Quote Johnny Eagles at 14 May 2014 2.15pm
To avoid it turning into an absolute waffle-fest, I'll concentrate my reply on just the points above.
I think we actually broadly agree. We differ essentially only on one point. You think it "unlikely that an "external culture" would be able to affect the original culture profoundly". I disagree.
To borrow your melting pot analogy, I see the recent wave of immigration (ie, all the Eastern Europeans) if it continues at a similar pace as much more than a few extra ingredients. I think it will completely change the recipe.
I'm not claiming certainty, but I do think it likely given the scale over the last few years and the changes which have already happened in a relatively short space of time. I've yet to see anything which convinces me otherwise. I think AT BEST the politicians who unleashed this wave of immigration have simply no idea what the long-term effects will be.
I therefore think it likely that the prevailing culture will be radically altered and many things which are "traditionally British" (I know this is an incredibly slippery term to use, but I don't want to get bogged down in long definitions) will disappear or alter beyond recognition.
I think that's fairly speculative and doesn't culture essentially operate on a supply and demand basis? If Morris dancing is part of the traditional culture, it will be maintained only if there's a demand for it.
Likewise if there are elements that disappear, that's not likely to be because the immigrants didn't care about it, more likely that non-immigrants couldn't be bothered to keep it going.
I'd argue that immigration has been going on for decades in the eyes of those alive today and yet there are few examples of culture that has died. Things have been added (curry being the most obvious example) but I don't think many elements of British culture have been mourned.
Quote Johnny Eagles at 14 May 2014 2.15pm
Which isn't to foretell doom, necessarily. He he who rejects change is the architect of decay and all that. And I love a curry as much as the next person. But it will be sad to see some things go. And, most importantly, it's absolutely fair enough for some people to be concerned and even angry about it. It's going to have a massive effect on them and their children and they've not been given any choice in the matter whatsoever.
I don't think politics should be the realm at which the parameters of culture should be defined, I think that culture should be an accidental product of society. If you want something cultural to survive, then promote it, simple as that.
Speaking as a white (notionally) Christian middle class man, many facets of culture simply don't appeal to me, British or otherwise. I find this odd, since I'm kind of the target group for it. But if I don't give a toss about St George's Day or Morris dancing or whatever, I fail to see the harm on an individual level.
If as an individual I ought to be contributing to the common good, I can't say I'm particularly fond of the common good being "culture", since I value far more tangible things like education, healthcare, jobs, housing and so on. If I thought immigration was a threat to these things, it might bother me, but I'm not going to lose any sleep at night over "culture".
"The fox has his den. The bee has his hive. The stoat, has, uh... his stoat-hole... but only man chooses to make his nest in an investment opportunity.” Stewart Lee
|