This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
It's almost like some people get to an old age and just never learn anything from history. Anyone remember Stalin? Anyone? Remember that war we had with Stalin when he invaded Hungry anyone? Anyone? No, I don't either....because we didn't have one. We made numerous agreements with Stalin....A guy who actually did have plans to take over most of Europe and partly did due to decisions we took in WW2 but don't talk about. The point being that once agreements are reached with Putin Nato is free to build up behind that demilitarised zone. No one needs to 'trust' do they....If Nato don't trust Putin then build up the militaries. Putin has said he isn't interested in attacking Nato but you know....apparently you can live with Stalin, who killed tens of millions but Putin....nope. These points are so obvious it's painful to have to make them because this stuff is going to happen anyway and all he has is blowhard waffle to try to cover the bad chess player stances he defended. As for his attitude towards BRICs....it's like he just doesn't follow what's going on...the very reason they exist. Like discussing reality with someone living on a cloud. There is reality and then there is what he's chewing. The very attitude he has is the reason they are there in the first place. Edited by Stirlingsays (18 Dec 2023 8.30pm) I love these examples you keep picking, they really are great examples of shooting your arguments in the foot. Firstly Stalin did not invade Hungary as he had been dead for 3 years. It was Khrushchev. Stalin did threaten the allies a few years earlier when he blockaded West Berlin, the allies just ignored it and he relented. Almost as if calling the Russians bluff has consistently been a good policy. Thanks for highlighting. Secondly, Hungary is a great example because the US did want to directly intervene in the crisis, however Britain and France attacked Egypt literally at the same times during the Suez Crisis which massively undermined western attempts to get involved. Almost like international rules apply to both sides.
|
|
|
Originally posted by snytaxx
I love these examples you keep picking, they really are great examples of shooting your arguments in the foot. Firstly Stalin did not invade Hungary as he had been dead for 3 years. It was Khrushchev. Stalin did threaten the allies a few years earlier when he blockaded West Berlin, the allies just ignored it and he relented. Almost as if calling the Russians bluff has consistently been a good policy. Thanks for highlighting. Secondly, Hungary is a great example because the US did want to directly intervene in the crisis, however Britain and France attacked Egypt literally at the same times during the Suez Crisis which massively undermined western attempts to get involved. Almost like international rules apply to both sides. Another excuse burger from another emperor with no clothes....pretty cold in winter. Czechoslovakia 1968 is another cold war example. Hungary had a communist government installed in 44 and the revolution was actually an uprising against the Soviets who were already there. No western military response....just excuses, like you have. Yes Stalin died in 53 but the point is that the Soviet Union invaded multiple countries under different leaders both before and after WW2. Here are the examples: The point is that Putin was a choirboy compared to Stalin and yet deals and agreements were made.....So this argument that you can't 'trust' Putin to make deals with him is just more nonsense. When the Berlin war fell there was a massive opportunity that neoliberals fecked up....like they seemingly do with everything. The rather obvious point is that the west makes deals and 'trusts' settlements with regimes it doesn't like all the time. Hell, it buys resources and sells military equipment to them all the time. This will be no different. I'll believe it's different when guys like you lot stick on fatigues instead of others. Edited by Stirlingsays (18 Dec 2023 11.42pm)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
Another excuse burger from another emperor with no clothes....pretty cold in winter. Hungary had a communist government installed in 44 and the revolution was actually an uprising against the Soviets who were already there. No western military response....just excuses, like you have. Yes Stalin died in 53 but the point is that the Soviet Union invaded multiple countries under different leaders both before and after WW2. Here are the examples: When the Berlin war fell there was a massive opportunity that neoliberals fecked up....like they seemingly do with everything. The rather obvious point is that the west makes deals and 'trusts' settlements with regimes it doesn't like all the time. Hell, it buys resources and sells military equipment to them all the time. This will be no different. I'll believe it's different when guys like you lot stick on fatigues instead of others.
