You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > The Roy Hodgson thread
November 16 2026 7.41am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

The Roy Hodgson thread


Page 25 of 65 < 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 >
southnorwoodhill Flag 10 Mar 19 10.15am

Originally posted by Tickled pink

Brighton were too organised for us to break down.

In that case all PL managers have our home tactics sussed. Statistically undeniable, just look at our awful home record. Therefore it is up to RH and team to study results, question why they have gone the way they have, and is there anything that can be done in terms of tactical approach that can alter them for a more successful outcome.
All season RH has not changed his Plan A approach, despite the evidence that it clearly does not work. This inflexibility is costing us.

 

PZ Eagle Flag Penzance 10 Mar 19 10.19am

Originally posted by MonsterMunch

Partly correct. The manager picks the team and chooses the tactics. Quite what Roy manages I don’t know. Even if it is obvious to Stevie Wonder Roy will stick with it over and over and over agin. Responsibility only lies with one person. Unless you are new to football. Our home record over the last 2 seasons is indefensible.

Edited by MonsterMunch (10 Mar 2019 10.10am)


I'd be interested to know how the manager is responsible for a hoof up the field which is missed by
our centre back and a goalie out of position ending in the back of our net. Also how is he responsible for a touch of class which was Brighton's second goal.

By your logic it was Pep Guardioala's fault that we beat Man City. Sometimes it's nobody's fault that a team loses it's just the way it is with football.

 


Conjunctivitis.com - A site for sore eyes.

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 10 Mar 19 10.24am

Originally posted by southnorwoodhill

What RH should have realised by now is that if we score first we are in a good position because we have the counterattacking capability to hurt teams as they come out trying to get an equaliser.
Why at home we start so slowly and let the opposition score first,, giving them the opportunity to sit back and counter is a mystery to me.
Manchester United under Ferguson would pummel the opposition for the first 15 minutes at home, we just pass it from side to side. We need to be on the front foot and up the tempo, give the crowd something to get excited about.

Seriously ? You are making comparisons with one of the most successful, if not the most successful teams and manager in modern football with our present day Palace ?

Our home form has been wretched for years now. While I agree that Hodgson has not resolved that problem, it's one that every Palace manager has struggled with since promotion to the Prem.

However, I didn't think Roy helped himself yesterday with his team selection in the midfield. It was a given that Brighton would concede possession and therefore it would make sense to select players most comfortable with the ball at their feet - Kouyate and Meyer. We had plenty of the ball but weren't good enough at moving it around quickly enough to draw Brighton out of position.

 


Old, Ungifted and White

ChrisGC Flag Wantage 10 Mar 19 10.24am

Originally posted by PZ Eagle


I'd be interested to know how the manager is responsible for a hoof up the field which is missed by
our centre back and a goalie out of position ending in the back of our net. Also how is he responsible for a touch of class which was Brighton's second goal.

By your logic it was Pep Guardioala's fault that we beat Man City. Sometimes it's nobody's fault that a team loses it's just the way it is with football.

What a pathetically defeatist attitude.

It was Tommo's fault for the first goal.
It was Hodgson's fault for the defeat. Predictable again, same old tactics, wrong starting line up, keep playing PVA etc etc.

To win you have to address the root cause. The attitude of "that's how it goes" is an easy cop out and will only lead to repeat performance.

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 10 Mar 19 10.40am

Originally posted by NEILLO

Seriously ? You are making comparisons with one of the most successful, if not the most successful teams and manager in modern football with our present day Palace ?

Our home form has been wretched for years now. While I agree that Hodgson has not resolved that problem, it's one that every Palace manager has struggled with since promotion to the Prem.

However, I didn't think Roy helped himself yesterday with his team selection in the midfield. It was a given that Brighton would concede possession and therefore it would make sense to select players most comfortable with the ball at their feet - Kouyate and Meyer. We had plenty of the ball but weren't good enough at moving it around quickly enough to draw Brighton out of position.

You have jumped the gun. All I am saying that it is a tactic employed that put them on the front foot immediately and let the opposition know that they were in a game from the off. If I cited Barcelona taking short corners to keep possession rather that pump hopeless balls into the box would that mean I am comparing us to Barcelona? No, I am exploring different ways of applying tactics that may help us overcome our very obvious deficiencies in certain areas. RH sticks to Plan A, IT DOESN'T WORK.

 

MonsterMunch Flag Cambridge 10 Mar 19 10.47am

Originally posted by PZ Eagle


I'd be interested to know how the manager is responsible for a hoof up the field which is missed by
our centre back and a goalie out of position ending in the back of our net. Also how is he responsible for a touch of class which was Brighton's second goal.

By your logic it was Pep Guardioala's fault that we beat Man City. Sometimes it's nobody's fault that a team loses it's just the way it is with football.

That makes no sense at all, the logic you are using is very odd. Mistakes happen. It’s palace total inadequacy to take the game to teams at home that is the issue. Using one off scenarios is pointless and holds no value at all. Roy at Selhurst park for 2 seasons has been abysmal. Most likely would have gone by now if he was any other manager.

