You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Southern Rail Strike - right or wrong
November 22 2026 12.41am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Southern Rail Strike - right or wrong


Page 26 of 44 < 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 >
npn Flag Crowborough 14 Dec 16 5.16pm

Originally posted by 7mins

Long post, but worth a read...

Thanks for that, it was, indeed, well worth a read. Informative, and plenty to chew on.

I didn't get all the way to the end (I bailed when the author starting letting himself down with personal attacks on and "unpleasant person" who is "nearly as bad as Beeching" - at that point I disengaged, but up to that point there were some very valid and thought provoking points, so thanks for posting it

 

steph_eagle Flag Thornton Heath 14 Dec 16 5.19pm

Originally posted by Helmet46

As a matter of interest how many of the posters on this thread regularly have to endure this strike? I do and my job is under threat because of it but I'd be really interested how many others actually know what it's like and appreciate it on a daily basis?

It changes your perspective after a while.

Sadly I have to use them on week days. I work in Brent so it's a bloody nightmare at the moment.

 

sickboy Flag Deal or Croydon 14 Dec 16 5.30pm

Originally posted by 7mins

Southern have rushed thru DOO, the technology isn't there... too many variables. DOO is less safe... the argument is it a lot more unsafe or just a little. Drivers think its a lot more unsafe.. DOO was originally implemented in the late 80's... passenger numbers have rocketed since then.

I thought you said it wasnt about safety. Again they dont seem to care about overcrowding on platforms and other(DOO) services due to their actions. Beyond a joke now for people who pay a fortune for a s*** service.

 

sickboy Flag Deal or Croydon 14 Dec 16 5.33pm

Apologies 7mins mis read your post. Everything else i said tho stands.

 

gambler Flag Kent 14 Dec 16 5.34pm

When the dispute is settled, whichever way, do people who use Southern Trains really believe the day to day service will improve?

 

Mapletree Flag Croydon 14 Dec 16 5.35pm

Originally posted by Helmet46

As a matter of interest how many of the posters on this thread regularly have to endure this strike? I do and my job is under threat because of it but I'd be really interested how many others actually know what it's like and appreciate it on a daily basis?

It changes your perspective after a while.

I used to. Then after the Brexit vote the Americans moved my job to Dublin so I am now a man of leisure.

As I said before, strikes are almost always due to management either being massively poor or because the management is choosing to precipitate them. I am guessing that in this case it is the latter. In order to accelerate change in the train industry they are being supported by other TOCs and the Government to take on what are relatively aggressive Unions.

I do not believe every Southern train driver or guard is a maverick Marxist doing anything possible to bring down the State. Whether or not the Unions were manipulated into what may become a disastrous strike for them is a moot point. Everyone involved appears to need to take a share of the blame but it is interesting that the Government hasn't banged heads together yet.

You have to ask why.

 

cardiff eagle Flag 14 Dec 16 5.45pm

For those who are saying that they aren't caring about the passengers don't you think this is their last course of action? Talking hasn't worked, southern haven't listened and I believe they want them to strike so they get the public vote and force the changes through.

Put yourself in their positions. Not only might you be made redundant but the industry you care about (people in the rail industry really do tend to care) is going to be made less safe as a result.

This is all about profit and cost cutting, nothing else. Surely safety is more important. The cost of a guard is tiny compared to the fares paid. Imagine a train of 1400 people all paying 25 pounds for a ticket. 1.5 journeys and the guards annual salary is paid for.....

 

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 14 Dec 16 6.08pm

Originally posted by Stuk

You can't contend something you haven't read, it took so long to scroll through it that there is a zero percent chance of me wasting time reading it. It smacks of some s*** copied off of facebook too.

Makes the "don't read this article' link i posted earlier more pertinent.

 

Part Time James Flag 14 Dec 16 6.26pm

Originally posted by Helmet46

As a matter of interest how many of the posters on this thread regularly have to endure this strike? I do and my job is under threat because of it but I'd be really interested how many others actually know what it's like and appreciate it on a daily basis?

It changes your perspective after a while.

I do and am on your side. I have to admit that because I also have the option of an extra 20 minute walk to an alternative station, I can get a Thameslink train and they are running like clockwork on strike days (no broken down Southern trains holding them up). I think I am comparatively lucky in that respect. Well, very lucky. I understand your plight though.

 




.TUX. Flag 14 Dec 16 7.02pm

Originally posted by Helmet46

As a matter of interest how many of the posters on this thread regularly have to endure this strike? I do and my job is under threat because of it but I'd be really interested how many others actually know what it's like and appreciate it on a daily basis?

It changes your perspective after a while.

Never, but i fully appreciate that it must be one helluva ball-ache for those who do.
As has been said many times here, striking is the last 'option' and as i'm sick to death of profit continually being put ahead of people, i'm with those striking.
The Govt (over many years) is to blame for all of this as major infrastructure of a country should NEVER be sold, especially to those who in reality, only want to make money.
And it's at your expense.

 


Buy Litecoin.

elgrande Flag bedford 14 Dec 16 7.32pm

Originally posted by nickgusset

Is it safe if the driver is taken ill or there is an incident?

