You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > CONservative government incompetence.
November 20 2026 6.21am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

CONservative government incompetence.


Page 260 of 362 < 256 257 258 259 260 261 262 263 264 >
EverybodyDannsNow Flag SE19 09 Feb 23 1.48pm

[Link]

 

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 09 Feb 23 4.05pm

Lee Anderson has a point about Food Banks.

Too often the media and especially the BBC parrot the line that nurses and fireman have to visit food banks without backing any of this up with facts.

Just how true is it that someone on £30-35 needs to visit a food bank. Anderson has thrown down the gauntlet and asked the BBC to produce someone which is why they are making a big fuss about the row he had with the Radio Presenter, they would rather focus on that instead.

He also said if they could produce someone he would help them, I assume the means he would check if they are claiming the correct in work benefits and help them manage their money.

Anyway I hope the BBC do respond.

 


One more point

EverybodyDannsNow Flag SE19 09 Feb 23 4.47pm

Originally posted by Badger11

Lee Anderson has a point about Food Banks.

Too often the media and especially the BBC parrot the line that nurses and fireman have to visit food banks without backing any of this up with facts.

Just how true is it that someone on £30-35 needs to visit a food bank. Anderson has thrown down the gauntlet and asked the BBC to produce someone which is why they are making a big fuss about the row he had with the Radio Presenter, they would rather focus on that instead.

He also said if they could produce someone he would help them, I assume the means he would check if they are claiming the correct in work benefits and help them manage their money.

Anyway I hope the BBC do respond.

Of course it's true.

£30k a year gross is about £24k a year net, so £2k a month.

Average rent in London is £1.5-1.6k conservatively with utilities and council tax on top - that's your £2k basically done.

Even if you find somewhere for £1200 PCM on rent, you're leaving £300 a month for travel, food and essentials. Impossible.

If you have kids or dependents the numbers make even less sense.

That whole argument is also centred around this idea that people doing jobs as important as nursing or firefighting should be happy saving lives all day for money which does not afford them any sort of social life, hobby or luxury. Is that a reasonable expectation?

"Yeah you may do life saving work, but if you ate nothing but oats and pasta 7 days a week, you wouldn't need the food bank!" is not the win some people seem to think it is.

At the same time as demonising key workers for being poor and not being able to budget, our Lee claims £223k a year in expenses on top of his salary.


Edited by EverybodyDannsNow (09 Feb 2023 4.49pm)

 

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 09 Feb 23 4.55pm

Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow

Of course it's true.

£30k a year gross is about £24k a year net, so £2k a month.

Average rent in London is £1.5-1.6k conservatively with utilities and council tax on top - that's your £2k basically done.

Even if you find somewhere for £1200 PCM on rent, you're leaving £300 a month for travel, food and essentials. Impossible.

If you have kids or dependents the numbers make even less sense.

That whole argument is also centred around this idea that people doing jobs as important as nursing or firefighting should be happy saving lives all day for money which does not afford them any sort of social life, hobby or luxury. Is that a reasonable expectation?

"Yeah you may do life saving work, but if you ate nothing but oats and pasta 7 days a week, you wouldn't need the food bank!" is not the win some people seem to think it is.

At the same time as demonising key workers for being poor and not being able to budget, our Lee claims £223k a year in expenses on top of his salary.


Edited by EverybodyDannsNow (09 Feb 2023 4.49pm)

In which case the BBC will have no problems finding volunteers and showing Lee Anderson up.

PS you forgot to include child benefit and possibly in work benefits but I take your point. If the facts support you let's see the detail on the BBC.

Edited by Badger11 (09 Feb 2023 4.57pm)

 


One more point

Teddy Eagle Flag 09 Feb 23 4.58pm

Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow

Of course it's true.

£30k a year gross is about £24k a year net, so £2k a month.

Average rent in London is £1.5-1.6k conservatively with utilities and council tax on top - that's your £2k basically done.

Even if you find somewhere for £1200 PCM on rent, you're leaving £300 a month for travel, food and essentials. Impossible.

If you have kids or dependents the numbers make even less sense.

That whole argument is also centred around this idea that people doing jobs as important as nursing or firefighting should be happy saving lives all day for money which does not afford them any sort of social life, hobby or luxury. Is that a reasonable expectation?

"Yeah you may do life saving work, but if you ate nothing but oats and pasta 7 days a week, you wouldn't need the food bank!" is not the win some people seem to think it is.

At the same time as demonising key workers for being poor and not being able to budget, our Lee claims £223k a year in expenses on top of his salary.


Edited by EverybodyDannsNow (09 Feb 2023 4.49pm)

And the old age pension is under £10,000 PA so all these life savers will find it a lot tougher when they've retired.