Edited by MonsterMunch (10 Mar 2019 10.48am)

 

JohnB Flag 10 Mar 19 10.49am

The players we have means we are always likely to be better away from home or against teams that attack us. When we're at home and teams are sitting a bit deeper against us we haven't got the composure and vision to pass through teams. We're great on the break with speed and power upfront but we miss that bit of creativity that other teams have.

Even with Kouyate, Meyer and Luka as a central three, that's not exactly a midfield three that are going to open teams up.

The teams that we should be competing with, the likes of West Ham, Watford etc. all have better midfields on the ball. Our strength lies in a solid back 5, protected by our midfield three with the ability to knock the ball out quick to the wings and counter through Wilf and Townsend.

If we really want to start winning more at home, we have to be braver and play a central three that can keep the ball and player that killer pass. That's where we miss the likes of Cabaye and RLC.

 

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 10 Mar 19 10.51am

Originally posted by southnorwoodhill

You have jumped the gun. All I am saying that it is a tactic employed that put them on the front foot immediately and let the opposition know that they were in a game from the off. If I cited Barcelona taking short corners to keep possession rather that pump hopeless balls into the box would that mean I am comparing us to Barcelona? No, I am exploring different ways of applying tactics that may help us overcome our very obvious deficiencies in certain areas. RH sticks to Plan A, IT DOESN'T WORK.

Ok - so how do you go about '' pummelling '' the opposition from the start - what does that entail exactly ?

 


Old, Ungifted and White

southnorwoodhill Flag 10 Mar 19 11.01am

Originally posted by NEILLO

Ok - so how do you go about '' pummelling '' the opposition from the start - what does that entail exactly ?

Overlaps in wide areas and getting men in the box. Quicker tempo. Constant questions asked of the centre halfs. Excite the crowd through positive actions.
It worked for Brighton, one situation that Tompkins had to deal with and he f***ed up! In other words make them work for their pay. Side to side passing in midfield is no threat whatsoever.

 

MonsterMunch Flag Cambridge 10 Mar 19 11.05am

If Roy gets us to a cup final he would have redeemed himsel. If we get past away Watford both games will be away from Selhurst so who knows.. if we go out next week a very, very underwhelming season. With the squad we have. Not good enough.

 

dynamicdick Flag Dormansland 10 Mar 19 11.06am

Originally posted by PZ Eagle


I'd be interested to know how the manager is responsible for a hoof up the field which is missed by
our centre back and a goalie out of position ending in the back of our net. Also how is he responsible for a touch of class which was Brighton's second goal.

By your logic it was Pep Guardioala's fault that we beat Man City. Sometimes it's nobody's fault that a team loses it's just the way it is with football.

Its not just about one game,

 


Bring back Brolin

PZ Eagle Flag Penzance 10 Mar 19 11.06am

Originally posted by MonsterMunch

That makes no sense at all, the logic you are using is very odd. Mistakes happen. It’s palace total inadequacy to take the game to teams at home that is the issue. Using one off scenarios is pointless and holds no value at all. Roy at Selhurst park for 2 seasons has been abysmal. Most likely would have gone by now if he was any other manager.

Edited by MonsterMunch (10 Mar 2019 10.48am)

Why would he have gone if he was any other manager?
When he took over and before he had settled in we were
soon W0 D0 L7 and no goals. Every pundit and newspaper in the country had us relegated but Roy kept us up against the odds. This season the only "striker" that he had available was Ayew. We win at Man City, draw at Man Utd and give Liverpool a scare. We've just had a two game winning away run scoring 7 with only 2 against.

But yet you and other eejits want him sacked. Just be bleddy careful what you wish for!!


Edited by PZ Eagle (10 Mar 2019 11.08am)

 


Conjunctivitis.com - A site for sore eyes.

MonsterMunch Flag Cambridge 10 Mar 19 11.16am

Originally posted by PZ Eagle

Why would he have gone if he was any other manager?
When he took over and before he had settled in we were
soon W0 D0 L7 and no goals. Every pundit and newspaper in the country had us relegated but Roy kept us up against the odds. This season the only "striker" that he had available was Ayew. We win at Man City, draw at Man Utd and give Liverpool a scare. We've just had a two game winning away run scoring 7 with only 2 against.

But yet you and other eejits want him sacked. Just be bleddy careful what you wish for!!


Edited by PZ Eagle (10 Mar 2019 11.08am)

So what because we beat Man City and got a draw at united and LOST to Liverpool (all away), these 3 games are enough to mask over the fact we have won 3 games at home all season, scored 6 goals in open play one of which was an own goal? Tactically he is lost at Selhurst. You need to have more ambition in my opinion and stop being such an apologist and defeatist. . If you are trying to tell me someone else could not have done better this season than Roy I think you are wrong. This was his season to move on and progress or at least show he is capable of progression. He is stuck and does not have the answers to this problem. It will Groundhog Day again against Huddersfield.

