You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > The Roy Hodgson thread
November 16 2026 7.58am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

The Roy Hodgson thread


Page 26 of 65 < 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 >
Maine Eagle Flag USA 10 Mar 19 12.43pm

Originally posted by jeeagles

On the topic of our home form.
3 home wins all season.
4 Draws
4 goals from open play. 1 own goal. The rest are penalties.

We can't score and don't look threatening.
Teams know that if they can get a get a goal they are more than likely to get 3 points. Soaking up pressure against us is easy as we just pass the ball around in front of the oposition and take pot shots.

When the oposition have scored at Selhurst we have picked up 2 points all season.
Brighton did just that yesterday.

Yet it's the same old tactics, starting line up, and substitutes every week.

F me that is embarrassing. That is in 15 games.

One of those was a fluke by MacArthur who was trying to cross it versus Burnley. Another was a worldie from Andros in the same game. Luka vs Leicester was from outside of the box. Only 1 tap in which was from Schlupp against Fulham after Michy’s turn and shot.

 


Trump lost. Badly. Hahahahahahaha.

radsyrendot Flag From Coventry now in Leicester 10 Mar 19 12.46pm

[Link]

A good read and true

 

PZ Eagle Flag Penzance 10 Mar 19 12.51pm

Originally posted by kev64

Nail on the Head .. need to change it up at home ..3-5-2 ? Something at least. Pva should of been subbed at half time , a mare of a game, the midfield were clueless, and one up front against a big defence, zero chance, I could see it after 10 min and I know very little, compared to Roy ..

Ffs that game was screaming out for 2 big guys up front, Sako muscle on the wing and Kayoute in midfield. Cabaye would of taken out that t*** after his challenge on Milo and not one of our team went near him. Soft as s***.

A short time ago posters on here were against Schlupp being moved to left back. Who else, apart from Papa, is a left back. Ward and Kelly ere not left backs.

I find this "lets clobber their players" argument pathetic. This forum goes into melt down when other teams do it to us. Do we really want a cloggers reputation.

 


Conjunctivitis.com - A site for sore eyes.

Wilesy01 Flag Bristol 10 Mar 19 12.57pm

Not convinced Roy knows how to play attacking football on the front foot.

Given we've spent relatively a lot of money on our team to find ourselves struggling to win home games and to score goals isn't really good enough.

 

Plumpton eagle Flag East Sussex 10 Mar 19 1.19pm

There can be no debate that Roy has not got a long term future as manger regardless of his achievements. I hope that succession planning has been ongoing for some time. Maybe Roy will leave with a genuine pat on the back and a big thank you at the end of this season. He would certainly go with my blessings and appreciation of his getting us out of a big hole last season.

I just can't see Roy as the man to move us to the next level. We have stopped progressing and should have moved on from yearly relegation fights by now. Like everyone, I am fed up walking away from Selhurst after yet another disappointing home result. I will keep going of course but do understand others that may not.

I would like to see a new manger in for next season. Who I don't know but surely the club has been working at this in the background? Maybe Roy could stay for a season as a technical adviser/mentor.

I mean no disrespect to Roy but there is a new breed of younger managers that seem more adaptable and flexible. This is surely where our future lies.

 

spartakev2 Flag Anerley 10 Mar 19 2.21pm

There was 2 good examples of managers changing the game yesterday.

Rafa changed to 4 at the back in thd second half and went more direct....

Soton manager made 2 subs at half time and pushed mors players forward.

Both were game changing decisions whicb resulted in wins.

Roy needs to be more flexible and take risks, especially at home.

 

AERO Flag 10 Mar 19 2.27pm

Although I like Roy , My prediction is that Come end of season Steve won’t sack Roy , but they will come to an amicable agreement that Roy will announce his retirement. Nobody loses face so everyone happy . Just my thoughts

 

CT GUY-BIGBALD EAGLE Flag bloomfield 10 Mar 19 2.50pm

Don’t understand why we can not do better than lousy Watford in scouting/signing a modern manager with vision. Yesterday’s loss purely on the manager. And that was one of many times this season. Time to thank RH and move on to the next phase with is club. Our overall result does not tally With the quality players we have,

 

JohnB Flag 10 Mar 19 2.53pm

Originally posted by AERO

Although I like Roy , My prediction is that Come end of season Steve won’t sack Roy , but they will come to an amicable agreement that Roy will announce his retirement. Nobody loses face so everyone happy . Just my thoughts

I can't see Roy leaving at the end of the season as there aren't many managers that would work in the Premier League with our limited budget. Roy has a job for as long as he wants all the time we're relatively safe from relegation and have a lack of finances.

 

Painter Flag Croydon 10 Mar 19 4.06pm

The usual complaints about Roy after a defeat, where we dominated the game and got done by a punt upfield in a swirling wind and somewhat unfortunate wonder goal from outside the box.
Roys remit is to keep us in the Premier, whether that means winning home or way is irrelevant, as long as we remain. We haven't been in the bottom 3 all season, in fact 16th has been our lowest point. The January transfer market indicated we are getting rid of fringe players that never get a game and new players recruited in the summer.
The expectation that we should win every game against teams around us, just isn't going to happen, all teams lose. The entitlement of some is strange, Bournemouth lost games in a row away recently, do you think their fans were calling for Howe to go?
Roy is an experienced manager and will keep us up comfortably.

 

Maine Eagle Flag USA 10 Mar 19 4.09pm

Originally posted by Wilesy01

Not convinced Roy knows how to play attacking football on the front foot.

Given we've spent relatively a lot of money on our team to find ourselves struggling to win home games and to score goals isn't really good enough.