 

EverybodyDannsNow Flag SE19 09 Feb 23 5.05pm

Originally posted by Badger11

In which case the BBC will have no problems finding volunteers and showing Lee Anderson up.

PS you forgot to include child benefit and possibly in work benefits but I take your point. If the facts support you let's see the detail on the BBC.

Edited by Badger11 (09 Feb 2023 4.57pm)

Yeah, who wouldn't volunteer to that - go and broadcast to the world how poor you are so you can have everyone pick apart every life decision you make.

What do you mean if the facts support me... I've just typed out the facts - if you don't agree, what would you challenge in the numbers?

Include child benefit if you'd like and tell me how you'd make the money work.

 

EverybodyDannsNow Flag SE19 09 Feb 23 5.10pm

Originally posted by Teddy Eagle

And the old age pension is under £10,000 PA so all these life savers will find it a lot tougher when they've retired.

Absolutely, and that's another disgusting stain our society.

There are stories of pensioners dying every week who can't afford to turn heating on or eat properly.

 

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 09 Feb 23 5.20pm

Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow

Yeah, who wouldn't volunteer to that - go and broadcast to the world how poor you are so you can have everyone pick apart every life decision you make.

What do you mean if the facts support me... I've just typed out the facts - if you don't agree, what would you challenge in the numbers?

Include child benefit if you'd like and tell me how you'd make the money work.

And what about Housing benefit?

My point is that unless we see a payslip what benefits they claim what rent they pay and what their debts are it's all speculation. You have not provided facts you have provided an example not quite the same thing.

If people don't want to back up their claims I quite understand but then the BBC should stop making claims they cannot prove.

I am not saying that no fireman or nurse has ever gone to a food bank what we don't now is why?

If somebody was in debt due to gambling that is the reason why they visited a food bank not because they are a nurse.

That is why you need specific examples to identify people who really did need to go to a food bank as their salary was insufficient.

 


One more point

EverybodyDannsNow Flag SE19 09 Feb 23 5.38pm

Originally posted by Badger11

And what about Housing benefit?

My point is that unless we see a payslip what benefits they claim what rent they pay and what their debts are it's all speculation. You have not provided facts you have provided an example not quite the same thing.

If people don't want to back up their claims I quite understand but then the BBC should stop making claims they cannot prove.

I am not saying that no fireman or nurse has ever gone to a food bank what we don't now is why?

If somebody was in debt due to gambling that is the reason why they visited a food bank not because they are a nurse.

That is why you need specific examples to identify people who really did need to go to a food bank as their salary was insufficient.

Sorry I think your position is really quite disingenuous - the idea that you can’t estimate someone’s take home salary, rent and living expenses to a reasonable degree of accuracy is silly.

Of course people have specific situations but we have more than enough information to draw general conclusions - you just don’t like the conclusions so you’d rather pretend we can’t.

Include housing benefit, include child support, include a gambling problem and tell me how someone on £30k a year makes ends meet based on the average cost of living in London.

 

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 09 Feb 23 6.07pm

Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow

Sorry I think your position is really quite disingenuous - the idea that you can’t estimate someone’s take home salary, rent and living expenses to a reasonable degree of accuracy is silly.

Of course people have specific situations but we have more than enough information to draw general conclusions - you just don’t like the conclusions so you’d rather pretend we can’t.

Include housing benefit, include child support, include a gambling problem and tell me how someone on £30k a year makes ends meet based on the average cost of living in London.

We shall have to disagree. We are discussing someone who has to go to a food bank not whether Nurses deserve more money because they do.

 


One more point

cryrst Flag The garden of England 09 Feb 23 6.30pm

Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow

Yeah, who wouldn't volunteer to that - go and broadcast to the world how poor you are so you can have everyone pick apart every life decision you make.

What do you mean if the facts support me... I've just typed out the facts - if you don't agree, what would you challenge in the numbers?

Include child benefit if you'd like and tell me how you'd make the money work.

Well you could just suck it up
and accept that life ain’t designed to be easy. Change how you live or move. Get a better job or really do what my first line is. Please don’t do the how do you know, I’ve got the book, t shirt and done the movie.

 

steeleye20 Flag Croydon 09 Feb 23 8.58pm

'HS2 is so expensive because ‘we are more responsible builders than the French and Chinese'.

How ridiculous.

Only when I 'larf.

Then we read that 'responsible' HS2 is discharging raw sewage into the River Colne already 5 times this year.

Only the basic still applies to HS2, it will connect Birmingham to Euston everything else has been discarded, and it may not actually reach Euston until 2038.

Its nothing more than a gravy train for a rich elite, its analogue in a digital age.


