You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Who’s at fault - Hodgson or the board?
November 16 2026 7.58am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Who’s at fault - Hodgson or the board?


Page 25 of 44 < 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 >
Maine Eagle Flag USA 13 Dec 18 5.28pm

Originally posted by rikz

Benteke and Sakho both had over 100 pages on here before they signed, the fans are just as bad demanding marquee signings every transfer window. The board would be getting slagged off now asking why we ain't showing the same ambition as other clubs if they hadn't been signed they're dammed if they do and dammed If they don't.

If signing Sakho meant falling afoul of FFP or generally screwing over any chance we had of spending more than 10 million quid over the summer then it was a poor decision, without also selling some players at the same time.

We have only really sold Murray, Gayle and Bolasie during cpfc2010s entire tenure. That fact along with signing big money defenders does not correlate.

Sign strikers for 25 m quid or more, but not centre backs.

We showed plenty of ambition getting in Benteke and that should be applauded but signing defenders for that amount of money (if it tips the scales on ffp/your finances in general) is a bad move.

We need players who can score goals in this side. Not doing better than Sorloth and Ayew in the last window is criminal.

We need to be signing the likes of Benteke out of Belgium, not the premier league. Different era but Villa paid 7 mil for him. We did well to scout players like Luka but whoever signed off on Sorloth needs firing.

Edited by Maine Eagle (13 Dec 2018 5.29pm)

 


Trump lost. Badly. Hahahahahahaha.

PatrickA Flag London 13 Dec 18 6.35pm

As a long standing supporter the current tribulations are part of being a Palace fan but it doesn’t make it any less annoying.
I remember the disintegration of the great ‘team of the eighties’ and subsequently the relegation of the team that had finished third in the Premier League equivalent under Coppell ( for newcomers the equivalent of what Arsenal, Tottenham and Chelsea are striving to achieve now).
At some point we are likely be relegated as all teams outside the top 6 seem destined
to encounter this at some point in the future.
The difference for me now is that we are no longer a selling club as we were in the past when we had to sell the likes of Ian Wright.
Despite our current striking problems the squad should be more than capable of surviving as we have some very good players.
For me this means that Hodgson has to take his share of responsibility as he is not getting the best out of the squad.


 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 13 Dec 18 6.39pm

Originally posted by PatrickA

As a long standing supporter the current tribulations are part of being a Palace fan but it doesn’t make it any less annoying.
I remember the disintegration of the great ‘team of the eighties’ and subsequently the relegation of the team that had finished third in the Premier League equivalent under Coppell ( for newcomers the equivalent of what Arsenal, Tottenham and Chelsea are striving to achieve now).
At some point we are likely be relegated as all teams outside the top 6 seem destined
to encounter this at some point in the future.
The difference for me now is that we are no longer a selling club as we were in the past when we had to sell the likes of Ian Wright.
Despite our current striking problems the squad should be more than capable of surviving as we have some very good players.
For me this means that Hodgson has to take his share of responsibility as he is not getting the best out of the squad.


Only because nobody wants any of our players !!!!

Edited by Willo (13 Dec 2018 6.40pm)

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 13 Dec 18 6.45pm

Originally posted by rikz

Benteke and Sakho both had over 100 pages on here before they signed, the fans are just as bad demanding marquee signings every transfer window. The board would be getting slagged off now asking why we ain't showing the same ambition as other clubs if they hadn't been signed they're dammed if they do and dammed If they don't.

If we were signing cheaper players we’d scouted nobody would give a fook about surplus to requirements players at Liverpool.

 


COYP

Maine Eagle Flag USA 13 Dec 18 7.01pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

If we were signing cheaper players we’d scouted nobody would give a fook about surplus to requirements players at Liverpool.

We do, only problem is they are generally utterly sh***.

Rakip and Jach spring to mind. My word the last January window can clearly now only be described as a complete horror show, with the benefit of hindsight.

 


Trump lost. Badly. Hahahahahahaha.

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 13 Dec 18 7.21pm

Originally posted by Maine Eagle

We do, only problem is they are generally utterly sh***.

Rakip and Jach spring to mind. My word the last January window can clearly now only be described as a complete horror show, with the benefit of hindsight.

We spent £11.5 Mill (Excluding the add-ons) on the likes of Sorloth,Jach,Rakip and Cavalieri.

Another "Horrow show" this coming January and I fear we will be in the Championship next season.

