You are here: Home > Message Board > Transfer Talk > Signings On The Way
November 22 2026 3.47pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Signings On The Way


Page 25 of 161 < 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 >
JohnB Flag 27 Jan 20 5.49pm

Originally posted by mattteo

I would argue that Schlupp is a left back and not enough for a side midfielder. How many goals does he contribute to while playing more advanc3d? Not many.

If you look at his stats, Schlupp is our most successful midfielder in terms of attacking contribution.

Played 14 games, 2 goals and 2 assists.

Zaha 25, 3 and 4.

Luka 21, 2 and 1

Macca 24, 0 and 3

Townsend 15, 1 and 1

Meyer 13, 0 and 0.

I have no idea how many of those appearances were from the bench or ended in player being substituted.

This does highlight how dire we are going forward though.

Roy also clearly sees him as a midfielder.

 

EddieMac Flag 27 Jan 20 5.52pm

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

He was bought as a left back

He played as a winger for Leicester when we signed him.

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 27 Jan 20 6.45pm

Originally posted by EddieMac

He played as a winger for Leicester when we signed him.

[Link]

Palace boss Allardyce told the club’s official website: “I am delighted we have been able to secure Jeffrey’s services, he is a player I have admired for some time and is a talented and athletic player. He will bring strength and experience to the defence and will be a major asset for the club having just turned 24-years-old.”

Ranieri confirmed on Thursday he was prepared to let Schlupp go for the right price after he fell behind Ben Chilwell and Christian Fuchs in the pecking order.

 

EddieMac Flag 27 Jan 20 7.39pm

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

[Link]

Palace boss Allardyce told the club’s official website: “I am delighted we have been able to secure Jeffrey’s services, he is a player I have admired for some time and is a talented and athletic player. He will bring strength and experience to the defence and will be a major asset for the club having just turned 24-years-old.”

Ranieri confirmed on Thursday he was prepared to let Schlupp go for the right price after he fell behind Ben Chilwell and Christian Fuchs in the pecking order.

He still played as a winger when we signed him.

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 27 Jan 20 9.28pm

Originally posted by EddieMac

He still played as a winger when we signed him.

Only because we had PVA and we probably thought we couldn’t waste all that money on a bench warmer! He was a centre forward as a kid, so a bit of an all rounder really. You are both right but I do recall same as ME that he was initially signed as a defender.

 

mattteo Flag 28 Jan 20 12.50am

Originally posted by EddieMac

Schlupp maybe a better left back than a midfielder but that certainly doesn't mean he is a left back. He is in my opinion one the weakest players in our squad who shouldn't be playing in any position when all others are fit.

Riedewald may have held his own for a few games at LB but over the course of a full season he would be found out time and time again.

PVA is our only recognised LB and we need an upgrade on him anyway.

I doubt Lewis could ever be considered an upgrade on PVA. Certainly not in the near future. Perhaps he will develop. Maybe. Unlikely though. 2 things I want to say about Lewis:

1. He's not that young anymore (22 going on 23, that's not young anymore, he's in the age range when he should be at his best)

2. Haven't seen him contributing much for Norwich, aside for getting into the squad as a starter last year. Perhaps he will grow with time (it's harder to know for side defenders how much they can improve), but he will be no PVA.

 

EddieMac Flag 28 Jan 20 6.34am

Originally posted by mattteo

I doubt Lewis could ever be considered an upgrade on PVA. Certainly not in the near future. Perhaps he will develop. Maybe. Unlikely though. 2 things I want to say about Lewis:

1. He's not that young anymore (22 going on 23, that's not young anymore, he's in the age range when he should be at his best)

2. Haven't seen him contributing much for Norwich, aside for getting into the squad as a starter last year. Perhaps he will grow with time (it's harder to know for side defenders how much they can improve), but he will be no PVA.

I agree with you that Lewis is not an upgrade on PVA. My original post was referring to the fact that we could do with an upgrade on PVA in general.

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 28 Jan 20 8.03am

Originally posted by mattteo

I doubt Lewis could ever be considered an upgrade on PVA. Certainly not in the near future. Perhaps he will develop. Maybe. Unlikely though. 2 things I want to say about Lewis:

1. He's not that young anymore (22 going on 23, that's not young anymore, he's in the age range when he should be at his best)

2. Haven't seen him contributing much for Norwich, aside for getting into the squad as a starter last year. Perhaps he will grow with time (it's harder to know for side defenders how much they can improve), but he will be no PVA.

I thought it is generally acknowledged that footballers reach their prime in mid-late twenties? Look at Ian Wright. Perhaps you know better.
I believe he lost his place through injury and his replacement has not deserved to lose his place.
Norwich fans, in general, do not want to lose him and say he has a bright future but hey, they only watch him every week so what do they know?

 

JohnB Flag 28 Jan 20 9.36am

Lots of rumours in the summer that Roy ultimately vetoed 3 or 4 decent players.

Rumours doing the rounds again that Roy has vetoed Carrasco.

Obviously these are all twitter rumours so could be rubbish but the narrative is that it seems like Dougie continually offers players for signing and Roy is blocking a fair few of them.

Catch 22, Roy's contract up at end of season, approcahing mid 70's. Do you back him or do you buy players he doesn't want trying to enforce the changes to the squad you think is best in the long run.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 28 Jan 20 9.41am

Originally posted by JohnB

Lots of rumours in the summer that Roy ultimately vetoed 3 or 4 decent players.

Rumours doing the rounds again that Roy has vetoed Carrasco.

Obviously these are all twitter rumours so could be rubbish but the narrative is that it seems like Dougie continually offers players for signing and Roy is blocking a fair few of them.

Catch 22, Roy's contract up at end of season, approcahing mid 70's. Do you back him or do you buy players he doesn't want trying to enforce the changes to the squad you think is best in the long run.