 

Teddy Eagle Flag 09 Feb 23 9.10pm

Originally posted by steeleye20

'HS2 is so expensive because ‘we are more responsible builders than the French and Chinese'.

How ridiculous.

Only when I 'larf.

Then we read that 'responsible' HS2 is discharging raw sewage into the River Colne already 5 times this year.

Only the basic still applies to HS2, it will connect Birmingham to Euston everything else has been discarded, and it may not actually reach Euston until 2038.

Its nothing more than a gravy train for a rich elite, its analogue in a digital age.


That's what happens when you contract out to a Swedish firm.

 

EverybodyDannsNow Flag SE19 09 Feb 23 9.18pm

Originally posted by cryrst



Well you could just suck it up

and accept that life ain’t designed to be easy. Change how you live or move. Get a better job or really do what my first line is. Please don’t do the how do you know, I’ve got the book, t shirt and done the movie.

Brilliant.

 

steeleye20 Flag Croydon 09 Feb 23 9.23pm

Originally posted by Teddy Eagle

That's what happens when you contract out to a Swedish firm.

'Italy launches new Rome-Milan high speed train: 2 hours and 45 minutes'.

The whole HS2 project was unnecessary.

 

Teddy Eagle Flag 09 Feb 23 9.38pm

Originally posted by steeleye20

'Italy launches new Rome-Milan high speed train: 2 hours and 45 minutes'.

The whole HS2 project was unnecessary.

But it reduces the carbon footprint.

 

Mapletree Flag Croydon 09 Feb 23 11.57pm

Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow

Of course it's true.

£30k a year gross is about £24k a year net, so £2k a month.

Average rent in London is £1.5-1.6k conservatively with utilities and council tax on top - that's your £2k basically done.

Even if you find somewhere for £1200 PCM on rent, you're leaving £300 a month for travel, food and essentials. Impossible.

If you have kids or dependents the numbers make even less sense.

That whole argument is also centred around this idea that people doing jobs as important as nursing or firefighting should be happy saving lives all day for money which does not afford them any sort of social life, hobby or luxury. Is that a reasonable expectation?

"Yeah you may do life saving work, but if you ate nothing but oats and pasta 7 days a week, you wouldn't need the food bank!" is not the win some people seem to think it is.

At the same time as demonising key workers for being poor and not being able to budget, our Lee claims £223k a year in expenses on top of his salary.


Edited by EverybodyDannsNow (09 Feb 2023 4.49pm)

£23,474 net.

Anderson started with £30k then tried to argue for £35k.

I believe the discussion was about a family, so more than one bedroom presumably.

Portico analysed 26,417 rental properties currently available on Rightmove (as of May 2021) throughout all 32 London boroughs, to find the most affordable places to rent in and around the capital.

The research found that the average rental price in London is currently £1,832 per month, with the average rental for a two-bedroom property at £1,800 per month. So £21,600.

There was no discussion about additional housing support or other allowances

So Anderson thinks you can feed, cloth and keep a family warm for less than £2,000 per annum.

EDN is entirety correct and Anderson is living on another planet.

 

Teddy Eagle Flag 10 Feb 23 12.19am

Originally posted by Mapletree

£23,474 net.

Anderson started with £30k then tried to argue for £35k.

I believe the discussion was about a family, so more than one bedroom presumably.

Portico analysed 26,417 rental properties currently available on Rightmove (as of May 2021) throughout all 32 London boroughs, to find the most affordable places to rent in and around the capital.

The research found that the average rental price in London is currently £1,832 per month, with the average rental for a two-bedroom property at £1,800 per month. So £21,600.

There was no discussion about additional housing support or other allowances

So Anderson thinks you can feed, cloth and keep a family warm for less than £2,000 per annum.

EDN is entirety correct and Anderson is living on another planet.

Assuming only one income.

 

cryrst Flag The garden of England 10 Feb 23 5.08am

Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow

Brilliant.

Ok so you have just got a mortgage and good luck sincerely with it. It is a long slow drag. What if you get to a point where you are struggling. What will you personally do ?

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 10 Feb 23 6.04am

Originally posted by Badger11

In which case the BBC will have no problems finding volunteers and showing Lee Anderson up.

PS you forgot to include child benefit and possibly in work benefits but I take your point. If the facts support you let's see the detail on the BBC.

He did cover himself by saying "find someone in Ashfield" and I agree with him that in many parts of the country where rents are cheaper it is possible to live on a nurses income without resorting to food banks.

Rents in the town in which I live are from £600 to £700 per month for a reasonable two bedroomed house or flat

 

Page 260 of 362 < 256 257 258 259 260 261 262 263 264 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > CONservative government incompetence.