Southern from my understanding have admitted that the twelve carriage trains do need 2 staff members, but refuse to guarantee that all trains will have 2.

Whilst I understand that shorter off peak trains may be safe enough to only have driver only, it seems the union are convinced that southern will run longer busier trains without a second person

So if a driver gets I'll on a 4 carriage train is OK then......what's the difference.

 


always a Norwood boy, where ever I live.

npn Flag Crowborough 14 Dec 16 9.17pm

Originally posted by Helmet46

As a matter of interest how many of the posters on this thread regularly have to endure this strike? I do and my job is under threat because of it but I'd be really interested how many others actually know what it's like and appreciate it on a daily basis?

It changes your perspective after a while.

I'm afraid I do. During the guard strikes I can make it in (though it can take 3hrs), during the driver strikes it's far harder unless I splash out on a £25 each way cab to get to a South Eastern Station

 

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 14 Dec 16 10.38pm

Originally posted by elgrande

So if a driver gets I'll on a 4 carriage train is OK then......what's the difference.

Not really.

 

legaleagle Flag 14 Dec 16 11.27pm

Originally posted by Mapletree

I used to. Then after the Brexit vote the Americans moved my job to Dublin so I am now a man of leisure.

As I said before, strikes are almost always due to management either being massively poor or because the management is choosing to precipitate them. I am guessing that in this case it is the latter. In order to accelerate change in the train industry they are being supported by other TOCs and the Government to take on what are relatively aggressive Unions.

I do not believe every Southern train driver or guard is a maverick Marxist doing anything possible to bring down the State. Whether or not the Unions were manipulated into what may become a disastrous strike for them is a moot point. Everyone involved appears to need to take a share of the blame but it is interesting that the Government hasn't banged heads together yet.

You have to ask why.

Indeed...and sorry to hear you are currently a man of leisure...

 

Part Time James Flag 15 Dec 16 7.37am

Originally posted by gambler

When the dispute is settled, whichever way, do people who use Southern Trains really believe the day to day service will improve?

No, not really. I guess it will be a marginal improvement on no trains at all though.

 




7mins Flag In the bush 15 Dec 16 9.10am

Got a text last night. Talks are difficult because Southern have limited ability to agree anything with out DfT's say so. It would have been easier if DfT had been involved in yesterday's talks, but I guess they want political plausible deniability. If talks fail and they were there, they'd get shrapnel.
Still think Southern will accept a Scotrail type agreement. This was offered as a compromise months ago, was close to being signed off, but DfT vetoed.

 

legaleagle Flag 15 Dec 16 9.40am

Originally posted by 7mins

Got a text last night. Talks are difficult because Southern have limited ability to agree anything with out DfT's say so. It would have been easier if DfT had been involved in yesterday's talks, but I guess they want political plausible deniability. If talks fail and they were there, they'd get shrapnel.
Still think Southern will accept a Scotrail type agreement. This was offered as a compromise months ago, was close to being signed off, but DfT vetoed.

Which,if right,tells you all you need to know....the Scotrail sensible deal (fair to both) could have been done months ago...without all the recent hassle for commuters but a government ministry vetoed it.....who cares about added commuter misery if you can squeeze some added union bashing and job reductions out of it..ho hum

Edited by legaleagle (15 Dec 2016 9.42am)

 

Sportyteacher Flag London 15 Dec 16 10.35am

Have a listen to the following that MIGHT change your opinion: [Link]

 

Kermit8 Flag Hevon 15 Dec 16 10.48am

Originally posted by Sportyteacher

Have a listen to the following that MIGHT change your opinion: [Link]

Blimey.

"An On-Board Supervisor has nothing do with despatch"


and then it continues...

"John told Nick that he is leaving his job, rather than take on the role of On-Board Supervisor (OBS), stating: "I didn't think I had a choice.

"If I was in a position where I took an OBS role and I had been on a train as an OBS going through one of the stations where I used to dispatch trains from as a conductor, if something went wrong at that station and somebody ended up underneath that train, either injured or killed, I would spend the rest of my life thinking 'If I had been dispatching that train, as I used to, would that person be ok?"

He explains why that conductor's role is so important, adding: "An on-board supervisor has nothing to do with dispatch.

"When a conductor is dispatching a train, a conductor is a second pair of eyes, acting in effect as a safety net for a driver.

"When there is an on-board supervisor on the train, they have nothing to do with dispatch, so the driver is on his own checking whether it's safe to go, he doesn't have a safety net."

Nick asked why a third of services that run successfully as driver-operated trains, but John explains: "Driver-only operation was established when a) there were a lot less people travelling on the trains and b) most of the trains were four and eight car. Now Southern are saying that this needs to be implemented with 12-car trains through very busy stations. It's an entirely different set of circumstances."

Nick responded: "I wish people were as rational as you who are involved in this.

"You are the most intelligent person I've spoken to with regards to management and unions for this entire conflict. I wish you well and I hope there's a resolution."

 


Big chest and massive boobs

[Link]


nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 15 Dec 16 6.49pm

Is it me or have the union bashers gorn a bit quiet on this subject today?

 

Page 26 of 44 < 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Southern Rail Strike - right or wrong