Also Pointing out the Soviet Union literally collaborated with the Nazis to invade defenceless European states doesn't really do your argument much good when the one country to really resist (Finland) got to keep it's independence. Edited by snytaxx (18 Dec 2023 11.41pm) Edited by snytaxx (18 Dec 2023 11.42pm)
|
|
|
Originally posted by snytaxx
It just keeps getting better. As per the link you shared Hungary was a German ally up until 1944 when the Soviets - allied to the West invaded and removed the German occupation force who had invaded in March of the same year after Hungary tried to switch sides. Also Pointing out the Soviet Union literally collaborated with the Nazis to invade defenceless European states doesn't really do your argument much good when the one country to really resist (Finland) got to keep it's independence. Edited by snytaxx (18 Dec 2023 11.41pm) Edited by snytaxx (18 Dec 2023 11.42pm) If Ukraine can fight off Russia then fight off Russia. Finland, did very well for its minnow status but it got to survive because Russia were fighting for survival against Germany's invasion. I like how you post passive aggressive nonsense as if you think you're winning some point. You are grabbing at straws to deflect from the main points. One: that Russia invaded multiple countries in the cold war without Western consent or military intervention, including a European one and two....multiple deals were made with Soviet regimes far worse than Putin. Indeed, with Stalin we had quite the selective memory over the moral consequences of all of it. Edited by Stirlingsays (18 Dec 2023 11.52pm)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
If Ukraine can fight off Russia then fight off Russia. Finland, did very well for its minnow status but it got to survive because Russia were fighting for survival against Germany's invasion. I like how you post passive aggressive nonsense as if you think you're winning some point. You are grabbing at straws to deflect from the main points. One: that Russia invaded multiple countries in the cold war without Western consent or military intervention, including a European one and two....multiple deals were made with Soviet regimes far worse than Putin. Indeed, with Stalin we had quite the selective memory over the moral consequences of all of it.
Ignoring the person attacks. Your history is still way off which makes the points you are trying to make rather non sensical if not actually really damaging to your argument - that's what I'm pointing out. The Soviets allied themselves with Nazi Germany form 1939 to 1941 to carve Europe up into spheres of influence via Molotov Ribbentrop. The winter war occured in 1939-40 (you can check this in the link you shared) while the Soviets were a German ally. They did fight the Russians off for the most part off with only a fraction of the aid they really needed. Odd how this makes me see so many parallels with Ukraine. The Germans did not ally with the finns until the following year when they invaded the USSR and that's when you get the continuation war which is a separate thing. So you appear to be confused as to what war you are actually talking about. Like how you weren't sure when the Soviets invaded Hungary to put down the Hungarian revolution. None of your other examples come close to the representing the situation in Ukraine given that while interventions have always occurred with differing levels of legality and support depending on your viewpoint. What is key is that Borders have remained static since 1945. This does not reflect Putin's ambitions to literally remove Ukraine from the map through might is right. Edited by snytaxx (19 Dec 2023 12.24am)
|
|
|
Originally posted by snytaxx
Ignoring the person attacks. Your history is still way off which makes the points you are trying to make rather non sensical if not actually really damaging to your argument - that's what I'm pointing out. The Soviets allied themselves with Nazi Germany form 1939 to 1941 to carve Europe up into spheres of influence via Molotov Ribbentrop. The winter war occured in 1939-40 (you can check this in the link you shared) while the Soviets were a German ally. They did fight the Russians off for the most part off with only a fraction of the aid they really needed. Odd how this makes me see so many parallels with Ukraine. The Germans did not ally with the finns until the following year when they invaded the USSR and that's when you get the continuation war which is a separate thing. So you appear to be confused as to what war you are actually talking about. Like how you weren't sure when the Soviets invaded Hungary to put down the Hungarian revolution. None of your other examples come close to the representing the situation in Ukraine given that while interventions have always occurred with differing levels of legality and support depending on your viewpoint. What is key is that Borders have remained static since 1945. This does not reflect Putin's ambitions to literally remove Ukraine from the map through might is right. Edited by snytaxx (19 Dec 2023 12.24am) Again, deflection, as I said Finland survived because Russia had to fight for survival in 41. Russia had already beaten it when it retreated. Personal