This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote Kermit8 at 19 Nov 2015 4.44pm
Quote jamiemartin721 at 19 Nov 2015 4.38pm
Quote Kermit8 at 19 Nov 2015 4.16pm
nato ground troops could wipe out the ragtag IS in Northern Syria in weeks and be home by Xmas. There just isn't the will or political opportunity to do it. I doubt it. Somehow I think it would turn out to be more akin to the Soviet Union in Afghanistan or Chechnya, a slogging drawn out guerrilla conflict in which the NATO forces would experience nightmarish logistical problems (given their only 'safe' borders would be through Kurdish occupied territory (via Turkey or through Iraq across what was once the Sunni Triangle). Plus there is the issue of what the other rebel groups and factions would do, and then what to do with the country afterwards (you can't just hand it back to Assad and neither the Kurds or the Rebel factions are going to accept each other being placed in control). Syria is a 'Vietnam' waiting to happen. It took NATO days to occupy Afghanistan and militarily defeat the Taliban, but fifteen years on, they don't seem to have been wiped out, in fact far from it. All of the factions involved are using guerrilla war strategies and have been for several years. Likely as not we'd easily take IS territory, and then they would happily just to just keep up hit and run and ambushes against NATO and US troops and launching strikes against International targets - something I doubt the UK has the political stomach for long term. A lot of people talk up 'sending troops in' but no one I know who has either been in the military or is still in seems to be keen on the idea of getting into the Syrian Civil War.
The Vietnam war terrain was perfectly suited to protection from air observation, but the reality of a Guerrilla army is its capacity to be able to obscure itself from the enemy. The terrain in Iraq didn't prevent a long insurgency with Sunni, and some Shia groups, plus the capacity for reliable human intelligence regarding who is IS will be very limited and unreliable - and many of those involved in IS have over a decade of experience in fighting an insurgency obtained from the Iraqi Sunni Insurgency. They'll fight militarily with forces they won't be able to maintain, and then strike with ambushes and low impact warfare in occupied areas, as well as hitting support and logistical targets. Likely as not they'll also divide into more independent groups, and move their 'command and communications' network out of Syria. Also you'd expect them to target targets across Europe as well as a response (as seen with Paris) and develop logistic support cells across Europe, planning attacks in different countries), notably through support from 'affiliated groups'. Israel has never managed to destroy Hezzbollah. Similar to the Taliban and Al-Qaeda, they won't be destroyed militarily, only their capacity reduced significantly. Groups like this can only be destroyed if you can cut out the funding and support and appeal they hold.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote Lyons550 at 19 Nov 2015 4.55pm
Quote jamiemartin721 at 19 Nov 2015 4.45pm
Quote Lyons550 at 19 Nov 2015 4.33pm
Quote nickgusset at 19 Nov 2015 11.57am
Quote Hrolf The Ganger at 19 Nov 2015 11.45am
Quote nickgusset at 18 Nov 2015 10.32pm
Quote Lyons550 at 17 Nov 2015 8.25am
Quote nickgusset at 16 Nov 2015 9.40pm
.
My point is therethere are plenty of Muslims opposing ISIS, something Lyons seems to say isn't happening. It doesn't suit (in my opinion) newspaper agenda to cover it.
So what about the Muslims in the Shia, and Iraqi forces fighting IS in Iraq, and those Muslims in Syria fighting IS, including the Kurds and the Syrian army - Not to mention people in Turkey, Jordon and Lebannon who are dealing with the humanitarian fall out from IS. Lebannon has around 1m Syrian refuges, a quarter of the population, we're getting s**ty about taking 20k over five years. Then there are those across the middle east who are funding those rebels and Kurds who are fighting against IS. All we're doing is dropping bombs and getting s**ty online. Out in the middle east there are tens of thousands of Muslims actually fighting against IS, putting their lives on the line. Our contribution, 900m in aid, over five years, 20k spaces for refugees, some 'military advisors' and some bombs dropped from 10,000ft on suspected targets and the occasional drone strike. But yeah, Muslims could do more.
