, while campaigners argue it shows tighter scrutiny of those deals is needed. You ask for laws made by us since we left the EU that are of benefit to us. I give you some examples from 2018 and you then you say we didn't technically leave until 2020. I give you an example from 2021 that you then say is merely an 'enabler', but it of course enables us to reap benefits. Another is Elections Act 2022. Edited by georgenorman (20 Jan 2023 8.29am)
|
|
|
Originally posted by georgenorman
You ask for laws made by us since we left the EU that are of benefit to us. I give you some examples from 2018 and you then you say we didn't technically leave until 2020. I give you an example from 2021 that you then say is merely an 'enabler', but it of course enables us to reap benefits. Another is Elections Act 2022. Edited by georgenorman (20 Jan 2023 8.29am) We have reaped no benefits. Only disbenefits. That is the point. I am not particularly party political. Brexit was economically not just foolish but almost suicidal. Populism trumping being the stewards of our children’s future. Since then the government of the day has been hung up on issues internal to itself and done little to mitigate that awful decision. We are not more in charge of our future now, that is dreadfully clear
|
|
|
Originally posted by Mapletree
I am not particularly party political. I don't think that any of the participants at the Mad Hatters Tea Party are. It's just that you all like arguing
|
|
|
Originally posted by Mapletree
We have reaped no benefits. Only disbenefits. That is the point. I am not particularly party political. Brexit was economically not just foolish but almost suicidal. Populism trumping being the stewards of our children’s future. Since then the government of the day has been hung up on issues internal to itself and done little to mitigate that awful decision. We are not more in charge of our future now, that is dreadfully clear You can vote for a different government to make laws that you think will be of benefit, you couldn't do that in the EU.
|
|
|
Originally posted by steeleye20
Fiona Bruce says Tory's NHS stats 'don't look so good' in awkward Question Time moment BBC Question Time presenter Fiona Bruce said a Conservative claim of record spending on the NHS “doesn’t look so good” in an excruciating moment on the show. Even in the financial crisis labour prioritised the NHS. The tories have managed an average annual increase of only 1.6% despite covid and all the increased pressures and costs over the last 10 3years. The old stat line eh. Well stats say 70% odd of Europeans want illegal or uncontrolled immigration to stop. How does that sound as a stat ?
|
|
|
Originally posted by steeleye20
Fiona Bruce says Tory's NHS stats 'don't look so good' in awkward Question Time moment BBC Question Time presenter Fiona Bruce said a Conservative claim of record spending on the NHS “doesn’t look so good” in an excruciating moment on the show. Even in the financial crisis labour prioritised the NHS. The tories have managed an average annual increase of only 1.6% despite covid and all the increased pressures and costs over the last 10 3years. Laughable. You actually believe left wing propaganda? It needs reform, and when anyone from the right ever says that, the dumbasses on the left try to claim that it will be destroyed. Even that waste of skin Starmer is now saying it has to be reformed. If he is as reliable as Labour usually are with their manifesto promises, then I wouldn't hold your breath.
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.