attack? That's a bit dramatic isn't it? It's not snowing yet so no need for snowflakes. The west paid for and built up Ukraine's army into the biggest in western Europe after 2014....700, 000 men. They started their war with Russia with more troops than Russia....who didn't start a war economy until about six months ago. Since then Ukraine has been recieving massive aid, way over, 100 billion if I remember correctly.....So this, accusation of that they haven't been supported enough is nonsense. Considering they aren't a Nato country the amount of treasure spent on Ukraine is....well, let's just say lots of people are rich, but it isn't the poor Ukrainian person in the street. I clearly stated at the start of this war....as did others....that if Nato was serious about winning a war with Russia (which is an extremely dangerous war) then it had to actually fight Russia with all its resources. Many of us could see that this was never going to happen and instead the biggest motivation seems to be to weaken Russia and biff Putin on the nose and hopefully get rid of him. That was always a highly risky policy because of the number of things that could go wrong and indeed most of them have and the consequences of Russia realigning economically have serious implications both for peace and future economics. We do not have intelligent men making decisions here, we have very poor outcomes that you guys rush to defend because 'Putin bad'. The outcomes are so much worse than they should have been.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
Again, deflection, as I said Finland survived because Russia had to fight for survival in 41. Russia had already beaten it when it retreated. Where? I'm replying to your posts. What you are saying is completely wrong and not supported by any form of history. The war was over in 1940 after the USSR received a mauling and signed a peace treaty. You seem to be insinuating that the USSR would have just restarted the war again 'but for the Germans'. Firstly there is literally no evidence of this as its alternate history. Secondly its a really silly point to be making because for someone who claims that Russia is a country we can 'do business with' and 'should trust' as it argues that if Ukraine was to appease as you want them to, Russia would just come back a year later and we would be back at square one? How can you not see what a undermining arguement this is? Originally posted by Stirlingsays
Personal attack? That's a bit dramatic isn't it? It's not snowing yet so no need for snowflakes. Yes, calling someone a 'fanboy' of an intelligence service (previous post) and marking their contributions as 'passive agressive nonsese'and now a 'snowflake' are attacks on a persons character is not really relevant to your arguements. Tone it down please. Originally posted by Stirlingsays
The west paid for and built up Ukraine's army into the biggest in western Europe after 2014....700, 000 men. They started their war with Russia with more troops than Russia....who didn't start a war economy until about six months ago. This is just completely untrue and very misleading. As per the House of commons library. Aid was minimal between 2014-2022. The US spent less than $4 billion over 8 years. None of it weaponary, apart from Trump who gave them million worth of Javelins (about 421 units given their cost). Which did not happen until 2018. The 700,000 is a quote from the Ukrainian defence minister where he actually says this would be the total number if the army was supplemented with revervists, border gaurds, national gaurd and the police. the active size was actually more like 250,000 which although large, was not shocking given the country had been fighting in the Donbas since 2014. Russia for reference, had over a million active with millions more in reserve prior to 2022. Originally posted by Stirlingsays
Since then Ukraine has been recieving massive aid, way over, 100 billion if I remember correctly.....So this, accusation of that they haven't been supported enough is nonsense. Considering they aren't a Nato country the amount of treasure spent on Ukraine is....well, let's just say lots of people are rich, but it isn't the poor Ukrainian person in the street. its €92 billion euros of military 'aid' totaled in almost 2 years which when carved up over time is about the same as what we, the UK spend on our military per year and about what half Russia spends. Given there are hundreds of donor countries, this really isnt the large sum of money you think it is. Not that this can really be compared because its a more a case that Ukraine has received €92 billion worth of assets which is essentially had to distribute over its front line and use as best they could due to training issues etc. Originally posted by Stirlingsays