 

HKOwen Flag Hong Kong 13 Dec 18 10.50pm

Cavalieri was needed in an emergency situation

Originally posted by Willo

We spent £11.5 Mill (Excluding the add-ons) on the likes of Sorloth,Jach,Rakip and Cavalieri.

Another "Horrow show" this coming January and I fear we will be in the Championship next season.

 


Responsibility Deficit Disorder is a medical condition. Symptoms include inability to be corrected when wrong, false sense of superiority, desire to share personal info no else cares about, general hubris. It's a medical issue rather than pure arrogance.

Maine Eagle Flag USA 13 Dec 18 11.28pm

Originally posted by Willo

We spent £11.5 Mill (Excluding the add-ons) on the likes of Sorloth,Jach,Rakip and Cavalieri.

Another "Horrow show" this coming January and I fear we will be in the Championship next season.

If we dont inject some quality in the final third and send Ayew packing it will be a travesty.

Travesties seem all too common though at the Palace, look at FDB.

Either Hodgson needs to work another miracle or we must invest (or perhaps both, as they are no doubt related) lest we succumb to the championship.

 


Trump lost. Badly. Hahahahahahaha.

Maine Eagle Flag USA 13 Dec 18 11.35pm

Originally posted by HKOwen

Cavalieri was needed in an emergency situation


With those 4 signings the goalie is not the one that concerns me.

Parish said Rakip was signed to make up the numbers in training.......no.....really, he honestly said that.

Jach is struggling on loan at a poor side in Turkey.

As for Sorloth he has no positional sense whatsoever, added to no physical presence. The least you expect from a centre forward is to get into the right positions and give the defenders a hard time but he is so easy to mark out of the game. Wilbraham would be a better option, and when you compare unfavorably to Aaron Wilbraham, you know you have issues.

He is absolutely nowhere near the finished article and must be loaned out urgently. Therefore we need to bring in new blood unless Wickham and Benteke are match fit on Jan 1, and even then we probably still need to sign a proper striker.

 


Trump lost. Badly. Hahahahahahaha.

Vaibow Flag vancouver/croydon 14 Dec 18 4.03am

Originally posted by Maine Eagle

If signing Sakho meant falling afoul of FFP or generally screwing over any chance we had of spending more than 10 million quid over the summer then it was a poor decision, without also selling some players at the same time.

We have only really sold Murray, Gayle and Bolasie during cpfc2010s entire tenure. That fact along with signing big money defenders does not correlate.

Sign strikers for 25 m quid or more, but not centre backs.

We showed plenty of ambition getting in Benteke and that should be applauded but signing defenders for that amount of money (if it tips the scales on ffp/your finances in general) is a bad move.

We need players who can score goals in this side. Not doing better than Sorloth and Ayew in the last window is criminal.

We need to be signing the likes of Benteke out of Belgium, not the premier league. Different era but Villa paid 7 mil for him. We did well to scout players like Luka but whoever signed off on Sorloth needs firing.

Edited by Maine Eagle (13 Dec 2018 5.29pm)

I agree, we need premiership standard defenders, not fringe champions league - if that makes sense. Almost like splitting the league in two and getting a squad that will win the bottom ten league - there are so many players from the top two leagues that combined and coached well can achieve this.

 


This was once a quality forum....

The Dolphin Flag 14 Dec 18 7.48am

Our squad is not strong enough and we all know about our transfer policy which is beyond this Manager's control - but I reckon Roy has this Saturday to save his skin!
A poor result will see him gone in my opinion.
Could we play differently, can we utilise our players better and have a different plan for different opposition?
I think we could and should be doing better than we are even with what we have available and that has to be down to the Manager.
He is beginning to look lost and his post match comments which were once insightful are now like a broken record.
If this were Pardew I would have been calling for his head and so...…………………………….

 

ARGILE OLD GEEZER Flag PORTIMAO 14 Dec 18 7.58am

Originally posted by Maine Eagle

With those 4 signings the goalie is not the one that concerns me.

Parish said Rakip was signed to make up the numbers in training.......no.....really, he honestly said that.

Jach is struggling on loan at a poor side in Turkey.

As for Sorloth he has no positional sense whatsoever, added to no physical presence. The least you expect from a centre forward is to get into the right positions and give the defenders a hard time but he is so easy to mark out of the game. Wilbraham would be a better option, and when you compare unfavorably to Aaron Wilbraham, you know you have issues.