I am convinced he doesn’t.

I believe it is 7 goals from open play in 15 games plus pens.

It took us 7 games to even score a goal from open play.

You don’t score an embrassingly low total of 7 goals from open play in 15 home games unless you have a problem.

Edited by Maine Eagle (10 Mar 2019 4.21pm)

 


Trump lost. Badly. Hahahahahahaha.

PatrickA Flag London 10 Mar 19 4.24pm

Why do some people feel Roy is immune from criticism?
We may have had more possession yesterday (60%) but we hardly dominated the game in an attacking sense.
I don’t recall their keeper making a serious save and we never looked like opening them up.
I accept he has us organised defensively but cannot see any evidence of innovation in the final third from basics , such as set pieces, through to switches of position or change of formations.
If people are happy with this, they are entitled to their opinions, but there has to be the equal right to voice concerns about our terrible home performances.
Yesterday was by no means a one off and can any of us seriously foresee a dramatic improvement in home form when we are so predictable?

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 10 Mar 19 7.00pm

Originally posted by dynamicdick

It is up to us to have the guile to break them down which, we were incapable of. Roy’s job and even if Brighton’s set up took him by surprise (God knows why), then he should have made changes at half time, one of those being Meyer. While we are at it leaving Kouyate out was brainless; it was a derby and his toughness was needed. As an aside i thought the atmosphere today was subdued.

I have it on good authority he had a slight back injury. Cannot understand not giving Meyer a start, he must be p***ed off only getting 15 minutes when we are losing

 

dynamicdick Flag Dormansland 10 Mar 19 7.17pm

Originally posted by Painter

The usual complaints about Roy after a defeat, where we dominated the game and got done by a punt upfield in a swirling wind and somewhat unfortunate wonder goal from outside the box.
Roys remit is to keep us in the Premier, whether that means winning home or way is irrelevant, as long as we remain. We haven't been in the bottom 3 all season, in fact 16th has been our lowest point. The January transfer market indicated we are getting rid of fringe players that never get a game and new players recruited in the summer.
The expectation that we should win every game against teams around us, just isn't going to happen, all teams lose. The entitlement of some is strange, Bournemouth lost games in a row away recently, do you think their fans were calling for Howe to go?
Roy is an experienced manager and will keep us up comfortably.

What an ambition ..... just staying up. After last season we should have kicked on but didn’t. Where we are at present is unacceptable and I really wish we all stopped looking down but instead up to at least 10th which, with this team we are more than capable of achieving. Too much acceptance of mediocrity and this is centred on our home form which, if taken in isolation would see us relegated. We won’t go down IMO but this is nothing to be proud of!

 


Bring back Brolin

Cucking Funt Flag Clapham on the Back 10 Mar 19 7.41pm

I despair of some so-called “fans”.

Is Palace Talk returning to the dark days of sheer stupidity? Looks like it is.

 


Wife beating may be socially acceptable in Sheffield, but it is a different matter in Cheltenham

Maine Eagle Flag USA 10 Mar 19 7.43pm

Originally posted by Cucking Funt

I despair of some so-called “fans”.

Is Palace Talk returning to the dark days of sheer stupidity? Looks like it is.

3 wins at home.

7 straight games without a goal.

7 goals from open play in 15 games.

Great performances away, utter dross at home = same players.

I would prefer a manager who can get us firing home and away after all of these years in the premier league.

 


Trump lost. Badly. Hahahahahahaha.

southnorwoodhill Flag 10 Mar 19 7.48pm

Originally posted by Maine Eagle

3 wins at home.

7 straight games without a goal.

7 goals from open play in 15 games.

Great performances away, utter dross at home = same players.

I would prefer a manager who can get us firing home and away after all of these years in the premier league.

Actually just winning at home would be a start, there are no extra points to be had by winning away...

 

Rachid Rachid Rachid Flag 10 Mar 19 8.01pm

Don’t care whether the points come home or away as long as they come. Roy got a tune out of us at home last season because he had a better squad than the one he has now with more decent attacking midfield options.

As for the next level, give it up there isn’t one. Sound like Charlton.

 

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 10 Mar 19 9.02pm

Originally posted by Maine Eagle

3 wins at home.

7 straight games without a goal.

7 goals from open play in 15 games.

Great performances away, utter dross at home = same players.

I would prefer a manager who can get us firing home and away after all of these years in the premier league.

Well so would I. I'm as fed up as anyone with our home record.

But Hodgson has been manager for ( almost ) 2 seasons out of 6. So it's hardly a new scenario.

Yep, love to have a manager that can get the home form to match the away form. If Hodgson had achieved that then on the assumption that we would have amassed the same points at home as we have away, then we would currently be 9th. That's ahead of West Ham and Everton, both who have spent fortunes in recent transfer windows. We would also be potentially competing for that poison chalice of a Europa League spot.

I don't agree with all of Hodgson's team selections, tactics or use of subs. Nor did I with those of a number of his predecessors. But I do think he's a good fit for the club at this moment in time.

So for a number of you, Hodgson has to go.

Fair enough. Yet to hear of a sensible suggestion as to who should come in though.

 


Old, Ungifted and White

PZ Eagle Flag Penzance 10 Mar 19 10.07pm

Originally posted by NEILLO

So for a number of you, Hodgson has to go.

Fair enough. Yet to hear of a sensible suggestion as to who should come in though.

They haven't got one that's why you haven't heard of one. Oh except for a daft comment that there must be one somewhere in the world we haven't heard of.

 


Conjunctivitis.com - A site for sore eyes.

Page 26 of 65 < 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > The Roy Hodgson thread