This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by Badger11
I've mainly kept out of this thread but does anyone think that the EU inviting Ukraine and Moldova to join them is baiting the bear? The EU should be inviting Russia to do some form of trade agreement with the EU in return for a deal over the Ukraine. Going to pop on and answer this one and apologies about the length of the reply, but with topics like this, they often need to be unpacked in detail with lots of context. For too long many people in the West have kind of held Russia with this odd sense of denialism and exceptionalism. I.e. We in the West should hold ourselves or at least our politicians to a certain level of accountability based on treaties, convention and international prescedent. But Russia, nah they are good they dont need to! To be VERY clear, we in the West are FAR from perfect, but what I find fascinating is how people can correctly point many times the West has pushed the boundaries, found itself on untested ground politically or just flat out broken the rules it helped to create, but when the same logic is applied to Russia (who also created those same rules), as if my magic those same rules just don't apply and nor should they ever have needed to! If you were to perhaps try and point this out, the response seems to be a) ignore the point b) ignore the point but bait you back with 'whataboutism' or c) just flat out make stuff up to try and soften what Russia has done. If I may go into more detail about said rules, since 1945 and the founding of the UN Charter reinforced by the Helsinki Accords in 1975. The general consensus throughout the world has been that countries are soveriegn, borders (<-- take note of this) don't just change because one country just wants them to and might above all should not make right. At this point I need to stress, this wasn't a set of rules just created by the West to 'bash the commies' the USSR actually helped draft and signed both the UN charter and the Helsinki Accords it and it's successor state (Russia) would often hold the West to account when they saw violation of these rules. So one would have thought it had an equal share in accountability no? Now, did this stop foriegn intervations and wars? Of course not. If anything it may have actually increased it. Korea (50-53) Vietnam (55-75) and the gulf war (91) all triggered police action wars because one side often wanted to just roll in the tanks like it was 1939 all over again and change a border. Did countries still bomb and intervene in other countries internal affairs, prop up governments they like, depose those they thought were a threat to the region, interfere if trade and / or were trying to proliferate? Absolutely! Suez (56), Hungary (56), Czechoslovakia (6 However here is the crucial difference which Russia is now downplaying, none of those conflicts involved a member of the UN security country just lopping off a countries terrority and keeping it because they felt like it. Thats what is happening now, this isn't just about trying to enforce your will or viewpoint on a country but deny the country it's right to exist full stop. This is the crux of the issue and where things start to get perverse. Ukraine, Moldova and Russia have had a very long history together - it's absolutely true. But they have always been three distinct peoples even during the height of the USSR. After the fall of the Soviet Union there was quite a bit of tension as to if Russian should be bound by what the Soviet's considered to be Ukrainian and Russian terrority (i'm going to leave Moldova out for the time being because they are super complicated but the general principal still applies). Given Russia was the official sucessor state to the USSR and it found itself neighbouring by now many independant nation states all armed with Soviet nuclear weapons and with different foreign policy aims this no doubt concerned Russia. Fair enough right? Behold another treaty! Budapest essentially asked Russia to put it's territorial concerns on paper with regards to Ukraine and can be boiled down to. "Now I (Ukraine) am going to give up many of my nuclear and offensive weaponary, so you can feel safer, can you please confirm you are happy with our borders?" "Okay thanks, yes thats fine. I (russia) respect your sovereignty and territorial integrity I won't use force against you, thanks for giving your nukes over to me" (3 years later) [Link] "I (Ukraine) detect some cocern on your part, are you sure you don't have any concerns about the borders? Perhaps we could work together on certan things?" "Yes I (Russia) am fine, we can be friends, force is not a way to settle our differences, we are two people with much in common". All good right? What changes? Putin changes Russia thats what. So to him, Ukraine, Belarus and all the other former SSRs can be 'indepedant' as long as they do what Russia wants. Forget that none of the treaties Ukraine has signed bind Ukraine to this viewpoint. Fast forward to 2010 and those Ukrainians have gone and elected a president (Yanukovych) who ran on a platform of economic modernisation and increasing trade links with the EU (this was literally in his manifesto). Oh he won! four years later he has drafted a treaty with the EU, ignore the fact he undid alot of reforms his predessors created during the Orange revolution (https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-europe-2012088 Uh oh! Russia doesn't like this, this violates Putins rules about the legitimacy of Ukrainian indepedance that at this point only exist in his mind) Yanukovych backslides after Russia pressures them with economic sanctions. What his people and party protest him for breaking a key campaign promise then impeach him for not doing what he would say he would do in his manifesto (sign a treaty with the EU)? Thats not very democratic, must be a COUP! THE CIA! COUP! EU HOW COULD YOU!? This is where it goes very wrong and where I actually finally answer your question. Russia has had to work overtime to invent this narrative in which it gets to just flat out annex territory as a form as punishment. It does this by presenting itself as the victim. "I was baited, I was wronged etc". Doesnt matter that all the treaties it agreed to since 1945 dont support it's viewpoint, countries only get to be sovereign and make their own decisions when Russia feels it okay and above all - thats the rule! It's always been the rule!, I'm the victom! So to recap, the whole 'baiting the bear' thing is just line to infer that Russia is the victim of [insert western organisation / person in here], has been total rubbish for decades if not centuries and always be unless we want to go back to a total war type world where countries just play a real life version of risk, it always will be. For now most Westerners and their government see what Russia is doing and decide to push back, hence the support for Ukraine. Thanks
|
|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
I don't have inside information on the current military situation or the overall global strategy of the US and its allies or Russia. OF course, Russia started the military conflict in Ukraine, which appears to threaten Europe and my only concern is the safety of those I care about. As someone who lives in the West, I rely on Western governments to protect my interests. I cannot make choices on how they choose to do that or to what degree my circumstances and others like me are considered in that scenario. I agree, it's pointless trying to argue on here as many people (being honest you can probably include me in this category too) have made their decision based on the evidence they (want to) see in front of them. What is striking on Western social media or even sites like this is no one can openly support Russia because what they have done is totally indefensible they no this, so the argyement switches to a kind of 'Ukraine bad' type discussion. Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
We don't have the bigger picture, and so we can only guess at the real motivations behind a strategy. Respectfully, we kind of actually do. Ukraine's motivations for fighting this war are to continue existing as an independant nation state. Russia's motivations are actually easy to find because Putin is the kind of person who thinks he is smarter than he actually is, hence the literny of boring essays where he actually talks about how he views Russia's relationship with Ukraine. This is why i've always found it odd how the pro-russians on here will always tell me what Putin's motivations are or claim ignorance even what presented with speeches or articles written by Putin explaining what his motivations are. Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
The global game of chess is on going and will continue until humans no longer exist. If money and power drive policy as it does most things, then nuclear war seems counterproductive in the biggest possible way. Only a state or group driven by warped ideology would consider such insanity. If there was ever a chance that Russia could cosy up to the West and become allied, then this disappeared after that brief moment of hope after the collapse of the USSR. I think this is a very astute comment. After the fall of the USSR Russia actually tried to run it's country as an actual democracy. The issue is Russia (even the Russian federation) is not a natural creation. It's terrority and borders stems from centuries of colonialism and autocray. The only thing which has kep the darned country together has been autocracy, demographic manipulation and borderline genocide. The reason we in the West don't realise this because the terroritory Russia colonised is directly bordered to the the beginnings of Russia (Muscovy). When Yeltsin essentially did silly things like allow for free press, self determination, actually upholding the USSRs commitment to a rules based order and even strengthening it, his country collapsed into anarchy and Russian's never really forgave him for it. Hence the whole "doesn count" line when ever anyone points out why Russia's invasion is so wrong. Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