Complicated further by us not having a clue on his successor. If we did then it would sway me to start rebuilding before we’re so slow with age we’ll be lucky to be 19th and not 11th with the help of Guaita and VAR.

 


COYP

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 28 Jan 20 9.43am

Originally posted by JohnB

Lots of rumours in the summer that Roy ultimately vetoed 3 or 4 decent players.

Rumours doing the rounds again that Roy has vetoed Carrasco.

Obviously these are all twitter rumours so could be rubbish but the narrative is that it seems like Dougie continually offers players for signing and Roy is blocking a fair few of them.

Catch 22, Roy's contract up at end of season, approcahing mid 70's. Do you back him or do you buy players he doesn't want trying to enforce the changes to the squad you think is best in the long run.


How much say does Roy have on incoming transfers? (I've got no idea - just asking)

 

Jacey Flag 28 Jan 20 9.53am

Originally posted by doombear


How much say does Roy have on incoming transfers? (I've got no idea - just asking)

Difficult to say.Roy went on record as wanting 4/5 new signings then stated recently as our players returning from injury were better than new signings!!

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 28 Jan 20 9.55am

Originally posted by JohnB

Lots of rumours in the summer that Roy ultimately vetoed 3 or 4 decent players.

Rumours doing the rounds again that Roy has vetoed Carrasco.

Obviously these are all twitter rumours so could be rubbish but the narrative is that it seems like Dougie continually offers players for signing and Roy is blocking a fair few of them.

Catch 22, Roy's contract up at end of season, approcahing mid 70's. Do you back him or do you buy players he doesn't want trying to enforce the changes to the squad you think is best in the long run.

My son mentioned this and that Castaneda was one. If these rumours are true then I cannot see how we can progress. I am a supporter of Roy but not happy about this if true. How can he moan about needing players? Perhaps Camarasa was signed without his knowledge and he refused to play him. Patience wearing thin in my household

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 28 Jan 20 9.56am

Originally posted by Spiderman

My son mentioned this and that Castaneda was one. If these rumours are true then I cannot see how we can progress. I am a supporter of Roy but not happy about this if true. How can he moan about needing players? Perhaps Camarasa was signed without his knowledge and he refused to play him. Patience wearing thin in my household

Meant Castagne

 

Den1923 Flag 28 Jan 20 10.13am

Originally posted by Spiderman

Meant Castagne

IMO, the problem with getting transfers completed at this club is much deeper than Roy using a veto, we have a long history now of not being able to get transfers done, players just seemed to find something about this club toxic and most rumoured moves seem to breakdown because Parish just cannot seem to be able make his mind up on what the club needs and how much to spend, in fact he doesn't like spending anything these days and just keeps trying for short term loan deals which is doing nothing for the teams on going development. I just despair that this transfer window is going the same way as those before and we will end up with nothing and then it is a hope and prayer for the rest of the season!

 

Bangell Flag Oxford 28 Jan 20 10.22am

Originally posted by JohnB

Lots of rumours in the summer that Roy ultimately vetoed 3 or 4 decent players.

Rumours doing the rounds again that Roy has vetoed Carrasco.

Obviously these are all twitter rumours so could be rubbish but the narrative is that it seems like Dougie continually offers players for signing and Roy is blocking a fair few of them.

Catch 22, Roy's contract up at end of season, approcahing mid 70's. Do you back him or do you buy players he doesn't want trying to enforce the changes to the squad you think is best in the long run.

The manager should never have to veto a player coming in; he should be involved in recruitment right from the start, so that the players we get in are ones that he actually wants for the team. Not going to give much credit to mere rumours, but it's very clear that there is a disconnect between management and recruitment at this club and we've suffered for it.

 

chris123 Flag hove actually 28 Jan 20 10.25am

Originally posted by Spiderman

My son mentioned this and that Castaneda was one. If these rumours are true then I cannot see how we can progress. I am a supporter of Roy but not happy about this if true. How can he moan about needing players? Perhaps Camarasa was signed without his knowledge and he refused to play him. Patience wearing thin in my household

Well we can assume he means players he wants and who will work hard in our shape. I do get annoyed after performances like Southampton and the two Brighton games, but really we're lucky to have Roy. In our last 14 games we play top 4 clubs 3 times, Liverpool and Leicester away and Chelsea at home - so not a horrific run in at all.

 

Petereagle Flag Brockley 28 Jan 20 10.31am

Originally posted by Spiderman

My son mentioned this and that Castaneda was one. If these rumours are true then I cannot see how we can progress. I am a supporter of Roy but not happy about this if true. How can he moan about needing players? Perhaps Camarasa was signed without his knowledge and he refused to play him. Patience wearing thin in my household

Let’s all wait until February 1st and see if any more players turn up? Loads of rumours still floating around, so we only need a couple of them to come off!

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 28 Jan 20 10.40am

Originally posted by Bangell


The manager should never have to veto a player coming in; he should be involved in recruitment right from the start, so that the players we get in are ones that he actually wants for the team. Not going to give much credit to mere rumours, but it's very clear that there is a disconnect between management and recruitment at this club and we've suffered for it.

How true and it's amazing that negotiations with Carrasco can have got so far before anyone bothered to check with Roy. That is if the Twitter rumours are true

 

JohnB Flag 28 Jan 20 10.44am

What I would add is the same twitter rumours say Tosun is now injured. I've not seen anything official so it could just all be a 13 year old making things up.

You have to assume though, that something is clearly wrong with the transfer strategy and the manager and DOF being on not just on different pages, but different books.

Edited by JohnB (28 Jan 2020 10.45am)

 

Page 25 of 161 < 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Transfer Talk > Signings On The Way