Quote Catfish at 01 Aug 2015 10.13am
I resent the implication of racism which is lazy and boring. There are examples, for instance an Afghan asylum seeker in the care of Birmingham Council, claiming to be 13 years old, was placed in a care home where he raped a 13-year-old girl. Evidence later suggested he was actually 19. Much of the abuse is organised crime. An agency worker call M. Kaur admitted on line that: “I worked for about a year with a national private fostering organisation specialising in sanctuary seeking children. We were encouraged not to question too much about ages of the Afghani young men and were criticised for our values when stating the obvious. As I spoke the same languages as some of them, many of them informed me that they were married in their countries of origin and were in their 20s! These lads were at school with British young girls aged 14/15 … the agency were charging the Local Authority over a thousand pounds per week for arranging the private foster care and making stacks of money!!!! It was all a scam”. A large proportion of those who are actually children placed into foster care disappear very soon after because they go to join the person who trafficked them. One council care home near Heathrow was noted as becoming a clearing house for such cases in 2009. It is common for children to be used in the vice trade and in cannabis farms. Others are simply used because of the additional benefits that can be squeezed out the system - such as Victoria Climbe. Loosening controls not only creates social division it plays into the hands of organised crime. The trafficking of children for the more mundane purpose of placing them into private foster care so that they get free education is a growth industry with agencies in West Africa making the arrangements and British schools thereby overflowing. Combatting all of this is made more difficult by the role of many in the legal profession who see only a legal aid funded gravy train. (that is not directed at you legal eagle).
The core problem is that none really has a common understanding of what immigration control is for or what it is supposed to achieve. Some people assume it is about population numbers, some that it is about protecting the labour market and others even now just want to "send them back" (meaning any person of colour they don't like). The debate on this thread amply demonstrates that people are driven by prejudice and ideology rather than any practical considerations.
I didn't suggest racism.I did suggest a seeming propensity (based purely on your prior post) to impute a greater likelihood to engage in sexual offences/harassment against girls aged 11-18 in schools by young men/youths because they were economic migrants/refugees as opposed to,say, within the existing UK school population.
Of course you can quote examples,just as I could quote examples of sexual assaults within schools/care homes by non economic migrants/refugees.Where is your evidence that the incidence of offending by male economic migrants/refugees in schools is profoundly different to that within the school population at large?
According to police data obtained under the Freedom of Information Act in 2014,more than 320 alleged rapes were reported in schools during 2011-14, with the NSPCC saying that pupils’ easy access to online p***.graphy had likely driven the surge in online child abuse. In 2011 alone, there were at least 1,052 alleged sex offences reported in schools, of which 134 were reported as rape. More than half of the claimed offences were said to have been committed by children.
Taking the "Victor" example.If someone was 13 when they came, but classified as being 11,they would be at school potentially when aged over 18...
I don't doubt at all there are various organised scams going on including trafficking of children and false ages being given .No system I've ever come across hasn't been being abused in some way and I'm aware of some of the rackets you refer to.But,its a huge leap to suggest such is the norm amongst say people arriving from Calais or that economic migrants/refugees from Calais are inherently significantly more likely to be rapists/people who engage in sexual assaults of young girls.
In relation to the "legal aid" "gravy train",I think you may find modern reality is that legal aid immigration work is far from being a gravy train for the majority and that those doing it (I don't) could earn somewhat more relatively easily doing other legal work.
As for your comments on immigration control,I don't disagree but to think your post was itself entirely devoid of your own prejudices and ideology (increased likelihood of rape etc because someone is a refugee/economic migrant) would IMO be a misnomer.
I am not sure that anything I wrote could be taken as advocating a "loosening" of existing controls.
Edited by legaleagle (01 Aug 2015 11.26am)
|