Personally, In the current circumstances, I am for negotiation but with strength. Negotiating in retreat is never a great idea. Putin needs a victory, and the West needs to show that it is ready to crush potential future incursions into NATO territory. Somewhere in there, a compromise has to be found. I don't see how Ukraine can be sacrificed, but equally, there must be a clear understanding about the future of Ukraine which allows for independence and no official allegiance to Russia or NATO. Again this is really on the money. The issue is as i've pointed out. Russia isn't willing to actually negiotiate in good faith. A lasting peace needs concessions by both sides. Ask the pro-russian lot on here what Russia should concede and you get either silence or the promise that Russia 'wont take MOAR territory'. As pointed out, even how hopeless Russia has been on the battlefield this gives Kyiv no reason to negiotiate. Russia knows it's being uncooperative so it projects with statements like "Ukraine is not serious!" This is because it needs it's supports to keep up a narrative that it is Ukraine that must conceed 100% and Russia not at all. Secondly, even if we could negiotiate with Putin, none of the Pro-Russians have found a way to actually enforce a treaty given Putin's previous for violating them. The only replies i've gotten are for a re-run of Budapest (94) violated by Russia or for a 'DMZ' to be put in place which hilariously we had from 2014-2022 and also... did not stop Russia. I genuinely think Ukraines door is open to negiotiation, but demands such as "Surrender please" or "let us run your country" don't really seem overly appealing.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
I don't have inside information on the current military situation or the overall global strategy of the US and its allies or Russia. OF course, Russia started the military conflict in Ukraine, which appears to threaten Europe and my only concern is the safety of those I care about. As someone who lives in the West, I rely on Western governments to protect my interests. I cannot make choices on how they choose to do that or to what degree my circumstances and others like me are considered in that scenario. We don't have the bigger picture, and so we can only guess at the real motivations behind a strategy. Personally, In the current circumstances, I am for negotiation but with strength. Negotiating in retreat is never a great idea. Putin needs a victory, and the West needs to show that it is ready to crush potential future incursions into NATO territory. Somewhere in there, a compromise has to be found. I don't see how Ukraine can be sacrificed, but equally, there must be a clear understanding about the future of Ukraine which allows for independence and no official allegiance to Russia or NATO. Yours is the common sense approach. I've learnt to look at the claims of both sides, I grew up in the 80s like you and remember the first cold war...I saw the Berlin wall come down and what happened in Russia after, the relationship with Nato, the Serbian war.......So this situation let's just say I don't go with the mainstream western narrative and only partly agree with Russia's....while being against the decision to invade as I've always said....Essentially the reasons that are all earlier in the thread. However, I'm English and I while I might disagree with my government my interests are for my island, not some foreign land, Ukraine or Russia...Not quite country right or wrong but my country all the same. We are part of Nato, the strength of Nato should be focused upon its members (Turkey shouldn't be in it and it expanded against our interests). Instead we have foolishly become involved militarily and now find ourselves at a significant disadvantage. I suspect we have lost people over there who shouldn't have officially been there but it's being kept quiet. This war ends in negotiation....it's not going to be a good one for Ukraine now. It's not going to be a negotiation from strength and that's the difference between what was practically possible long term and what people prefer to be the case. People will see that not negotiating in March 21 was madness. The deal will be much worse for Ukraine. Nevertheless, afterwards Nato can start building up behind a demilitarized zone.....and hopefully a Trump can de-escalate from these cold war boomers who aren't living in today's world. Edited by Stirlingsays (17 Dec 2023 5.02pm)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
The reasoning that the NATO countries should only focus on their own defence so should, as a consequence, not be providing support to Ukraine seems to lie at the heart of the argument from those who are prepared to appease Putin. The truth is, of course, providing indirect support to Ukraine is also acting in their own defence. We live in an ever shrinking world. One in which what happens on the other side reverberates here. How much more so when the event is on your doorstep? The USA came to our aid during WW2 because it understood that what would happen in Europe if it didn’t would ultimately threaten them too. The creation of NATO subsequently was the practical embodiment of that realisation only then it was the USSR and not Germany where the threat existed. Recently we have had a populist President undermining the whole idea of NATO. Someone who could still do damage and whose supporters are now trying political tricks to allow their support to continue. Is it any wonder that Putin organised support for Trump and interfered in the 2016 election in the way he did? Talk about 5th columnists! You don’t need to look very far! I am as English as anyone else here but I have enough common sense to realise that ensuring our own peace and prosperity involves a great deal more than only concentrating on ourselves. I would love to think that Russia is a peace loving country we can trust and deal with. Maybe one day it will be, but not now. For now we must protect ourselves and our friends. Including those in Ukraine. This, this and this! We have a country making real tangible movement to becoming less corrupt, more democratic and more accountable. Being attacked by a country which is fundamentally hostile to those values on a path way to Lebensraum. Essentially what we have is the chance for one of our greatest threats to be severely weakened for less than 10% of our defence spending. Money already spent. Helping isn't just our moral duty. It's literally to our benefit and will likely save British lives in the future once appeasement fails.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