The point I was trying to make was more to do with Muslims being more vocal in the media to help the reduce the generalisation that I've been seeing all over said media regarding the muslim population. As I stated earlier..I posted a video of a guy doing just what I was hoping some would do...and I've seen similar instances of others doing so as well. The more the better. I'm well aware of the examples you pompously cite...but you see the point is its not needed for MY benefit...its for the imbeciles that still lump the muslim community into the one generic term. That's all...i'm pleased to see the seeds of a growing trend #notinmyname etc....lets hope we hear and see more doing so. It'd go a long long way to fostering greater understanding and hopefully build new bridges across communities in the process. Which is EXACTLY what ISIS don't want! That is the responsibility of the media to then focus maybe more on those individuals than trotting out the traditional Choudary / Hamza types. The problem is that reasonable friendly Muslims don't 'sell copy' or airtime. The Media is a business, and it sells product to its audience, and packages to that market - Typically that means successes in 'the war on terror' are achievements become 'Western' successes, stripped of the fact that the successes in retaking parts of Iraq belong to Iraqi's (mostly Muslims). Certain popular media isn't in the business of information or news, its in the business of pandering to its market demographics. Fear, Hate and Anger sell far more than compassion, understanding and unity. We can't even objectively look at why these attack occurred in the media (France's bombing of IS for example) or issues that do affect the Muslim population without getting 'knicker wetting'
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote Kermit8 at 19 Nov 2015 5.03pm
The next big genocide could well be visited on the minority Shia muslims the way things are panning out in the Middle East and perhaps North Africa. The IS Sunni lot and their ilk see them in such a way as to make them very vulnerable. Reported genocide, it seems that there has been a significant amount of 'revenge' in Sunni areas of Iraq liberated from IS. Civil war and genocide/mass murder are largely inseparable.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote nickgusset at 19 Nov 2015 4.32pm
Quote Cucking Funt at 19 Nov 2015 4.05pm
If Gusset had been PM in 1940, he wouldn't have declared war on the Germans until they were actually goose-stepping up Whitehall and even then he'd have apologised to them first for getting their feet wet when they landed.
Of course, he'd also have avoided the disaster of Dunkirk and the massive loss of equipment, men and arms of the BEF, which would probably have led to a shortening of the war (both in North Africa and Europe), and possibly have averted the blitz (we left and lost a lot of aircraft in retreat from France).
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote dannyh at 20 Nov 2015 10.39am
Quote Kermit8 at 20 Nov 2015 10.20am
Quote jamiemartin721 at 20 Nov 2015 9.30am
Quote Lyons550 at 19 Nov 2015 4.55pm
Quote jamiemartin721 at 19 Nov 2015 4.45pm
Quote Lyons550 at 19 Nov 2015 4.33pm
Quote nickgusset at 19 Nov 2015 11.57am
Quote Hrolf The Ganger at 19 Nov 2015 11.45am
Quote nickgusset at 18 Nov 2015 10.32pm
Quote Lyons550 at 17 Nov 2015 8.25am
Quote nickgusset at 16 Nov 2015 9.40pm
.
My point is therethere are plenty of Muslims opposing ISIS, something Lyons seems to say isn't happening. It doesn't suit (in my opinion) newspaper agenda to cover it.
So what about the Muslims in the Shia, and Iraqi forces fighting IS in Iraq, and those Muslims in Syria fighting IS, including the Kurds and the Syrian army - Not to mention people in Turkey, Jordon and Lebannon who are dealing with the humanitarian fall out from IS. Lebannon has around 1m Syrian refuges, a quarter of the population, we're getting s**ty about taking 20k over five years. Then there are those across the middle east who are funding those rebels and Kurds who are fighting against IS. All we're doing is dropping bombs and getting s**ty online. Out in the middle east there are tens of thousands of Muslims actually fighting against IS, putting their lives on the line. Our contribution, 900m in aid, over five years, 20k spaces for refugees, some 'military advisors' and some bombs dropped from 10,000ft on suspected targets and the occasional drone strike. But yeah, Muslims could do more.