I clearly stated at the start of this war....as did others....that if Nato was serious about winning a war with Russia (which is an extremely dangerous war) then it had to actually fight Russia with all its resources. Many of us could see that this was never going to happen and instead the biggest motivation seems to be to weaken Russia and biff Putin on the nose and hopefully get rid of him. That was always a highly risky policy because of the number of things that could go wrong and indeed most of them have and the consequences of Russia realigning economically have serious implications both for peace and future economics. You cant have this both ways, intervening aginst Russia = super dangerous (which I doubt but thats the topic of another post). Versus have Ukraine voluntarily causing Russia to dig its own grave also being 'highly risky'. This is just a dog whistle for 'better appease Putin'. Originally posted by Stirlingsays
We do not have intelligent men making decisions here, we have very poor outcomes that you guys rush to defend because 'Putin bad'. The outcomes are so much worse than they should have been. Love that you just copied my point about how you can't openly admit to supporting Russia so it has to be 'Ukraine bad' but applied to Putin. Unfortunately, when the lynch pin of your arguement is 'please appease Putin'. I am duty bound to point out what a untrustworthy character he is as agreed by you given you seem to think he is at least one of the unintellgent people in charge making decisions.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
I read a request to 'tone it down' and stopped reading. No, I won't 'tone it down' because the charge is ridiculously sensitive. So I will compromise and no longer respond to you. Translation for those joining us, Stirling has been struggling to come with any meaningful data or evidence to back his arguments, doesn't like the scrutiny when I pull data to contradict his points and instead played the man rather than the ball. After being called out on this too he has decided do the 'comprising' thing and pretend he can't hear me. Lovely stuff.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
You see this all the time, people who won't read a thread but want you to continually repeat yourself because they think what they type is some kind of gotcha. I've pretty much covered those points all on this thread but I won't be told to self censor.
Thanks
|
|
|
Originally posted by snytaxx
Translation for those joining us, Stirling has been struggling to come with any meaningful data or evidence to back his arguments, doesn't like the scrutiny when I pull data to contradict his points and instead played the man rather than the ball. After being called out on this too he has decided do the 'comprising' thing and pretend he can't hear me. Lovely stuff. If you stick around long enough you will realise this is a standard pattern. As soon as a boxed in corner is encountered the personal attacks come out to try to divert the thread. Brick walls are more pliable.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Perhaps better if ALL posters stick to the topic.......
A stairway to Heaven and a Highway to Hell give some indication of expected traffic numbers |
|
|
Originally posted by PalazioVecchio
having avoided this thread cos of ....boredom with constant wars....i saw all the usual msm propaganda today and have decided that 'we' are losing this War. and i got absolutely zero sympathy for NATO , the EU, the yanks and anybody else stupid enough to march their flags in the footsteps of Napoleon & Hitler. To describe it as another Vietnam would be an understatement. Edited by PalazioVecchio (20 Dec 2023 4.49pm) The Light Brigade will sort them. Although Charge of the Light Brigade is now a Green Tax.
Red and Blue Army! |
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
In other news the Russians continue to take ground in Ukraine and the media continue to largely keep quiet about it. So where do you get your true version of events? And what do "the Western media" gain by hushing it up? The EU are discussing ways of ignoring Hungary's opposition to giving Ukraine a huge 50 billion (EU democracy) and in America it looks like funding will be delayed until at least early new year. All money the western taxpayer won't get back.It may be money well spent. If the same effort had been made to stop Hitler, WW2 could have been avoided. Biden will have to make significant changes to border policy for it to happen....and the republicans won't allow him to fake it. However, I expect them to eventually get that 60 billion to Ukraine somehow regardless. All money that is ultimately being thrown away to attempt to rescue a situation that makes no sense.....Hitler found out that population size defeats quality of army if your opponent is ruthless enough. The Soviets beat Germany despite losing around four or five times as many people against them.They had a greater pool of peasants then. And it was Germany invading Russia remember? However, the supporters of this war will fight until the last Ukrainian....press ganging men into the army along the way, which has been happening for some time in Ukraine....even woman are now being put into the army.
There's a lack of common sense, but ok, we will watch it play out because that's what was decided. You think Russia should be allowed to win. What kind of message will that send to Putin and his thug cronies?
Edited by Eaglehamster (20 Dec 2023 9.16pm)
I have now sufficient funds to last me the rest of my life. Provided I don't buy anything. |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.