 

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 10 Mar 19 11.29am

Originally posted by southnorwoodhill

Overlaps in wide areas and getting men in the box. Quicker tempo. Constant questions asked of the centre halfs. Excite the crowd through positive actions.
It worked for Brighton, one situation that Tompkins had to deal with and he f***ed up! In other words make them work for their pay. Side to side passing in midfield is no threat whatsoever.

What worked for Brighton was a hopeful punt upfield where Murray had time and space following Tompkin's error. In other words, it was on the break. Still a top finish though.

I agree with you about a quicker tempo and I thought that was where it all went wrong yesterday, the ball wasn't moved quickly enough. But that's the sort of difference provided by the top players - they have the ability to play at pace and in tight situations.

 


Old, Ungifted and White

PZ Eagle Flag Penzance 10 Mar 19 11.53am

Originally posted by MonsterMunch

So what because we beat Man City and got a draw at united and LOST to Liverpool (all away), these 3 games are enough to mask over the fact we have won 3 games at home all season, scored 6 goals in open play one of which was an own goal? Tactically he is lost at Selhurst. You need to have more ambition in my opinion and stop being such an apologist and defeatist. . If you are trying to tell me someone else could not have done better this season than Roy I think you are wrong. This was his season to move on and progress or at least show he is capable of progression. He is stuck and does not have the answers to this problem. It will Groundhog Day again against Huddersfield.

OK tell me who could do better. Is he available and would he come to Palace? Please don't say Wagner or Ill split my sides laughing. You say I'm defeatist yet you are already conceding defeat against Huddersfield.

 


Conjunctivitis.com - A site for sore eyes.

spartakev2 Flag Anerley 10 Mar 19 11.53am

For a team who pride ourselves inon our wide play, how many times did we get it wide and put a good cross into the box yesterday. While I don't think batasuAi is the answer to our scoring problems, the service into him is s**t.

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 10 Mar 19 12.00pm

Originally posted by NEILLO

What worked for Brighton was a hopeful punt upfield where Murray had time and space following Tompkin's error. In other words, it was on the break. Still a top finish though.

I agree with you about a quicker tempo and I thought that was where it all went wrong yesterday, the ball wasn't moved quickly enough. But that's the sort of difference provided by the top players - they have the ability to play at pace and in tight situations.

Agreed

 

jeeagles Flag 10 Mar 19 12.31pm

On the topic of our home form.
3 home wins all season.
4 Draws
4 goals from open play. 1 own goal. The rest are penalties.

We can't score and don't look threatening.
Teams know that if they can get a get a goal they are more than likely to get 3 points. Soaking up pressure against us is easy as we just pass the ball around in front of the oposition and take pot shots.

When the oposition have scored at Selhurst we have picked up 2 points all season.
Brighton did just that yesterday.

Yet it's the same old tactics, starting line up, and substitutes every week.

 

Maine Eagle Flag USA 10 Mar 19 12.35pm

Originally posted by PZ Eagle

OK tell me who could do better. Is he available and would he come to Palace? Please don't say Wagner or Ill split my sides laughing. You say I'm defeatist yet you are already conceding defeat against Huddersfield.

Fans are allowed to question Roy Hodgson and not have an intimate knowledge of every manager in the world.

Perhaps there is a really good manager in some country in the world, and we have never heard of him, but he could come in and do a job? It’s not too hard to imagine is it PZ? Had you heard of Southampton’s manager before he landed in England?

This is the same exact argument people have made for years about Parish, with the chairman it actually has more credibility as some of them are bananas. However we can still assume a better chairman might not have hired FDB, sold Murray etc.

You cannot argue the facts - Roy is unwilling or unable to make us competitive at home with his team selections and tactical setup.

There are no longer any excuses for having the second worst home record in the league. The players we have are better than the second worst home record in the league.

 


Trump lost. Badly. Hahahahahahaha.

kev64 Flag Cambs 10 Mar 19 12.41pm

Originally posted by jeeagles

On the topic of our home form.
3 home wins all season.
4 Draws
4 goals from open play. 1 own goal. The rest are penalties.

We can't score and don't look threatening.
Teams know that if they can get a get a goal they are more than likely to get 3 points. Soaking up pressure against us is easy as we just pass the ball around in front of the oposition and take pot shots.

When the oposition have scored at Selhurst we have picked up 2 points all season.
Brighton did just that yesterday.

Yet it's the same old tactics, starting line up, and substitutes every week.

Nail on the Head .. need to change it up at home ..3-5-2 ? Something at least. Pva should of been subbed at half time , a mare of a game, the midfield were clueless, and one up front against a big defence, zero chance, I could see it after 10 min and I know very little, compared to Roy ..

Ffs that game was screaming out for 2 big guys up front, Sako muscle on the wing and Kayoute in midfield. Cabaye would of taken out that t*** after his challenge on Milo and not one of our team went near him. Soft as s***.

 

Page 25 of 65 < 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > The Roy Hodgson thread