The point I was trying to make was more to do with Muslims being more vocal in the media to help the reduce the generalisation that I've been seeing all over said media regarding the muslim population. As I stated earlier..I posted a video of a guy doing just what I was hoping some would do...and I've seen similar instances of others doing so as well. The more the better. I'm well aware of the examples you pompously cite...but you see the point is its not needed for MY benefit...its for the imbeciles that still lump the muslim community into the one generic term. That's all...i'm pleased to see the seeds of a growing trend #notinmyname etc....lets hope we hear and see more doing so. It'd go a long long way to fostering greater understanding and hopefully build new bridges across communities in the process. Which is EXACTLY what ISIS don't want! That is the responsibility of the media to then focus maybe more on those individuals than trotting out the traditional Choudary / Hamza types. The problem is that reasonable friendly Muslims don't 'sell copy' or airtime. The Media is a business, and it sells product to its audience, and packages to that market - Typically that means successes in 'the war on terror' are achievements become 'Western' successes, stripped of the fact that the successes in retaking parts of Iraq belong to Iraqi's (mostly Muslims). Certain popular media isn't in the business of information or news, its in the business of pandering to its market demographics. Fear, Hate and Anger sell far more than compassion, understanding and unity. We can't even objectively look at why these attack occurred in the media (France's bombing of IS for example) or issues that do affect the Muslim population without getting 'knicker wetting'
That's the right-wing base media for you. Easier for control and more profitable.
Keep em baffled with bullsh1t tell lies and say everythings fine. Thats the Left wing base media for you. Easier to ignore problems than tackle them. Well that's actually how all forms of media work, if you ask me. The Liberal to liberal left media tend towards a more abstracted view of reality, in which they tend to focus on diverting the problem away from the immediate causes towards institutions in society. Obviously there is a problem in the UK and world, with Some Muslims and versions of Islam, and media such as the Guardian (which I quite like) will tend to go out of its way to avoid mentioning that (or for more traditional leftist blaming capital or institutions of capital) and ignoring the fact that there is actually currently a problem. All of these media outlets are effectively biased towards appeal to their readers, and maybe feeding on their sense of moral superiority. What tends to then happen is the middle ground where most of the truth lies gets ignored. You'd think the only response to IS would be either 'kill them all' or 'change our international policy towards xx and xxx'. The problem this causes, is it tends to polarise political response, as Politicians respond to what the media says the public want, rather than necessarily dealing with the public, and engage with the public through the media as intermediatary. Obviously, to eliminate IS you have to deal with the problem you have (armed f**ktards) but long term you also have to deal with the issues, especially the legitimate issues, that leads to people being drawn into radical circles and ultimately into such groups. As well as dealing effectively with those who supply, support and fund such groups, even if they're 'your friends'. The Troubles in NI couldn't really ever be dealt with until the issues that fed into the radicalisation of Republicans and the concerns of Catholics were approached responsibly but also in the mean time, you also had to eliminate the INRA, PIRA, UVF etc capacity, will and assets. Otherwise you just end up with a new generation of utterly butterly f**ktards, because they are the 'only voice of dissent' that's being heard.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
|
Could they not send The French Foreign legion in? What is their remit? (Awaits Jamies answer)
Pro USA & Israel |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote Jimenez at 20 Nov 2015 1.29pm
Could they not send The French Foreign legion in? What is their remit? (Awaits Jamies answer) No, not really. Its a logistic nightmare to support troops in Syria as supply lines would either have to run through Iraq (via the Sunni Triangle) into Syria or via Turkey and Kurdish territory (and Turkey is never going to allow that). Its complicated by the fact that some of the 'good' rebel factions aren't much more pro-Western than IS, the fact there is an ongoing civil war with at least four clearly different factions (one of which is the Assad Regime who won't be too compliant either) Potentially supply routes would have to cross a number of different fronts, if you only wanted to engage with IS across the country, and maintaining those lines of support would be exceptionally difficult given the distances of territory (and the value of the supplies). To achieve a reasonable goal, you have to look at a full scale invasion via Turkey and the Kurdish republic, or coming down through Israel (which would mean taking on the Assad Regime as well), or pacifying the Sunni Triangle. Other options would be the Kingdom of Jordan or Lebannon, neither of which are particually reliable or stable. Hezzbollah in Lebannon aren't going to be too keen on the first, and Jordan notoriously refuses to take sides.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.