He is absolutely nowhere near the finished article and must be loaned out urgently. Therefore we need to bring in new blood unless Wickham and Benteke are match fit on Jan 1, and even then we probably still need to sign a proper striker.

Wilbraham was a very good player, just couldn't score goals.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 14 Dec 18 8.41am

Originally posted by ARGILE OLD GEEZER

Wilbraham was a very good player, just couldn't score goals.

Scored at all 4 levels of English football, but I accept he was not that proficient although he didn't do too badly at Bristol C.

Deeming him a "Very good player" is in my humble opinion over-egging the actualite.He is a player known for his workrate and the ability to hold the ball up well.He is currently on the books of Rochdale.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 14 Dec 18 9.37am

Originally posted by ARGILE OLD GEEZER

Wilbraham was a very good player, just couldn't score goals.

So not a good enough striker at the championship level then.

Edited by Rudi Hedman (14 Dec 2018 9.37am)

 


COYP

becky Flag over the moon 14 Dec 18 12.19pm

Originally posted by Maine Eagle

With those 4 signings the goalie is not the one that concerns me.

Parish said Rakip was signed to make up the numbers in training.......no.....really, he honestly said that.

Jach is struggling on loan at a poor side in Turkey.

As for Sorloth he has no positional sense whatsoever, added to no physical presence. The least you expect from a centre forward is to get into the right positions and give the defenders a hard time but he is so easy to mark out of the game. Wilbraham would be a better option, and when you compare unfavorably to Aaron Wilbraham, you know you have issues.

He is absolutely nowhere near the finished article and must be loaned out urgently. Therefore we need to bring in new blood unless Wickham and Benteke are match fit on Jan 1, and even then we probably still need to sign a proper striker.

Since there's no guarantee (based on previous) that both of them still would be fit on Jan 2nd, we definitely need to sign one (or give one of the youngsters a chance to shine).

 


A stairway to Heaven and a Highway to Hell give some indication of expected traffic numbers

A89M Flag Streatham 14 Dec 18 12.25pm

Originally posted by becky

Since there's no guarantee (based on previous) that both of them still would be fit on Jan 2nd, we definitely need to sign one (or give one of the youngsters a chance to shine).

I've said Sorloth should start Saturday but i'm coming round to the idea of a youngster coming in instead - James Daly. Two crosses were flashed across West Hams box last week, one from McCarthur and one from Zaha and a striker who's not got the mental baggage/pressure of not scoring all season on his shoulders may have just made the type of run that gets on the end of those crosses.

Edited by A89M (14 Dec 2018 12.26pm)

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 14 Dec 18 1.11pm

Originally posted by A89M

I've said Sorloth should start Saturday but i'm coming round to the idea of a youngster coming in instead - James Daly.

Isn't he on loan to Kingstonian?

 

bexleydave Flag Barnehurst 14 Dec 18 1.29pm

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

Isn't he on loan to Kingstonian?

Yes, he's on a season-long loan.

 


Bexley Dave

Can you hear the Brighton sing? I can't hear a ******* thing!

"The most arrogant, obnoxious bunch of deluded little sun tanned, loafer wearing mummy's boys I've ever had the misfortune of having to listen to" (Burnley forum)

Maine Eagle Flag USA 14 Dec 18 1.44pm

Originally posted by Willo

Scored at all 4 levels of English football, but I accept he was not that proficient although he didn't do too badly at Bristol C.

Deeming him a "Very good player" is in my humble opinion over-egging the actualite.He is a player known for his workrate and the ability to hold the ball up well.He is currently on the books of Rochdale.

Wilbs was a “very good striker” the way that Owen Garvan was a “very good midfielder”.

Point is he could put himself around, time his runs, not give fouls away too much and generally be a nuisance.

Sorloth is as much a nuisance to opposition back fours as a lottery win.

Ayew at least can hold the ball up and has some close control but choosing between those two to lead the line is like picking between sanogo and bamford.

 


Trump lost. Badly. Hahahahahahaha.

Jacey Flag 14 Dec 18 1.57pm

Questions must be asked if we lose the next two games against Leicester and Man City with only a win against Cardiff likely to prevent Parish from pulling the trigger on poor old Roy's beleaguered tenure,as the table doesn't lie.
Very sad state of affairs which should never have happened.

 

Page 25 of 44 < 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Who’s at fault - Hodgson or the board?