The reasoning that the NATO countries should only focus on their own defence so should, as a consequence, not be providing support to Ukraine seems to lie at the heart of the argument from those who are prepared to appease Putin. The truth is, of course, providing indirect support to Ukraine is also acting in their own defence. We live in an ever shrinking world. One in which what happens on the other side reverberates here. How much more so when the event is on your doorstep? The USA came to our aid during WW2 because it understood that what would happen in Europe if it didn’t would ultimately threaten them too. The creation of NATO subsequently was the practical embodiment of that realisation only then it was the USSR and not Germany where the threat existed. Recently we have had a populist President undermining the whole idea of NATO. Someone who could still do damage and whose supporters are now trying political tricks to allow their support to continue. Is it any wonder that Putin organised support for Trump and interfered in the 2016 election in the way he did? Talk about 5th columnists! You don’t need to look very far! I am as English as anyone else here but I have enough common sense to realise that ensuring our own peace and prosperity involves a great deal more than only concentrating on ourselves. I would love to think that Russia is a peace loving country we can trust and deal with. Maybe one day it will be, but not now. For now we must protect ourselves and our friends. Including those in Ukraine. Let's not forget that we paid a price for that aid...... we had to give them the design for the jet engine and we repaid over £3 billion to the US and 2 billion to Canada from the end of the war to 2006. I doubt that we will ever see anything back from Ukraine for our aid - except of footage of barely trained 'soldiers' indiscriminately firing millions of pounds worth of shells at indeterminate targets. Forgive me if I resent my tax money being used for this.....
A stairway to Heaven and a Highway to Hell give some indication of expected traffic numbers |
|
|
Originally posted by becky
Let's not forget that we paid a price for that aid...... we had to give them the design for the jet engine and we repaid over £3 billion to the US and 2 billion to Canada from the end of the war to 2006. I doubt that we will ever see anything back from Ukraine for our aid - except of footage of barely trained 'soldiers' indiscriminately firing millions of pounds worth of shells at indeterminate targets. Forgive me if I resent my tax money being used for this..... Do you resent any of your taxes being spent on defence? For this is essentially the same purpose. So far as I am aware we haven’t imposed conditions on the assistance offered to Ukraine. Remember the USA didn’t just send equipment. They sent men.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
You will notice that this guy regularly defends what he supports by saying, 'yeah it's a crap outcome, but it'd have been much worse'.....People should remember the promises that were made when these approaches were being sold to them. Imagine a failing football manager or any manager at work coming out with that. In the real world that doesn't work and they get the sack....but with elites there is no one above them to sack them and many of those supporting and enabling these decisions aren't even subject to being voted out. Regardless, there will be the end result to this and we will see who supported what policies and what the result is.....It's going to be pretty bad for Ukraine and those who didn't support March 21 are not going to do well. The policy towards Russia has been the wrong one since the nineties and it is hardly me just saying it or the DR....There are high ranking diplomats who were warning about the direction of travel ten years ago.....they were ignored and here we are. But apparently not getting into wars is appeasement. These people are why the country is heading towards penury. Biden's running because he doesn't trust the next lot to keep him out of jail, he has a lot of enemies even within the Democratic party....Trump's running because of the same reason. The difference between them is Trump is more popular with the voters....but both of them are too old and unsuitable. Biden is even more damaging in terms of foreign policy as leaders know he's not all there half the time. America has suffered a massive loss in soft power since he's been in power. Edited by Stirlingsays (17 Dec 2023 11.32pm) Don’t bother taking up chess.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Mapletree
Don’t bother taking up chess. Little late for that.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.